Re: college degree, a view from one without
Grant in Iowa
The instructor in Jerry's observation likely had really only one perspective, and wouldn't likely know what (most) students went on to do after his course. He could, however, see readily those who took a trade school course of study after college, since they came through his doors. Therefore, I wonder if his perspective reflected the actual state of things.
I am a man who all through high school was told I must go to college to amount to anything in America. In high school, I tended towards Industrial arts, drafting, art, and similar hands on courses of study. I did OK at the sciences and mathematics, usually managing a "B" without working too hard. At risk of sounding conceited, I had been tested and qualified for MENSA, though I had no interest in actually joining the organization. Key to understanding the situation was that I came from a broken home with little chance that mom and dad would be of any help with college tuition.
I was lucky enough to enroll in a work study program, wherein I apprenticed at a local machine shop. The owner saw a spark of something in me and urged me to go to engineering school--robbing himself of a future machinist. I took the ACT test, and scored well enough to be offered a years tuition at a local Catholic college. The school at the time was making the change from being a predominantly all girl, to co-ed, but nobody asked the nuns who taught there what they thought about the change. They seemed (as I recall) to try to make things difficult for me and six months in I enlisted in to the Air Force and dropped out.
The US Air Force trained me in telecommunications and, after 12 years as an enlisted man, I declined to re-enlist and joined the corporate America work force. I made a good living, was as happy as any I suppose. 13 years in Corporate America was enough for me, so I found a non-profit to work for as a Facility Manager. I don't make as much, and I work longer hours, but I no longer feel like I am working to pay for some CEO's leer jet. Life is good when the cause is worthy.
What does this all mean? I can summarize by saying that college indeed is not for everyone. I could neither afford (there weren't many student loan opportunities back then), nor could I grasp the benefit of another four years of school at the time. I am fortunate to have enlisted, tested well on the ASVABs, been assigned to a lucrative career field that has served me well even today.
The Moral? If there is one, I would paraphrase Mike Rowe and say that everyone doesn't need to go to college to "get somewhere" in life. This is not to say young people don't need an education, just that college isn't always the right course for everyone. A college degree is no substitute for work experience.
On a related note, as a facility manager I often run up against degree'd engineers and architects who have no practical experience. This inexperience causes more blunders and stupid designs than I can count. I think Engineers should be required to work in a related trade for a period of time to gain practical knowledge before being state certified. Buildings and civil infrastructure would be much better in many ways if this were the case.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa