Re: COSTCO???
Alex Grigoriev
Most modern fixtures (except for total cheapo ghetto ones) have electronic ballast, which is flicker-free.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: COSTCO???
Alex Grigoriev
Most modern fixtures (except for total cheapo ghetto ones) have electronic ballast, which is flicker-free.
Re: Warning
Randy Johnson
I have replaced hundreds of ballasts over the years and have no idea what you are talking about, unless.....
Are you talking about starters? Small aluminum cylinders with two prongs on one end? It would have to be an old fixture to have one.
As long as the first operation is disconnecting the hot lead ( and making sure not to take apart the neutrals if they feed through) changing a ballast is about as easy as an electrical repair can get. Unless you have to do as I did once and replace about twenty in a supermarket where there was something under almost all of them.
Re: In defense of Ray
William Duffield
I notice that my Freud blades make a lot less noise than my WWII, especially when they are in the wood, but I can still hear them, even with the DC going and my hearing protection on. My old DeWalt radial arm saw is a horse of a different feather. After I've turned it off it is completely silent, but the blade takes maybe 4 or 5 minutes to spin down, and I can only see it from way around at the left side.
Re: Gonna Pass
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Did a comparison between the Costco light and a "traditional" 4' light with T12 daylight F-tubes. The LED comes in at 3700 lumens while the pair of T-12s put out 5300 lumens. New fixture + 2 (18yr. rated) tubes costs under $30 as opposed to $40 for the subject LEDs.
For me, the extra $10 ain't no thing, but the 1600 lumens of light output is the deciding factor for these aging eyes.
Re: COSTCO???
Jim Orasky
I purchased one of these shop lights last time COSTCO stocked them (about 2 months ago). The light they produce is very even and adequately bright to mount on an eight foot ceiling over a bench.
The biggest drawback is the way they are wired. You have to use the corded plug they provide. You cannot mount them via a junction box.
They are also not the easiest lights to hang. They provide a cable mount to hang them or you can use the "keyed" slots to flush mount them. If you choose to flush mount them you cannot remove the cover to mark the holes. The holes are actually in the end caps, and when you remove the end caps, you cannot use them to mark. You have to measure to mark the holes (not always fun when you are work overhead.
Bottom line - I will not be buying any more.
Hope this helps
when buying lights one is buying LIGHT
Thanks
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
More evidence to stay with what I have and just upgrade the lamps
Re: Cheap Shop Lighting Upgrade
William Duffield
With the regulatory demise of T12 fluorescent lighting fixtures, y’all might be interested in my solution to the problem, and to other related annoyances related to shop lighting technology.
About 6 years ago, even before federal regulations began to force the replacement of T12 fluorescent lighting fixtures, I began the retrofit of my shop lighting fixtures from T12 to CFL technology. I was annoyed with the failure rate of both the ballasts and the bulbs, with the slow startup in cold weather, with the limited color temperature choices, with the hum and flicker, etc.
There are some other advantages of the upgrade path I took vs. the recommended upgrade to either T8 or T5 fluorescent tubes. CFLs are more easily replaced. No longer do I have to worry about replacing ballasts, since the ballast is contained within each CFL bulb. I can mix and match wattage and color balance within the same fixture to get exactly the intensity and color I want from a particular fixture, and as the next technology advancement (e.g., LEDs) becomes cost effective, all I have to do is replace the individual CFL bulbs as they burn out with newer, cheaper, more energy efficient and more reliable LED bulbs. Just like with the T12 to T8 or T12 to T5 conversions, all the 4 foot, two tube fixtures I’ve already installed get hung up and plugged in the same place they’ve alway been, on the same breakers, same switches, same pull cords, etc.
A warning: Could I get UL and CSA approval for this? Probably not. Are they safe? I haven't had any problems.
Here’s one of the modified fixtures, from my shop about six years ago.

To convert to one of these, you will need a half dozen of these:

Leviton Model 167, medium base. I suppose you could use four or five, or seven or eight, but six seems about right to me. Six typical “100 watt equivalent” watt CFLs provide 1600 lumens each, so six provide 9600 lumens, using 138 watts of power. If that's too much light for that place in your shop, use 60 watt or 75 watt equivalent bulbs instead.
You can find these at your local Borg, or buy them in bulk off the internet.
Here's an Orange Borg sku code:

or order them online from several sources, where I've found them in boxes of 25 for less than $60.
You will need some tools, including one of these:

to drill 5/8" diameter pilot holes, to accept the mandrel of one of these:

available from Harbor Fright. The set is about $25, but they're sometimes on sale for $20. None of the failures described in the reviews occurred on my set, although it has been used to convert several fixtures in my shop and other shops.
http://www.harborfreight.com/knockout-punch-kit-91201.html
You will need a socket wrench, or at least a crescent wrench, to operate the knockout punch.
For each fixture, you will need about 7 ft. of 12 AWG stranded insulated copper wire. As shown in my photos, I originally used some 16 AWG lamp cord. Although so far, I haven’t had any problems with it, I can’t recommend it, because the 167 sockets specify either 12 AWG or 14 AWG stranded (not solid) wire. The smaller diameter lamp cord may have problems making proper contact with the fixture’s pins, which could cause overheating and failure of the smoke test. Always follow the manufacturer’s recommendations.
Unplug the fixture, remove and recycle the tubes, the tombstones and the ballast. Keep the electrical cord, the switch, the pull chain, the ground wire, wire nuts, etc. Drill six 5/8” diameter holes with the titanium step drill in the reflector or the metal fixture case. Neatness counts. Mount the 1-1/4” punch in each hole, and enlarge the hole to 1-1/4” diameter. Disassemble the sockets. Discard the galvanized steel hook. Secure each socket to the holes in the reflector with hot melt glue. Some recommend epoxy instead, but so far, the hot melt glue has held in all my fixtures.






Re: Shop lights
Mark Philippi
I replaced 8 4 foot flourescent fixtures with the COSTCO $40 LED units. They seem great. I think they are 3700 Lumens and 4000 degrees.
They have been up about 8 weeks so far no complaints.
Wow, now there's an article
Re: Wow, now there's an article
William Duffield
You're welcome to use it.
I know that by posting it on the forum, you automatically get copyrights to it. Who is on your article editing and formatting staff? You have my e-mail address, so just let me know if you need any of the description clarified, and if the photos make sense. The fixtures are easy to unplug, take down, open up, photograph and reinstall. I'm getting ready to convert a couple more fixtures, if more photos of the process are needed.
After they've been converted to CFLs, reconverting them to LEDs is as easy as falling off a log.
I know it's buried a little deeply in this kind-of-related thread, but it seemed like a logical place to put it, and the discussion prodded me to finally finish and post it. At least one of the photos was taken in 2008, and I started writing the description in 2012. You're welcome to bump it to the top of a new thread if you think it warrants more exposure.
Re: Shop lights
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Personally I will just replace any lights that have the ballast fail. Unlike Bill, I have had zero problems with the "cheap" shop light fixture ballasts. I have replaced many ballasts when the fixture cost warrants the labor, however I have about 20 double bulb 4' fixtures with average cost of about $10 each. All are at least 10 years old and none have had a ballast fail yet. I did have a couple fail in a storage room, but as I recall the fixtures were used when I installed them. I installed new $10 shop lights.
I only have one expensive 4' fixture in my utility room that warrants ballast replacement (over $100 new). When I built my shop I installed switched duplex receptacles in the ceiling, the lights are hung with chains and hooks so replacement will be a 10 minute job (figuring 5 min to get the ladder). All are instant start ~ I have installed the "daylight" temperature T8 bulbs, the blue tint helps me see better at my age.
Hmm, article staff?
Ellis Walentine
That would be me myself and I. I'll put this together asap, good lord willin and the creek don't rise.
As for copyright, you retain copyright to all your words and pictures here. All I get is ongoing non-exclusive rights to use posted material. I can't transfer any of those rights to anyone else; only you can do that.
Thanks for a very nice article, William.
Ellis
Re: Warning
TomD
Yeah, that would be it. Didn't take you long to imagine it, don't sell yourself short. If I am not mistaken that is a pun.
Re: Hot, hot, not...
TomD
"Put a 60W or 100W equivalent LED bulb in a table lamp and let it run for about 10-15 minutes. Now tightly grab the base of the lamp near the socket and then come back and tell me there was no heat generated - actually, you had better touch it delicately. They do generate heat and for that reason most are not rated for putting in enclosed fixtures."
Actually the one I have on the table next to me is not hot in the socket at all, but the "bulb" is hot. The problem seems to be that each replacement bulb needs it own transformer to get the supply in the right zone for the bulb. On can do a number of things about this, but I don't have a recommendation. What we may need is a world where the supply is in the same form as the bulb wants to run at, or where a super efficient remotely located, or useful to the heating of the house, transformer could be placed for a range of lighting. Some house are set up with home runs and maybe the ones serving lights could be converted to 12v or whatever.
I would also like to know when they say a bulb is 5 w does that include losses to the transformer? I will have to borrow the library current monitor and see what the whole mess draws. Because if it really is only 5W, the heat is probably not too severe.
I recently bought these two terribly cute bulbs for old singer sewing machines. They are corn lights, and about the size of a slightly shortened AA cell. The protection for the corn rows is silicon rubber, not glass, though it looks like a "bulb". They run direct off 110, it seems, they do not get hot, and they kick out 3W which is relatively blinding. The old 15w bulbs scared many a housewife who just wanted to better dress here family and home. If a person mistakenly installed the 25w version it burned the paint off the sewing machine. We are a long way from that with the replacements.
Re: Most workshop safety is (mostly) total BS
TomD
There are government rules on strobe related issues, but so far not on SawStop. I have only had a few accidents in the workshop in 50 years, all of which, except a kickback problem, were way out on the edge of the Bell curve.
I just didn't understand the post, sorry.
Re: I just didn't understand the post, sorry.
William Duffield
Sorry, let me try again to elucidate my points. We were discussing points of whether whether being able to hear the blade turning was of any help in warning you to keep your fingers out of the way. Mark also mentioned hearing loss. Of course the noise generated by a table saw contributes to long term hearing damage. That can be reduced some by using Freud blades instead of Forrest blades, because the Freud blades are quieter. Quieter blades, however, can reduce the sense of danger, if other mitigating circumstances, including dust collectors and air filters running, Metallica playing in the background, wearing hearing protection, etc., disguise the noise of the saw. After power has been removed from the saw blade, it can continue to turn. Table saw blades, at least the ones in my experience, usually come to a stop within a few seconds. However, that is not the case for all saws. A case in point is my old DeWalt radial arm saw, which has no dynamic breaking, or belt and pulleys to slow it down. A spinning blade, even one not under power, can still do substantial damage to your hands. The RAS is particularly dangerous since it makes no noise at all after power has been removed, and the blade cannot even be seen if you are standing in front or to the right of the saw head, due to the blade guard and other parts of the saw head obstructing your view.
False: Warning
Lee Schierer in McKean, PA
The starter (which is simply a timed switch) allows current to flow through the filaments at the ends of the tube.
The current causes the starter's contacts to heat up and open, thus interrupting the flow of current. The tube lights.
There is no residual charge in the old style starters it is simply a switch.
Lee
Re: False: Warning
Alex Grigoriev
In a dual bulb fixture, one is using an inductor for ballast, another is using a capacitor. The capacitor will keep charge when the fixture is turned off.
Re: False: Warning
Lee Schierer in McKean, PA
I believe he was referring to one of these, which does not contain a capacitor.
Lee
Re: Costco LED
Bruce Mack
It took a while for the local stores to resupply with the Feit LEDs. As mentioned, they are rated at 3700 lumens. I installed two units today. They come fully assembled with the 2 light tubes in place. The supplied short hang cables are braided and plastic coated. There is a metal connector with a notched waist that snaps securely into the top surface of the light near each end. A loop slips over the threaded eye bolt you supply and screw into the joist. The LED units are lightweight and hang straight. To my eyes the illumination is about that of a 2 tube T8 fluorescent fixture. Interestingly Feit has obtained a warmth of 5000K I believe, warmer than I expected. I actually prefer a colder light in my shop. Current price $40.
Re: Costco LED-Rebates *LINK*
Tom Dunlap
Your local utility might have a rebate for these or other lights.
Rebates
Re: Costco LED
Alex Grigoriev
"warmer" light tone means lower color temperature. I'm not sure if you actually want "colder" light of 6000K, which is clear day sunlight.
Re: Costco LED
Bruce Mack
You are right, and when I bought 6500 K fluorescents I did so tentatively. Though the light is stark and clinical it seems brighter than the warmer tubes and I see better in the shop. I can't explain this but invite the comments of others.