Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

Posts

Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#1

Bart Goldberg

Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

Bart Goldberg

While at a crafts fair in Morristown, NJ over the weekend, I saw two different booths touting that their cutting boards are stronger because they use biscuits between their boards, and they had some cut away demos to show this. Note that these were not end grain cutting boards, but long grain boards. I discussed this with a pro woodworker friends and he agreed with them and was also of the opinion that biscuits will reinforce the strength a glue joint. I differ on this and believe that biscuits are only useful as an alignment mechanism and that if the glue joint fails, that the biscuit will not help at all, and in fact will reduce the strength of the glue joint cause your removing some of the wood used to make the glue line between boards. What do you all think?

Thanks

Bart

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#2

Baloney

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A well made glue joint in solid wood is stronger than the wood being bonded. Given that the wood fractures before the glue line, exactly how do they explain the perceived benefit from biscuits? I don't even find them useful for alignment. I can get more precise alignment without them.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#3

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

BrianMonumentCO

A possible argument could go as follows; Since a biscuit is generally coated in glue and inserted into a slot, the amount of glue surface would be increased over a simple glued butt joint. In this way the joint takes on a glue surface more akin to a tongue and groove assembly more than a butt joint. But the impact of this would appear to minor.

Good grain selection, orientation, good glue, and proper preparation would appear to have a greater impact on the strength of any glueup.

On the down side of using biscuits in making panels, is the alleged "telegraphing" of the biscuit shape in thinner stock.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#4

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

There was a study of this a few years ago in one of the woodworking magazines. They determined that biscuits add little if any joints unless they are used in a end grain to long grain joint. Sorry I don't recall which magazine or year that the article appeared.

Lee

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#5

Re: Obvious truth

TomD

1) You can't have a meaningful discussion without specifying the failure mode. It is trueish that glue joints are stronger than the surrounding wood when well made. But a biscuit is a glue joint in wood, at right angles that is stronger than the surrounding wood, so perhaps someone could explain why all of a sudden this is now weaker in every failure mode.

2) It is generally accepted that cross grain matrices like plywood are stronger as panels and less strong as elements, for given weight and spec. When did that all of sudden stop being true? Hard to think of a cutting board as either a panel or an element.

3) It is generally accepted that when glued up that sidegrain butt joints are potentially as strong as the surrounding wood, but that is the weakest fracture line in any wooden structure, so there can be situations where we shouldn't be all that cocky about it. I have repaired both my wife's pre-marriage cutting board, and several neighbour's boards when they separated along glue lines. A good way to make a living is to sell as an advantage a feature that really just lowers your call-backs or returns. So I wouldn't immediately assume the guys in the biz are out to lunch.

4) While the butt joints are stronger thing is generally accepted it actually isn't always true. It is stronger when you set out to crudely break the joint with some massive force. And even in that case generally only if the solid comparative piece was easy to split up parallel grained wood. It is far from true if you just toss two identical boards aside for 20 years, one glued up and the other solid wood. And things that make matters much worse for the glued board are the following:

- Dissimilar wood species;

- Moisture variation;

- Dissimilar grain orientation.

All pretty common in cutting boards.

5) There are rowed woods cut one of those and glue it, then tell me it is stronger at the glueline.

There are a number of truths in woodworking that while true are also false if taken too far, and by far I don't mean ridiculous lengths. For instance the idea that endgrain joints aren't as strong as sidegrain joints (often people even say they have no strength at all). Or the idea that you can't usefully add structure to sidegrain joints.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#6

Re: Obvious truth

don stephan

Endgrain to endgrain ad even endgrain to sidegrain glue joints are as strong as sidegrain to sidegrain glue joints? That's not been my experience with yellow glues and with hot hide glue. I'd love to have them be equally strong, can you offer a technique for this?

