Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Shop lights

Posts

Shop lights

#1

Shop lights

Paul Blackwell

When I built my basement shop about 2 years ago, I bought and installed ten 4' fluorescent fixtures. Recently one of them goes out shortly after turning them on. I took it apart yesterday and made sure the connections were tight, but it goes out about 30 seconds after turning it on. If I turn the switch off for ten seconds or so and turn it back on, it lights but goes out after 20-30 seconds. Is this a bad ballast? I've tried replacing the bulbs, with the same results. I haven't located the exact ballast the unit has, but they appear to be about half the cost of a new fixture. Worth installing a new ballast assuming that is the problem?

Re: Shop lights

#2

Re: Shop lights

Bruce Mack

Hijack. You might consider a LED fixture. Costco is advertising a Feit fixture with 2 LED lights for $40. It's not yet in my local stores but I will buy two to check them out in my workshop/cave. The Alaska Woodworker has a very favorable review today.

Re: Shop lights

#3

Re: Shop lights

John in NM

Yes, it sounds like a ballast to me, short of some kind of weirdness happening in the wiring connections or the bulb sockets themselves. That kind of weird open connection or short is really rare, but they do happen now and then.

The ballast is half the cost of a fixture, or even 3/4 sometimes, because the ballast is pretty much the fixture. Other than sheet metal, some plastic bulb sockets, wire and paint - all cheap stuff compared to a transformer where the bulk of the materials live (most of it copper).

Myself, I hate working on these fixtures. I installed outlets in my ceiling so I could replace the fixture when it broke rather than waste time and energy on servicing a $20 lamp. But that's just me :D

You can probably guess how I would approach your problem! :D :D :D

Re: Shop lights

#4

Dammit...

John in NM

I'm going to town today too.... going to have to swing by Costco. I hate going to Costco :D

Those lamps sound too cool to pass up a look at if they have them. Thanks!

Re: Shop lights

#5

Re: Shop lights

John E in SC

Last time I checked the price of a new ballast for the 8' fixtures I have in my shed, the ballast was within $0.37 of a the whole new fixture! I splurged on the extra 37 cents.

Re: Shop lights

#6

why and how to replace the ballast

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My experience is that cheap shop lights come with cheap ballasts. A quality replacement will likely last forever.

replacing a ballast is trivial, once you get past getting the correct ballast. Buy a box of grey wire nuts, and a stripper. Cut off the leads from the failed ballast, remove it, screw in the new one, strip wire ends and wire nut the pieces together. 5 min and done. Add pull chain switches at this time where handy to have them.

Re: Shop lights

#7

COSTCO???

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Anybody have any experience with the LEDs they're advertising? I'm in a position to do some replacing of fixtures and $40 a pop with light sources I can pass to my heirs sounds interesting.

Re: Shop lights

#8

Re: Warning

TomD

Not about anything Bill said, but there is a little capacitor or booster in the fixture. I remember once telling my dad not to touch the ends of the thing as he was taking it out. To which he said something like "what? these things?" and touched them. Sometimes the capacitor is separate, and sometimes it is built in, and there are apparently circuits that can limit the hazard in some. If separate, it looks like a small battery. Just don't touch the contact.

Re: Shop lights

#9

Re: COSTCO???

Bruce Mack

I just drove to my second Costco. I live in the Minneapolis area. The associate told me they quickly sold out their last batch, albeit only 60.

Re: Shop lights

#10

more to buying than price

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

metrics for buying shop light.

1.presumably one is buying to get the light. So compare light output in lumens.

2. Lamp and electronics life. Who knows on this new stuff.

3. Color temperature and a confusing measure of how well the lamp renders the color. For example I prefer light to look like the sun in my windowless shop.

Re: Shop lights

#11

Re: COSTCO???

TomD

No experience with that stuff, but I have replaced most of the bulbs in the house with LEDs, and finally after quite a long wait, we have some that are just great. The Province gave a subsidy, and it operated through the dollar store, so that was good, though the charge was something like 6 bucks. The bulbs were very bright, dimmable, none of the early adopter problems. I have also been buying lamps off ebay where they come direct from china with free shipping. Recently bought two sewing machine light replacements. Brighter, solid, no breakable bulbs; cute as a button; Generate no discernible heat. The stock bulbs always presented a burning hazard, which could even peel the paint. And this really is a case where the bulbs can be passed on to the kids. The bulbs are so nice I wish I could come up with a project for them.

I am not sure, but I think one benefit for them in the shop is that you do not have the synchronization issue where the light is really flickering, and can at times make a high speed turning object, like a TS blade, look like it is standing still. Is that correct?

Re: Shop lights

#12

Strobe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I have had flor-tubes for 20 years and have never experience that alleged effect. I strongly suspect an internet mythe. Consider: A table saw is anything BUT silent. You'd have to be deaf not to know the machine was operating.

Re: Shop lights

#13

Re: Shop lights

Tony - Memphis

I replaced all the ballasts in my lights (4 footers) over the last year. I had the "old" kind and replaced them with the newer electronic ballasts and T8 bulbs. The twin bulb ballasts I bought were Phillips? from Lowes. It took about ten minutes tops to replace the ballast. What a difference! In fairness, the bulbs were old, so that was part of it. But the new ballasts are more efficient and they turn on instantly.

So, in short, I would try swapping the ballast.

Tony

Re: Shop lights

#16

A table saw is anything BUT ???

