Re: Biscuit question
Sgian Dubh
"I've used thousands of biscuits since they came out. I've never seen the swelling problem that many mention." Dick, the swelling does occur, it's real, but there are techniques for preventing the swelling showing up in finished panel, particularly where the panel is a horizontal surface, such as a table or cabinet top. However, this is not a characteristic unique to biscuit joints used for alignment in edge joinery. A similar effect can be found in plain edge jointed panels, as well as in panels assembled with a spline, dowels, etc used as alignment aids.
Here are a couple of descriptions to mull over. Let's say a panel is assembled at 9 am using a water based adhesive: any of the methods just mentioned might have been used. Let's say, as a follow up, that said panel is removed from the clamps at about lunchtime the same day and prepped for polishing, and then polished. In other words, the whole job has taken less than about 12 hours from glue-up to polished: I've seen it done, so don't assume this is unheard of. The following visible results are likely.
1. Biscuits: a furrow along every glue line and elliptical depressions spanning across the glue line revealing the position of every biscuit.
2. Basic butted edge joint: a furrow visible along the glue line.
3. Spline reinforced joint. a wider furrow than 2 above along the length of the glue line.
4. Dowels: a furrow as all the above, but with additional cross grain dips indicating the position of the dowels.
Note: the likelihood of each of these possible end results varies from job to job, i.e., it's unpredictable.
Now, as to the cause of all these results? The only common factors are:
1. Water based glue, e.g., PVA, aliphatic resin, hide glue, urea formaldehyde, etc.
2. Haste. Too little time allowed between assembly and polishing.
The solution to eliminate all the faults described is simple, i.e., time. The water in the adhesive causes swelling of the wood locally where it was applied. Time will allow the added moisture to dissipate from the wood causing it to shrink again. After the wood has shrunk it can be worked, prepped and polished with little chance of the faults described showing up later.
As to the strength of biscuit joints, they're pretty tough. I've used them fairly frequently for assembling some, or all horizontal panels to vertical sides in cabinets, as in the following examples, none of which have shown any sign of failure. I don't use biscuits very often in panel glue-ups, but that's simply because there's usually no need for them if the joint preparation is good in the first place. In fact, I find that biscuits, or any other "alignment" or "strength" aids used in this context help very little in making up for deficient edge preparation. In other words, if the edges aren't well aligned in the first place, they'll almost certainly fail, whatever method of assembly is used. Slainte.