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#7

Re: Obvious truth

Ron Pemberton

A fellow demonstrated a miter joint reinforced by biscuits in a woodworkers club meeting I belonged to many years ago. He used 2 x 2 stock about 12 inches long. The glue had sat overnight. He tried to pull the joint apart but couldn't. He then put it in a vise and got a small hammer and tried to break the joint but couldn't. He then got a bigger hammer and finally broke the joint. I don't remember what part of the joint failed. That demonstration must have impressed me because that happened over 40 years ago. Most of my picture frames contain a biscuit or spline.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#8

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

waroland

I owned a biscuit jointer back many years ago and used it on several projects until I figgered out it was easier and less time consuming to NOT use it. The glue joint is stronger than the wood on a proper joint and I don't need the biscuits for alignment. M2C.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#9

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

Uncle Jess

Here's a datapoint. When I took Intro to woodworking at a local community college, in the second class, after a short demo of using the jointer and planer, we edge glued two boards. We were absolute rank amateurs. After clamping for 30 minutes, we were given hammers and told to bang on the assembly until it broke. Not a single one of the 20 of us got a break on the glue joint.

Yes, butt joints need something more, but there are lots of better fitting joints than a biscuit. Just don't see the point.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#10

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

North of the Border

If you go by Tage Frid's advice (Fine Woodworking, "Textbook Mistakes"), you would put nothing there, just an edge to edge glue joint. He even considered the use of T & G joint a waste of time.

I have never had an edge to edge glue joint failure with any cutting boards, the first one made at least 14 years ago (could be much longer). I didn't even have Titebond III. So practical purposes, I wouldn't even bother to use any biscuits.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#11

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

mdclor

"...I saw two different booths touting that their cutting boards are stronger because they use biscuits between their boards, and they had some cut away demos to show this."

IMO this is simply a marketing gimmick to impress potential buyers that don't know better (maybe 99.9% of the population) and to justify the high cost of their products.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#12

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

ChuckInND

I was a meat cutter for about 18 years, and quite a few years ago wood cutting boards were banned from the trades when cutting meat on, they absorb bacteria and there is not a guaranteed way for all of the removal of it. So everyone in the trades was forced to use poly cutting boards. It was a decission that I agree with. I remember the old days when I did cut on a maple butcher block style table in a retail meat shop.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#13

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

David Yoho

I think your data is outdated. If I remember right, they're now saying the reverse is true.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#15

OIL?

david weaver

If you were to oil the board regularly, maybe you could eventually get a failure. You would have to put a lot of oil on it, though.

I'd be indifferent about biscuits because the board would end up being planed down and used for a laptop computer board in my house while we use the plastic cutting boards to prep food.

Well, I guess that means I shouldn't be indifferent about the biscuits, I could plane into them and that would look really dumb.

(the last time I bought a wood cutting board, it was alternating maple and walnut and the maine state correctional facility in thomaston was selling large ones for $12 - makes a good laptop board).

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#16

Hysteria about the unseen bugaboos

david weaver

I guess none of us would never know what made us sick. A cutting board that is allowed to dry off of one that is bleached is usually not going to be housing anything.

I suppose in future decades, we'll be reading more stories about which of the two is more favorable. Until then, I know I can bleach plastic without issue. Cosmetically, I don't know that such a thing with wood would turn out cosmetically nice.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#17

Bart Goldberg

Re: OIL?

Bart Goldberg

So are the strips in the boards suppose to represent prison clothing?

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#18

Oil not an isue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a cutting block 48 years old that I have oiled with cooking oil for this time. Oil doesn't penetrate enough to cause glue failure.

In my youth I passed by a grocery in grade school. Behind the butcher sales counter was an enormous butcher block where stuff got cut up. Miraculously, by today's reckoning, patrons survived eating stuff cut up on this block. Maybe they had better immune systems back then. Or maybe fretting about cutting boards is unnecessary for all but the severely immune compromised.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#19

Re: Obvious truth

TomD

Sidegrain to sidegrain is 100% percent subject to some of the reservations noted. But endgrain to endgrain is not, except obviously scarfs. But endgrain to sidegrain is about as strong as sidegrain is maybe moreso since you get great glue penetration. this is the basis of stuff like endgrain balsa core. And in joints that I break, the endgain is bonded to the sidegrain. The glues I use are the regular things like yellow, hide, or epoxy. What doesn't work is that you can't just glue a board end to end and it is good to go. But in many cases that is extrapolated to statements that it either has no boding strength at all, or none that matters. The former isn't true and the latter depends on design.

I doubt I have answered your question?

