Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Cordless tools

Posts

Cordless tools

#1

Cordless tools

Roy Girolami

I had occasion to use my old Bosch cordless drill and tried to charge it up. One battery wouldn't take a charge and the other won't keep one long enough to do any drilling. Granted, the drill is over 15 years old and the batteries are probably toast. But I looked up on the Bosch site and found the parts diagram for my drill and there was the battery. So I put it in the cart and a message popped up saying part discontinued. Okay, so I can't get one from the manufacturer. It looks like Interstate batteries sells one that looks like it would fit. I'm assuming they re-build them with new cells.

So, it looks like if you spend the money to get a quality tool, technology will make it obsolete and soon non-functioning. I'm wondering if I have been going down the wrong road with respect to tools and should pay more attention to the HF offerings. I was in HD today and glanced at the cordless drills. They ranged from about $80 to over $200. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.

Roy

Re: Cordless tools

#2

Re: Cordless tools

Hank Knight

I agree. We are rapidly becoming a disposable society. Not only does rapidly advancing technology render things obsolete quickly, it is becoming increasingly difficult to repair things that should be repairable. It's often easier to chuck it in the trash and buy a new one than to repair it - or find someone who can repair it.

Having said that, there are services that rebuild batteries for cordless tools. You don't have to buy a whole new battery. Just send your old one to them. They open the case, replace the batteries inside, reseal it and send it back to you. Often the new batteries are better than the old ones.

Re: Cordless tools

#3

Re: Cordless tools

David Bassett

Been there & done that. This the reason my last replacement was Ryobi. Not the stoutest, nor the highest quality, but good enough for me and they decided to keep their battery compatible over many generations. (If I had any, and it held charge, I could use a 10+ year old NiCd in my current drill. My current LiIon battery would power that 10+ year old drill, if I had it.)

Of course, with my battery luck they'll change with their next generation.

Re: Cordless tools

#4

Re: Cordless tools

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Roy, might I suggest seeing what Rockwell has for you. OI bought the 3rill a couple times and am totally satisfied with it. Batteries are rechargable in about 1/2hr....and you get two of them.

I total, after my robbery a while ago, I have four batteries so I can work without end while the rest recharge. Cost was about $128.

Re: Cordless tools

#5

Re: Cordless tools

RK near Boston

Dewalt is even worse. They took the 18V lithium batteries that were compatible with the old 18V NiCd tools, renamed them to 20V max (actual nominal voltage is still 5x3.6 = 18V), changed the form factor a bit and now they are physically incompatible with the older 18V tools.

Re: Cordless tools

#6

Fix them?

John K Jordan

I have done two things. One, zap the battery pack (if nicad) with enough current to vaporize the crystals that can grow and short the cells internally. This may or may not work depending on several factors. Years ago we used a bank of big electrolytic capacitors for this but now I use a welding machine. (I think Ralph Watts told me about the welding machine method) If it does let the pack take a charge I immediately put it through several charge/deep discharge cycles. This method works on some but not a majority of the dead packs.

Two, which always works, rebuild the battery pack with new cells. The local battery store will no longer rebuild the pack but will sell the individual cells with tabs spot-welded on each end. Some battery packs come apart with screws and some must be cut apart. This can be messy.

Two-point-five, take apart several old battery packs, test each cell, and rebuild one pack from the good cells. (Usually not all cells are bad in the pack.) This requires charging and testing equipment and takes a lot of time. Much easier to buy new cells.

If the packs will still charge but not last long repeated deep discharge cycles worked for some of mine. When notching a bunch of 6x6 PT posts to support beams for my shop (up on a ladder!) I cut repeated slices with a circular saw until each pack was dead and counted the number of cuts I got with each charge. It was surprising how much better several weak packs worked after a few cycles. Some battery packs that were about worthless are still good almost three years later.

I have grown to very much prefer corded tools except where impractical around the farm, i.e. far from 110v power. I wish several mfgrs would form an alliance to build tools with interchangeable battery packs. I also wonder if someone could get rich building universal replacement packs with adapters for the various brands, assuming any licensing issues could be resolved.

