I found a small Potpouri crock pot at Goodwill for about $2. It will heat water up to and hold it at 140 deg. So far I've only used it for heating Old Brown Glue for a project. Any reason it wouldn't work with granular version? I'm thinking of using a small mason jar for the glue and using just water in the pot. That way I can remove the glue without having the cleanup everytime. There were some project photos posted here several weeks ago and there was a crockpot in the background so I'm thinking others have used the technique. Any issues I need to be concerned about?
Two issues, both are important to both OBG liquid hide glue and hot hide glue:
First, the rheostats in these things that control the heating element are not precision devises, and they can drift. I use a jelly thermometer in the water, and watch it carefully. You don't ever want to let the water bath temperature get over 150° or you will cook the glue, and it won't be glue anymore.
When using OBG, some people recommend transferring it to a smaller bottle, and keeping it in a pocket instead of trying to heat it in the crock pot. Body temperature keeps it warm enough to use.
Second, the heating element gets much hotter than the average water temperature. Keep your inner container, either the OBG bottle or your mason jar separated from the element. With canning jars, I make a lid with a close fitting hole in it and drop the jar into the hole. Of course, I use a jar that will not reach the bottom of the crock pot when suspended in the lid. I also drilled a small hole in the lid to fit the jelly thermometer.
I put a bail on my lid, and attached three feet to the bottom of the lid that don't quite reach the bottom of the pot. That way, I can pick up the lid with the jelly jar and the brush in it, and set them out on the top of the workbench while i'm using them. The lid with bail is a lot more maneuverable than a crock pot full of water and a short, stiff electrical cord.
Sorry, I don't have any recent photos with the bail and feet installed. Until I can get out to the shop, you'll have to use your imagination.
That's great idea, Tom. We've got lots of flat glass marbles around here right now. The wife has been putting them in bowls with forced narcissus bulbs. My sniffer doesn't work, so it's all lost on me, but a layer of the flat beads in the bottom of the crock pot should keep the OBG bottle from contacting the heating element and melting, with consequences that only the bench dogs would appreciate.
I'm not sure, as I've never performed an experiment to any sort of scientific standards. In general, I try to set up the glue-up late in the day, or make sure I have room to work around it. The next day, I can remove the clamps without fear of the joint coming apart or the veneer curling off. An often-recommended value is 24 hours in the clamps.
The discussion is about a wood glue that is not instantly ready to use, can be damaged during warming up to use, requires a heating device to prepare it for use, has poor shelf life after being made up from dry flakes, needs 24 hours clamp time according to one source (many would disagree), results in a weaker mortise and tenon joint, weakens substantially under hot and/or humid living conditions, is difficult to use in a cool shop, etc. Why does anyone use this stuff?
To head off the usual reply that it is" reversible", does anyone have data (not opinions from the traditional glue enthusiasts) that Ttitebond Original (or equivalent) isn't?
The longest working time for a widely used wood glue is liquid hide. This property has something to offer in a complex assembly. In this case there are two choices. There is the "brown glue" formulated in a boutique manufacturing facility and made liquid with traditional chemistry that results in limited shelf life. Or there is Titebond, made liquid with modern chemistry that results in years of shelf life under moderate storage conditions.
I just replied to a steak post above and realized that the sous vide temperature controller I'm contemplating would work to keep your glue at the correct temperature.
The hot hide glue has superior tacking properties. If you need to "rub" a joint--say in a panel, that's the glue of choice, and no clamp needed. Samething true of small veneer jobs where the hot hide glue seems to shrink the veneer onto the substrate when using the hammer veneer technique. It is also stronger than the liquid hide glues, though the liquid glue is generally strong enough, making that a minor factor in most applications. The speed of set and the nature of the "tack" can be varied by choosing different varieties of the glue.
You can also make your hot hide glue into a version that is liquid at room temperature. One way is by adding salt. You could also add urea as is done with the Old Brown Glue I believe. You would have to hunt for the right proportions of such additives, I haven't messed with that.
Bill, it is very rare that I disagree with you! However my experience in the last 50 years or so has convinced me there is a very valid reason to use hot hide glue in some applications.
The discussion is about a wood glue that is not instantly ready to use, can be damaged during warming up to use, requires a heating device to prepare it for use, has poor shelf life after being made up from dry flakes, needs 24 hours clamp time according to one source (many would disagree), results in a weaker mortise and tenon joint, weakens substantially under hot and/or humid living conditions, is difficult to use in a cool shop, etc. Why does anyone use this stuff?
Over the more than 50 years that I have repaired loose chair rungs and other joints that are subjected to extraordinary stress, I have re-glued many. In my youth, I tried to completely clean out (usually unsuccessfully) all the old glue and re-glue using yellow glue, then various other types. I started doing this in the 50's. When the joint loosened again, inspection revealed areas with no or very little adhesion. Some failed within one year, others somewhat longer.
I don't believe any chair in regular use will ever remain "tight". The effort to repair these joints was both tedious and lengthy. Over the years, I have resorted to re-gluing using Hot hide glue. I merely remove the loose derbies, lightly sand the areas, shim with very thin shavings held in place with hot hide glue, and re-glue the joint. In my opinion this method does last the longest, is the easiest to re-do and is well worth the effort to heat the glue and toss out the the unused portion. I certainly don't see any need to "clamp for 24 hours" as the hot hide glue will actually work in many applications with Zero clamping! I find that I release my clamps holding hot hide glue joints sooner than I do using Titebond without any issues.
To head off the usual reply that it is" reversible", does anyone have data (not opinions from the traditional glue enthusiasts) that Ttitebond Original (or equivalent) isn't?
As I stated above my experience proved to me that the yellow glue did not adhere well to remaining "cured / dried glue). I have seen test data showing the actual bond strength of various adhesives to "old" glue but cannot find the site at the moments, the test data did validate my findings.
The longest working time for a widely used wood glue is liquid hide. This property has something to offer in a complex assembly. In this case there are two choices. There is the "brown glue" formulated in a boutique manufacturing facility and made liquid with traditional chemistry that results in limited shelf life. Or there is Titebond, made liquid with modern chemistry that results in years of shelf life under moderate storage conditions.
I have seen data (again can't find the site at the moment) that indicated the liquid hide glue do not have the bonding strength of "Hot hide glue" (although it is probably still stronger than the wood).
One thing that cannot be denied, hot hide glue (and variations of today's hot hide glue) has been proven to hold furniture together for many hundreds and even thousands of years. We have no evidence that the "new" glues will (admittedly no contrary evidence either). I have tested glue joints using Hot Hide glue, yellow glue, Titebond 1, 2 and 3, Epoxies, and other adhesives and in almost all cases glue joints are stronger than the base material.
One other attribute of hot hide glue is that it can be used to create "rubbed" joints. IE: a coating of hide glue can be applied to a joint, the joint rubbed together and the joint will adhere without clamping at all. This is widely used in piano repair and other similar applications.
I have a small "Hot Pot" and my method is to mix a small batch of glue in a jelly jar, I place the jelly jar in water heated in the pot (I do use a thermometer to insure temperature is controlled ~ the device is pretty stable though), if I need extended time to align and clamp, I do heat the wood somewhat with a hair dryer prior to applying the glue. I do my glue-up, and unless I have need for more hide glue in the next day or so, discard the unused glue.
I don't regard this as a hassle, anymore than wiping down a project with solvent to see if any sanding marks are left. I don't use Hot hide glue often, usually use Titebond 2 or 3, depending on the project use, but I certainly do find hide glue to have a spot in my shop.
While reading this thread, I have been thinking about building a temperature controller out of an Arduino. I think it would be pretty easy to turn the pot on and off using a relay. Hmmm....
Although I've never used hot hide glue, I have and do use the Titebond liquid hide glue. The chair repairs I've done with it are still holding strong.
While I do have and use Titebond II, and a few times (cutting boards) Titebond III, I've found the liquid hide glue has become the most used in my shop. As long as the piece isn't intended for use in a bathroom or outdoors, the hide glue is my glue of choice. I like the rubbed joint aspect, hides better under a finish should any get left behind, longer open time, reversibility, shorter clamp time, how it cures hard and doesn't move, and easier clean up.
Ever glued a miter joint or any joint where there's end grain to end grain? I use a technique where I "prime" the ends with a coat of hide glue. You can do this with yellow glue too but don't walk away and forget it and the glue dries. With the hide glue it doesn't matter. I come back when I glue and assemble the joints, apply another coat of hide glue, clamp (in most cases), and I'm done. The first coat fills the end grain and allows the second coat to be on the surface and stick. If the glue dries fully the next coat simply dissolves the first and becomes one. Works like a champ.
I go through more bottles of liquid hide glue per year than Titebond II now. I've repaired enough antique furniture through the years to need it to do the job right. I learned the value of it from this experience and am sold on it.
I asked if there was any reason to endure the disadvantages of hot hide glue. You provided reasons. We haven't disagreed yet.
Chairs indeed are a special case. A round tenon in a round hole is mostly end grain adhesion- poor. And the stress of humidity changes on this joint are severe. Repair expected so easy repair desirable. Ditto for violins and pipe organs.
We may disagree on rubbed joints. Titebond makes a dandy rub joint, at least for glue blocks if the mating of parts is good.
I don't find I have to "endure" any disadvantage with hide glue, the procedure to make and use it gives me time to think about what I'm doing and plan my steps and is generally relaxing.
