Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

college degree

Posts

Re: college degree

#26

Re: Our MIT guy...

Jesse Cloud

Heard the one about the two Ivy Leaguers at the urinal?

A Harvard man and an MIT engineer were doing their business. The MIT guy finished first and started to leave.

The Harvard guy said "At Harvard, they we learned to wash our hands afterward."

The MIT guy replied "At MIT we learned not to pee on our hands."

Re: college degree

#27

Actually, I've heard that one...

John in NM

When I was in college a professor told me that joke as we were both washing our hands. At the time it seemed slightly creepy, as I didn't know the guy. Now it doesn't seem so.

Re: college degree

#28

Not last week...

John in NM

Weather's been good for a while, I've only had the chains on a couple times this year.

Observatory is several miles past the gate though, the dirt road won't re-open to the public until April 15th or so, that is when public tours of the site also start up again.

Whatever were you doing out here in the middle of nowhere? :D

I work at the radio telescope, btw.

Re: college degree

#29

Re: Not last week...

William Duffield

I was in Tucson on vacation. We were getting really tired of the winter we've been having on the East coast. We could see the telescopes from downtown, and from the National Park.

Re: college degree

#30

Aha...

John in NM

You were looking at Kitt Peak then, I work at another of the U of A's sites over in Cochise county, about 3 hours from Tucson.

Kitt Peak is much lower in elevation (6,000 feet or so) and rarely need 4wd let alone chains. Our staff tend to prefer going up there (we have a radio telescope there too) over coming to this site.

You can visit Kitt Peak year round, incidentally, paved road right to the observatory and a visitor's center when you get there.

Re: college degree

#31

Re: OTJ training....

BrianMonumentCO

OTJ can produce good results but require a synergy between the employee and some workers who teach what is needed.

Re: college degree

#32

Re: Our MIT guy...

BrianMonumentCO

I heard a different version about that and it works with any 3 universities or instutions works well with the military as well.

Institutions A, B and C have representatives at the urinals.

A starts to leave without washing his hands

B says at B that taught us to wash our hands after peeing

A says at A they taught us not to pee on our hands

C says at C they didn't have to teach us any of that.

Re: college degree

#33

That is a good one.


Re: college degree

#34

Re: Aha...

William Duffield

I got confused. I thought I read that you were an hour drive from Tucson. I was looking at Mt. Lemmon, where UA also has several telescopes. Also, it's Steward Observatory there is closer to 9000' than 10000' elevation.

Re: college degree

#35

That aint the half of it...

John in NM

If you want the whole run down :D

Steward is the operational end of the U of A's astronomy department, but usually we just refer to the whole mess as Steward Observatory.

We have telescopes at Kitt Peak, two peaks on Mt. Lemmon, Mt. Hopkins to the south of Tucson, and at Mt. Graham (where I work). Sites vary from 10,000' - Mt. Graham - to 6,500' or so at Kitt Peak. The other sites are in between.

Kitt Peak and Mt. Graham are the only sites where I've worked, we only have the two radio telescopes. The job I just interviewed for is at an optical scope in NM, run by NMSU.

Re: college degree

#36

Re: college degree, a view from one without

Grant in Iowa

The instructor in Jerry's observation likely had really only one perspective, and wouldn't likely know what (most) students went on to do after his course. He could, however, see readily those who took a trade school course of study after college, since they came through his doors. Therefore, I wonder if his perspective reflected the actual state of things.

I am a man who all through high school was told I must go to college to amount to anything in America. In high school, I tended towards Industrial arts, drafting, art, and similar hands on courses of study. I did OK at the sciences and mathematics, usually managing a "B" without working too hard. At risk of sounding conceited, I had been tested and qualified for MENSA, though I had no interest in actually joining the organization. Key to understanding the situation was that I came from a broken home with little chance that mom and dad would be of any help with college tuition.

I was lucky enough to enroll in a work study program, wherein I apprenticed at a local machine shop. The owner saw a spark of something in me and urged me to go to engineering school--robbing himself of a future machinist. I took the ACT test, and scored well enough to be offered a years tuition at a local Catholic college. The school at the time was making the change from being a predominantly all girl, to co-ed, but nobody asked the nuns who taught there what they thought about the change. They seemed (as I recall) to try to make things difficult for me and six months in I enlisted in to the Air Force and dropped out.

The US Air Force trained me in telecommunications and, after 12 years as an enlisted man, I declined to re-enlist and joined the corporate America work force. I made a good living, was as happy as any I suppose. 13 years in Corporate America was enough for me, so I found a non-profit to work for as a Facility Manager. I don't make as much, and I work longer hours, but I no longer feel like I am working to pay for some CEO's leer jet. Life is good when the cause is worthy.