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

What internet mythe? Table saw is anything BUT silent? Can you explain? I'm a little slow sometimes and don't always get it. I don't mean to be mean, I seriously just don't understand.

p.s. too many people on the "intrenetweber" thingy are mean, it's not my style. :)

Re: Shop lights

#17

Ray

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The mythe is that a flickering florescent light will act like a strobe to make the spinning TS blade appear to be stopped, leading to someone touching it or laying something on it leading to serious personal injury. So with that in mind . .

Go to the shop. After making sure the area is clear, turn on your saw. Can you not HEAR it running? Can you not HEAR the whistling air generated by the spinning blade? Can you honestly tell me that you cannot tell if the thing is running?

If you can tell the machine is running, why would you ever expect to be able to touch that spinning blade because of some flickering light bulb?

Re: Shop lights

#18

Re: Shop lights

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I'm going to Costco tonight. Co-worker told me our local Costco has them.

If they do, I am buying one. I want to try it.

Re: Shop lights

#19

Re: COSTCO???

Bill Howatt

Put a 60W or 100W equivalent LED bulb in a table lamp and let it run for about 10-15 minutes. Now tightly grab the base of the lamp near the socket and then come back and tell me there was no heat generated - actually, you had better touch it delicately. They do generate heat and for that reason most are not rated for putting in enclosed fixtures.

Some people are more sensitive than others to florescent lamp flicker but I never notice at all unless a lamp is on it last legs and this is a gross flicker. The 60Hz flicker where you might see a strobe effect is very little in modern lamps because of improved internal coatings that cause the glow to linger as the line goes through zero volts.

Bill

Re: Shop lights

#20

In defense of Ray

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

with the dust collection on or anything else on you can not hear that my saw is running. The blade does not make a sound, just the motor. ( I do have one blade that screaks) That said, the modern electronic ballasts do not flicker so there can be no strobe effect. And, I never saw the effect when I had magnetic ballasts that did flicker.

Re: Shop lights

#21

Re: Strobe

TomD

I have seen it. I don't think it is a myth. But you have the wrong scenario. It isn't that the saw is running full blast, making a lot of noise and someone reaches for the blade. Which actually happens without fluro lights, which is part of why we have Saw Stop. What happens is you turn off the saw, presumably look somewhere else like the switch, then you are planing to change the blade, say. As you look back at the freewheeling saw blade, it for a second or two appears to be still so you go about your work, and whack you get a bad cut. It had spooled down to maybe 100 rpm, or whatever synchronizes, and it was still being driven by a motor that weighed tens or even a hundred pounds, at that speed, still very nasty.

I think the issue is more of a concern when dealing with low speed power, like a lot of machine shop processes. There, cutting may proceed at low rates of speed, and the motors have reduction gearing where the result of an accident can be a lot worse than loosing a finger. The UK standards (first found) address this stuff. They note, as I knew, that the effect can be offset, but I have been in shops, where for economy the only lighting was fluorescent.

http://www.healthandsafetyworksni.gov.uk/health_and_safety_in_engineering_workshops_hsg129.pdf

page 16

Actually. My current lathe came with a task lamp that the sophisticated guy who ran it had filled with a fluorescent twisty bulb. It may be a special one such as bill mentioned, I have never seen a strobe with it. I have mixed lighting in the shop. I see no particular ongoing advantage to fluorescent tubes.

Humility is the way to approach accidents. Of course everyone who gets hurt is an idiot, didn't know what they were doing, or wasn't paying attention. All that really does to help is ensure that if one is in an accident one suffers a simultaneous mental injury.

Re: Shop lights

#22

Re: In defense of Ray

Barry Irby

I have an assortment of scavenged light fixtures in my shop. Many 4' fluorescents with dying ballasts. Never notices my TS blade appear to strand still, but I do use the strobe effect to a good end. My Perfomax has one of those power take off sprocket things that transfers the power form the motor to the shaft of the drum. It has alternating black and white rectangular teeth. When sanding, I watch the connector. I can judge the speed of the shaft by the strobe effect. Sometimes they appear to be turning "forward", sometimes the stand still and sometimes they appear to go backward. Kind of like the spokes on the wagon wheels on the old westerns on the old TV's. (OMG! How Old am I?) I can tell if the Performax is dogging down by watching the shaft. I adjust the depth of the cut to keep the speed up. Or adjust the feed rate.

Re: Shop lights

#23

Re: Shop lights

Barry Irby

I did not see them at our local Costco. I did look at a bunch of led bulbs there, but did not see any four footers.

At a local freight auction I did see a bunch four foot led'd made to go into troughs in drop ceilings. Tried to buy the pile but was out bid at $500. Another guy got a pile of "stuff" an got four of them. By the time I tracked him down he had sold them for $25. I would have given him $25 Each. The auction is monthly. I will be watching for more. These listed for $99 each retail.

Re: Shop lights

#24

Re: In defense of Ray

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

A. I'm not attacking Ray. No defense needed.

B. I'm impressed with such a quite saw. My cab saw (3hp JET) runs very smoothly. I've got significant hearing loss in the upper ranges. I have a 2 hp DC plus an ambient air cleaner running when working in the shop, but I have no trouble hearing the table saw when it's running (without my tin ears in place).

Re: Shop lights

#25

Strobe is (mostly) total BS

Alex Grigoriev

There are the following mitigating factors:

1. An induction motor is actually not turning at exactly 3600 rpm (60 per second). If it's 3500 rpm, then even with ideal strobing its would have appeared to make >1 turn in a second.

2. Each strobe of an individual tube lasts long enough so that a blade will not appear standing even if it turns at exactly mains frequency. Motion smear will be present. There are 2 strobes per mains period, also.

3. In dual tube fixtures with old school non-electronic ballast, there are an inductor and a capacitor. They make the bulb flicker with different phase, which reduces their summary flicker.