Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

Posts

Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#1

Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

Henry Higginbotham

Maybe this is just a harebrained scheme, but let's say you have a central dust collection system of 3hp, 5hp, whatever. Usually it works adequately, but sometimes it could use a bit more air flow.

Now let's say that you were recently buying goodies at a surplus sale and the seller just gave you a 2hp New York Blower model 106, because it was 3 phase and nobody else seemed to want it.

Is there some way to incorporate the bonus blower into the system, maybe essentially parallel with the main system air flow, or in some other useful way? Anyone done this or seen it done?

'Tis the season for Christmas Vacation, too, so I'd put it on a separate switch, labeled "Auxiliary Nuclear." :D


Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

Jesper, Denmark

NOT harebrained, but it is better in series rater than parallel.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#3

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

Henry Higginbotham

As in putting it between the cyclone exhaust and the filters, or some other way? The reason parallel appealed to me is that the second blower wouldn't have to run all the time, but in series wouldn't it just be in the way if not running?

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#4

That would be one way, but another,

Keith Newton

would be, If you had a tool way off beyond the others, you could leave a gate closing that branch off, while you #1 took care of most everything else, but when you needed the extra boost, you could turn it on.

But that would be counter productive, if it ran while you were trying to use any of the others.

If you don't have gates on any of your drops, that might be a better next step for what you've got.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#5

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

Bill Howatt

I don't think this is a simple question. It depends on fluid mechanics and all that neat stuff. The interaction between the 2 fans could actually make things worse if for example the main fan was caused to cavitate due to the action of the second fan. This is my non-quantitative wondering.

Where I see it may be an advantage would be at the end of a long run which normally does not get the draw the other parts of the system do.

Bill

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#6

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

NO, NO, NO!!!!

There was quite a lengthy discussion of this on Sawmill Creek a few years ago. Without going into a lot of detail- without a sophisticated monitoring and control circuitry, if you put two blowers in series you will cause oscillating flow and you will have runaway current and eventually burn up one motor or both motors. Also, if you do get it to work, one blower will act as a limiter and any improvement will not be worth the complexity and cost.

A parallel configuration has another set of issues, not the least of which is the ducting leading to and coming from the blowers and a mismatch in SP.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#7

Ouch!

Henry Higginbotham

So, uh, that's a No? :D

Not the answer I was wanting, but pretty much what I was expecting. At least I'm not out any money, and might even be able to move the extra blower on Craigslist or eBay.

Thanks, Alan.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#8

Re: Ouch!

ChuckInND

Who is to say that you can't split your ducting appropriately into two different systems. You don't give much information on what you have got going on, which includes if you have 3 phase in your shop already, or if that would be another expense. It's kind of a wishy washy post if you ask me.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#9

Oscillating flow?

Dick Coers

The dust actually goes back and forth? I'd like to see the engineering, or physics, on that. Were these observed problems, or Internet speculation? I know a lot of these discussions are based on speculation and not factual data. NOT saying you are wrong, just slightly skeptical. Just my engineering side thinking about looking into the proof.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#10

Re: Oscillating flow? *LINK*

Dick Coers

Found this info, where they suggest a sophisticated switching. Their second option, manual switch. They call their unit a duct cleaner to blow out dust drop out.


http://www.qamanage.com/DustCollection/DuctCleanerBooster

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#11

Second reference to booster fan *LINK*

Dick Coers

No specifics, but a professional reference to a booster fan in the last paragraph on the page. I didn't continue reading the article.


http://www.farrapc.com/applications/woodworking/

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#12

Re: Ouch!

Henry Higginbotham

Hmmm . . . okay. I've reviewed the original post and don't see the wishywashiness that you see. Being too specific in the question sometimes limits the creativity of the solutions.

The question is whether anyone has seen a secondary blower incorporated in any way. The blower was free (and I do have 3 phase), so I'm willing to consider any possible use of it, though preferably one that integrates it with a central system.

Splitting into two systems, as you suggest, sounds like it should technically work*, except that it would require a second cyclone with another set of filters. I was hoping to just force more air through the primary cyclone and filters.

Another idea I've toyed with is to use the second blower with its own cyclone, but vent it to the outside with minimal filtration, which here in Alabama I can do 8-9 months out of the year.

----------

*Alan--if a secondary blower pulls from the central plenum at some distance (10-15 feet) from the primary blower, and sends whatever dust it corrals through a second cyclone and filter, would the same concerns apply? And would it even increase the air flow at the machinery?

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#13

Re: Oscillating flow?

ChuckInND

Dick, from what I can tell, a booster fan is actually not even a fan or a blower, it's quick pulses of high volume compressed air. I can't imagine what the cost of a air compressor that would keep up with it, plus the controls. I wish that people would be more specific as to what their actual situation is when looking for advise. And maybe they could do a little more research for themselves, it wasn't that hard to find.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#14

Re: Oscillating flow?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

No, it may pulse, and possibly do so dramatically, because the blowers will be unable to synchronize. As #1 pulls or pushes harder/more CFM than #2, #2 will attempt to respond by overspeeding (moving too much air) or slowing the air flow. #1 will then respond accordingly and the whole process can keep cycling and quite rapidly, until one motor burns up. Compounding the problem the SP of the system is not static- it changes as you open and close machine blast gates- so any dual motor control must be able to adjust for that, and adjust quickly.