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#20

Re: Oil not an isue

TomD

I think it is a misconception that anything penetrates wood that much. Apparently Oil is used by some japanese craftsmen to saturate their plane blocks (though some use nothing at all as a finish or penetrant). But in that case, and there are probably similar ones over here, it is coming in through the end. For the most part finishes have molecules that are too large to penetrate wood. Sometime carriers will penetrate wood. Water is obviously able to.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#21

Re: True not worth doing

TomD

"If you go by Tage Frid's advice (Fine Woodworking, "Textbook Mistakes"), you would put nothing there, just an edge to edge glue joint. He even considered the use of T & G joint a waste of time."

Edge to edge is more than strong enough, and T&G I don't even consider a glue joint, far to hard to get a perfect pressure fit over all those surfaces. I would agree entirely. It isn't worth doing for the most part, but that is different from saying it doesn't strengthen the joint. You just don't need stronger than strong enough.

"I have never had an edge to edge glue joint failure with any cutting boards, the first one made at least 14 years ago (could be much longer). I didn't even have Titebond III. So practical purposes, I wouldn't even bother to use any biscuits."

I agree entirely. I would take it one step further and say I wouldn't bother to make a cutting board out of pieces, it is sophomoric design to make those stripped things, and single pieces of solid wood are lying around free everywhere. Why glue at all.

But you are a woodworker, you make your own joints, and we can do things to make them more durable in this environment, and one hopes enforce treatment of the product that is non-insane. But if you make stuff for the market you will be handling returns on the dog that ate my homework general level of common sense, and you will have worked out how many returns it takes to make the whole line unprofitble. Surprisingly few would be my guess. If someone doing that says biscuits are better, I have heard zero in this thread that would displace that view.

I actually have some minor experience of this type of board. My Dad makes them as a sideline. A lot of his have cracked, it is a laboratory of glue joint failure, I can imagine how he came to use dowels. :) His pieces are about 1/2 inch square.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#22

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

ChuckInND

Thats an interesting article, and I can understand some points, but for me I still prefer plastic. It's easier to maintain, which in my opinion makes it safer from bacteria. At the end of the day it's alot easier to take the cutting board off the table and wash and bleach, try doing that with a stationary butchers block. When the plastic gets scared up, every once in awhile we would sand them down to remove the scaring. And I'll add that doesn't it make sense that boards put together with end grain exposed tops are probably the worse for absorbing things ? I know when putting a finish on the end of any board it sure sucks up the finish fast, usually taking more coats then the rest of the board.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#23

Re: It depends on how much, what kind and how ..

david weaver

...and how you apply it.

One of the things that I have done on old planes that don't weigh enough is something George Wilson suggested, and that is to plug the mouth and fill the mortise with raw linseed oil before oiling the ends of the planes.

When I do that, the oil literally goes to the other ends of the planes. I've never done it on a new plane, but something does definitely happen to beech as it gets older and it seems to be weaker in the late wood. Whatever it is, oil flows freely through it within a day.

This saturation may not be an issue with butcher blocks because who would do that? It is enough of an issue with planes that I don't do it with any of my newly made planes because I don't want my fresh glue joint on the handles to have any reason to not hold 100%.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#24

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

ChuckInND

I'll also add that at the Federally inspected meat plants that I worked at, the poly cutting boards were removed from the table, sprayed with foam soap, scrubbed, then power washed. I'd be very surprised if you'll find a wood cutting board nowdays in a city or federal inspected meat shop, or plant.

Re: Biscuits reinforce glue joint?

#25

Re: It depends on how much, what kind and how ..

edward in vancouver

Ahh... cutting boards.

Well, I've been cooking professionally for close to 35 years now, and in three continents as well, so I have formed some opinions about cutting boards.

For me, as a cook (and owner/operator) the main question is how do you sanitize the board? For nylon, it's a no-brainer--you toss it in the d/washer and it's done. For wood, you need to scrape off all remaining debris, wash it with bleach or quats, wait the prescribed time, then wipe off, air dry, and possibly oil it. A p.i.t.a. and one that many cooks don't do properly if not supervised....

Yes, nylon scars easily, so does wood, but not as easily as nylon. For the good, commercial quality nylon cutting boards (5/8 - 3/4" thick) it doesn't make sense to toss the board out if it's heavily scarred. There is an invention called a thickness planer and it works beautifully on nylon. I used to earn beer money from previous employers, taking the scarred boards to a friend and running them through his planer, giving thee boards back with two pristine new surfaces. The sushi places have a different tactic, they use a clothes iron to "iron" the board smooth when it get's scarred.