Anyone done box finger joints in plywood? I have to make a 48"x20"x10" box that will be suspended at the corners. The joints will be hidden inside the four legs, but wondering about durability.
Have some nice cherry ply to make the 10" deep seat box rather than using solid wood that will have movement issues with the corners cut into the legs. Legs are 2-1/2" and the box will penetrate a good 1-1/4" or so to be glued and doweled. I figured to use 1" fingers.
I have a couple of carpenter's toolboxes, built by my Dad in the 1950's. They're constructed with 1/4" finger joints in 1/2" plywood. Still going strong, and Dad
In the photos, there only appears to be about 1/4" backset from the front and sides of the legs, so why not just think of them as tenons. Were the fingers just going to form a box corner which set inside a L corner cut out of the leg? I think that would make a stout joint for the box, but not so sure it would be as strong for the leg.
I think if they are that far out, I would use 3 tenons on the short ends rails, top, bottom, and middle. then two on the long front-back rails which would fit in between the others.
I have made a number of drawer boxes in the past with both joints in 1/2" Baltic birch plywood. The issue I ran into was how tight they fit. With plywood it's not easy to pare the joint parts so they fit together easier like you could with solid wood. There's also the problem of the veneer splintering off when trying to dry fit things and take them apart again. It was such a problem I decided in the future to either use solid wood or not try to use these joints in plywood.
I understand your application is not a drawer box but since the corners will be unseen why not use a simple rabbet joint glued and tacked. This has proven strong enough for me in the past and surely much simpler to make and assemble. I you still feel you must use either of these joints I think Keith's advice about fewer and farther apart makes better sense.
I've made the legs a bit heavier, 2-1/2", than the originals. The box will be glued into 1-1/4" x 1-1/4" rabbets in the legs. There will then be a 3/4"x3/4" block glued into each inside corner to "refill" the legs. As in the originals, the leg/box joints will be pinned with 8 ebony dowels. I'm betting this will be more than strong enough.
My dado is a max 1" so that's as large as I can go and still maintain precise registration and size of the fingers. I'd rather not go back to the band saw or try double cutting with the TS jig. Since the ply is a shade under 19mm, I plan to cut the fingers a tad short (18.75 or so) and then use thickened epoxy for the corner/leg joints to fill the small gaps.
I have no doubt that this is very different construction than the originals which would have been solid wood joined to the legs with pinned M&T joints. The result, of course, is that my seat-box will be a bit smaller and the legs will stand a bit prouder from the box. Still in the planning stage on this however and will probably do a mock-up or two of different box/leg configurations before deciding. I could make larger rabbets and increase the interior corner-block size or just go with full M&T joints using the plywood panels without doing the box glue-up at all.
Through the years, I'll bet I've had to repair hundreds of broken dowel joints, and I don't claim to be in the furniture repair business. I only take that kind of work from close personal friends, so I can do the work that I want to do. Otherwise, I would be buried in repair work, and probably half would be failed dowel joints. There is actually a chair of my nephew sitting behind me now, waiting it's turn.
I would use a bunch of screws & glue, and cover them with that inside corner block, if you proceeds with the blind rabbet joint. ;-)
"Pinned" Joints. With the box corners glued into the legs and the corner blocks, the pins are there only to prevent racking stress in the joint like a pinned M&T joint. I will, however consider the interior screw option and use the ebony buttons as mere "show."
The seat box with jointed corners was the option to using the ply panels like boards and doing regular M&T joints in the legs. Looks like I'll be doing a few more mock-ups before I decide on the final configuration.
I have a Leigh Jig for dove tails. Two thoughts, why not just use dovetails if you have a jig for it and I think the Leigh jig will do finger joints also, but I have not tried it.
If I go the route of a pre-made box that's then fit with legs and seat surface, my finger joint jib is quick and very accurate on the table saw. No point in using dove tails as the corner will be buried inside the legs and would never be seen The issue with the box option is the amount of inset from the outside surfaces of the legs. I couldn't cut the notches of more than 50% of the leg's width or depth and still maintain strong legs so the reveal would be 1-1/4" both ways; not what the original designers had in mind.
The other option is to do M&T joints at the legs. Cutting tenons on the ply panels. Does make things a bit more complicated when gluing up with the box bottom in place and having to notch out at the corners.
I have used hand cut dovetails, in ply. Stuff a lot looser than the tight birch Roger showed, and it works well. I don`t overdo it on the tails. I think that too many joints weakens it, or more likely just doesn`t strengthen it. You get a lot more glue bond and interlacing, but it also ends up cutting across a lot of fiber.