Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

college degree

Posts

college degree

#1

college degree

Jerry Gibbs

I didn't want to hijack another thread that referred to a college degree to operate a complicated workbench. I was at a woodworking lecture given by an instructor at a two year technical school, which had many technical programs. One of the instructor's constituents had asked him how many students went on to get a four year degree. He said the question was backwards. He had a lot of students with a four year degree that had returned to a technical school to get a job. (For what it's worth, I have a bachelor of arts in political science.) Jerry

Re: college degree

#2

Re: college degree

BrianMonumentCO

Jerry, At this point in time what do you do for a living?

And did you ever have a job that used your poly sci degree?

Re: college degree

#3

Re: college degree

Jerry Gibbs

Retired lawyer. Never used the poly sci degree except to get into law school.

Re: college degree

#4

Re: college degree

paul in AZ

I knew someone who taught at a hotel management/culinary school. He said they hardly ever had any graduates because the kids were snapped up before ever nearing graduation.

Re: college degree

#5

jobs and degrees *LINK*

Bob Lang

What is interesting is that we have a generation of kids that were told they would be losers if they didn't go to college that now have a pile of student loan debt and few prospects of ever landing a decent job. Unless they go for more schooling and additional loans to get a graduate degree.

On the flip side of that there are hundreds of thousands of jobs in industry, especially the woodworking industry, that go unfilled because there aren't enough young people with the technical skills and training to make the stuff that we still make.

The pendulum is starting to swing away from "everyone needs a college degree" back to "we need skilled people to make stuff and we need people to teach them how".

Interesting video about one guy who is doing that at the link below.

Bob Lang


Shop Class Success Story

Re: college degree

#6

Re: jobs and degrees

BrianMonumentCO

Aside from the students choosing relatively useless degrees, the system is flawed as you describe.

Useless degrees from my side of the street include such things as qualify one to work for the postal system as french literature, english literature, foreign history etc.

Kids should be encouraged to learn a trade if so inclined.

Electricians and plumbers make good money and it appears that their skill sets will never become truely obsolete. The building code may change.

But I think one of the problems is that most public schools have terminated their shop classes as being too dangerous and wrought with all manner of possibilities for lawsuits.

Re: college degree

#7

what is needed

Jerry Gibbs

Students need critical thinking, problem solving and the need to re-train/reinvent themselves as their fields evolve.

Re: college degree

#9

Not About Qualifying for a Job

Hank Knight

A college education shouldn't always be about qualifying for a job. I'm probably one the few people left who still believe in the value of a liberal arts education. Not only does it give you a broad understanding of and appreciation for our culture, it gives you the tools and background to enjoy the finer aspects of life. I also think it helps in any field to be able to write a complete sentence with correctly spelled words that expresses a thought clearly and concisely. That skill is becoming hard to find these days. If you're going to spend four years to get a college degree, you might as well get one you can use and enjoy your whole life.

Re: college degree

#10

I've used my science degree a lot...

John in NM

While I understand and agree with you to some degree, I still think that a non-vocational degree is a luxury. I pursued a bs in geology and had a job right out of school. That degree got me my current job, which may be what gets me the one I just interviewed for - a big step up in responsibility and pay.

Never would have gotten any of that with a degree in creative writing or whatever. Job market wasn't as bad then as now, but it wasn't too good either (Bush 1 recession, 1994 or so).

I found the arts and sciences elective courses to be exactly what you say, very broadening and interesting, and I wouldn't have missed them for the world. But I never would have considered a degree in one of them - couldn't afford to spend 4 years and thousands (back then) on a degree which would not lead to a job.

I remember people telling me not to view college as a white collar voc school. Seemed a pretty silly thing to say then, as it does now. Fine advice if wealthy parents are footing the bill, but for the rest of us it isn't worth going unless it is a white collar voc school. Kind of sad to see so many grads these days who didn't seem to understand that.

Re: college degree

#11

Re: I've used my science degree a lot...

Bill Howatt

Yes, it has become a white-collar vocational school for the most part. However, I did hear of as study a few years ago that said the earning power of liberal arts degree holders was actually very good in comparison. That said, I can still see the problem of getting the first job.

They used to say that a degree's primary purpose was to show that you have the ability to learn at a certain level. True but it has to be factored in with the other side of the coin which is the employers. Especially in today's business they want a new employee to produce and not embark on a further education program so they can function in the company.

Having said that, there is a difference in working these days compared to what it was decades ago. Few people in white-collar jobs will retire doing the job they were started with or were even trained for. The days of starting and ending with a single company are getting rarer. They may stay within the same company, particularly if a large company, but their duties will change and will often look like a career change. This is where the ability to learn comes in and forward thinking companies will look at a potential new hire not just for the current opening but where their abilities may take them in the company in the future.

But getting that first job is still the hurdle.

Bill

Re: college degree

#12

Re: I've used my science degree a lot...

Hank Knight

John,

I don't disagree with you at all, at least for those folks who know what they want to do with theit lives when they enter college. For those, a focused degree leading to a job in their chose profession is ideal. There are many, however, and I was one, who have no clue what they want to do with their lives. For those, I think a general or liberal arts degree is the better choice. They can re tool later when their world focus becomes clearer. That's what I did. I began as a pre med chemistry person. Hated it and ended up with an English/history double major and went to law school when I was 30, after the Army and a stint in a manufacturing management job. Perhaps a liberal arts degree is a luxury for many. It wasn't for me. I was raised to believe in the value of a college educationand I ended up paying my own way through much of undergrad school and all of law school. I have enjoyed my liberal arts education to this day. It directs my interests, travel and reading habits. I've never regretted switching to a liberal arts degree program, and I've never found it an impediment. But that was 50 years ago. I think things are much different these days. If 4 year college has become the new tech school, I think that's too bad and a loss for our culture.

Re: college degree

#13

Funny thing...

John in NM

To me at least.

One of my grandfathers was a civil engineer who never graduated from high school - he got expelled for arguing with the math teacher about math. Went on to work in construction and quickly moved up to the office level, calculating how much material was needed for various aspects of building hydro-electric projects.

I would say that the loss to our culture is the understanding that education does not equal intelligence. Over the decades many employers have incorrectly concluded that a 4 year degree means you're smart, so you're the one they want. Were it not for that, I would agree with you that there is no reason not to get a liberal arts degree if one did not have a specific career path in mind.

I didn't know what I wanted to do at the start of college either. Started out in architecture, moved on to engineering and then geology. What tipped the scale to the last one is that I was able to get summer jobs that actually paid well in geology and liked the work. Most students have very little idea what kind of work they will do in their field.

Re: college degree

#14

Re: Not About Qualifying for a Job

BrianMonumentCO

The biggest problem with the liberal arts degree is that is leaves you qualifed to do NOTHING but deliver the mail. (sorry to all the mailpersons out there.) The first thing that should be happening at a college fresh out of high school is to learn something that will get the student his/her first job. After that where they go is up to them to shape their future with additional education either formal or just simply reading and practicing.

Realistically, when I was a technical lead looking for programmer, I rarely looked at those with liberal degrees unless they came with substantial experience in the programming area. Yet there are people who have worked their way into a job that their education would not appear to be suited for. I knew a guy that had a biology degree and was headed for med school (never made it) and he was the manager/tech lead of the unix group at a company I worked at. He knew his stuff yet his degree didn't show it. I doubt I would have selected his resume out of a pile without the experience showing on his resume. Bottom line is that the degrees tend to mean less as time goes by. And experience means more as time progresses.

I am not a fan of liberal arts degrees.

Modern liberalism is not good.

Look to John Locke for true liberalism.

Re: college degree

#15

Re: what is needed

Jim Hoeller

As a nation, we are in desperate need for individuals capable of critical analysis. Just look at the current members of Congress.

Re: college degree

#16

Two Things

Hank Knight

I absolutely agree that a college doesn't mean you're smart. I know some pretty dumb people that have college degrees. What it may mean is that the degree holder has a good work ethic, especially if the degree is backed up by a good academic record. Sure, there are a few smart people who can tiptoe through college, doing little work, and still end up with a degree. But for the more pedestrian majority, achieving a 4 year college degree requires a lot of hard work.

Hiring is basically a crap shoot. There are few reliable indicators as to how a candidate will perform in a job. A 4 year degree with a good academic record tells me, as a potential employer, that the candidate is at least capable of sustained, productive effort in a competitive environment. That's a positive indicator in my book. A good work ethic is far more important to me than a demonstration that the person is familiar with the technical aspects of a job.

Second, I don't mean to suggest that a liberal arts degree is for everybody, only that it is still a viable option in our society.

Hank

Re: college degree

#17

Two More Things

Hank Knight

I think there there are a number of jobs for which a technical background is necessary, or, at least, highly desirable. Few employers these days are willing to invest the resources necessary to train a raw recruit to do a technical job. I would submit, however, that a raw recruit , regardless of the nature of his or her college degree, with a good work ethic and a desire to learn the job will make a better employee over the long run than a whiz bang tech school grad with training in the field and a poor work ethic. I believe that a person's work ethic is the most important factor in his or her success in a job.

