Re: Down the rabbit hole
Sgian Dubh
Ellis, I too am not going to get involved in the wood or plastic cutting board debate, but you did say the following which I'd like to add something to:
"If the wood is oily or not particularly receptive of glue, the joints will fail before the wood will. In that case, biscuits or other splining methods will add a degree of adhesion that will hold the component pieces in their intended position even if the glue line itself fails. In those cases, the biscuits/tenons/whatever will also add a mechanical barrier against torquing the glueline further.
I'm not a regular user of biscuits, splines, dowels, etc in panel edge joinery, particularly if the adhesive used is a non-creeper, e.g., epoxy resin, urea formaldehyde, etc. However, such edge joint reinforcement can sometimes have a role in edge joints put together with creepy glues, such as PVA and aliphatic resin. I am aware that some users claim that creep doesn't exist in such adhesives, and they have data to 'prove' their contention. That's all fine and dandy, except that my experience of using these glues over decades shows their data must be flawed. What else but creep can explain the following examples of the phenomenon that I have witnessed?
1. An acquaintance made a sofa with laminated rails glued together with PVA. The cushions were supported by rubber webbing with metal tangs that slipped into grooves worked into the top edge of the rails, i.e., grooves orientated parallel with the plane of the laminations. A couple of years later the sofa failed because the laminates had crept to the point where grooves had near enough become rebates, and the metal tangs simply slipped out.
2. An older style television (they used to be pretty heavy 15 - 20 years ago) was placed with a foot set next to an aliphatic resin assembled glueline on a panel I'd made. I cannot think of anything other than creep to explain the fairly localised step in the glueline that developed over a two or three year period.
So, in the latter situation, I think a spline or perhaps a series of biscuits would have prevented the creep, and in the case of the sofa with the laminated rails, perhaps something like dowels fitted across the thickness every few inches would have prevented the laminates from sliding past on another.
On the whole though, apart from particular circumstances such as those outlined and others not described for the sake of brevity, or to satisfy the needs of a mass production furniture operation, I've not found a circumstance where biscuits, splines, dowels, etc, really add anything useful to a well formed plain edge joint. Slainte.