Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Upcut, downcut straight router bits

Posts

Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#1

Upcut, downcut straight  router bits

Gary Smyth

I'm confused. If the router is upright do I want an upcut or a downcut carbide bit? If the router is upside down as in a router table which bit ought be installed? Should the sawdust be pushed up into the kerf or directed downward into the router?

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#2

Re: Upcut, downcut straight  router bits

don stephan

Can't speak for anyone else, but when cutting a rabbet or dado sometimes I'll use a spiral to push the wood down to avoid chipping along the surface. When cutting a deep dado I'll use the other direction spiral so the chips/sawdust gets lifted out of the cut. Up and down may depend on frame of reference. I don't use a straight 1/2" bit very often in favor of one of the spirals.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#3

Re: Upcut, downcut straight  router bits

roger lance

Recently made some storage cabinets with adjustable shelves. Used baltic birch ply which has a real tendency to splinter badly when drilled. So I used a down cut spiral bit in a plunge router to make the holes for the shelf pins and had no issues/problems with splintering/etc. Used the jig on the left to aline the holes.....


Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#4

Re: Upcut, downcut straight  router bits

John in NM

A downcut pushes the chips into the cut, and presumably out sideways. The idea is to reduce chipping out of veneer or laminate surface I believe.

An upcut pulls the chips out of the cut through the flutes in the bit - towards the router motor. Doesn't matter if it's upside down in a table or not, chips still go towards the motor. These are good bits for speed.

Straight bits are inexpensive.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#5

And let's not forget compression bits

Dick Coers

Compression bits are combination, uncut and downcut. They protect both faces by bringing the chips to the center of the board. It's mainly about protecting the faces. I was surprised to read about boring holes with a downcut, but to each his own. I personally don't own a downcut, except for not having a choice when I bought an Amana inlay kit. I quickly replaced it with an upcut. I've never had any chipping problems with hardwood, it's mainly for veneer and other man made materials.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#6

Re: Upcut, downcut straight  router bits

AZ in Colorado Springs

I have a Rockler router table, and use their shim set to configure the router table for edge jointing. Works great for small and medium size boards. I got a 3/8" downcut spiral bit for this, thinking it would push the chips up and away from the motor, and toward the shop-vac-dust-collection port. And it works great.

Then I got a box joint jig for the router table. That same 3/8" downcut spiral bit pushed the stock up and the box joints fit together poorly. I switched to up cut spiral bits (1/4", 3/8", & 1/2"), and they work great and do not push the stock away from the jig.

Remember that this is all upside down for the router table, so the up-cut bits pull the stock down toward the router/ jig/ table top (or at least they do not push the stock away from the router/ tabletop/ jig).

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#7

Re: Upcut, downcut straight  router bits

del schisler

when in the table use a down cut , this pull's the chips out of the cut, when other way use a up-cut this pull chips out, join this site, it is all about router's and tip's ect , i been a menber for yrs.

http://www.routerforums.com/

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#8

Re: Upcut, downcut straight  router bits

TomD

Those are nice Roger.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#9

Re: Upcut, downcut straight  router bits

roger lance

Thanks Tom. The first jig was from Norm Abram who also used a downcut bit and the second jig is from The Woodwhisperer for making dados. To further clarify using a downcut spiral bit to make clean holes in ply, I've made a couple of photos.....


I don't know if all downcuts have this end geometry, but this bit is designed for boring......and the results are nice clean holes.....


Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#10

Re: Upcut, downcut straight  router bits

TomD

Nice, I would give it a try, except I have the LV jig already.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#11

Re: Upcut, downcut, ought to be Right and Left

Keith Newton

Like screw threads, right hand threads are the normal direction. I don't know why they aren't designated like that. Even drill bits are R&L.

The right hand spirals really make precise fast drills, even in large sizes, when using a jig like Roger shows below.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#12

Re: Upcut, downcut, ought to be Right and Left

R. Payne

Only they don't work when spinning in different directions (like right and left drills or right and left threads), they both are right handed. One clears the chips up the other clears the chips down so up-cut and down-cut is correct.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#13

Correct

John in NM

Cut direction is right hand with both, the flute twist direction is what influences where the chips go.

