Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

Posts

Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#1

Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

don stephan

In the 1980's I didn't know the difference between surfaced lumber and flat and straight lumber. I knew that clamps would straighten out twists and such during glueups, but always wondered why frame and panel cabinet doors would be twisted when the clamps were removed.

The procedure for surfacing rough sawn lumber I gradually learned from extensive reading is to first flatten the bottom of a board by running it through a power jointer without any downward pressure (multiple passes until the bottom surface is uniformly jointed) and then make the upper surface parallel with light cuts through a power planer, what one might call "flat and straight parallel." I'll stack and sticker a week for the board to acclimate, then repeat.

As I understand mill operations, lumber yards and such surface rough sawn lumber by passing the boards through a two sided planer if you will, that removes wood from both the top and bottom surfaces simultaneously. This will make the two surfaces parallel, but not necessarily flat and straight. Most of the surfaced lumber I've seen has some twist or other type of warp. This is what I'm referring to as "two sides parallel." With baseboard and other trim, the warping can usually be counteracted with enough finish nails. Some warping can be incorporated in furniture without obvious problem, but for the last couple decades I've only been using "flat and straight parallel."

And of course, with a bit more exertion and practice, rough lumber can be surfaced to either both sides parallel or flat and straight with hand planes.

I'm curious how many of the forum participants regularly use "two sides parallel" with any incorporated warping, and how many use "flat and straight parallel."

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#2

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I guess it depends on whether I'm building furniture or siding a barn. In the former case, in general, I use "four square" which you complicate (and some might deem "obfuscate") with the label "flat and straight parallel." In the latter case, S3S (joint one face; joint one edge, rip to width) is offen sufficient.

A practice which yields better results than the one you describe is as follows: Joint one surface flat; Plane the opposite surface parallel to the first surface; remove approximately equal amounts from both surfaces until the desired thickness is achieved; choose your show surface. If you remove all the excess thickness from one surface, you are much more likely to end up with boards that are not flat.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#3

Depends on the application

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



The top for this table was made from one board, cut in the middle and folded back on itself to make an edge match. The grain in this folded configuration matched well and the curl in this board was a nice feature. I was highly motivated to use this board for a top. However, the board twisted up on one end 1 1/2".

When I glued the two boards together I mashed the twisted board flat in the clamps by jacking against the ceiling above my bench. When the glue dried the twisted end bent up the formally straight board adjacent to it. The top was not flat by more than 1".

The top was attached to the table frame and over the course of a month I slowly pulled the top against the frame with screws. After a month it was pulled flat and has remained so for more than 10 years.

I don't have a one size fits all rule for how I handled typical variance in lumber. Had I needed a long piece of lumber that had to be flat and unsupported I would have chosen a flat board to begin with. One of the many advantages of having a stack of lumber is being able to pick a piece according to the application. In the end it all gets used for something.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#4

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

TomD

There is a third method I use which consists of knocking off the high points, particularly diagonal corners and then putting it through a planer. This will often yield near perfect results without having to go all the way with the planer or with the 4 square process.

While there are workarounds to everything, the main method that is used to lay out on cabinetwork is using the edges and surfaces as reference points. So it is desirable to have properly dimensioned pieces. Basically one of the differences in bespoke or couture is how the cloth is laid out so it is highly accurate and the matched pieces identical. Using tailor's tacks for on method. Similarly with cabinet work it should be done with highly accurate methods, But there can be workarounds.

One example would be a leg as on Bill's table where the piece might start out with two sides squared but it might be possible to cut away waste without squaring the other two sides, there are many examples of that kind of thing.

