Re: Question - and data request
TomD
"The discussion is about a wood glue that is not instantly ready to use"
Obviously you have a point, but it is more ready to use when you are actually working, and there is an open pot sitting there. No argument that for jobs where one works all day to get to a glue-up point and then grabs a bottle of T1, that is easier in that case, but not easier in the opposite minor assemblies all day long style. This covers some regular crafts, book binding, guilding, instrument work, etc... I rarely use a brush with T1, because it gels and goes bad when exposed to air (you know, the atmosphere). But Hide can be open all the time and you have your brush sitting in it, and you can get a good coverage right away.
"can be damaged during warming up to use"
All glues have some ideal temperature, and can be wreaked raising them to temperature. As a cook, you know how seriously one should take that objection, particularly since there are abundant sources of heating elements commonly available that work just fine.
With white glue it goes bad in the bottle needs to be tossed in the direction of the kids at end of year, and is adversely affected by the cold.
"requires a heating device to prepare it for use,"
That is a point. I was quite happy with my dry baby bottle warmer 25 years ago, but I threw it out when I got the fancy pot. Since then I have not been fully happy. But there are many options. Overall heat is probably an advantage. It is amazing that you can use hide in so many different forms.
"has poor shelf life after being made up from dry flakes,"
That is like complaining about the shelf life of a bullet after firing the gun. Overall hide glue shelf life is infinite. I buy T1 in gallon bottles, and toss it at the kids when the year is up. I would keep it longer if I didn't make stringed instruments. The hot ticket with hide glue is to buy a 50 pound bag and use it up over your lifetime. So which has the worse shelf life in the real world. And there are ways to keep even the stuff you have cooked, as there is with food.
"needs 24 hours clamp time according to one source (many would disagree)"
Many would, if they could stop laughing first.
"results in a weaker mortise and tenon joint,"
Data, reams of not subjective data, please, we need the facts.
"weakens substantially under hot and/or humid living conditions"
We need data, you don't even have anecdotes. Though they wouldn't be sufficient.
"is difficult to use in a cool shop"
On two levels at least.
- One is that you can use it in a really, really, wintery shop. It comes with it's own source of heat, both for the wood and the glue. And this was common practice with hide glue. You had a wood stove for heat. The parts are tucked in there, and the glue was initially spread thick to carry heat to the joint, then the extra rubber was tossed back in the pot. In these kinds of conditions the T1 has frozen or makes a chalky stain.
- But few of us work in those conditions. I get about 2 weeks of that a year, or a month. And I just give up these days. But in the proximate conditions, it is actually easier to use than T1. I don't have to carry a bottle in my pocket, and it works pretty much normally. As you suggest, normally may or may not be more trouble than T1 depends on what is what. But it isn't additionally hard to use. So they are what they are at room temp. As it gets colder, T1 gets harder to use and hide has the edge. When it is really cold T1 doesn't work at all.
And more generally nothing is hard once you know how. It's like riding a bike, there is a learning curve, then hard no longer enters into it, I guess until you get old. This concern about temp is based on newbies not getting enough heat in there to do the job. But it is just a technical issue, basically everything we have in wood can be made with hide glue in most conditions.
"Why does anyone use this stuff?"
The problem with the reversibility argument in my mind is that it presupposes people care about repairing one's crap in the distant future, or that they will recognize the construction, and that if they do will know how to handle it. Given the minor presence of real hide glue, that is probably a stretch. This leads to another approach where you use the glue, or the multitude of glues that you think are most likely to give the longest pre-repair lifespan. For one thing very little furniture is actually saved or lasts a long time. And we have little reason to believe the amateur project stuff will be among it.
One use you did not bring up, but will blow your mind is the whole, "it makes better sounding instruments stuff". Enjoy.






Also, you have a minimally larger footprint and a better chance of snagging the crock pot cord, and that could be a major annoyance for those of us with messy bench syndrome. 


