Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

Posts

Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#1

Bart Goldberg

Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

Bart Goldberg

I am curious if anyone knows if I can use Veterinarian-grade mineral oil for treating/sealing end grain cutting boards, or do I need to buy the more expensive "food grade" variety?

Thanks

Bart

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#3

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If selling them I would use food grade, whatever that is. This stuff is dirt cheap so we can't be talking about much money. For myself, I would use the cheapest stuff I could find, if I used it, but I don't.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#4

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

John McGaw

I use whatever is on the shelf at the local drug store. If you are careful to recover that which does not soak in overnight (I do my soaking in a disposable aluminum roasting pan) and put it back in the bottle you will find that it lasts for a long time. Besides, it is dirt cheap. If you don't believe me, compare the price of good walnut oil -- my old finish was a homebrew mixture of walnut oil and beeswax.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#5

Treenware Treatment

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I use a mix of mineral oil, paraffin, and bees wax that I cook up in a pan then pour into sauce cups to go with the item.

I have also taken to applying a good soaking coat of Waterlox (red can) sealer first. Warm the item (bowl or board) in the oven to 125°, then apply the Waterlox. Allow to soak in for 20 minutes then wipe dry. Allow to sit for at least 4-7 days to get the drying oil to set up and polymerize, then give it a coat of the mineral oil/wax. The sealer will stay in the wood, is food-safe when cured, and will retard water and food juice from penetrating, and won't form a film that will flake off in use.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#6

It's one for the lawyers

John in NM

Functionally, I don't believe there is a difference at all.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#7

Bart Goldberg

Re: Treenware Treatment

Bart Goldberg

Mark,

Why both Paraffin and Beeswax? Seems like they would be somewhat similar as part of this brew?

Bart

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#8

Re: Treenware Treatment

TomD

He may be referring to paraffin in the English sense which is Kerosene though that doesn't sound like something I want to eat.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#9

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

TomD

I like Watco, dries to a beautiful finish, and is OK when fully cured.

Mineral oil not veg oil is probably the best thing for ongoing maintenance type finishes. You can buy it in a form where it is safe if taken internally.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#10

Re: Treenware Treatment

robbcarr

Wood magazine (http://www.woodmagazine.com/materials-guide/finishes/is-your-finish-food-safe/) says: "Is Your Finish Food Safe? The U.S. Department of Agriculture's Forest Products Laboratory suggests melted paraffin wax...After it soaks into the wood and dries, scrape off any surface excess with a putty knife."

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#11

Paraffin

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

(sealing or candle wax) is rather brittle and the paste it makes with M-O gets a bit grainy. Bees wax is softer, smooths out the paste, and makes for a lower sheen. Paraffin molecules are actually pretty large and will not penetrate the wood's pores very well (as I've been told), but the bees wax gets into the pores better so the application lasts longer. This is why I give a batch along with the piece and give out the recipe. I also suggest the person apply the mix then work over the surface with a hair drier to get better penetration into the wood before they wipe off the excess.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#12

Personally

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I don't like using cooking veg oil on stuff. Over time they tend to get gummy and take on a certain smell that I find unpleasant, especially in something that I'll be putting food on or in.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#13

wax penetration correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Bee wax molecules are actually a bit larger than paraffin wax molecules. But it doesn't matter because both are tiny compared to a wood pore. There is no reason to suspect one would be different from another in getting into the wood.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#14

Re: Welcome Correction

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Although what I've been told for many years is that wax doesn't actually penetrate wood like the oil, but merely sits in pores and makes for a temporary shine. The old Johnson's Wax motto "Good For The Wood 'Cause It's Wax" was total ad-man BS.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#15

Disagree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the wax is dissolved in a solvent to make it liquid it most certainly will penetrate. The average wax molecule is smaller than the average linseed oil molecule, for example.

If the wood is dipped in hot wax it may not penetrate much, not because of molecule size, but because of viscosity. As soon as the wax cools to become a solid the material is no longer mobile and able to diffuse through the pores.

There is another issue the will affect penetration. To penetrate the pores the material must wet the surface (spread on the surface). Wax alone might not wet the wood. But wax dissolved in oil will, if the oil will. I think motor oil will penetrate into wood and if this is the case then wax will wet the surface as it is essentially the same as motor oil in terms of wetting.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#16

ebd

Re: Personally

ebd

My wife had me treat a black walnut bowl I just finished sanding with mineral oil because she wanted an "old time finish". Not something I will ever do again. It looked fine when first covered with the oil. Once the oil soaked in (multiple times) and was wiped off - not so much. The oil darkened the grain way, way too much and obliterated it. Too late now to do anything about it. I'm only glad that it wasn't one of the really great flame & grain blanks that I found inside the tree.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#17

Patience

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Multiple washings with soap and water will pull most, if not all, of the oil out of the wood over time. Any oil will do the same thing.