What does this all mean? I can summarize by saying that college indeed is not for everyone. I could neither afford (there weren't many student loan opportunities back then), nor could I grasp the benefit of another four years of school at the time. I am fortunate to have enlisted, tested well on the ASVABs, been assigned to a lucrative career field that has served me well even today.

The Moral? If there is one, I would paraphrase Mike Rowe and say that everyone doesn't need to go to college to "get somewhere" in life. This is not to say young people don't need an education, just that college isn't always the right course for everyone. A college degree is no substitute for work experience.

On a related note, as a facility manager I often run up against degree'd engineers and architects who have no practical experience. This inexperience causes more blunders and stupid designs than I can count. I think Engineers should be required to work in a related trade for a period of time to gain practical knowledge before being state certified. Buildings and civil infrastructure would be much better in many ways if this were the case.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: college degree

#37

Re: college degree, a view from one without

Jesse Cloud

Good points!

I think we put way too much emphasis on trying to get everyone into college. We should take trade schools much more seriously and they should work with local employers to make sure their offerings fit current needs.

Amen to the idea that designers should have to work in the trades for a while. We would all be better off.

And the idea of a job for a cause rings true. I worked all my life in pretty lousy jobs - very political, some seemed to have no particular purpose, some just out-in-out silly but making a boss look good for a while. They paid well and I could retire early, but looking back I wish I had had a job I liked.

Re: college degree

#38

Proud father of four

John Foster

Just my take on education. My oldest three children are a portfolio manager at a retirement fund, an auto mechanic and a registered nurse. All of them had no trouble finding jobs, and make more money than I do. My youngest is in university taking diverse courses such as communications, theology, philosophy etc. I joke that I will have three trained children and one educated child ( who may be unemployed).

My take on things is that it beautifully colours our world to have creative and educated people in these liberal arts fields. We just have to remember that they are "our product" . We farmers, carpenters, miners, sailers,etc. etc etc. invented civilization so that some people would be free to pursue these enriching activities. Both sides have to remember that the cultured crowd are here to increase the worker bee's enjoyment of life; as opposed to thinking they are some sort of elite and looking down on us workers. Just my rant, I am all for the arts, just remember who makes it possible.

Re: college degree

#39

Re: college degree, a view from one without

Tony - Memphis

Well said!

I would, however, like to speak for those of us engineers who are not know it alls that assume our degree makes us smarter than everyone else. One thing college does, to quote a previous manager, is it makes us a sponge. We are trained to absorb. When I got out of college with an ME degree, I worked at a 'race car parts' company. There were lots of people there that knew more about lots of things than I ever will and I appreciated that and repsected them. I also worked as hard as I could to absorb as much of what they could teach me. Several of those guys never graduated high school, but they were smarter than most folks I know.

I've been an engineer for 26 years now and I still assume that I can learn something from everyone I meet. Most importantly, from the 'customers' I work for. I have learned that when you approach your customer and make THEM the expert, you get more of what you need to then go do YOUR job (which is often to support that customer). When I say customer, it could be an internal customer or a consumer, etc.

I believe in education. OJT is priceless -especialy when there is a worthy mentor. I've tried to impress upon nieces and nephews that whatever you want to do, go to school first. It will get you off to a much better start. We have a very good technical school here in town.

Funny, we had a family friend offering to mentor a nephew in plumbing. The nephew replied that he wasn't interested in shoveling... He was saying that to a plumber that made more money than me! Sad that the nephew was too ignorant to realize the oppurtunity there. Oh well.

I've enjoyed reading all the replies. We need to do something in this country. We are falling behind. I hate to see young people making life harder than it has to be.

I've been at the corporate thing for almost 20 years. I may got to the local tech school myself for my next phase. 20 years in Dilbertland is quite enough!

Tony

Re: college degree

#40

Re: college degree, a view from one without

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have had a similar experience, my father passed in 1952, a few months before my 11th birthday. He died from cancer of the trachea, most likely from mustard gas burns he acquired in WW1, all his army records were destroyed in a fire (he fought in the Spanish American conflict and spent 7 years in the Army during and after WW1), his exposure to Mustard gas happened when he was training a group in a gas mask exercise. As the records were destroyed we could not prove a service connected condition caused his death, so my mother & I were left with little financially.

I graduated HS in 1959 with more credits than anyone had had before. I was tested in HS and told by the teacher I had the highest IQ in the school. I attempted to enter Purdue, did all the testing, even visited a fraternity, I tested out of about 1 year of classes but could not obtain any aid or get a loan so went to work in Industry.

Long story short, I had several decent jobs in about 4 years then went to work for a large electromechanical manufacturer. I started as a Technician, within a year I was promoted to a Jr. Production Engineer.