When I started out I bought my first planer, an Inca, with jointer and planer the same width, so that I could joint as wide as I could plane. I have seen German over/under machines as wide as 24 inches set up like that, for cultures where real wood working is still widely practices. But over time I came to understand that there were workarounds and the cost of such machines were not necessary. These days I just run a lot of material through the planer, I have developed the eye to know when it will work out, and when it won't. There is a lot that goes into the early work of laying out a piece that is hard to pin down. It is like the work a mill does to get yield from it's stock, but there are so many other factors to consider in fine work, the factors are almost infinite in combination. This would appear to someone working through the shop to be slow work for just arranging pieces, but it is one of the most important steps in making high quality projects, and a lot of the issues are never addressed in the woodworking press.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#5

Re: Depends on the application

don stephan

Using clamps to mash boards flat, and screws to pull down twisted tops, is fine for one's own personal pieces, but both are incorporating additional stress in the finished piece. Often there is too much additional stress from treatment and/or environmental conditions (HVAC vents is a prime example) placed on completed furniture, so starting out with incorporated stress already built in can make a bad situation worse. In any case, I can't afford the risk to reputation of selling a piece of furniture with incorporated stress from boards mashed flat by clamps and such. I'll continue to make boards flat and straight and parallel before using them.

It would be a luxury to be able to purchase 1000 board foot stacks of lumber with the necessary storage space and time to continually sort through and restack, but not an option for me. I'm glad you have this option.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#6

you asked the question....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'm curious how many of the forum participants regularly use "two sides parallel" with any incorporated warping, and how many use "flat and straight parallel."

I offered an example of what can be done with lumber that isn't perfect and can't be made perfect. It can be useful to push the boundary to see what can be done. The learning can come in handy at some later time. I have to wonder why you asked your question. (BTW, stressed wood relaxes over time)

It would be ideal if everyone had a jointer wide enough to flatten every board they needed and lumber so perfect that every board could be flattened and still be thick enough to be useful. For the bystanders I offer the suggestion to learn to work less than perfect lumber. For the majority of applications perfectly flat is unnecessary and can be wasteful.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#7

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

Tony - Memphis

My situation here in Memphis is that we have no hardwood dealers. So, I am forced to buy online. Given that, it is tough to get flat lumber. Once it gets here, it moves according to my local environment. I have bought a lot of wood from a place in AZ. From there to here is a big difference! So, I've learned to live with less than flat wood. I either order it thick and work it down, or try and work around what they send me. So far, so good. I just finished a laptop desk with a 17" x 24" glued up top. The boards were not flat, but i was able to get a decent top out of them. I think the AZ source sends 13/16" as 4/4, so there isn't a lot to work with. But, even when I could buy local, it was the same thing, I was just able to pick through the stack. If you look at the bottoms of most of my glueups, you'll see a lot of rough patches because I try to leave as much thickness as possible by leaving the unseen surfaces rough. I mean I clean them up, but there may be some rough spots here and there. This same issue leads to color matching problems too. maybe I need to start building with borg poplar and paint it all!

Tony

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#8

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

No hardwood dealers? That's a real tragedy. I checked, or I asked Woodfinder to check for me, and was astounded by the results. There's a Woodcraft in Nashville, about 180 miles one way, but that's the closest we could find.

Why do you buy your lumber from Arizona? Surely, there are reputable dealers whose shipping costs to you are much lower, and who cut their wood more or less locally, and season it in a climate much more similar to yours.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#9

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

RK near Boston

I just bought a nice load of ash, cherry, walnut, etc. from these guys seeing them mentioned in D. Weavers earlier post.

https://www.westpennhardwoods.com/

They have a free shipping thing for 150 bd feet of domestic hardwoods, can be mixed species. I am now set for foreseeable future, but have to worry about storage now:)

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#10

Baloney

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"My situation here in Memphis is that we have no hardwood dealers"

You need to get out more.

The correct statement is that you have not found any. In a city of that size there must be dozens of shops working hardwood. If they are big enough they will buy truckloads from regional distributors. If you approach one of these places like you know what you are doing and are willing to buy by grade off the top of the stack it is most likely that they will sell you lumber.

Farther down the food chain there will be places that buy packs of lumber and then resell smaller quantities to smaller shops (this was our business at one time). To locate such places ask at a cabinet shop, or local school that has a wood shop or at a local WW club.

