I am looking to build a decorative frame for a plastic planter box I have. I want to use 2x3 studs room HD for the design. It will have zero contact with dirt outside or inside the planter. It will be on my deck. Will it hold up to Portland OR rainy climate? Can I stain and seal to help it last? What would I use? Thank you all for your help!
Not without a lot of extra fussing with some type of finish and even then... it would seem destined to be short lived. Your area sees a lot of cedar in use outside. Have you considered using it instead?
Most of the studs sold at the big box stores locally seem to to be cut right out of the center of the tree and often contain the heart or pith. This is what's called juvenile wood and is the poorest quality wood in the tree. Also they are from SPF lumber which stands for Spruce/Pine/Fir, meaning its pretty much anything and unsorted, and none of them are particularly decay resistant. So, I agree those above, No, don't use it
The alternative here in the East would be redwood, cedar, or treated lumber. The redwood we get here is pretty crappy. (The rumor is they keep the good stuff on the west coast) Redwood heart wood would be excellent for your project, but sap wood or the white part, not so much. The sap wood is not nearly as decay resistant as the heart wood, but is probably better than the studs. Cedar (Western Red Cedar) is better than the studs, but not as good as the heart Redwood. Treated pine would be decay resistant but comes soaking wet from being treated and is PRONE to warp.
Its been my experience you get better wood at the big box stores if you buy a larger piece and cut it down. A 2 x 10 MUST come from a larger more mature tree than a 2 x 3 and may have denser straighter grain. If you have the ability to rip it down, I would buy bigger pieces and cut it to size.
I agree with Barry on the wide wood. I built a window sash using Doug fir 2x10s ripped to produce quarter sawn strips. It should work for you,just treat the wood well.---Jack
Bill and Jack are right....Paint it......but don't just paint it, do what we used to do on houses, back prime it. Cut out all your parts and prime them thoroughly one all surfaces, maybe two coats of primer or a coat of primer and then a coat of paint, then assemble it and paint it again. Sealing the end grain really helps.
Maybe I miss read your post, but as I understand it you are saying this planter will be used inside only? You state it will be on your desk? If this is a planter that will be used inside and protected from the dirt and moisture of the soil used, ANY wood with any finish will hold up fine forever. The fact you have high humidity or a lot of rain outside is immaterial if the object is to remain inside.
If this is an inside project finish would not be critical, you could stain and coat or just apply a clear finish or whatever you desire. The postings above all are correct if you are using the planter outside. Personally I would use a more attractive wood if it were to be on my desk, possibly cedar, Walnut, Cherry, or a figured wood like curly maple with a clear finish. I am sure you are not building a giant planter so cost for a nicer wood would be minimal.
but some for maybe 2 years, others for 10+. How old a "fellor" are you? LOL Anyway, most of the resistant woods species from the past don't perform like they used to. Young, fast growth redwood doesn't come close to old growth, and young growth sapwood might last less than good fir. If you want a long term result, I would use plastic or a plastic/wood composite. Build it, forget it. Any wood product will need maintenance and if you paint it anyway, they would look the same. You just have to be able to justify the cost. But back to the age thing. If you are 30 years old, how many wooden ones do you want to build over your lifetime?
17 or 18 years ago I had a fence put up in my backyard. The fence company said the wood was 'white cedar'. I don't know if it is, but my yard smelled like a hamster cage for a few weeks after installation.
They left me extra slats and scraps. Still have some.
At that time I used some to make a planter box for my wife. It's about 3' long, 5" deep, and 5" wide. Give or take.
It's put together with nothing more than little brads. No finish or anything. I screwed it to my garage with two deck screw. It's been hanging there all this time. No protection from the weather. Right now it's filled with snow.
I happened to take it down last night because we noticed squirrels jump from the ground up and onto it, then from there jump to the bird feeders 2' away.
It hasn't fallen apart yet, but it's probably time to make a new one.
Jeff...a couple of years ago, I made a pair of deck tables from the "plastic" home trim that is available from big box stores (Menards)......these pieces come in various sizes and shapes and they can be glued up to give you 2x stock etc.....you can use ordinary woodworking tools, paint it if you want.....used stainless steel screws from McFeelys.......
another possibility that requires very low maintenance.