Re: Cordless tools

#7

Re: Cordless tools

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roy

Here in Oz - and I am certain that it will be the same in your area - there are companies that specialise in re-packing batteries. Alternately, they sell non-badged replacements.

This is the case with the Panasonic cordless drills I have owned for a few decades. The 12V is at least 20 years old and on a third set of batteries. I just gave away a Panasonic 15.6V, which was about 12 years old, with functioning batteries, one original and one generic. This was recently replaced by a 10.6V Festool - nice drill, but not in the same class as the ageless Panasonic.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cordless tools

#8

Re: Cordless tools

John McGaw

Huh? AFAIK Dewalt has only had two form factors for their rechargeable batteries. The old style has the stalk protruding from the top which determines which voltage tool it will fit into. They are still selling all of them as of the last time I checked and still sell a lithium version (heavy duty or lightweight types) which will work in 18V tools whether they came with ni-cad or lithium originally. Dewalt's new version batteries don't have the stalk and use slide-in contacts. I'm not sure what the compatibility is with those since all of my Dewalt tools use the old-style batteries.

What is the model of the battery you are wanting to replace?

Re: Cordless tools

#9

Re: Cordless tools

RK near Boston

You are exactly right. I am not really looking to replace batteries, but they stopped making new tools with the old style batteries. I guess I was being a bit picky because of that marketing approach, especially the whole 20V max thing.

Re: Cordless tools

#11

Re: Cordless tools

John McGaw

What 18V tools are you interested in? You can still buy a limited selection of the old-standard tools at Amazon. Most recently I got a little circular saw for rough-cutting sheetgoods and a drill/impact driver set through them. BTW, the charger that comes with the 18V lithium batteries is much better than their old setup, being usable with anything from the ancient low-voltage ni-cads up to the 18V lithiums.

Re: Cordless tools

#12

Re: Cordless tools.....

roger lance

never owned one.......never will.

Re: Cordless tools

#13

Re: Cordless tools

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Have to agree with you! I own and use several battery powered tools, Impact driver, drills, screwdriver etc. However, I have found that replacing the batteries cost as much as a new tool with new batteries, even if you have the batteries rebuilt. Although I have to admit they are somewhat handier to use, I have gone back to using corded tools whenever I can. I have 2 tools from Rigid, and though the tools and batteries are supposedly guaranteed for life, it seems it is a big hassle to get them replaced. I registered the tools in my son's name as I purchased them for him ~ most of his work in done in my (our) shop. The registration process took about 3 months but I do have a "customer number" for the supposed warranty.

Re: Cordless tools

#14

Amen to that!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

When my old B&D Industrial 9.6 charger went belly up and I couldn't find a replacement, I tried a friend's 18V and it had wayyy too much power and thus not enough control. I got a Makita 12V and it is wonderful.

Re: Cordless tools

#15

Re: One more point ..

John McGaw

I guess that if one was lucky enough to have a set of power tools for this and another set for that and another set for whatever then you might be right. Me, I just have tools and I use them for everything. In actuality, my newer 18V cordless drill is lighter, smaller, more maneuverable, has finer control, a better chuck, and runs longer on a charge than my ancient 14.4V drill as well as having more brute force when needed. The 12V drill that came before was just as heavy and clumsy as the 14.4V and had even worse battery life. BTW, I use my little 18V impact driver when making furniture too -- a great boon when using many pocket screws.

Re: Cordless tools

#16

Second more point

GolfSteve in Calgary

Why would anyone need a cordless drill for furniture making?

My Makita corded drill is almost 25 years old and still working perfectly.

The cord is sometimes inconvenient when I'm doing home renovations, running up and down ladders, etc., but most of the time it always works, it never needs charged, the battery never dies, the chargers don't take up bench space, and it had lots of power.

An egg-beater is also a handy cordless drill for small jobs.

Re: Cordless tools

#17

Batteries?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Not sure where to put the battery on this cordless tool (not mine, but I've got a similar one...or two...)


img

Re: Cordless tools

#18

Re: Batteries?