Since there do exist left hand cut machines (I have one), it is handy that they went with up-down nomenclature for the twist direction. Googling for left hand cut bits would be a pain otherwise.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#14

Re: Upcut, downcut, ought to be Right and Left

Keith Newton

But an up cut for hand held, is down when it is in a table router. do you agree with that?

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#15

Re: Upcut, downcut, ought to be Right and Left

Carlos Clarke

no.

Think of it with respect to the board.

An up cut with the router in a table will cause the chips to fall down but they are being pulled up out of the board. The important thing is chip out. The up cut may cause chip out because it is pulling up against

the surface whereas the down cut will push the surface into the board and minimize chip out. That is

true regardless of the orientation of the router.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#16

Re: Upcut, downcut, ought to be Right and Left

James Heaston

What about Auzzies? Are up cuts down cuts & down cuts up cuts to them?

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#17

Anyone?...Anyone?

Gary Smyth

Has anyone EVER had a router fail because wood chips and dust is drawn into the router? The underside of my router does not appear to be sealed. When placed upside down in a router table in a permanent configuration I generate a lot of dross. Has anyone lost a router by directing material into it?

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#18

Re: Anyone?...Anyone?

Barry Irby

I have not and I have had an ancient Stanley router mounted "upside down" for years. I have read discussions about which ones are better for router tables. Which have bearings designed for that application and which suck in the least dirt. I don't remember a indicative answer or a compelling one. Wonder if it really is a problem or something fabricated out of what seems like it might be a Problem?

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#19

Re: Anyone?...Anyone?

Dick Coers

There were reports quite a few years ago of Craftsman routers breaking cooling fans from eating chips, but I've never witnessed any problems with any routers in the 40+ years I have been doing it.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#20

Re: Anyone?...Anyone?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Yes, I lost my Craftsman(8ys old) to this because it caused the bearing housing to become clogged with the dust and it just melted the housing of the bearing to the point that the entire mechanism has to be replaced.

End of case....I just went and bought a new router and am looking forward to returning to making my rocking chairs this Spring.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#21

Other than bearings, no, not me...

John in NM

I used to replace bearings on shop routers and sanders when I worked for a shop. Usually the bearing fit in the aluminum housing was too loose for replacement by the time it started making noise.

This was certainly caused by dust, perhaps not chips per se, but I rather doubt it would be aggravated much by an upcut bit. The airflow should be towards the bit, pushing the junk out sideways even in a router table - that is assuming all manufacturers use that basic bit of common sense.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#22

any one use the air hose ??


Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#23

The way bearings are sealed...

John in NM

Compressed air may do more harm than good, pushing dust past the seal. I'm a bit skeptical on that theory myself.

For what it's worth, the most of these tools I was referring to were more heavily used than home-shop tools, so one can expect a shorter service life. Actual run hours were probably about the same.

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#24

Re: The way bearings are sealed...

del schisler

i belive the way the beiring are in the router the air doesn't get to the seal, they are prested in the case so air goes past them and most of the air blow's air in to the aramature and the case , just keeps dust out , i been doing this for maybe 40 or so yrs and haven't had a beiring go out yet, just luck i guess , evertine you use the tool it is like new no dust, i blow out all the motor's also just me ? thanks for reading

Re: Upcut, downcut straight router bits

#25

Re: The way bearings are sealed...

John in NM

One side of the bearing has the seal exposed to the inside of the case - the seal that faces the armature. The inner and outer race of the bearing each have a little lip under which the edge of the seal fits. The theory is that positive pressure on the outside of this seal can push it in enough for dust to enter and soak up the grease. I doubt if any one has tested said theory though, your experience come closer than any I've seen claiming the opposite.

The only personal tool that I've replaced bearings in was my Hitachi slider. I bought it used and had to replace the bearings and brushes about 10 years later. At a guess it was 15 years old by then, perhaps 20. Never gets blown out with air because in addition to the bearings it has gearing in there, not as well sealed as the bearings.

Routers I do not use often enough to worry about in my view, so I do not blow them out either. I suppose much of that is habit from not having a decent air compressor for the first 20 years or so. I can't say as I'm convinced one way or the other.

My old jointer motor I always blow out however. Taking the ends off the housing messes up the field timing between the armature and the field windings - only motor I've ever taken apart with no tab between whatever the brushes are on and the field housing. Never taking that one apart again, even though I marked the housings with a chisel once I got it all aligned again.