Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Jointer Recomendations

Posts

Jointer Recomendations

#1

Jointer Recomendations

Jake Dahn

Looking for some guidance from the group. I am looking for the best jointer for my budget. Approximately $2k before taxes and shipping.

Minimum 8"

Powermatic is having a Black Friday sale, 15% off.

Looking at their 8" parallelogram jointer, (pj882), with straight knives. I can pick up a insert cutterhead later for less that the $800 upgrade from powermatic.

Are there any other recommendations?

Is the parallelogram worth the upgrade?

Thanks

Jake

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#2

Re: Jointer Recomendations

Clementine

General International

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#3

Re: Jointer Recomendations

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Spiral cutter heads are worth every penny. They produce much less tearout, especially with figured woods. They are quieter and require less physical effort to move the wood through.

Parallelogram design is a good thing. It keeps the mouth opening at the cutter head tighter than other design.

T.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#4

Re: Jointer Recomendations

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Have you considered the used market for either the Powermatic or the Delta DJ-20, which has basically the same internal workings? If you are going to replace the head with a Byrd anyhow, you've already committed to the time and effort to make sure everything is in alignment. The alignment procedures for a parallelagram jointer are a bit more complicated than for a wedge bed jointer (like the General Internationals, etc.), but they rarely if ever go out of alignment, and the relignment will restore the machine to original performance specs, where it will stay for many decades. I would not recommend a wedge bed jointer. They are designed for ease of manufacture, not robust components, and will eventually get sloppy due to vibration, friction and wear in the bed ways.

If you do consider a used PM or Delta, take an accurate straight edge with you to make sure the beds and the fence are flat. Taking twist out of one of these components would require a competent machine shop (as would remachining the bed ways on a wedge bed jointer).

I've lifted my old DJ-20 (bought third hand in the late '90s) several times by the ends of the tables, and this has never caused alignment problems. I wouldn't recommend that with a wedge bed machine.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#5

Alternate opinion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have an 8" 1970's Delta. It has been involved in working thousands of bdft of lumber over the years. Based on this experience I have concluded:

1. Buy the widest longest jointer you can afford. That said, I have never not been able to do something on what I have, but longer and wider would have been more convenient at times. I once, with help, made a 16' long 2 x6 oak stair hand rail for a store.

2. By going slow I have never failed to get an acceptable cut on the native woods I use.

If cost and space was not an issue I would own two jointers, one for flattening and one for edge preparation. Flattening is hard on knives. Before I used my jointer much for flatening I would go years before needing to sharpen an 8" knife. (I would start with the fence at one end of the knives and mover it in 2" increments as the knives got dull over time)

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#6

Not in my lifetime

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You make two statements that are contrary to my experience with an early 1970's Delta.

"They are designed for ease of manufacture, not robust components, and will eventually get sloppy due to vibration, friction and wear in the bed ways."

Mine is 40 years old and hasn't . It has had as much use as one could imagine in a part time shop. I've worked thousands of bdft of lumber on it and I change cutting depth often. I don't see any wear, looseness, etc. As far as I can tell it is good as new.

"Don't lift by bed"

I drag it around regularly with no apparent ill effects. To joint longer than 8' I have to drag it to run the lumber out a door.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#7

I wore out a wedge bed

Dick Coers

But it was because it was machined poorly. It was an 8" Grizzly, purchased in the early 80s. The infeed got pretty sloppy. When I pulled it off, you could see three wear points on each wedge. If it had been machined in a straight line, it would have been fine. I tightened up the gibbs to use it a little longer, but that cost me some travel distance. Sold it soon after, and bought a Delta.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#8

Ellis Walentine

My take

Ellis Walentine

You can get a lot of jointer for 2K. The parallelogram adjustment system is a nice amenity, but not strictly necessary. It makes adjustments quick and effortless and takes feed-screw backlash out of the equation. It is definitely tricky to readjust if necessary, but once set, the alignment should last indefinitely.

As a side note, I'm not at all against inclined ways on a jointer. You can always shim them if the table needs adjustment. More important is the flatness of the table surfaces, regardless of which type of jointer you get.

On yet another note, you can probably get a wider jointer than 8" on your budget. It's very handy to have a 12" or 16" jointer if you ever anticipate flattening wide planks.

And, finally, regarding which one to recommend, I always think back to my earlier observation that the jointer is a really primitive machine. As long as the tables are flat, you should be able to get them into proper alignment with the cutterhead.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#9

Re: I 100% agree with Ellis

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

My first joiner was a 6" Grizzly. At that time I stored it in a back room of the house and carried it outside to use it - by the beds in all cases. I used it for about 7 or 8 years, it NEVER got out of alignment, nor did the ways require shimming or readjustment.

