Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

How the environment becomes safer

Posts

How the environment becomes safer

#1

How the environment becomes safer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One way. People have near misses and accidents. They get reported. Avoiding hazardous situations becomes part of rules and codes (building, electrical, fire) and embedded into work practices and culture. One of the important roles the WoodCentral Forums can play is to provide a venue for reporting near misses and accidents so that others can benefit from the knowledge.


I don't recall why this mallet was on the table of the table saw. It certainly was serving no useful purpose being there. And I don't remember what happened that it found its way into the blade which turned it into a missile. The point is that it was some trivial event that got it there that I did not anticipate. I can't be certain a similar trivial event won't occur but I can eliminate the occurrence of a potential missile being available for launch.

As a result the table saw is off limits for storage. If it isn't wood being cut, or part of some fixturing securely fastened it is banned from the saw table.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: How the environment becomes safer

Jesper, Denmark

It's a noble intention......and I concur.

Problem is only, will I abide by it ?????

I do manage (mostly) to always lower the blade below the table surface after use and pull the safety switch if under-age visitors in the shop.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#3

Re: How the environment becomes safer

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

The take-away for me in these last couple TS safety related threads is to remember to think about what I am doing and to maybe rethink some current practices.

Right or wrong, those recent threads/comments are a reminder to me.

I am guilty on a lot of levels. Mostly because I use my cabinet saw as a work bench more than anything. I always have the blade down as a result when not in use, and when I do use it, it gets cleared off. Usually and mostly - see, I am guilty...

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#4

Re: How the environment becomes safer

Keith Newton

Bill, While I agree, I have to admit that I'm guilty. But it's not my fault,,,,,,,, I always like to blame someone else for my shortcomings, and a certain image of Sam Maloof comes to mind. He loved to assemble his chairs on the TS. he he.

Besides the obvious things laying on top of the tool, even really small things way back on the catch table can lead to problems. A finish nail laying back there somewhere becomes a roller pushing that end to one side or the other, as well as screws and pencils.

Another hazard that has caught me off guard, was having my pocket knife activate the start switch as I was reaching over, while the blade was up.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#5

Misplaced analysis

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

If you managed to light off your table saw with that big hammer in play, then I am no longer offended by your remarks earlier—I'm saddened by them.

The failure mode was not that the hammer was on the table, it was that you didn't clear the area—a far more serious flaw in your fundamental work protocol. Sterilize the work area all you want, if you don't clear the environment before firing up a powerful tool, the fault can easily be found in a mirror.

All this discussion has done for me is narrow the field of voices I value. Well, not all—a conscientious introspection of my own practices has revealed that I'm just fine in my safety approach. And I now know a little better whose counsel is worth embracing, but more importantly, whose is not.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#6

Re: How the environment becomes safer

roger lance

What happens if good men say nothing?? Many years ago I had a kickback on the table saw....the details of which I don't recall....but it was quick, unexpected, and very forceful.....part of what I was working on got flung across the shop and struck the side of a clamp which was holding together a glue up.....red chards went flying everywhere.....


still have the clamp as a reminder of how potentially dangerous a running saw can be and to limit the potential of another unexpected event by respecting that tool and its power.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#7

Re: How the environment becomes safer

Paul Leuba

Thanks for the post, Bill! This sharing of safety and accident information helps keep in front of us all the importance of being alert and thinking about what your doing in the shop and not day dreaming about something else.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#8

Opinions.....

roger lance

Have to agree.....this discussion has been revealing.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#9

PS......

roger lance

Liked your auxiliary fence.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#10

Re: How the environment becomes safer

Jesse Cloud

Thanks for the post Bill. It is dramatic and useful. I will carry that image in my head for a long while.

Its important for us all to remember that we are human and no matter how smart or meticulous we are, we still need to be mindful in the shop.

My own transgression is usually the fallacy, "Well, its just one cut, no need to clean up, set up, clamp down, etc." Caught up with me last year and I ran a 5 inch jig saw blade through my hand. Lost some range of motion and it took me almost a year to relearn how to hold a chisel. Only accident in 30 years of wood working, but the odds catch up to you sooner or later.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#11

Not a bad idea...

John in NM

At work I usually get the response you are now very familiar with, because I'm the guy who yells at whoever is using the drill press without clamping or otherwise restraining their work piece.

At work we're usually drilling steel or aluminum, in my own shop it's almost always wood so at home I would be bad and get as complacent as the people at work.

I now have a wonderful scar to show them :D

Fresh the cut didn't look too bad:


This is the scar after about 18 months - it still looks the same today:


Had this been caused by a steel burr rather than aluminum, there is a good chance it would have hit that vein.

While I understand, and often share the immediate reaction people have on this subject, I've also had enough near misses to appreciate how you just don't see them coming. Before the accident it seemed unlikely, impossible, dodgeable. Afterwards it is obvious that it was just a matter of time.

I would say the first rule is don't do things with which you are not comfortable. The second rule is to pay attention to the other guy's discomfort with something you are comfortable with. The first one is obvious to any sensible person - it's the second one that gets far too many people's hackles up, and I include myself in that group.

Sometimes that other guy is out there, worrying over nothing. Other times, he's pointing out a mistake from which he's already learned his lesson.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#12

Re: Misplaced Ire

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Anybody can make dumb mistakes. We can all learn from them if they are willing to share without having to deal with Monday Morning Judgements.

Like your nifty flotsam tray, but would opine that it (or anything else) has no business sitting on a table saw fence. Especially on a saw that's not equipped with a blade guard. Something gets bumped and falls into the spinning plade, we'll be writing "knew him well" messages in memorial posts here.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#13

Re: How the environment becomes safer

Thomas S Stockton

Bill

A simple blade guard would have prevented the hammer from falling into the blade.

I used to have an excalibur on my cabinet saw and really liked it easy to remove when needed and worked well.

Tom

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#14

Is there one that fits with a sled in place?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the mallet was on the side of the sled which was on the saw. My sled covers the entire saw table. I regard it as the safest way to cross cut.......unless there is a stray mallet around with an urge to jump into the spinning blade. Again, the whole affair seemed so trivial and unanticipated that I don't recall how it happened. But I can easily ensure it will not happen again.

I have the nice (and expensive) Delta guard, flipped out of the way to dramatize the mallet and blade.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#15

Bill, thanks for the post

Mike Potts

It is so very easy to find fault, but it take a real man to admit there was a problem, then go public in hopes of helping others.

keep it safe

Mike

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#16

Re: How the environment becomes safer

TomD

Good to share, glad nobody was hurt, I gather. I do think some of the responses if I took them correctly are a little harsh. Nobody was hurt, no laws were broken. A home shop is a sanctuary, and you can do what you want, and avoid the bloodshed how you wish. I think one has to be aware of the bad stuff that could have happened, but also realize a miss is not a hit.

There are two reasons people think the other guy is a fool after an accident. One is because he did something stupid, and it is impossible that one would have done something equally stupid, which is reassuring. The other is because the person who thinks the other guy is stupid is not so good at dealing with the randomness of bad outcomes, and wants to lull himself into the sense that the thing, or the thing that would sucker him, is not out there. Just for emphasis, that last attitude is not life affirming.

Re: How the environment becomes safer

#17

Re: Is there one that fits with a sled in place?

Jesse Cloud

The excalibur that Tom mentioned will work over a sled - it lowers from an arm above.

Another way to skin the cat is to build the guard into the sled. I've seen pics of sleds with a three sided acrylic shield that attaches to the pieces of vertical wood in the center. They attach with a piece of acrylic or whatever that has a slot in the middle and a screw to set the height in keeping with the application.