Certainly knowledge of the technical aspects of a job are essential to success and if a person doesn't have and can't get that knowledge, the person cannot perform the job. Over the years we have turned over the responsibility for imparting technical knowledge to our institutions of higher learning. They have become, and are regarded by many, as training schools. The focus of modern higher education is increasingly narrow. I fear that our culture will suffer, and has already suffered, as a result, becoming less colorful and intellectually constricted. I think that's sad.

Second, if you are equating a liberal arts education with "modern liberalism," you're missing the point and far off base. I know many very successful people with liberal arts degrees who are staunch "modern conservatives."

Re: college degree

#18

Re: Two More Things

BrianMonumentCO

Work ethic is real important. Yet how does an interviewer know/learn that a person has a good one.

Very hard to do and as you said in another post hiring is a crap shoot.

As for liberalism, My view of what could be taught in a liberal arts curricula could impart modern liberal concepts that are well, USELESS. Many of the classes would appear not to be routed in science or other firm disciplines and that leaves the mushy emotional feel good nonsense that is associated with many liberal arts programs.

You are right if you believe that I went to a top engineering school. If you were not studying engineering, math, physics, chemistry, computer science or even architecture, you were a slacker. Management degrees were for hockey players who weren't allowed enough study time or who knew they were headed for a career in the nhl. The liberal arts degrees what few were awarded were viewed as well ............ I don't want to say.

I suppose that makes me a technical snob of some sort..... I guess I accept that.

I do in a way look down at liberal arts degrees as useless. I have yet to see any counter proof to that concept. I am still looking. If you have counter proof, I would be interested in seeing it.

My premise is what value is a liberal arts degree in the real world? What does it teach you?

Re: college degree

#19

Re: what is needed

BrianMonumentCO

I would rather not look at congress for anything other than a lesson in corruption, stupidity, laziness and greed.

Re: college degree

#20

Re: college degree

Jesse Cloud

There's no easy answer in recruiting. Most of my life, I've worked in technical areas and I've run across more than a few Harvard and MIT nuclear physicists who new reactors inside out but couldn't make a piece of toast without help. Though most tech graduates are capable of critical thinking, a tech degree is not a guarantee of that ability.

The best computer guy I ever hired came to me straight out of a graduate theology program. In the interview he seemed bright and asked good questions. He turned into the best programmer in the company in a few years. I asked him why he thought theology prepared him for that and he said he was taught there to see several sides of any question and to evaluate the soundness of several possible answers. While the other programmers jumped right in to coding, this guy thought about it for a while and came up with solid systems that did exactly what the client wanted, with no false starts or surprises.

Re: college degree

#21

My advice to high school seniors...

Joe Pack

I used to tell high school seniors, "If your dream is to major in modern dance and minor in marine biology, go for it! Follow your dreams! But learn to weld, too."

They got the idea...at least most of them did.

Re: college degree

#22

Re: college degree

BrianMonumentCO

Make no mistake, some Harvard and MIT grads cannot tie their own shoes.

As far as SW development,there are several key factors to building successful systems in my view;

1. persons who understand what is required by the customer in spite of any documents. Requirement docs are notoriously hard for anyone to write. let alone get correct.

2. a "oneness" of design. IE a central designer.

3. the rest of the crew/team need to understand what they are building and their roles. Not all developers can be the central figure.

4. Having enough time to;

A. understand the project

B. design a solution

C. code the solution

D. integrate and test the solution

E. user acceptance testing

This all leads me to the conclusion that xtreme programming or something like it is more useful than many are inclined to believe.

Re: college degree

#23

Our MIT guy...

John in NM

An electrical engineer who always jacks the truck up to put chains on it :D

5 minute task that now takes 30 minutes!

Re: college degree

#24

OTJ training....

John in NM

I'm convinced that what got me the first telescope job was extensive work at remote sites (in Mexico mostly). The boss knew I wouldn't get lonely on a mountain an hour from Tucson, as so many of our more delicate hires tend to do.

Other than that, I knew nothing of astronomy, and less of radio at the time of hire. The ability to learn OTJ is vital in weird fields, no one comes out with a bachelor's prepared to do this job.

Re: college degree

#25

Re: Our MIT guy...

William Duffield

I've finally figured out where you work, but not which telescope. When I was out there last week, would I have needed chains to get to the observatory? I now understand that it is a popular scenic drive, but I didn't know it last week.