OTOH, if you'd put a film finish on your piece, it would start to peel and crack before long if the bowl were actually used; salad dressing will penetrate pretty readily to break the film's bond in spots and the piece will have to be stripped and refinished. Just my view, but treenware isn't the place to use wood that you want to just display the grain and color.

BTW, your walnut will get lighter over time if it gets enough UV light.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#18

OK, But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

if the wax penetrates in liquid/dissolved form, it should remain after cooling and/or evaporation of the solvent, and not be removed by mere water. I find the opposite to be the case on cutting boards and salad bowls that I tried to use hot paraffin (no oil or solvent) as a finish; stuff lasted 2 dish-detergent washes and was gone which doesn't seem like much in the way of penetration.

Years ago there was a marketing attempt at treated SYP lumber supposedly infused with paraffin such that finishing wasn't required and the stuff would be waterproof. Effort failed. I and several others I know used it for deck furniture and the water bead lasted about 6 months after which we had to go back to finish sealers to protect the wood.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#19

agree with that

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"treenware isn't the place to use wood that you want to just display the grain and color. There are art projects and stuff that gets used. Kind of like workbench and a hall table. One is designed and finished to withstand use and the other can be designed and finished to look at.

Any time I have oiled walnut or cherry with any sort of oil it darkens.

The episode with the mineral oil is not over. It will bleed back out for ever. It has nothing to recommend it for wood treatment.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#20

Walnut oil vs vegie oil-some chemistry facts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Anyone happy with walnut oil for treenware (didn't know that word before) has no reason to eschew vegie oil of any sort. The composition difference between walnut oil and say corn oil is minor. Walnut oil has a bit more unsaturation which means it will react with oxygen a bit more to polymerize into a bit more tougher film. All other chemistry including the dreaded (by some) propensity to become rancid is identical.

I would point out that anyone that fears the faint odor of a used cutting board should avoid cheese and anything fermented so as to avoid the same odor making chemicals.

If treenware is exposed to vegie oil or animal fat (it's a salad bowl, pastry board, carving board) some of this oil or fat will become part of the cutting board and do what ever it is gong to do, which isn't anything that was fretted over until recently. Anyone that finds this fact a problem to be attacked by hot water and detergent would be better served by using plastic.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#21

Nut Oils

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

especially walnut and peanut (yeah, they're legumes), are a no-no in my book for food-use items unless they are proven to be highly refined to render them hypoallergenic by removal of the sensitizing proteins. Many can poo-poo the whole nut-allergy thing, but I won't take the risk, especially with folks I'll never meet and never want to hear about having a problem from one of my bowls or boards.

In my experience, any non-drying oil will leach out of treenware during use and cleaning, and will have to be renewed to preserve the wood's color. That's why I give a sample of my homebrew mineral oil/wax stuff. It's absolutely food-safe as well as being both tasteless and odorless, and will stay that way, a good stinky cheese notwithstanding :D

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#22

agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Selling stuff is a different world than making stuff to use one's self.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#23

Re: agree

TomD

I guess, none of us have nut allergies, but what if people visit. Can you make bowls out of Walnut safely? There is a legal aspect too, if someone died and you had used a walnut bowl, my experience with suits is that you don't have to be actually in error to get nailed. There are lots of ways this works, one is to impeach you because you said you never used anything nut related in preparing the food, then you are a liar, and it is all over. Or even if it wasn't a factor, most lawsuits are settled when it becomes apparent the defence is unreasonably expensive. So a mounting list of things you would have to prove in court is a problem.

My mother in law covers the cracks in the walnut cheese tray I made her by rubbing it with walnuts, or maybe the shell. How does one know that didn't happen, apparently it is some traditional thing.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#24

Re: Patience

TomD

Watco hardens off, and is in the wood.

A lot of bowls are sold on the wood, so I can't fully agree the issue is irrelevant. But bare wood can be pretty when it gets really burnished, and is washed over and over.

Re: Treating Cutting Boards with Mineral Oil

#25

Re: Frying pans

TomD

I have to think we all just don't really know what we are doing. With frying pans there is a seasoning, and use mode that works great, no rust, no burned residue, ease of cleaning. One possible problem arises when you go low fat, it sorta depends on abundant oils. So the thing got out of whack, or some people lost the thread when tefal came out, and low fat cooking. I have lived with cooks who's pans looked like a kreasote paint pot.

The point being, wooden ware was around for ever. It used to be every part of the place setting, plates, bowls, glasses, spoons. With something like a salad, we use oil on the bowl, we use oil in the salad. There has to be some way to care for the bowl that does not require stripping and refinishing with every use. Now that we know that wood is additionally mildly antiseptic, it should be possible to come up with, or resurrect a better way to do this.

We are looking at this as a wood finishing problem, but that takes it somewhat out of the actual cycle of use.