Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

Posts

bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#1

bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

Adrian

My 14" Grizzly G0555 saw (with riser block) is getting increasingly frustrating. The guide post is not perpendicular to the table (off by 1/4" or so) so the guides need constant readjustment. A couple days ago I was resawing some 9" wide mahogany and the kreg fence slipped. And I had forgotten to tinker properly with the guides so the blade got forced forward and once I lowered the guide assembly I had a really hard time getting it to come back to center (my wheels are coplanar). It seems like it's time to think seriously about an upgrade.

So I've been looking at the options and trying to read old posts on the forums. I'm mostly a hand tool shop and I do not have a table saw. I use the bandsaw for ripping, for resawing, and occasional curve cutting. I have found over the years that changing the blade is so much trouble it just never happens, so I have a 3/8" 3/4 tpi carbide blade on the saw. I'm thinking that I should look at 16"-18" saws. Note that I have ductwork on the ceiling giving me a height limit of about 78.5".

So in pondering what the new saw should do, I think it must have a brake. I want a quick tension release that can be seen from the front so I can tell if the tension is on. I have never wished for more resaw capacity than I have now, at 12", but I have often wished for more throat depth. So while I wouldn't say no to increased resaw, I'm not sure that it's important. I have to be able to get the saw down the stairs into my basement shop. I saw one saw advertised "geared trunnions", which seems like it would be nice for adjusting the table accurately. Table extensions seems like a great idea. It's hard to tell which saws have which features.

So what saws do I see as options? There's Laguna LT16, Multimaster MM16, Aggazanni (no info on models seems to be available online, B18???), and the Hammer N4400. Have I overlooked anything? The Felder is too tall. It appears that neither the Laguna nor Hammer have a quick tension release.

Can you comment on whether saws have or don't have features I'm looking for? Do you have one of these saws? If so, what is your least favorite thing about it? What about it bugs you?

Will the stock fence be adequate or will I need to plan for a Driftmaster or some other sort of aftermarket fence? It seems like each saw has its own different guide system, and I'm not sure how much of a difference this really makes.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#2

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Stuart Johnson

I don't know if they have all the features you want but you might want to consider adding MiniMax to your list. Personally I won't go near Laguana after the terrible experience I have with the quality and service I have received from them after purchasing a 20 inch disc sander.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#3

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Adrian

Uh, I wrote "Multimaster" instead of "MiniMax" for some reason. Don't know how that happened. The MM16 is on my list. They have very skimpy info about it on their site. I have heard that Laguna has terrible customer service.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#4

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Hank Knight

I have a Laguna LT 18 that I've been very satisfied with. I don't have the Driftmaster; the stock fence has served me well. I haven't seen need to drop major bucks on the Driftmaster. I think any of the ones you mentioned would be an excellent choice. They're all good.

Hank

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#5

P.S.

Hank Knight

I think Laguna has addressed some of their customer service issues. When I ordered my saw, it came with the wrong bracket for the lower blade guide. I called Laguna. They responded immediately and sent me the proper guide by Fed Ex. It arrived in SC from California in 2 days. I've had no further issues with my saw, so I've not had an occasion to call again on Laguna's customer service. There are posts here and elsewhere on the Internet, however, that indicate Laguna is doing better in the CS area.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#6

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I looked long and hard before purchasing my MM-16, I have been very satisfied with the saw after about 6 years of hobby use. While I was "shopping" I looked at the Laguna, it did look nice but had less throat height and there were a LOT of internet complaints about customer service. When I purchased my saw the company rep called me after I received it to see if I had any problems. I thought that was a nice touch.

The only (minor) issues I have seen with the saw is the on / off switch. Works ok but kind of an odd arrangement, also the "mobile base" is a arrangement that uses 2 fixed wheel and a removable handle with a wheel, does work ok but have to store the handle, also you do have to remove the rear wheel to open the door completely ~ which you must do to install wide blades (1 in or so). It does not have a "quick release tension guide, I personally don't release the tension and have had no issues in 6+ years. I have re-sawn 12" purple heart and the saw had plenty of extra power. The fence is cast iron and easily adjustable, although I would drill and thread it and install a "higher" fence if I were re-sawing thick stock (10" or more) more often. I see no reason to ever purchase a "better" fence.

The Euro style (ball bearings) guides are a bit of a hassle to align, but hold adjustment very well. All in all I would definitely purchase the same saw again.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#7

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

John McGaw

I've had a very old, perhaps the original, Laguna LT16 which was made for them by Meber and beyond the difficulty of aligning the guides it has been excellent -- plenty of capacity and the ability to handle a big heavy carbide resaw blade with no effot. If I were doing it today, no matter what the maker, I'd go for the ceramic guides though.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#8

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Adrian

What is the difficulty in aligning the guides?

