Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

OT--overkill

Posts

OT--overkill

#1

OT--overkill

Paul Blackwell

I just received a pair of solid brass hinges from Lee Valley-made in the USA by Brusso. Affixed to the package is a warning--This product may contain a chemical known to the State of California to cause cancer. Do they know something that the other 49 States are unaware of? Come to think of it, everything known to man is known to cause cancer, at least in California. Must be why I have no desire to go there.

Re: OT--overkill

#2

Re: Over reaction

Mark Nowicki

Even though California is the land of fruits and nuts, it has enough natural beauty and history to ignore their the fear and concern about cancer and give it a try at least once.

PS. By beauty I don't mean this kind:

http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2014/03/castro-san-franciscos-public-nudity-ban.html

PPS. I assume that you are over 18 and you know what a naked butt looks like. If you are not or you don't, or you bend a needle in in half when you sit on one, DON'T click on the link.

Mark

Re: OT--overkill

#3

Re: OT--overkill

David Bassett

CA voters passed a well intentioned but very poorly worded law. The net effect is that is you can't get (much of) anything here without a label. (I've gotten books with a label.) I don't remember the words, but the interpretation of the law is that if you don't label something that is hazardous there can be big fines & other liability. If you do label something non-hazardous as possibly hazardous, you don't have any liability (under this law.) Hence, everything (including public & business buildings) gets labeled and the label has become meaningless.

Ignore it. We do.

Re: OT--overkill

#4

Re: OT--overkill

Dave Bair

Probably the lead content.

Re: OT--overkill

#5

Re: OT--overkill

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The law was precisely written to sound good to liberals and provide income for others. Unfortunately the cost can not be ignored by the product manufacturers. But if a repeal was attempted the people making money from the regulation would mount a lobbying effort that would appeal to the technically ignorant.

I used to substitute teach chemistry on occasion. My first words in class would be, "If you promise to never vote I don't care what you do today in class so long as you don't interrupt the rest." That approach was so novel that many paid attention.

Re: OT--overkill

#6

its California!

paul in AZ

What do you expect?

Re: OT--overkill

#7

Is there a label on Water?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Because I read once that 100% of people that drink water die...

:b

Re: OT--overkill

#8

Re: Is there a label on Water?

Barry Irby

Water kills a lot more people than brass hinges.

Re: OT--overkill

#9

You ought to go there

Joe shelton

Just don't walk on a sidewalk in San Francisco or drive a car south of Malibu. It's a great place.

And they call Missisippi "flyover" country...

Re: OT--overkill

#10

Re: OT--overkill

Dave Bair

What the heck does being liberal have to do with this issue? The people I know who are the most paranoid about chemicals are raving conservatives.

Re: OT--overkill

#11

Re: Is there a label on Water?

Jesse Cloud

couple of points...

For its intended use, there is clearly no great danger from the lead in a pair of hinges. It is clearly over reaction.

Not sure about this particular reg, but in most cases, there is a procedure to get exemption from a reg for a particular use. But this costs more money than just printing something on a label, so many companies don't bother.

Funny you should bring up water. The one case where there is arguably a concern is in plumbing fixtures. A new brass fixture will leach a small amount of lead into the water that runs through it. That declines rapidly with use. Arguably, something the consumer should know about. Personally, I might consider running a good amount of water through a new fixture before drinking from it....

Re: OT--overkill

#12

agree

paul in AZ

Unfortunately that sort of mindless knee jerk labeling of people is becoming the norm on the internet.

Re: OT--overkill

#13

data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Why is this law in CA and not in TN? The answer presumably is the majority of voters in CA supported the law. Which state is most liberal when it comes to voters? The correlation is obvious. I rest my case.

Re: OT--overkill

#14

What the law does... *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

It is amazing how much smack gets talked by people who don't really know what the scope of the law is. Such griping says more about the complainers than about the law.

The California law that necessitated the stickers we see is the 1986 Proposition 65, also known as "The safe drinking water and toxic enforcement act". And, it passed by popular majority. Reading up on it, I would have voted for it, and I consider myself a centrist.

Essentially, it was the result of the California people demanding a stop be put to hazardous stuff being put in their environment by companies and others. Some who opposed the law said to leave it to free market to make that happen. We tried that, and it wasn't happening (my comment).

To be fair, there have been unintended side effects (like the silly stickers), but by and large it has been a good thing. The effects have been to also change chemical makeup in products nationally and beyond, reducing exposure of millions of people to stuff they couldn't see, couldn't know was present in a product, or weren't even aware was hazardous.

