Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

Posts

Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#1

Alan Young

Clamping odd shaped work pieces  ???

Alan Young

This is "combo post"-partly related to last Ides thread re: "Making do". The logistics of my shop have kept a real woodworking bench from ever taking shape and position. So I end up doing a lot of my work on the table saw. I've been thinking about making one of those bench-on-benches to clamp onto the saw or other surface. Before going too far into the process I thought I'd show the the latest reason for needing something. I am making a pair of music stands. The bases for each stand are three-legs glued to a center triangle with loose tenons



Once I get the pieces all cut I will refine the legs with lots of filing,spokeshaveing, sanding etc....Holding these oddly curved pieces is a challenge- whether I do them individually or all glued up. So I am searching out recommendations for a good type of vise-clamp-fixture etc to incorporate into what ever bench top bench I end up constructing.

-Alan

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#2

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces  ???

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

It won't help much now that the legs are cut to shape, but you could have left a lug on the top and bottom where the leg joins the triangular block to give a clamp a place to grip. Then when the glue dries, sand it off or cut it off wih a flush cut hand saw.

Lee

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#3

Alan Young

Yup-Shoulda thought ahead! 


Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#4

Re: Yup-Shoulda thought ahead!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

So put one back on with hot-melt glue. When the glue-up is finished, pull out the heat gun to resoften the hot-melt and just remove it. With a little heat it should release cleanly. Try on some scrap first. ;)

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#5

Lee Valley *LINK*

Yonak

This solution from Lee Valley comes to mind :


img

Veritas® Spider Vise

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#6

Alan Young

I think it's too late-That which was is now.....

Alan Young

I took the "waste" and glued it to the top for each piece...



Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#7

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces  ???

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I don't know if that hole in the middle of the triangle is a through hole, or if it can be in the design. I'm going to assume it is or can be.

I think I'd then be tempted to set up a clamping jig on a sheet of, say, 3/4" plywood that used folding wedges (two wedges with opposing tapers) acting against blocks on the plywood and cutoffs from your stand's feet to protect the feet and give a flat surface for the wedges. Before tightening up the clamps by hammering in the wedges, I would then run a bolt from the plywood to the hole in the triangle, and tighten it just enough to prevent if from lifting when I tightened up the wedges.

I'd also be tempted to try this with scrap first.

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#8

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces  ???

roger lance

I'd just glue one joint at a time.....take my time.....no rush.....and no need to make a complicated clamping solution.....KISS baby!!

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#9

Second Thoughts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You may consider reducing your center triangle a tad to exactly match the width of the legs so that you don't have white wood showing in the joins.

In that same vein, make tenons with grain that is oriented across the joint out of the same wood used in the legs. Running a loose board with grain running with the joint compromises the strength of the splines. Orienting the spline grain across the joint will also tend to hide them on the surface of the finished leg if you use the same wood as in the rest of the piece.

Of course, of you'd like to show off the joinery using a white wood like hard maple for the spline/tenons, that's fine as well.

I wouldn't depend on stain to blend two different woods to a similar color.

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#10

Alan Young

Re: Second Thoughts

Alan Young

When all is said and done the stands will be Black- The joinery will hopefully be covered by layers of filler, paint and top coat. I will sculpt the glued assembly into something like this:

Overall look will be even more organically rounded-Sort of "Maloofian"

-Alan

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#11

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces  ???

Keith Newton

I would start by glowing a couple of sheets of plywood together, cut to triangle, large enough to have U blocks that the toe of each leg fits into, to keep from splaying out, when you drill a, or maybe 3 holes to clamp down from the top I've the center of that hole.

On my phone, I can't tell the grain direction on that triangle. I hope it is not parallel to any side, and of course it needs to be across those splines. But I'm wondering why you didn't just cot a larger triangle that acted like finger, or box joints.

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#12

Oh

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"Never mind"

:D

ps: Still use cross-grain splines

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#13

Design opportunity.....

Barry Irby

Just a thought.....

Why not change the design and eliminate the triangular block? Cut a 120 degree angle on each of the legs and join them directly to each other.

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#14

Alan Young

Re: Design opportunity.....

Alan Young

Interesting idea- Might work next time- I played around with this in my drawing It would be a challenge to get the angles dead nuts--

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#15

Re: Design opportunity.....

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Alan, what do you have in mind for the rest of the music stand.....post, table for sheet music...etc

A drawing of the design would be helpful.

Re: Clamping odd shaped work pieces ???

#16

Re: Design opportunity.....

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Alan, thank you for the design and construction steps you sent me offline. I admire the beautiful work you did on all three stands.

I have been looking at the stand under construction you have shown trying to consider a simple method of gluing up all in one setup and making all close and neat joints. In the hole in the center block I would insert a long bolt extending above the base a little, then on each leg i would insert a 1 1/2 " drywall screw...top and bottom of each leg. Then glue up all and place in proper connection for the joints and apply baling wire around the bolt and each screw...twist a couple times to snug up. Do this under neath also. Simple and I think it will work fine.