Re: True not worth doing
TomD
"If you go by Tage Frid's advice (Fine Woodworking, "Textbook Mistakes"), you would put nothing there, just an edge to edge glue joint. He even considered the use of T & G joint a waste of time."
Edge to edge is more than strong enough, and T&G I don't even consider a glue joint, far to hard to get a perfect pressure fit over all those surfaces. I would agree entirely. It isn't worth doing for the most part, but that is different from saying it doesn't strengthen the joint. You just don't need stronger than strong enough.
"I have never had an edge to edge glue joint failure with any cutting boards, the first one made at least 14 years ago (could be much longer). I didn't even have Titebond III. So practical purposes, I wouldn't even bother to use any biscuits."
I agree entirely. I would take it one step further and say I wouldn't bother to make a cutting board out of pieces, it is sophomoric design to make those stripped things, and single pieces of solid wood are lying around free everywhere. Why glue at all.
But you are a woodworker, you make your own joints, and we can do things to make them more durable in this environment, and one hopes enforce treatment of the product that is non-insane. But if you make stuff for the market you will be handling returns on the dog that ate my homework general level of common sense, and you will have worked out how many returns it takes to make the whole line unprofitble. Surprisingly few would be my guess. If someone doing that says biscuits are better, I have heard zero in this thread that would displace that view.
I actually have some minor experience of this type of board. My Dad makes them as a sideline. A lot of his have cracked, it is a laboratory of glue joint failure, I can imagine how he came to use dowels.
His pieces are about 1/2 inch square.