Roy Girolami

I need to put down some concrete backer board for some tile in my bathroom. My old Bosch did fine when I did the same in the sun room. Now i'm finding I can get a replacement generic battery for $60. It looks a lot like the ones from China that sell in lots of 20 to 30 for $25 apiece. But on HD or Lowes I can get an impact driver with two batteries for under $100. This is funny, because the Ryobi is more expensive than the cheaper ones, which are Milwaukee and Makita. Bosch makes an inexpensive one also, but I'm sort of reluctant to give them any more of my money.

Roy

P.S. I use a Stanley 923 brace a lot when I'm screwing things, but 60 screws in the floor needs some power assist.

Re: Cordless tools

#19

How's it work....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....with a half inch drill? 3/8? I find it barely acceptable with a 1/4".......but they are dandy for the small drill sizes. In fact for installing house trim I employ three for #6,4 and brad sized nails respectively. But it is not what I grab for a 1/4" hole.

Re: Cordless tools

#20

Re: Second more point

AZ in Colorado Springs

Why have a cordless drill in furniture making?

I like the clutch feature when driving screws. I have not seen a corded drill with a clutch. I understand there was or is one such model out there, somewhere.

I could use a screwdriver, sure, but using a cordless drill is much faster.

And it's nice having one less cord snaking around for tasks where the cordless drill is appropriate.

Well, I also like the cordless tool for working around the house, and so I use it in the woodshop, too.

Re: Cordless tools

#21

Re: Second more point

John Pappas

" I have not seen a corded drill with a clutch. I understand there was or is one such model out there, somewhere."

I have a Ryobi with this feature. At the time I purchased it, Sears also had one.

Re: Cordless tools

#22

Re: Batteries?

TomD

Nice looking egg beater, who makes it?

Re: Cordless tools

#23

Re: Second more point

TomD

One thing I have noticed about corless is that one can end up talking at cross purposes if one isn't using the lattest gear, which I am not, so your gear may well do stuff better than mine. For furniture, assuming I am not in a factory or something, I really like a brace and bit for heavy driving. It has much better control than a drill driver, and while it isn't as fast the difference is not significant in this use. Torque is unlimited, never wreaks a screw head, and I can set the head by degrees for a perfect set, but there are probably cordless drills that do that today.

Re: Cordless tools

#24

Re: Cordless tools

TomD

"Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me."

Did you try looking for them on ebay? Sometimes you have to dig down pretty deep, specifying free international shipping or a variety of odd categories based on number of cells or whaterver. Years ago I go various cameras and camcorders, and it became impossible to get the batteries, but then now with ebay, even amazon, they sometimes pop up. It can be worth just trying again in a few months.

As far as being fooled, the battery tool segment has moved quickly. When I got my first Makita Drill driver back a long way, 25 years or so. It cost 165 + + for extra battery and chuck. It was built to last but eventually the batteries packed it in, I took it apart and the machinery in there was beautiful. But I replaced it with a Cambell Hausfeld (the compressor people) drill driver from Costco foro 30 bucks which is more powerful, came with the second battery and charger, had a hand tightening chuck which was an extra on the Makita and so forth. I probably had 250 in the makita one, but didn't replace it because the tech had moved on and the cheapos were better than the Makita was.

Various contractor places around here sell cordless tools that cost a fortune, but I get by with the cheapos. I have tried the more expensive ones, and they are better, but I have a lot of options. If I am driving a lot of heavy screws, I use my Milwaukee corded drywall gun; or I use a yankee push drill for small hardware; or a brace with a bit accepter LV sell; and so forth.

I am not tangled up in the men's jewlery thing that is driven by renovators spending money that homeowners didn't have, and that the financials sold to an unsuspecting world. Same thing with the cost of pick-ups shod in the lattest mag wheels, it was in large part driven by the housing bubble, maybe.

Re: Cordless tools

#25

It's a Millers-Falls

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

and it's "who made it." I don't know of any modern manufacturer producing an eggbeater drill of the quality of the old ones - not enough of a market for what one like that would cost.