Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

Posts

Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#1

Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The theme here is that the inside of logs never look as good as their owner's imagine and Holly is hard to dry and keep white.

Getting the tree- Brother in law called to report that his neighbor 300 miles from me was removing a large Holly tree that had no limbs for 6' or more and had been limbless for 6' since 1980. The large part was accurate. After complex negotiations involving cutting the tree, cleaning up the brush, cost, etc. the owner wound up paying a tree company to cut the tree and the first 3' was promised to me for $50. In fact what became allotted to me was the nearly 6' "clear" section. The tree was larger diameter than I expected but in spite of bystander fretting I got it uneventfully into the truck and home just in time for an unexpected January heat wave.

Sawing the tree- It was clear that I was not going to be able to slab this tree on my band saw. Finding a mill willing to saw a small yard log is not a trivial matter. The temperature was 65 degrees and mold stain was looming.

I had noticed a new Woodmizer being set up near by. I visited Sat. AM and hopefully took the log along for the ride. I found the owner resting in his easy chair. After much discussion of logging, sawing, weather, woodworking, the price of diesel fuel and the peril of moldy Holly the owner said lets saw it.

There followed a discussion of my notions on how to saw the log for the eventual purpose of converting it to inlay and stringing. The owner rolled his eyes and told me to saw it however I wanted it sawed. I have not sawed on a band mill but the Woodmizer was easy to run compared to a circle mill and in short order I had the log slabbed to my satisfaction. He wanted $10 for his trouble and I gave him $20, a $10 investment on future needs.

From the lumpy surface of the log I expected knots to lie within. I was not mistaken. The outer third of the log is mostly clear and the interior is as knotty as most holly trees seem to be.

Drying and the peril of mold stain- I don't know if mold attacks Holly faster than the notorious soft maple and white pine or that it just shows up easier on the white wood. I have never dried Holly but have seen plenty of it blue or black with mold stain. Based on what I knew about white pine here is what I did and it seems to be working. The weather was outrageously warm and wet, ideal mold growing conditions, and I needed to work fast.

Step 1 was to remove any loose sawdust which will mold in hours and inoculate the rest. Then I de-colored the occasional iron stain from the saw blade with a spritz of phosphoric acid (citric or oxalic would have worked too). The bark was removed with a draw knife, a step that went easier than expected. All surfaces were sprayed with a 1:1 Chloxox in water mix to sterilize the surface. This was a risky step that was tested on a small piece. Chlorox is highly basic and strong base will color some wood, for example mahogany. It did not color Holly. Finally the planks were placed on saw horses and a fan directed a flow of air over the planks. Mold will not establish on a dry surface. I am finding that Holly is a soggy wood and the surface dries slower than I expected.

It is cold now and I can move the planks outdoors to continue air drying with less risk of mold growing. Stay tuned for the final result.

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#2

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

Keith Newton

Never tried Holly myself, but I think I've read suggestions to re-stack pretty regularly with new dry sticks in different places, if you think this is needed.

Are those 4 boards all of it? I was thinking of reminding you about that method I wrote about, using the tarp with space heater. I've got a big batch of oak running in one at the present, which could use a bigger heater, so it is going slowly.

I was needing to use some other wood, which had been KD, but left in unconditioned air for too long, so I just put this small project batch in the bathroom, closed the door, turned the heat up to the max. With the boards standing on end, it has really been dropping quickly, and was so easy. And since this is a totally interior space, any escaping heat just goes into my living space to heat it.

Oh, one last thing. I was in a supplier last week, and notice they had some Holly in stock, and it is only $35 BF, so take care, and good luck.

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#3

that's it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

4- 8/4 planks and some "crumbs" from getting a side more or less flat to lay on the carriage. In addition to it's other problems the log was less than straight. That was part of the sawing discussion. I wanted the crook at the end to have a grain orientation that would yield straight grain when the crooked part was cut off. That strategy worked out ok.

By day I have it outdoors with good circulation and it is too cold to mold now. It should nicely freeze dry the surface and then I can move it indoors to finish drying this winter. I don't need any of it any time soon.

Holly has every indication of drying quickly but it was soggy to start.

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#4

Did something similar 5 or 6 years ago

DizD

except I rolled on DNA to sterilize the surfaces. Put it directly beside rafters under the roof of the shop and had the surface dried within a matter of days and it turned out great.

I understand also that there is an enzyme reaction within the wood which causes a greyish cast. You will probably see some of that when you crosscut.

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#5

Olive adventure-

paul in AZ

Something similar going on right now. A neighbor had an olive tree taken down last month and I salvaged several 3+ foot lengths by almost a foot in diameter of the trunk.

Sawed them into 1 1/2 to 2 inch slabs on my bandsaw. Man, that wood is soaking wet and heavy! I didn't brush sawdust off some of the smaller edge cuts and these were covered with mold spots by the next day.

The slabs are now stickered outside under cover and the surfaces are dry and mold-free.

It may take quite a while to dry all that water out. Ambient humidity right now is moderate but low compared to most of you north and east. We won't get to our really dry season of +/-5% humidity for another 3 or 4 months.

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#6

alcohol surface treatment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have heard that alcohol does well for a surface treatment. It will not only sterilize but the evaporation of the alcohol will take the surface water away with the alcohol. Had I thought about the convenience of rolling it on I probably would have used this treatment. We are in for a week of below freezing temperatures so I am hopeful that freeze drying will get me past the mold worry.

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#7

Re: surface treatment

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

rather than chlorox (which can tend to impart a yellow case to white woods) you can try spraying peroxide on the surface. It's an effective mold/fungus destroyer and has been in use as a wood bleach for many years.

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#8

Other than the adventure aspect

Gary Smyth

do you think it worth the effort? I had (probably still have) an opportunity for I'm told 50bf of cherry in a place named Tionesta,PA. About a 200 mile round trip. I'm wondering about the expense. My time is not a factor, but with the trip, weather, wood condition, prep, storage, waiting for it to dry, I declined. The wood is almost free (a meal, maybe two). You seem to be still up in the air about the result. Would you do it again?

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#9

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

Roger Myers

Hi Bill,

Looks Good! I would now select the portions of each plank that have the clearest and straightest grain and resaw that for stringing asap. Leave the figured and knotty areas for other inlay work and purposes. But I resaw to .040/.050 as soon as I can and then bundle that material and store it in a cool, dry, dark place. My experience has been that I can keep the color best that way, and of course, it dries fairly quickly at that thickness.

Just something to consider....

Roger, who is trying to keep warm today.... -8, with -20 wind chill....

Re: Holly harvest adventure- drying Holly

#10

Would you do it again?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Yes.

Recall the holly was next door to brother in law and not far from daughter so the drive was written off as a visit to these people. I would not have made the trip just for the log.

The rest is entertainment. I like hanging around saw mills and in this quest I met a new sawyer who I can work with in the future.

I've dried thousands of bdft of lumber. We used to dry most of the poplar we sold as it is easy to dry without problems, unlike oak. So drying a few holly planks is amusement to experiment with what can be done and how it works.

The surface bleach treatment has eliminated any mold from forming on the surface and the current below freezing temperatures are going to preserve this situation. Meanwhile the surface is drying nicely which will eliminate the risk of mold when it warms up. I am gaining confidence that I will wind up with white holly.

I brought a few "crumbs" inside and set them by the fireplace. Holly gives up its water quickly, like poplar or basswood, without checking. It will be no problem drying this wood.