There will be regional distributors that run trucks from their storage to the city and surrounding area and drop ship packs or partial packs of lumber to customers.

All told there will be many places to buy 100 bdft of anything that grows in the US or is imported in any quantity. You find these places by looking where lumber is used.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#11

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

Tony - Memphis

Well, I got on their mailing list and saw a sale, tried them, was happy with the price and the quality, and just kept buying from them. I've gotten real good deals on mahogany, tiger maple, and cherry. We used to have two hardwood dealers, but they closed. The good old days! Ha! I watch for the monthly deals and stock up when appropriate.

Tony

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#12

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

Tony - Memphis

I'm familiar with them, but haven't ordered from them. May try them out. Yeah, I'm a little short on storage too. I have a nice stash of mahogany and tiger maple in our excercise room. Nice to look at while on the treadmill or lifting weights (sometimes better than tv!). I got lucky when one local place started closing up. I got two very large pieces of mahogany (12/4 I think) - 8" wide and 6-8' long. Great for leg stock. They sold them to me for a real good deal. Back then, I was buying mahogany locally for $6 /bdft I believe.

Tony

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#13

There should be several yards....

John in NM

Probably your lumber from AZ came from TN in the first place!

Google gives lots of options in your area, Whittington Lumber and Gates Lumber are two of them. You could probably find mill direct lumber if you look around a bit surrounding the city. I would love to be over your way, everything we get here comes by train or truck and costs at least 2x what you could pay at a small mill.

Not all commercial yards will serve walk in cash customers, but most I've tried do. The construction lumber yards are more picky about that than hardwood yards in my experience. I usually just walk in to the sales counter and ask them, even if the answer is no, I've never had anyone be rude about it.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#14

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

John in NM

Only time it matters hugely to me is when making doors of any type. Even taking the greatest care in the world, I only remember twice having a door or pair of doors come out perfectly flat and easy to hang.

There are lots of casework applications where you can pull it all together with no great ill effects. Flat and straight just make that kind of application easier, but it is by no means mandatory for me.

Just how I do things, no worries if you want to approach it differently.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#15

The "secret" to dealing with a commercial yard

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Look like you know what you are doing and act like their typical customer. The yards that cater to commercial customers sell to these customers by grade and species and the lumber is priced for this kind of transaction. For example, a typical order for us might have been "send us 250 bdft of FAS1F 4/4 oak". We pulled 250 bdft off the top of the pack, loaded it on a truck and delivered it. If it was oak, 4/4 and FAS1F grade the customer was satisfied and we got paid. The lumber was priced for this amount of effort on our part. We had no interest in spending the time with a customer that needed specific lengths or widths or expected to sort through the pack. Woodcraft prices their lumber for this kind of customer need. Our lumber was less than half their price. You want the service you pay the price.

It will be common to have a distributer that has a delivery route for their trucks. These trucks often will deliver over a 100 or 200 mile radius. We used to get lumber from Gilbert Hardwoods which came from over 200 miles away. Atlanta Hardwoods has a wide delivery route. Sometimes these places want a dock to deliver to in which case see if you can find a place to receive the lumber. Other places will make residential deliveries.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#16

Think of lumber as a good investment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your mahogany now wholesales for $10/bdft if it is S. American.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#17

Dale Lenz

Memphis is the home of NHLA

Dale Lenz

Several dozen places in Memphis area to buy hardwood lumber.

For some reason can not get the Link URL to accept my link...IDK

https://www.google.com/search?site=&source=hp&q=hardwood+lumber+memphis+tn&oq=Hardwood+lumber+memphins&gs_l=hp.1.0.0i13l2j0i22i30.4998.12673.0.16010.25.20.0.1.1.0.1064.4018.2-1j2j2j2j0j1.8.0.msedr...0...1c.1.64.hp..17.8.3624.0.CWlRVupLq5A

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#18

Re: There should be several yards....

