vise facing
Brad Bransky
What wood do you prefer for your bench-side vise?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
vise facing
Brad Bransky
What wood do you prefer for your bench-side vise?
hard, tough and cheap
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Maple is good but ash, beech, hickory etc would do
Re: vise facing
Jesper, Denmark
Whatever is in the scrapbin that fits. Deep counter sink!!!!
Re: vise facing
Tony - Memphis
Mine are maple. Not a preference really, just what I had. I made some extra cheeks that slip over those that I use for delicate situations.
Tony
Re: vise facing
Brad Bransky
Interesting you all favor hard woods. I had read some time ago the best choice is a soft wood because hard wood might make indentations in a soft wood put in the vise.
Responde?
Re: vise facing
Hank Knight
Face the hardwood with thick vegetable tanned leather. It improves the grip and prevents marring your work.
Re: vise facing
Pete in Holland MI
Knot-less pine. Soft & doesn't dent my hardwood projects, and conforms to slightly irregular projects.
Re: vise facing
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
Almost all my vise faces are hard maple. That's partially because I put dog holes in their tops, and sometimes their sides. Hard maple has much less tendency to split and chip and shatter, and if I do get a diivot in it, is easy to scrape smooth again. I do have a couple of vise faces that are white oak. When I wear them out, thye will be replaced with hard maple. If I make an auxiliary jaw to closely hold curved work, I cut it out of tulip poplar, because it is softer, and it's easier to work to the proper shape. If I need to be very careful of a finished surface, I'll temporarily line the face with leather or a few layers of blue tape, or some high-tech gasket material that I can't get any more of. I wouldn't use pine, ever.
Re: vise facing
roger lance
Don't know if this product is what you are referring to.....but I've used this rubber high friction pad material from LV on my vise face and it has worked well. Look at item # 88K59.05 at LV site.
Similar advice
Ellis Walentine
On the benches that Frank Klausz and I built about ten years ago, we faced the shoulder and end vises with regular old upholstery leather. It grips without marring and it is only about 1/16" thick so it doesn't compress so much that you lose tactual feedback. OTOH, in my old shop I had five Emmert vises and for my biggest turtleback, I used a hard rubber facing glued to 1/4" hardboard that was given to me by another old friend, Willliam Tandy Young. I really hated to lose those pads because I liked them better than any hardwood I've ever used. I hadn't been able to find anything similar since.
I'll have to check out the LV material. Thanks.
Ellis
Re: Similar advice
TomD
The LV stuff that came on my LV vise is that rubberized cork material. It is good but easily damaged.
I think we need to differentiate between jaw materials as to whether: The wood in a wooden jaw, or the heavy surfacing that is used on some installations of metal vises, either to flush them in the bench, of enlarge their jaws; and materials like the cork and rubber that are there to enhance grip.
Re: vise facing
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
It couldn't be the same product--it's a different color. ;^) I really don't know the name or the manufacturer of what I'm using, but the L-V product has a similar description and sounds promising. When I run out of this pinkish/orangish stuff, I'll try the L-V pads. What I have is scrap from a day-job discontinued product of a friend who also makes hand tools. For almost everything I do, though, wood or leather over wood is sufficient.
Re: vise facing
roger lance
I know you'll remember this photo......the LV product is on the removed vise face.....

its handy stuff.....I've found many uses for it in the shop.
Hard "rubber" facing material
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Go to a shop that sells/makes gaskets. There are all sorts of materials that vary in all sorts of hardness. It never crossed my mind to use it on a vise but I have some thin red stuff that should work.
Re: vise facing
Jack Guzman from Maine
Soft wood vise jaws wear out too quick. The edges become rounded and don't grip small objects.You have to replace them more often.They would make sense if you had to hold delicate objects but I prefer hard jaws with leather faces.---Jack
Not if the jaw faces are kept smooth
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"hard wood might make indentations in a soft wood "
Re: vise facing
Barry Irby
Wonder why a piece of inner tube wouldn't work? But unless you get a huge one, its not flat. Stop by a business that does or sells roofing materials for a flat roof. They might have some EPDM roofing scraps. To me it looks exactly like inner tube and is about a 1/10" thick and is flat. Comes in rolls 6' or 2 meters wide. They install it by the acre. Any little scrap they have would last a lifetime as vice jaw liner. My only question would be if it leaves black scuff marks on the work.
Re: vise facing
roger lance
Using this LV product in this way was an experiment.....I found that it doesn't mare/leave black streaks on the stock....the adhesive on the product is adequate to hold it stable without shifting under load when used in a larger piece such as for a vise chop/face.....but I've experience some movement of the product in smaller applications....it cushions and holds the work piece well.....and seems durable with little wear noted. So. I'm giving it a thumbs up.