Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Table saw again

Posts

Table saw again

#1

JL

Table saw again

JL

Looked at the reviews for the Ridgid 4512.

Found the Steel City 35990CS contractor saw at Woodcraft. That looks to be a decent saw.

Also got opinions on the Grizzly G0715P hybrid.

The "honey bee" who is donating more than 1/2 the money would prefer the hybrid

The Steel City is a decent saw. The majority of the "worker bees" want it.

The Grizzly would be a forever saw. Probably would never replace it. Most of what I am ripping are 2 x 4s, etc. and plywood.

The Grizzly would cost $900 delivered and the Steel City about $750.

I am getting an electrical estimate tomorrow.

Re: Table saw again

#2

Re: Table saw again

Howard in Toronto

I can always spend your money".....

BUT

$150 doesn't strike me as all that big a difference if we're discussing a "forever saw"vs something you might replace sooner than "forever."

So I'd recommend that bite the bullet and get the Grizzly.

Howard

Re: Table saw again

#3

Re: Table saw again

mdclor

If the honey bee wants the hybrid, that is the one I would get. However, I would let him/her know, in the nicest way possible, that you are are giving up some accessories to accommodate his/her desires and see if he/she will spring for the extras.

Re: Table saw again

#4

Not sure Grizzly would be forever

Dick Coers

Personally, I have a very low opinion of Grizzlty machines. Maybe if you don't use it a lot, it will last forever. But if you intend to run it every day, don't count on "forever"!

Re: Table saw again

#5

Hmmm... don't know about that...

John in NM

I've known some guys using various Taiwan and Chinese tools for ages. They aren't as sexy as Unisaws and such, but there's not a whole lot of difference when it comes to cabinet saws.

Add in that it's for a set shop - no offense intended to JL, but that is not a high precision environment compared to furniture. The Grizzly will likely be just fine for them.

Re: Table saw again

#6

JL

L1023 saws

JL

I've seen the cabinet saws - they have lasted for years.

Re: Table saw again

#7

For years and forever are two different things

Dick Coers

Unless you guys are a lot older than me.

Re: Table saw again

#8

what makes you think any table saw lasts forever?

John in NM

Motor, bearings, and belts - all wear out on the best of saws. Nothing much else goes wrong with them. Nothing is "forever" if you want to be literal about it.

Re: Table saw again

#9

Re: Table saw again

John Lucas

I have not been a grizzly fan but found a deal this summer on a grizzly cabinet saw. It had been used extensively by a cabinet maker but seemed like all the moving parts worked well. I've put it through its paces in the last year and the only problem I've had was to readjust the cam that locks the fence.

Re: Table saw again

#10

Re: what makes you think any table saw lasts forev

William Duffield

You forgot the pin and bearings that the arbor pivots on for raising and lowering the blade. I've worn out those parts on a contractor's saw.

A warning about hybrid saws: Their mechanisms, including trunnions and arbor and the other parts that wear out, are no more robust than contractors saws, they just hang the motor off the bottom, enclosed in a metal box, instead of out the back. That's an advantage for dust collection. However, you can't easily remove the motor to reduce the weight of the saw when you want to put it in the back of a pickup, like you can a contractor's saw. It's also a marketing advantage, to fool those who don't know the difference, into thinking they are getting a real cabinet saw.

There is of course, one exception to the problems with contractor's and hybrid saws, but that's not directly related to the OP's question.

Re: Table saw again

#11

Well stated!


Re: Table saw again

#12

Owners of PM 66 or Unisaw

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Owners of these saws are convinced that after 50 yeas of use they indeed will last forever. After 40 years I had to replace belts and bearings. The rest will last several more generations. I just bought a dandy PM 66 for $600 and there was not a saw mentioned that I would trade for it.

Re: Table saw again

#13

Unisaw

John in NM

Mine was made in the 50's some time. The fence absolutely sucks. I replaced the old R-I motor a couple years ago, cost as much as the saw did when I bought it ($500). Nothing is forever. Might have gotten the old motor fixed, because it is pretty, but the commutator was pretty much worn down to nothing. Probably would have cost as much as a new motor to get it done.