When I built my new shop and upgraded my equipment, I purchased an 8" Grizzly with the spiral carbide inserted head. That was about 8 ~ 9 years ago, never regretted my decision. Prior to purchasing that joiner, I attended a woodworking show at Indy. I looked at the Delta and other name brand offerings ~ in my opinion (I was a manufacturing engineer for about 40 years so do know a little about equipment) the "imported" Delta, Powermatic equipment did not have any advantage over the Grizzly tools. In fact the fit and finish was far worse on the Delta.

Actually there is very little difference in any of the basic joiners, except for the parallelogram style. I can't comment on any advantages of that design, but as Ellis has stated the inclined bed does work well and I personally have had no reason to pay the extra for that feature. I am quite anal about precision alignment of all of my equipment, as I can make enough errors without fighting a poorly aligned machine.

Personally if I had a budget of $2k for a joiner I would opt for a wider, longer bed machine with the spiral head. As an aside I have a Byrd head in my 20" stationary planer and I cannot tell any difference in finish or performance between the Byrd or Grizzly designs.

I also purchased the Powermatic (I believe it is the PM-2800) Drill press at that time. It was a rather disappointing purchase. It is obviously an Asian made machine. The chuck does not work well, and the press is very noisy. Had I to do it over I would opt for a Grizzly for quite a lot less money.

I have a Powermatic lathe and Delta Unisaw (both US made). I really liked the older US made equipment Delta, Powermatic and others made, but since they are purchasing their tools from Asia now, I think the Grizzly has an edge in equipment due to their experience dealing with those manufactures and knowing how to control their quality better than Delta!

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#10

Re: Jointer Recomendations

Jake Dahn

Thanks for the input. I have found it hard to find good used equipment at a decent price.

I agree a large jointer to flatten wide boards and a narrow one for edge jointing would be preferred, but one one is in the plans for now, just not that much space in the garage, or $ in the wallet.

It looks like General makes a nice jointer, I'll look there as well.

I will see how the straight knives work. It's less than $400 to upgrade to a Byrd on amazon

Thanks again,

Jake

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#11

Re: Not in my lifetime

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Is your Delta a wedge bed or a parallelogram? Your date of manufacture does not clarify that. The antique Deltas of both designs were reputed to be built to a much higher quality than most modern Chinese machines. I don't know whether the DJ-20s are still built in Taiwan, or whether their manufacture has been moved to mainland China.

I did not recommend not lifting it by the bed. I suggested only that the users' manuals do not recommend lifting many, if not most, jointers by the ends of the tables. If you have to lift it they recommend lifting them by the beds, which is equivalent to lifting them by their bases, the bases usually being easier to get hold of.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#12

Bart Goldberg

Re: Jointer Recomendations  *LINK*

Bart Goldberg

I have an older Delta DJ-20 that I upgraded with a Byrd Helical cutterhead. Based on my experience, I would only buy a Jointer with that kind of cutterhead. Just did a quick look on amazon - the current Delta DJ-20 is over 2K. However, you can get a Jet 8" with Helical cutterhead for just under 2K. I'd probably take a good look at that one.

Bart


Jet Jointer on Amazon

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#13

Griz 8" spiral parallelogram for $1425

Ronster

I've got an eye on this one. What do you think?

http://www.grizzly.com/products/8-Jointer-w-Spiral-Cutterhead/G0490X

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#14

On the fence!!!!!! Grizzly opinions?

Jake Dahn

Ok.....first of all thanks for all the responses.

Second, I have to come clean..... I am an engineer.....don't hold it against me. :-)

Being said engineer, I am VERY particular. I had a very old 16" jointer that I partially restored . The tables were not flat and it was not worth the effort to get them flat. It has gone down the road. I am looking for something with way more precision than that.

As there is no grizzly showroom anywhere near me, Minneapolis, and my only experience was with very early grizzly machines, I had ruled them out due to less than stellar quality. Per some of the above comments that might have changed. How does griz today compare with jet and powermatic?

Also, the old saying, "you get what you pay for" creeps into my mind. I can get ALOT more machine with grizzly than the others. Are the tables stable? Did they come flat and stay that way? Am I paying for a name with powermatic and general?

I frequently visit the local Rockler store. The have warned me against delta. The customer service has been awful the last couple of years.....it's getting better, but I don't want to be the first one back on a patched up ship.