By ceramic guides do you mean the laguna system, which I understand is their own special guide setup? What makes the ceramic guides superior?

One comment I saw regarding the Hammer N4400 was that the guides are bad.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#9

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Dave Bair

FWW just did a 14" bandsaw review in their annual "Tools and Shops" issue (244). The Laguna 14/Twelve was rated a best overall and a best value, the Powermatic PM1500 was rated a best overall and the Steel City 50155G was rated a best value.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#10

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Adrian

Have they done any recent reviews of larger saws? I saw a that a review was done in 2004, but that's pretty old.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#11

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

TomD

Is steel city still around? They seemed popular for a while and then all their dealers no longer had anything, in Canada, anyway.

I got a 16 inch from laguna, the guides were a special carter version, and they have never worked properly, very clunky to adjust. That has to do with how they were fitted, not knocking the Carter guides.

Resaw is to a large extent the blades, and my Taiwan saw used the standard blades for a 14 inch so it was easy to get good blades cheap, or at all. It served better as a resaw than the Laguna. The folks I know who are happy with their Lagunas use the carbide blades, and they cost what my first bandsaw did, but they seem to work really well.

My only other gripe is my Laguna came with Maber decals, which while they are probably more real, Laguna is better known around here.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#12

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

John McGaw

The ball-bearing guides are simply difficult to get into the right position and then lock down. There never seems to be enough range available and sometimes I have to adjust where the blade tracks on the wheels to get the thrust bearing to do anything useful. What I've read about the ceramic guides (yes, Laguna) is that they envelop the entire blade and eliminate a lot of fussy setup. I have a hard enough time with the existing guides, a bastardized mixture of Euro and US-style, that I leave one 1/2" blade in place 99% of the time.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#13

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

jcousins

i have had the mm16 for at least 7 years - so it's an older generation - it really has been a wonderful tool - i use it strictly for resawing.

the only catch has been that the fence does not automatically set to 90 degrees from the table when i tighten it - the table came a bit warped. mm offered me $100 to take it out and have it reground - but could not find a shop who had a big enough grinder - so i do use a square to make sure.

a few years ago i switched over to laguna ceramics (that was after moving from the original euro guides to carters - and finally laguna) - the lagunas are easy to set and really hold the blade well - seem to provide the best support for the 1" carbide blade i keep on the saw.

jerry

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#14

Re: MM16

Henry Higginbotham

I've had a MiniMax MM16 for a few years and have been happy with it, but there are some issues, as with most any tool.

The biggest issue, unless they've redesigned it (and I suspect they haven't), is that the table doesn't tilt on trunnions but rather on a more simple pivot. As a result, the point of intersection of the blade and the table surface changes with table tilt. This doesn't sound so bad until you discover that you need custom throat plates for about every 5° of tilt. They're not hard to make, but it does take a little time. 30° on the left; 5° on the right:


Another look. As the tilt increases, the blade moves back toward the column.


And as someone mentioned earlier, the mobile base uses a separate handle with wheels. This works very well when you're using it, but it may be the most contrary thing to store that I own.

Generally, though, it's a very good machine, and I wouldn't sweat the lack of lever-operated tension release, since the wheel is large, works well, and takes all of five seconds. And the Lenox TriMaster carbide blade is well worth what it costs.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#15

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Don Evans

You mentioned concerns of blade tension release for your new saw. I also, like Larry, have a MM16 Minimax and NEVERS release the tension on the blade. There really is no need to do that.

The Taiwan made saws all use cast metal for their tensioning mechanism and with that it IS important if you want it to last any time at all to release tension on the blade.

The difference with the MiniMax is night and day, it is built like a tank seriously.

The blade tension will never damage it.

No saw is perfect but the customer service with them has been excellent and I've not had any problem with the saw.

It is nice to have a bandsaw that doesn't vibrate things off the table when it is running but to get that make sure you take the time to level it properly with the allen bolts that come with it. Two more things, when I purchase mine it came with a tool case with all necessary wrenches and allen's needed to fit anything on the saw.

Also, I think they now call the MM16 a Model S 400P. There is a lot of information on this saw at their site, I don't understand your comment about not much info? Be sure and watch the video's with S. Blasko, he worked there and may still work there for all I know but he is a woodworker also has a really professional shop and knows what he is talking about.

I have no affiliate with them but would purchase this saw again without hesitation.