I prefer these old tools, usually because they are cheaper to start up with than new ones, at least until motors and bearings fail. But I won't look down on any one running a Grizzly - that guy is getting work done when a lot of old arn 'o philes are busy waxing their ancient tops :D

Re: Table saw again

#14

Re: Owners of PM 66 or Unisaw

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

There is another saw, whose name (due to the WoodCentral forum rules against political discusssions) will not be mentioned, that I think you would find superior to the PM66. For a while I had a Rockwell Delta Unisaw, which if I had kept it would have significantly benefited from an upgrade to a Beisemeier fence. It was also a very competent saw. More recent saws of exceptional quality include the PM-2000 and one of the early Steel City cabinet saws (whose model number I cannot remember). The Steel City saw was even available in a 12" model. I'm afraid I have no experience with the recent Steel City saws.

The contractor saw I had was a Delta. It eventually wore itself out due to vibrations caused by cost reduced pullies on the motor and arbor, a cheap belt, and the lack of a lubrication method for the bearing surfaces connecting the front trunnion, the arbor bracket and the arbor bracket shaft. Most people who would use a contractor saw for its intended purpose would not be much bothered by the problem, but I demanded a lot of precision from the saw that it lost due to wear.

Re: Table saw again

#15

The Unisaw fence-  I like it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If faced with a "classic" Unisaw fence and any new fence made I would choose the Unisaw fence for how I use it. I find it easy to adjust to a tiny fraction of an inch. For ripping close to the blade I run the narrow fence between 1st and second fingers with one finger on lumber surface and the thumb pushing. In this configuration one's hand can not stray into danger territory. The thin fence has lots of holes for screwing aux. wooden fences to. I just don't see what is to not like about it.

Re: Table saw again

#16

This one?

John in NM


Pic I grabbed off the web, but that is the one. It works, but not as well as a modern fence. I had a Craftsman of a similar vintage that had a worse fence, one where you had to check for parallel every time you moved it. The Delta you can lock and release it several times when setting it, and it will fall into parallel, most of the time.

Re: Table saw again

#17

Is exactly  parallel very important

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have not found it to be so. I have not checked my fence in years. The last time I did, it was not. But I had not noticed any ill effects. As you described the way this fence is used is to double pump the lever to align it- one partial and then a full lock down.

In any case, indeed, the picture is of the fence I prefer. Apparently I like it because I don't fret parallelism, to what ever degree is isn't.

Re: Table saw again

#18

Ditto on the fence.....

roger lance

I also have an older Unisaw with the old fence.....JetLock fence, I think its called.....when I bought the saw, I was able to test out a number of these fences and got one that was perpendicular to the table and parallel to the blade (set now slightly away from the blade in the rear).....I like the ease of being able to attach jigs/etc to this fence......with all the stuff that you need to buy to outfit a shop, I never got around to replacing this fence.....people say that other fences are much better, I don't know as I've not worked with them.

I've also never had a pick-up with an automatic transmission.....people say that's better too.


Re: Table saw again

#19

It isn't...

John in NM

Important, most of the time.

The other trick with this fence is to always set it moving towards the blade instead of away - that way if it is out of parallel, the back is wider, which does no harm. Even after using it for years, I occasionally slip up and run a board through with the fence tighter at the back of the blade.

I've been using this fence for a dozen years or so. It's not so bad that I'd spend the money to replace it, but it's still a pretty marginal fence. I might have bought a Unifence by now if Delta still offered them, but so far materials and other machine upgrades have always taken priority.

Maybe I dislike that fence so much because it is just good enough to make replacing it a low priority - hows that for anthropomorphizing? :D

Re: Table saw again

#20

Better keep your old pickup then  ....

John in NM

Last I heard, they are all coming with automatics now! If my neighbor ever wants to sell his 78 Ford, I'll never buy another pickup :D

Re: Table saw again

#21

Good point.....

roger lance

Thats a good point about setting the fence only when you have moved it toward the blade. If I have to move the fence away from the blade, I moved far enough that I have to move it again toward the blade for a proper setting.

Other tools are like this as well.....adjusting plane blades come to mind.....set the blade when moving the blade deeper.....not when retracting.

Re: Table saw again

#22

Re: Table saw again

ChuckinND

Buy a used American made saw. Imported steel, iron, and motors are just not as good of quality as American made. I have a Delta 34-445X Contractors table saw with a 30" Unifence that I bought new in 94. I wouldn't trade it for anything that your looking at. I think that it's a shame that people nowdays think that a Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector is something to brag about. It's got to be the cheapest made and over rated 2 hp dust collector out there. A really bad investment in my opinion.