So, do I stretch the budget with:

a 12" spiral head grizzly, $2725 + $255 shipping

or get a 4 knife 12" grizzly $2050 + $255 shipping

the 8" poweRmatic $1908 (free shipping)

A replacement segmented cutter is $700 from griz. Could be an upgrade later to shave cost.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#15

Re: On the fence!!!!!! Grizzly opinions?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I can't answer any of your questions, but, the local Woodcraft will have machines to look at. Grizzly seems a pig in a poke to me. I'd be considering General and Oliver.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#16

Re: Jointer Recomendations

mdclor

I have had the G0490X since 2008 and am very happy with it. I mainly work with qswo and a little bubinga and have had only minor issues with tear out. I am still using the same face of the cutter heads. I adjust the cutting depth all the time because it is so easy to do-about 1/2 mm for face jointing and 1/16" for edge jointing. I would buy it again in a heartbeat unless I could justify a wider one. :D

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#17

Buying Grizzly can really be a crap shoot

Dick Coers

You can get a good machine, you can get a piece of junk. The piece of junk they sent me was a bandsaw. I ordered parts, worked on, and ordered more parts. After two weeks, I finally gave up since about the only good parts were parts that didn't move. They took it back. I had a lot of effort including paying for a lift gate delivery that didn't happen on the first delivery. I took time off of work twice, just to get it, then more time off for the truck to take it back. So for me, I would really look for a machine that had a dealer within a day's drive. Waiting for truck delivery, suspecting shipping damage, and even needing to recrate and wait for a truck for return, can all be possibilities when ordering on the Internet. Grizzly will no longer be an option for me since that bandsaw should never have been shipped.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#18

Re: Jointer Recomendations  *LINK*

Stephen Kirk

I've been using this Grizzly jointer for several years now without any issues. It was easy to set up, but you do have to mount the motor - which is quite heavy. Near as I could tell, the parallelogram beds were near perfect out of the box. I still haven't turned the cutter heads - they last a good long while. Helical is totally the way to go.

Fortunately, a Griz store is only about 2 hours away from me so I could pick this up and save shipping.

One note - these are beastly heavy, have some help around.


http://www.grizzly.com/products/8-Jointer-w-Spiral-Cutterhead/G0490X

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#19

Re: Griz 8" spiral parallelogram for $1425

Stephen Kirk

I posted below that I have this. Been working several years with no problems. Let me know if there is any specific info you'd like.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#20

Re: On the fence!!!!!! Grizzly opinions?

Robby Wright - San Marcos, CA

Figuring out which jointer to buy is a lot of fun! I bought a Grizzly 8" straight knife jointer four or five years ago. I was really hesitant, but went ahead anyway. The jointer came in three boxes and I had to mount the jointer on the base and install the motor, which was a bit of a bear. Once I got everything together, I plugged it in and started it up. There was a weird rattling noise coming from the motor, which I traced to the fan blade on the motor.

I called Grizzly and got a very pleasant man on the phone. After I told him what was wrong, he sent me a complete new motor. I asked what I should do with the original motor and he said to keep it for my troubles.

The jointer has been great. It arrived adjusted properly; I just had to set the fence at 90 degrees. It is a bit loud, but so are all the straight knife cutter heads. Cuts are very nice and the tables adjust easily and repeatably. I would buy another in a heartbeat.

Oh, and the motor: After a little investigation, I found that the dimple for the set screw of the fan wasn't large enough in diameter. I redrilled it, installed the fan and all is well. The motor is going into my bandsaw during this Christmas break.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#21

Re: Jointer Recomendations

TomD

I have used a bunch of different jointers, never over 11 inches though. Length is not important to accuracy, but it can add support.

Parallelogram and spiral might be improvements, but the old tech works fine. I like something I can sharpen myself. Tearout is an issue if you have to spend a lot to completely replace the replaceable cutters, but not if you can keep the machine sharp.

Big takeaway. Buy something you can measure with a perfect rule. Jointer is fundamental to accuracy, and you can really find machines that are out of true. Some machines like bandsaws are mostly steered anyway, mostly dependant on the blade. Some like drill presses perform up to requirements (on wood) at a very low cost. But Jointers are not cheap to make accurate, and not terribly useful if they aren't.

It seems to be a characteristic of US inspired tools that they avoid obvious and well established safety features. So in Bill's idea of two jointers, one could have one with a safe guard for jointing, and one with a safe guard for planing. The cam guard isn't all that fab for either.

One thing that the more hobby oriented machines often have is a more closed mouth, for working smaller pieces.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#22

Re: I wore out a wedge bed

TomD

They can be redone by hand, not a big job. Unfortunately machine re-building is moving towards hobby status.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#23

Re: On the fence!!!!!! Grizzly opinions?

TomD

Yeah, this is not a features machine, this is the machine you have to see and measure before you buy. So it is a local proposition. So even Craigslist can be preferable.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#24

Re: On the fence!!!!!! Grizzly opinions?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It might be worth the time to cruise up to Tried and True Tools. Google says its in Mpls, but it's more like Brooklyn Park, just N of 694. They're a bit more expensive than C List, but you're likely to have a better choice.

Re: Jointer Recomendations

#25

Re: On the fence!!!!!! Grizzly opinions?

Jake Dahn

Bruce, I gave them a ring. They only have two on hand. One is an old delta that is by their admission a project. The second is an 80's vintage powermatic that they want 400 less than new.

As of right now, just nothing that interests me.

I stopped by the woodcraft and checked out a 6" powermatic. Seems to be well made

Thanks for the input.

Jake