Less than a year later I was again promoted to a full Engineer. During my 39+ years with the company I worked as a Process Engineer, Manufacturing Engineer, Project Engineer and Quality Engineer. During the last 4 years or so I was the Management Representative for our ISO and QS-9000 Quality System.

When I started my tenure the plant I worked in employed approximately 1200 people. A few years later, due to products from Mexico and China, we dropped several lines and went to less than 150, more than 15 Engineers were let go, I was retained. As we restructured, we went to about 500 employees. When I retired about 9 years ago there were about 400. Since then the production has been moved to China and the plant sold. However, I know I made near the same salary during my employment as the Engineers with BA's and some with MA's, considering I had no student loans and had had substantial earnings prior to my working there, my total earnings were probably higher than almost all of them.

During my life, I was unemployed for about 2 weeks after leaving HS until retirement. I drew 1 weeks unemployment in about 1960 (started in a factory the same day I graduated HS).

I was married twice and had custody (after a prolonged court fight) of my two sons, my second wife (now married 45 years) had three children and we had one for a total of six. So I did work two jobs (or more) for a large part of my working career. So during those times I was an Insured, bonded contractor, a State licensed Plumber, had a license to drive commercial trucks, and a bartenders license.

Re: college degree

#41

Plumber Story

Hank Knight

A hot shot corporate lawyer was annoyed by a leaky faucet in his expensive condo. He called a plumber who showed up promptly and, in 15 minutes, had the leak repaired. He presented the lawyer with a Bill for $75.00. Aghast, the lawyer said, "You only spent 15 minutes on this job and you charged me $75.00. That's $300.00/hour! I'm a lawyer and I don't make that much." The plumber smiled and said, "I didn't make that much when I was a lawyer either."

Re: college degree

#42

Re: college degree - Great posting !!!

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I read through the entire thread and read everyone's responses. This has to be one of the most interesting "Off Topic" postings I have seen here. Some great insight and backgrounds from all of you.

I don't want to get off on a rant but ..... a lot of what you all said should be taught today in our schools. A good dose of getting your hands dirty and learning a trade is worth just as much as a college degree in some cases.

Re: college degree

#43

Amen!


Re: college degree

#45

Re: Not About Qualifying for a Job

TomD

Completely true. Liberal arts degrees are to make you a more cultured person in a broad sense. People who worry about where the next buck is coming from, probably aren't from the right class anyway, and should consider something more practical. It's all about knowing who you are and where you belong. You already lost if you are trying to figure out what someone else wants to hire you.

Re: college degree

#46

Re: I've used my science degree a lot...

TomD

Everyone who is successful looks back from their perspective and wonders why more people couldn't have been like them. That isn't what faces people trying to figure out where to go from here. Sure someone got a job in plastics and got to punch a white collar clock for a lifetime, but maybe the next plastics graduate gets offshored right out of school, we will only know 40 years from now. So who do you want to be for the next 40 years. If you pick the obvious thing, you are in a large cohort. If you pick the unlikely thing, it's a crapshoot. Best thing is to be in the top 5%, and then you don't have to worry. I tell my kids to figure out how to destroy someone else's job, surprisingly little qualifications required if you know how the system works.

Re: college degree

#47

Re: I've used my science degree a lot...

TomD

"They used to say that a degree's primary purpose was to show that you have the ability to learn at a certain level."

Other than whatever it was in, it's main purpose is to show you belong in a certain class. Obviously a lot of us didn't go to the top private schools and all that, though I did. But the point if you didn't is to show you belong there anyway. So you need to either go to Harvard because your parents did, or because you are going to lead your year. Otherwise you should check out the cheapest state college you can find.

Re: college degree

#48

Re: Funny thing...

TomD

"Over the decades many employers have incorrectly concluded that a 4 year degree means you're smart, so you're the one they want."

Maybe, though that would be extraordinary. The graduate may do till smart shows up though. Macnamara, was a bit of a disaster, but his metrics might have really been what GM needed.

"What tipped the scale to the last one is that I was able to get summer jobs that actually paid well in geology and liked the work."

Finding work you like and will really embrace is a great gift from the universe.

"Most students have very little idea what kind of work they will do in their field."

I know what you mean, and it can be debilitating, but it is also part of the charm, your life isn't mapped out. Control is a dangerous illusion.

Re: college degree

#49

Re: Proud father of four

TomD

Good for you. When I started in the investment industry the two first CEOs I worked with were Philosophy majors. We have the non kleptocratic investment industry, for the most part.

Re: college degree

#50

Re: college degree - Great posting !!!

TomD

" A good dose of getting your hands dirty and learning a trade is worth just as much as a college degree in some cases."

I am reminded of FK's remark in the dovetail tape "Handwork is Production!" Which I would stretch to mean that the stuff that is thought to be impractical, actually runs the world.