Again, this is an extremely difficult configuration to balance. A few folks (like home shop cyclone pioneer, Jim Halbert- I'm not sure but believe Bill Pentz may mention it on his website) claim to have successfully done it by using blast gates to balance the blower flows. But, while he said he was able to get it to work, I don't recall if it was for any sustained amount of time or when actually used to collect dust in an operational configuration (I doubt it). He also said he burned up a motor or two during his experimenting. So, unless you have a lot of experience with motor/blowers, fluid dynamics, and sophisticated monitoring and control circuitry and equipment, you pays your price and takes your chance.

As I said there is a much better discussion of this over on Sawmill Creek.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#15

Re: Ouch!

ChuckInND

( let's say you have a central dust collection system of 3hp, 5hp, whatever. ) Which is it ? That doesn't sound wishy washy to you ? Plus no layout or pictures of your actual current ductwork setup. I'd be willing to bet that any dust collection company would want ALOT more information then you give before throwing suggestions to you. It's hard to help people that don't want to put much effort into things, and then expect others to do it for them. It's not like anyone gets paid around here, well except for one person.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#16

Re: Ouch!

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

*Alan--if a secondary blower pulls from the central plenum at some distance (10-15 feet) from the primary blower, and sends whatever dust it corrals through a second cyclone and filter, would the same concerns apply? And would it even increase the air flow at the machinery?

You are still asking two totally different blowers with different fan curves and no control system to work together in a fashion, just a little farther apart. Both would be attempting to pull from the central plenum, from the tool(s) with open blast gates, and . . . . . from each other- working against each other- especially when all tool blast gates are closed. It is a different situation than attempting to put two blowers in series, but it would take some serious analysis to determine the end result. There are some similarities but it is different than summing vector forces- e.g. two people pulling on two ropes to lift one object- some force/energy is used (wasted) just keeping the two people apart.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#17

Re: Oscillating flow?

ChuckInND

Alan, I'm not a big fan of Bill Pentz, or anyone else that insinuates that a dust collector is going to save your lungs. A dust collector is NOT an air filtration machine. Also, I'm wondering if the original posters shop is a hobby shop or a commercial shop.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#18

Re: Oscillating flow?

Dick Coers

Sorry Alan, but due to my continued verbal descriptions of Grizzly's poor bandsaw quality, I am not allowed to participate in discussions on Sawmillcreek.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#19

Re: Oscillating flow?

ChuckInND

Dick, you mean that I'm not the only person thats been bullied out by a different forum ? Their loss, don't feel like the lone ranger. It's not like it was a paying job anyway.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#20

Re: Oscillating flow?

Dick Coers

I wasn't bullied out, I was kicked out by the owner. He goes to great lengths to protect paying advertisers.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#21

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

Jason in OC

As has been mentioned, there will be load matching and flow matching problems in a DC system that aren't worth getting into. Other possible uses:

Make a spray booth with it.

Make an air cleaner with it. I have one that is a squirrel cage fan inside of a box, with filters on 3 sides of the box and the exhaust on the 4th side.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#22

Re: Oscillating flow?

ChuckInND

Trust me Dick, I know it all too well. I'm not a fan of Grizzly either, and I've had quite a few discussions with people that want to brag about Harbor Freight, I ask them if they promote cheaply made imported furniture also. I use to be a pretty big fan of Delta, but thats not looking so good either, along with the majority of the woodworking machinery companies nowdays, which all seem to be imported.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#23

Thanks for all the advice

Henry Higginbotham

I kind of suspected that I wasn't going to get something for nothing, but my knowledge of fluid dynamics is just about nil. Probably now it'll sit around for a while until I bark my shin on it a couple of times, and then it's off to Craigslist.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#24

Re: Thanks for all the advice

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I was just contacted by Jim Halbert who says he has been using a series system for almost 20 years and says he has helped others make similar systems. He is using two 5 hp Leeson motors driving two DIY centrifugal blowers with 15" straight blade impellers for his current system. He confirmed he burned up a few motors in his early attempts, but claims that was due to them being cheap Taiwan/Chinese motors (think, Harbor Freight, Reliant, etc. etc.)

I won't post any other details until I get clarification from Jim on a number of points.

Re: Can you put a "helper" blower on a DC system?

#25

Re: Thanks for all the advice

Larry in NW Ohio

Now there is a name I have not heard for years, Jim Halbert. My wife and I was going to Branson on vacation about 10 years ago and asked if anyone lived close there, and I heard from Jim. He gave me his phone number and address and invited me to stop in for a visit. Well we did get to Branson and we did go to see Jim at his house. He is quite a woodworker and makes some really nice DC, I wish I had half his talent for makeing things. His double motor DC system is something to see and hear. I`m glad to hear that he is still around. I would really love to stop in and see him again sometime. Larry