Tony - Memphis

Yeah, I know of both of those places...neither has furniture lumber.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#19

Trust me!

Tony - Memphis

Yeah, I know how to Google. Been here for many many years. None of those places are for hobby woodworkers. Wish it were true, believe me! About the only thing you CAN find around here is red oak. I hate red oak! Several of the companies listed are not even really here. They have a presence, but no stacks of lumber. There was a fella milling storm lumber, but I don't think he is in business anymore and his supply was spotty anyway. I have several buddies around here that share the pain. We seem to be in a woodworking void here. We have one woodworking store and it ain't much. They have some affiliation with Rockler and stock a lot of their products. Their prices are VERY high though. They have a few boards in the back but they are expensive and not very good quality. Might be good for small boxes, etc.

The place in AZ is Woodworker's Source. I really have no idea where he gets his wood. I doubt is here though. I also found a good source for tiger maple several years ago, but I can't recall the name offhand. I bought some nice boards from him and it was very reasonable. The last stack of tiger maple I got on sale at WWS was really nice. Some of that was used in the desk I made my wife not long ago. I think I posted pictures of it.

I hate that you all think I'm crazy, but if anyone can point me to a decent hardwood resource around here, I'd be thrilled!

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#20

PS

Tony - Memphis

One of those places is Memphis, NY!

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#21

Nobody would have found us through Google

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The way to find a source of lumber is from someone using it. When we were in business someone new to the area would not have found us with a computer but every user of hardwood lumber in the area knew we sold lumber and how to buy it. There will be dozens of shops using hardwood lumber in your area. There will be in turn several sources supplying them.

If several of you are looking for lumber the task is even easier. Jointly buy a pack of cherry or walnut or what ever. The price will be attractive

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#22

Dale Lenz

Another idea...

Dale Lenz

Find the TN Forestry Division/commissions. Ask about their Timber buyers list or some such thing. Let you fingers do the walking. Since your so close to AR, try the same for them.

Been buying green rough sawn lumber for well over 25 years. You might want to start off with kiln dried. If you buy green, learn how to control powder post beetles!

Purchased some white oak and cherry in Jan, #1 & Btr??....Gave something like $0.88/bd.ft., green rough sawn. Around here, every mill has their own grading standards, they say they follow NHLA but ?????

I've learned to buy from the folks that cuts the trees and has their own mill. By doing this you cut out several of the "middle men". Many of these types of sawmills are commonly called: Pecker Wood Mills...Very small operators. I have found they don't take good care of their inventory, so I ask that I get the lumber on the same day the tree was felled, or close to it. This way, I can take charged of the lumber and have had good luck by doing so. Your mileage may very.

Another mill North of me 1.5 hours from here sells kiln dried, planed etc. They will get in you pocket fast.

Good luck

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#23

Kneale Brownson

Re: Baloney:  see woodfinder  *LINK*


img

Memphis area

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#24

Kneale Brownson

Re: Baloney:  see woodfinder

Kneale Brownson

No idea where the image came from.

Re: Parallel Surfaces vs Flat and Straight

#25

I Feel Your Pain!

Hank Knight

Tony,

I'm in your exact situation here in Columbia SC. We have no place locally to buy quality, furniture grade hardwood. The phone book and Google both list hardwood dealers; but, for various reasons the listings are not helpful - the dealer is not really local, the wood is poor quality or not stocked locally, etc. I order by phone from our-of-state suppliers or drive out of state to make my own selections. Several weeks ago, I was in DC for the birth of my grandson. I took the opportunity to drive over to Dunlap Wood Products in Chantilly, VA, about 20 miles from DC, and bought some beautiful 8/4 maple. That kind of thing is sometimes available locally at Rockler, but I can Drive to Chantilly and back for what Rockler charges for their stock. It's a problem and inconvenient, but I've generally been pleased with wood I've purchased from reputable out-of-state dealers. Just wish I didn't have to pay for shipping.

Hank