My comments aren't to say that the State of California is without fault. Far from it. I am just proposing that people at least know what they are talking about before taking a position.

And while I am at it, labeling groups of people, and making blanket statements about states and their citizens takes the conversation in the wrong direction every time. It is also a good way to be wrong most of the time. Otherwise intelligent people are often too quick to choose sides whenever politics comes up. I'd like to think this is one of the rare places we can still have an intelligent conversation based on facts. I hope I am right.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


Proposition 65 at Wikipedia

Re: OT--overkill

#15

Re: data

Denny

You're assuming this is a political issue. Maybe it has to do more with education or some other parameter we aren't considering. Just my $.02.

Re: OT--overkill

#16

Re: Is there a label on Water?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I am a retired plumber...and do not understand just where this idea that lead from a soldier(sic) joint comes from.

Once the soldier is cooled and set there is no, IMHO, any leaking of any lead from it.

Re: OT--overkill

#17

Re: OT--overkill

Joseph Mulherin, sr

No matter what it is or where it is located on this world...if there is money to be made some jerk...be it either a good scientist or some paper clerk in and office...they think their "opinion" is a must for us to know about....either good or bad.....

Re: OT--overkill

#18

Re: data

Dave Bair

"Why is this law in CA and not in TN?"

Maybe it has to do with the ease of placing referenda on the ballot. People tend to vote differently than their representatives when politics and special-interest lobbying is not an issue. If you put it up to vote, a lot of things would change on any number of issues. Heck, Jack Daniels is produced in a county where it's illegal to buy it. Why is this law in TN and not CA?

Re: OT--overkill

#19

Re: Is there a label on Water?

Jesse Cloud

Joseph,

I wasn't talking about solder. Its the actual fixture itself.

Brass is a mixture of copper and zinc, but lead has historically been added to improve machinability. The FEDERAL (not California) regulation allows fixtures carrying drinking water to contain up to 8 per cent lead.

My understanding is that the lead in a new fixture's surfaces that actually contact water soon leaches out into the water that flows by, and that the lead away from the surface remains stable.

When the fixtures are brand new, they can add enough lead to drinking water to exceed federal standards for lead in water.

Sorry if I wasn't clear on that.

Re: OT--overkill

#20

Re: Is there a label on Water?

Barry Irby

Joseph, I don't have any actual chemical analysis data to prove or disprove lead in water, but from examining plumbing systems I can see how there might be. A properly soldered joint would have the space between the pipe and fitting filled with solder and there woudl be a tiny ring of solder visible on the interior. That joint woudl allow for a very small exposure of solder/lead int he water, essentially none. What I have seen on several occasions is the plumber ran so much solder into the joint that it ran two or three feet into the pipe. I have also seen copper pipe that was so eaten up by well water that a four foot long piece of it weighed almost nothing and was as thin as a soda straw and you could easily crush it between a thumb and forefinger. And there were about twenty "bandaids" of inner tube with a hose clamp on the rest of the system. The pipes had been reduced to copper foil. Any lead inside the pipes woudl have dissolved with it.

Re: OT--overkill

#21

Re: Is there a label on Water?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Barry, I, too have seen guys do as you said about putting too much solder into the joint. Using 95/5 it is easy to do. I learned early in my career in the plumbing how to solder using just the exact amount of

solder for each size joint.

Back in the 80s I was moved from one job to another job in a shopping mall(Macy's store) and did about 4,000 joints on pipe that had already been cut, cleaned and pasted up in the hangers about 12-15ft above the floor at places. Heated up the upper part of the 3" joints and ran the 95/5 solder into the joint and letting the solder run down the sides bugging out a little. Let cool on the upper portion and then heated the lower portion in a wave style drawing the exposed solder into the joint on each side of the bottom. No wasted solder too.

I figure I did about the 4,00 joints and had not one single leak using air to pressure prior to letting in water. All of them done and then it came down to soldering the control panel and I did have a problem with a 1/2" joint which I asked the foreman to do for me.

Re: OT--overkill

#22

Re: Is there a label on Water?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Yes, Jesse, I do now understand what you said and agree....just never thought of it back in those early days

Re: OT--overkill

#23

I have to agree...

John in NM

CA has gotten it's reputation for a reason.

In my experience, technical and scientific ignorance spans the political spectrum. The ignorant of different political leanings have their own hobby horses, but paranoia over chemical exposure is definitely in the left hand camp.

Unfortunately, I find that technical ignorance is most pronounced in our political animals. It does little harm in the average joe, but in politicians I find such gross ignorance of the world around them to be somewhat unforgivable.