Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT Long Undies?

Posts

OT Long Undies?

#1

OT Long Undies?

Keith Newton

It is forecasted to get down to 12º here tonight, which is probably balmy compared to some of your locations. I think I heard on the radio -40º forecast for some places. My big old shop is pretty cool, and energy hungry when it gets cold. I'm sure I'll be wearing my long undies for the next few days, which are getting fairly old, and needing to be replaced before long.

So far, Patagonia Capilene has been the best that I've ever worn, and would likely stay with, but I was in a outfitter recently, and gasp when I checked the price, which was about $80 for a top or bottom of a mid weight. This seemed like an extreme jump in price for what I had spent however many years ago that I bought my current set.

A month or two ago, I bought a cheap set, but wish I hadn't wasted the money. I was just wondering what some of you that live up where the Winters are more extreme consider the best value / comfort level. Or do you just count on the outer levels?

Re: OT Long Undies?

#2

Re: OT Long Undies?

CJ in MPLS

I like fleece myself. When it gets truly cold that is what I put on under the windproof bibs I use for skiing. Otherwise I've had luck with smartwool.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#3

Re: OT Long Undies?

Terry in Edmonton

I don't know if you have these brands but my favourite are Helly Hanson and MEC ( Mountain Equipment Coop). Both are polypropylene and are very comfortable. A pair of these, jeans and some wind pants are good for -30C or so.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#4

Imagine how cold it would be.....

roger lance

if not for global warming !!

Re: OT Long Undies?

#5

Re: OT Long Undies?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I really like duofold, a wool/cotton blend. Mine are very warm, very soft and comfy. I was working in the shop yesterday afternoon, temp 0F and later had a delivery to make outside, windchill of -25F. They helped enormously. Of course, for prolonged outdoor work on really cold days, nothing beats an insulated coverall.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#6

Re: OT Long Undies?

Tom Dunlap

Never cotton!

Cotton Cools...Kotton Kills

Check prices at Sierra Outfitters.

Stand on anything in the shop. Get some insulation between your shoes/boots and the floor.

I bought some zip T tops at Costco for under $25 earlier in the season. They have long arms to match mine. I'm happy with them. No bottoms though...I have enough.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#7

Re: OT Long Undies?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I know the prohibition on cotton, Tom, but you should try these things.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#8

The Alberta Clipper

CJ in MPLS

I pride myself on being accustomed to the cold and laugh at my wife's family (all living in the southern US) about their concerns about our living in Minneapolis. Then I think of the Canadians and it starts to make sense.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#9

Get Charged Up

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Keith,

There are several lines of heated duds that are being marketed using Li batteries. From socks to pants & shirts to outerware. They'll keep you toasty.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#10

Wool

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When deer hunting in the cold I wear wool. I don't like the creepy feel of the modern stuff. The itchy wool will keep you warmer because it stimulates circulation. The Merino not itchy wool feels luxurious next to hide.

I find a down vest provides warmth without weight or constraint. I wear a vest a lot for working outside under moderate cold conditions.

That said if my shop was too cold to work in ordinary clothes I would be figuring out some way to heat it.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#11

Same here

John in NM

I only need the wool pair a few times a year at home, more often at work since it gets colder there. I've never cared for smooth wool.

My favorite pair of long underwear are Stanfield 80/20's, made in Canada. They also make full union suits if one would like to go really old school :D

Re: OT Long Undies?

#12

Re: Imagine how cold it would be.....

Dave Bair

Normal

Re: OT Long Undies?

#13

Re: Wool

TomD

"The itchy wool will keep you warmer because it stimulates circulation."

That's a new one, there must be a lot of data to support that. I will try it on the kids. They don't like wool, and pile is so common that they know little of wool for insulation. The moment they come home they are liable to switch into their fleece.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#14

Re: OT Long Undies?

TomD

I probably bought some of the first Chouinard/Patagonia stuff, back in the early 70s, and it was really cheap at the time. Since he was out front with a lock on the fleece market in the US for a few years, he really had no choice but to dump the girl that brung him and switch from the dirtbag element to yuppies.

I don't really see getting the value out of a technical product like that unless one is doing something appropriately weird. I remember skiing in the MEC Wallace Berry top, and nothing else on top, when it was minus 50C in Algonquin, and so dry you could virtually see sparks (we had Jackrabbit graphite on the skis, so it wouldn't create static) and it was comfortable. I used to do a lot of waterfall ice climbing, and almost anything, weather wise, could blow up, or fall down on you, so technical gear made sense. I'd wear the underwear with goretex over it. Used to work in sales and design for a Goretex company, Back in the early 80s, still have one of the Jackets. But I wouldn't buy any more at this point. There is usually a simpler way that works better, unless you have cray conditions, or need to deal with masses of sweat, or weigh is extremely important.

Today I just wear however many 10 dollar sweats are required for the condition. I am not sure there is any real benefit to cramming something under pants, when you can just slap something in a larger size over them.

Also, and this is a real issue, the plastics are a miserable experience if you ever end up in a fire. Guy I slightly know, is a well known international bow hunter, and he was in a narrow cabin when a guy accidentally doused a fire with a pot of white gas. It is bad enough to get burned, let alone to deal with all the melted crap. Kinda ironic, because he sold all kinds of really high end dense wool products for bowhunters, because most synthetics are too noisy, but his base layer was plastic.

I almost got burned to death on a plane once, but I guess you don't need to worry about surviving that. Not something you ever really see coming. I only mention it because if you have some appliance for heat, that has any possibility of causing a fire, you might want to reconsider plastics. Fact is, once in Ireland, in a sweets shop, I melted some gray flanel trousers onto my leg standing too close to a red hot space heater. So you never know. Natural fibers all the way. Unless you really have a reason.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#15

Re: OT Long Undies?

Basil

30+ years ago, the X-wife bought/ordered me some thermal underwear. I thought they had come from Maine and thought they were made in Maine. I only remember a bit about the name and where they came from but believe this was the name of the company. Appears to be English made but looks like them.

http://www.damart.co.uk/C-70836-mens-thermals

Anyway, she paid about 3 times what your ordinary thermals were selling for back then. I, of course, pitched a fit because they weren't any thinker feeling than your usual common Hanes or Fruit of the Loom T-shirts felt. Well lo and behold, they were the warmest I had ever worn....had to eat crow and apologize. They were excellent down into the upper 20's with little other clothes on. She later bought me a set of the medium weight and it had better stay below 30 on the days I wore them or I would have to open/shed my coat and flannel shirt.

Re: OT Long Undies?

#16

ARMY . . .

Steve Mackay

I got issued the ARMY "Polypro" when they came out. (Prior to that it was wool.)We considered them a Godsend. Comfortable, warm and easy to care for. Since retiring 16 years ago I get 'em on Da'Bay. They're "cost effective", have out-standing performance, easy to get jeans over and take years of hard ware and washing. The new "issue" is about $120 per set. Looks like the cooling suit for a space walk. Are they kidding ? Ain't no "long handles" worth THAT kinda money.