I use hot and have on occasion made it liquid. I've also use it to make contact cement for leather, and there are additives to make it water resistant. In short it is more versatile than PVA glues given recipes that have been figured out over the millennia that hide glue has been used (one glue with a couple of additives for most any purpose instead of several).
But the biggest reason I prefer hide glue (and probably not many have this problem) is that if I get any of the PVA glues on my skin it will itch (apparently contact dermatitis, even if washed off immediately), a problem I noticed when working as a trim carpenter that I don't have with hide glue.
Yes, that looks like it would certainly work well.
Whether I want to build one right now calls for more contemplation. The cost is about twice as much as I paid for my crock pot and the thermometer. It's quick and easy to test hide glue to see if it's time to go into the dog food bowl. (The dogs always think it's ready for them.) I think the main reason my thermostat is unstable is because the pot is old, I haven't used it enough lately, and it was very cheap to begin with.
Don Williams has another cheap but effective strategy. Whenever he's wandering around a flea market, he buys coffee warmers. They are really cheap and plentiful. When he gets them home, he plugs them in and sets a beaker full of water and an accurate thermometer on top. When the temperature has stabilized, he writes that temperature on the coffee warmer. They vary all over the place, but with a small collection, he can always find one that keeps whatever concoction he needs to brew at the time at the right temperature.
If you search his blog (Musings) for "hot hide" you just might approach enlightenment.
and in link below. Thanks for sharing. Since my lil pot doesn't have a lid I can design something that works for me. I expect 2 to 3 oz batches will do what I need.
but I only have about 45 years in so far. Hot hide glue is definitely my first choice for chairs. The chairs I just finished were pre 1920, based on the fact that the chair seats were chestnut, so I knew hide glue would bond to whatever was left in the hole. Used the same technique you described. Thanks for sharing your experiences.
"To head off the usual reply that it is" reversible", does anyone have data (not opinions from the traditional glue enthusiasts) that Ttitebond Original (or equivalent) isn't?"
- I think when people talk about reversibility, the excitement is somewhat limited to those glues that give you somewhere to go when you reverse them. Like epoxy and hide glue.
You absolutely can reverse white glue, including Titebond I. I don't know about the various other versions that include some moisture resistance. Neck resets on guitars can be steamed apart, and the joint is built to allow that. Hide glue is better in pretty much every way in this application, except maybe cheapness, and you have people who prefer it, but certainly during a reset you would vastly prefer to face hide glue. And once it is apart, you have a very easy job cleaning surfaces and you have virgin wood. However, thousands of resets have been done with white glue, and as with any professional activity beyond a certain point it is just a job, not really a big deall whatever is in there, except maybe epoxy.
- A second factor is the range of reversability, can you get a part apart is one question, with hide glue you can move pieces around when veneering, or placing braces, etc...
You can reverse with solvent, or heat, The range of reversible options is far wider, and they are all easy. and non-toxic.
I have a similar project in mind for something different. I would guess a cheaper (you have to access the fun factor [F is for friends who do things together; U is for you and me...]) option is a PID controller off the Bay. They run 10-20 dollars are set up to do exactly what you are talking about, and come with the controller, the juntion for you circuit; and the thermocouple. Lots of stuff on Youtube.
Not that you said anything to the contrary, David, but I use the overholter proximity method of joining soundboards with Titebond, and have made many rubbed joints with it. There are many glues you can rub, normally you can tell by just putting a drop between thumb and forefinger. The stuff is amazing for that.
Other than shelf life, in every respect I prefer the LMII white glue, however I use T1 because I can get it locally. T1 is totally proven in high stress uses like making guitars. I am all set up for hide glue also, but haven't been using it since I haven't been able to get the stuff i want for a while.
William, I will follow those up. One thing that surprised me a while back was not being able to find any coffee warmers. They all went USB. I saw one recently at Walmart, so maybe the local retail pendulum has swung. I suppose USB is an option with a plug head, but it just didn't yell POWER TOOL to me. Flea market sounds like the ticket.
There is a pretty reasonable one available from LMII, it is designed for the task.
If you look at the size of the acid brush in the set-up, you can see it is not a big hot plate. I use a copper closed end as the pot. I would not call the glue pot cheapish. Joel had something about how copper is way better for glue pots, so I grabbed the thing most to hand. I am going to tig on a sleave so the whole thing is taller, because I can only get the 1.5 inch end. And I turned the base flat so the heat transfer would be better. But neither is needed.
(checked the price on the 2 incher on Amazon.ca 19 bucks. Aaahh!
For a heat jacket, I use carbon felt from minibull designs. I find the windscreens are better value than the raw material. Carbon felt can take red heat, so it will never catch on fire just encircling your glue pot in contact with the element.
I keep hearing about this, which is the best additive in what quatity, and how water resitant, and what does it do to the glue that one wouldn't want? That's a lot, but even just the additive would be a first step.