Don

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#16

MM16

David Yoho

I started with a 14" Delta, which I still have. Ten years ago when I decided I wanted something larger and heavier I purchased the MM16. I fitted it with a one-inch Lenox TriMaster blade and haven't looked back. Unlike others, I release the tension each time I'm done using it from habit but it only takes a few seconds with the hand wheel. I also have a spot where I store the handle/third wheel that's out of the way but still handy. I haven't had a need to move the saw since sitting it in position 10 years ago. I bought it for re-sawing but also have used it for ripping large timbers. I use the Delta for curved cuts and quick cuts, which allows me to leave the Trimaster blade on the MM16 fulltime. Great saw that has paid for itself in my shop.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#17

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

del schisler

first off i can't comment about other saws , i have the old delta and you don't want the wheel's coplaner, you want the blade's gullet to ride in the middle of the top tire, first back off all gude's and thruse beiring's and set the blade so it is in the center, now adjust all guides and thrust briring's , their should be adjustment for the post to get it 90 degree's if not you may have to shim the table , i had to do that to mine and now my post is 90 degree's all around the table , after all that you should have a good saw, you may have to do a blade drift after and set fence ? after that all should be good , good luck watch this video with alex very good info http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGbZqWac0jU&list=FLYDEiGLzvqQNIl-nqvD2OOQ&feature=mh_lolz

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#18

Re: MM16

Adrian

My existing saw uses trunnions, but the throat plate I have wouldn't work when I tilted the saw to 45 deg (which I just did recently). I was just running with no throat plate. I don't think that the blade moved as much as in your example, though. I probably would have been OK with a 30 deg tilt.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#19

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Adrian

Are you saying that having coplanar wheels is bad? Right now I believe that the blade is square to the table in both directions. There is no adjustment for the guidepost. If I shim the table then the blade will no longer be square. So then I'll have to mess with the tracking to get the blade to run differently?? Or I use the top wheel tilt to try to change the blade angle, giving up on coplanarity?

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#20

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Adrian

The only saw with less info available online is Aggazanni, for which I have found nothing.

I can't even tell if the height of the MiniMax saws is low enough for them to fit in my shop---they don't give the dimensions. They don't give the throat depth. They do give weight, and I have to admit that the 530 pound weight gives me pause. I know weight is good. But I have to be able to get the thing down the stairs to the basement!

The video did convey some information. It appears that the fence doesn't have a low profile setting, which would be annoying, as I cut lots of thin stuff and like to be able to bring the guard down to the work. I also saw that the guide post has adjustment for square, which seems nice since the lack of such adjustment is driving me crazy right now. I notice that in the video the saw comes with euro guides but one of the pictures says "carter guides standard". But the specs don't say what sort of guides are included.

Someone mentioned the lift bar being hard to store and that they never move the saw. Because of my shop layout, I have to move the saw (only about 12") when I want to cut long stuff to line it up with a doorway. The rest of the time I want it shifted up close to the wall so that I can walk straight into the shop and not into the saw.

Regarding tension, I know from my own patterns and habits that I already have a hard time remembering to release the tension on my saw, and I have started it twice with the tension off. The current saw has a small red lever that I can see if I look at the back of the saw, and I try to look at it as I leave the shop. If there is no tension quick release, then I'll have no indicator at all of whether the tension is up unless I look closely at the tension gauge. For me this just won't work: I will have to leave the tension on all the time.

So then the next question: is that OK? Heck, if there's no reason to release the tension I'm all for it, since it's one less thing to worry about. It seems like there are three things people express concern about: warping the frame, fatiguing the spring, and denting the tires. The first seems unlikely to be a concern. The second I'm not sure about. The third seems likely to be an issue, especially if the blade is not wide. I'm likely to have a 3/8" blade on the saw a lot of the time.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#21

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Matt Robinette

I also have the older MM16 and it is a work horse. Minimax is owned by SCMI who also owns or buys their band saws from Aggazanni. It's an Italian thing. I also have and older FSB35 Minimax planer jointer combo that is from the 1980's,SCMI still has limited support for it.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#22

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something el

Bruce, a MN Galoot

try checking out an engine shop that grinds flywheels. They frequently have a Blanchard grinder that can handle something the size of your bandsaw table.

Re: bandsaw upgrade: italian, hammer, something else??

#24

Re: MM16

Rob Sandow

I have the same setup as David. I have an older Laguna LT16, the one from the late '90s that only has a 9" resaw capacity, but that has been enough for most everything I need to do. It has a 1" Lenox Tri-Master in it full time. I have a 12" Delta benchtop bandsaw that I use for everything that can't be done with a 1" 2/3 variable TPI carbide blade.