Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

Posts

Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#1

Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.




I superficially finished the perspective piece of lumber for the top to see what the knot would look like with stain and a couple of coats of shellac. I have no experience using a knot in furniture. The knot does center nicely in what would be the top, but, it remains a knot, something I have always removed from wood to be used in furniture. I would appreciate opinion of whether to "knot or not"

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#2

Knot......

roger lance

you seem like a stable person.....not inclined to being a radical.....so, why not a knot at this stage??.....besides, if you are loosing sleep worrying about what you've done, you can always replace it.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#3

Re: Things we ought knot to have done

Hank Knight

There are things which we ought to have done and things which we ought knot to have done. It is unhealthy to have done those things which we ought knot to have done, but, as Roger says, you can regain your health by replacing the knot with not a knot.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#4

Knot


Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#5

Ellis Walentine

Roger, need valid email address

Ellis Walentine

The e-mail address you're using appears to have been discontinued. Notifications you've requested are bouncing back to WC. Would you mind updating your profile and resetting your preferences?

Ellis

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#6

happy to do that but.....

roger lance

me and electronics don't always mess.....so I might need your help....

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#7

done....and without blood.....

roger lance

:D

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#8

No knot

Gary Smyth

I have no objection to the knot, but it seems to me that if you do use the knot you will always wonder why. The knot is interesting, handsome even, but if it is used for the top, and depending on where it will be displayed, it may or may not be seen. My guess is that your own sensibilities want the cabinet to be as well made as you can make it. The knot did not figure in from the beginning so why go against your instincts in favor of public opinion? From what I've seen so far, there are plenty of other things working for the cabinets that demand expert fabrication and visual attention. The knot is superfluous, so why now? That knot can be used for a different project where it can be part of your planning and result in complete satisfaction and not a question. Just sayin.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#9

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

William Duffield

The knot is tight, you have expertly filled the check, it is pleasingly located on the board, and the pattern of the figured wood around it are interesting. The board appears to be structurally sound, even though it is being used for a non-structural purpose. The color matches the rest of the case. It is not in a prominent location, where there is any chance it will distract from the form of the piece. If you save it, you may never find another esthetically pleasing use for it, or for a piece of it, and you will have wasted the effort you expended in finishing it. I don't see any downside at all in using it right where you planned.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#10

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

David Yoho

Personally, I like the knot. I'm in agreement with what William said. Go ahead and use it.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#11

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

joe mohnike

You could also make a veneer out of it keeping the look of the knot. I like the knot it looks good and will add a lot to your box.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#12

Alan Young

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

Alan Young

I guess I am in the minority-I really like the knot photo-and the not a knot photo but I can't see them in the context of size and perspective to the actually Spice Box-So that would leave me uncertain about the overall-effect. I might be tempted to just mount the Knot board on the wall as a Wood-Art Piece.

-Alan

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#13

Alan Young

OKAY- I messed with your knot

Alan Young

If you have enough material and can re-saw the knot board you'd get this


Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#14

That would be cool.  Like eyes!


Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#15

Knot? Not!

Jesse Cloud

Couldn't resist using the subject line, but actually I agree that if you like it, and think whoever you are making it for would, go for it.

If you really like it, however, it might be wasted as the top of a cabinet. Will only very tall people see it? Maybe build something else around that piece to highlight it. Top for a large box/chest?

Personally, I use bold figure sparingly. It can detract from the form and feel of the piece.

And, gasp!, I think book matching is way overused.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#16

Alan Young

Or This

Alan Young


Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#17

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

TomD

I would not use the knot, even though the panels you have prepared are beautiful (well one appears highly figured without a knot). As you know, a knot is woodgrain running somewhat perpendicular to the surface, which is a radical change in the grain direction that affects all manner of things from structural integrity, to the degree to which a spice box might protect spices if there was that free a movement of vapor through the side of the panel.

Aesthetically it would seem to lack the formality of your recent work, but that is for you to decide.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#18

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

TomD

Another point, maybe not critical is that you would get a lot of wood movement in all direction not just perp to the grain of the wood, whatever that is in this case.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#19

That's spooky

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would take your creativity to incorporate it into something worthy

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#20

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

Barry Irby

Every time I try to use a piece like this I wish I had done better. I see others do it they get the Wow! factor. I get the Wonder Why effect.

Another thought that has not come up....If you could center the knot left to right you could mount the piece on a lathe and turn a recess into it where the knot is and install medallion. Perhaps something made of walnut with eight or ten pieces radiating out from a center point. This would eliminate the knot as a negative point to wood workers and yet save the beautiful grain around the medallion. Just what you needed, more work.

Beautiful boxes, either way.

Another thought. These are gifts, Right? Ask the recipients.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#21

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

For what it's worth, I vote no knot.

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#22

So, to knot or not to knot....

roger lance

that is the question.....what's the answer ??

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#23

Re: That's spooky

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I vote for the first photo by Alan Young

Re: Spice Box Top- Knot or Not

#24

Re: So, to knot or not to knot....

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Personally I really like the looks of the Knot. I prefer the natural look in Woodworking as long as the piece is structurally stable.