Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

Posts

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#26

Re: It depends on how much, what kind and how ..

Tony - Memphis

That's interesting.

I took some cooking classes at a local school. The owner bought oak flooring that was made for semi trailers and used it as counters. There was a spray bottle with a diluted bleach mixture at each bench. He said the health inspector loved it.

Tony

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#27

Ellis Walentine

Down the rabbit hole

Ellis Walentine

What started as a discussion of the possible advantages of biscuit joints in long-grain applications, turned into an enlightening discussion of wood vs. polyethylene cutting boards, two different topics for sure.

In respect of the first question, I'd echo TomD's advice that strong enough is good enough. In other words, long grain joints don't need biscuits to keep them from breaking at the glue line.

Now, a couple extra thoughts on this...

If the wood is oily or not particularly receptive of glue, the joints will fail before the wood will. In that case, biscuits or other splining methods will add a degree of adhesion that will hold the component pieces in their intended position even if the glue line itself fails. In those cases, the biscuits/tenons/whatever will also add a mechanical barrier against torquing the glueline further. So, they do add redundant strength.

I'm not going to weigh in on the cuttingboard question here.

Ellis

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#28

Re: Sorry Ellis

ChuckInND

I know that I'm at fault for the misdirections. Perhaps I should of started a different thread about where I went with it.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#29

Re: Down the rabbit hole

Sgian Dubh

Ellis, I too am not going to get involved in the wood or plastic cutting board debate, but you did say the following which I'd like to add something to:

"If the wood is oily or not particularly receptive of glue, the joints will fail before the wood will. In that case, biscuits or other splining methods will add a degree of adhesion that will hold the component pieces in their intended position even if the glue line itself fails. In those cases, the biscuits/tenons/whatever will also add a mechanical barrier against torquing the glueline further.

I'm not a regular user of biscuits, splines, dowels, etc in panel edge joinery, particularly if the adhesive used is a non-creeper, e.g., epoxy resin, urea formaldehyde, etc. However, such edge joint reinforcement can sometimes have a role in edge joints put together with creepy glues, such as PVA and aliphatic resin. I am aware that some users claim that creep doesn't exist in such adhesives, and they have data to 'prove' their contention. That's all fine and dandy, except that my experience of using these glues over decades shows their data must be flawed. What else but creep can explain the following examples of the phenomenon that I have witnessed?

1. An acquaintance made a sofa with laminated rails glued together with PVA. The cushions were supported by rubber webbing with metal tangs that slipped into grooves worked into the top edge of the rails, i.e., grooves orientated parallel with the plane of the laminations. A couple of years later the sofa failed because the laminates had crept to the point where grooves had near enough become rebates, and the metal tangs simply slipped out.

2. An older style television (they used to be pretty heavy 15 - 20 years ago) was placed with a foot set next to an aliphatic resin assembled glueline on a panel I'd made. I cannot think of anything other than creep to explain the fairly localised step in the glueline that developed over a two or three year period.

So, in the latter situation, I think a spline or perhaps a series of biscuits would have prevented the creep, and in the case of the sofa with the laminated rails, perhaps something like dowels fitted across the thickness every few inches would have prevented the laminates from sliding past on another.

On the whole though, apart from particular circumstances such as those outlined and others not described for the sake of brevity, or to satisfy the needs of a mass production furniture operation, I've not found a circumstance where biscuits, splines, dowels, etc, really add anything useful to a well formed plain edge joint. Slainte.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#30

Re: Down the rabbit hole

Barry Irby

It seems to me that if the glue fails on a cutting board and a crack opens but is restrained from complete failure by biscuits or splines, its worse that the board falling apart. The crack, no matter how tiny would be a cavity for crud to accumulate and turn nasty.

I made a bunch of end grain cutting boards out of scraps. They were about 12" X 18" and 1 3/4" thick. Out of about ten of them two failed because the wood shrank in the middle of the boards and cracks opened. In one case the crack extended to the edge of the board and in the other it did not. The failures were about fifty fifty wood and along the glue lines. They were glued with Titebond II. I am convinced the failures were form some of the scraps not being as dry as others. Even thought the boards did not fall apart we through them away because of the crud factor.

Incidentally, I set these boards up and soaked the top side with cooking oil (Safflower I think) for hours or days until the oil literally soaked through and dripped out of the bottom. Then I turned them over and soaked any dry areas on the other side. They were Walnut. My opinion on this is that it would be better to make cutting boards out of closed cell woods That would not let the oil (and crud) drool through. IE, white oak rather than red oak, but probably something better than even white oak.

I think creep in the glue is less of a problem in cutting boards because it at least does not open and allow for the crud.

I am a fan of wooden boards over the plastic ones.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#31

Ellis Walentine

Good point

Ellis Walentine

Certainly you don't want cutting boards with open cracks, along the glue lines or in the wood itself. My point about the possible constructive role of biscuits was that the glue strength in the biscuit joints should be enough to keep even a failed glue line tight enough that it would be barely noticeable and functionally sound (enough, or not). This is the same principle that governs the rack resistance of a mortise-and-tenon joint of whatever design. The shoulders are not glued but the glue surfaces inside the joint keep them tight to the leg or stile, providing rack resistance proportionate to the length of the long shoulders. Depending on the thickness and stiffness of the tenon member (e.g., the biscuit), it will also lend a measure of beam strength across the joint as well.

Ellis