Is it really possible to get decent results face jointing boards wider than the jointer bed by removing the guard? If so, what is the technique? I've some 10" wide stock that I'd like to joint on my 6" with helical cutter head.
I have face jointed thick, wide boards before using my 8" jointer.
I basically took off the guard (NOT RECOMMENDED, DO AT YOUR OWN RISK), adjusted the height so it only took a little off. Did this a couple times to establish an "edge" or line down the middle of the board. Rotated it 180 degrees (end for end) and did the part that hadn't been jointed. After I go a reasonable surface, I took it to my planer.
Doug..... it is definitely possible to face joint boards wider than your jointer.....but what you are trying to do is get the board flat and stable enough to go through your planer.....do not expect to get a finished surface on wider boards on the jointer......so with this in mind, remove the guard (and focus your mind as you have just done something that is dangerous and I'm not recommending it....verstanen sie ??).....pass your stock over the jointer as you would normally.....once you have established a consistent flat surface, turn your attention to the other side.....if what remains is fairly narrow, I take the board to my bench and use a hand plane to remove the excess and get the board to where it is flat enough to be stable and then go to the planer......if the board is much wider, then work on the remaining side on the jointer checking often to be sure that you are getting both halves on the board to that stable state.....then the planer.
Doug.....what I often do without using the jointer, is to place a wide board on my bench and take off the high spots with a scrub plane so that I can get the board to lay stable and not rock and then take it to the planer and run my stabilized side face down and take very light passes so the planer will not be compressing/distorting the stock and get that side reasonably flat and then plane the original side....etc....etc.
Also, with wide boards sometimes it works to cut them length wise on the bandsaw......flatten each piece on the jointer.....plane them....and then glue them back together.
Yes you can. I've been doing it for years. It requires some finesse. What you want is the step dwn the middle of the board to be the same height all the way down. Then turn it over and put it through the planer to get the opposite face flat. Then turn it over again and take out the step. The reference face for the planer doesn't need to be flat. All it needs to keep the planer rollers from distorting it is one edge and the top of the ridge down the center to be continuous and parallel.
You run into problems only if the board is twisted, and then only half the time. If the twist is such that the right rear corner is lower then the left rear, start with the right front corner on the outfeed table (like you might do if you were tapering a table leg), and make as many passes as you need to get the step to the same height down the whole length of the board.
If the twist is such that the right rear corner is higher than the left rear, you can't take the twist out, because you can't move the fence to the other side of the cutter head. Then you would need to use a scrub plane and some wedges under the board, or a planer fence with wedges.
The problem with the frog fence that the others recommend is that it gets in the way of applying downward pressure where it is needed while consistently pushing the stock over the cutter heads. Just about everyone I know who has tried to use one, including myself, has subsequently tossed it. Instead, I would recommend using a "boat" to push the stock over the head. Here's mine.
It's a bit fancier than you need. A 4x4 with a couple of dowels glued into the top and a block glued into the bottom rear to do the pushing does the job. In case I need to push a thin board through the jointer, when they get too short, my push blocks are replaceable. I drive them out from the top with a punch, and drive new ones in from the bottom.
So it is always available when I want to face joint a board, it lives here:
I have face jointed stock wider than the jointer many times. I have never used the flip-it-the-other-way-'round method. While the saying goes "don't knock it 'til you tried it" I can't see that this would be effective.
I have used the method that roger described, flattening eight inches of the board (I have access to an 8" jointer), then using a hand plane for the rest of the first face.
I read the suggestion to knock down the high spots with a scrub plane so the board doesn't rock, then run it through the planer. I believe you need a wide (at least 2/3 of the width of the board) and long (90-95% of the length of the board) plane surface on the side that faces down when you begin machine planing. If that side of the board is not sufficiently flat, then the feed rollers will distort the board -- unseen by you -- and the planed surface on the face toward the cutterhead will be similarly distorted when the board comes out of the planer.
The problem I foresee using the flip-it-around method on the jointer is that the portion of the face being jointed is being flattened to its lowest point and according to the "terrain" on that surface. When you joint the other half of the same face, there is no common reference to keep the board positioned in the same way -- the other half is flattened according to its own lowest point, and according to the shape of the wood on that face. I'd think you'd wind up with a wedge, or a wedge shaped cavity in the center of the board, with the two halves of the same face not likely even being symmetrical.
What part of this am I missing?
Perhaps if you then plane it to wafer thickness, you can get both faces straight and fairly parallel?
I've done it lots of times and it works. Is there something in my explnation above that doesn't make sense? The height of the step down the middle of the board tells you whether there is some wind you need to remove. You do that by setting the low end on the outfeed table so you don't take any off that end, but a full depth off the other end. Once you get full (or mostly full) flat surfaces on each side, you deal with removing the wind. When you turn it over and put it in the planer, one edge and the ridge down the middle are the only parts of the board in contact with the rollers, and you know they are straight and true, so the other face ends up flat and parallel to those two lines.
While I have a 12" jointer, sometimes I get big lumber that is just too massive for me and a helper to run properly over a jointer. On those occasions, I use my Makita 6" wide power-plane to flatten the first side. Since I can change the depth on the fly, I like to set it up on a bench or horses with the bow up.
I start out examining it with winding sticks, and may go across the grain on each end to establish a reference or target on both ends to hit, to keep it flat with no twist.
I then may go out to the middle or highest point, and start working on knocking down any humps. then I try to establish a straight flat path on the 6" nearest me.
After that, I skew the plane, so the out feed bed rides on that first path, as I widen it with consecutive passes working my way across, as I traverse down the length.
If you can step back a ways and squat down close to the line on sight, it is easy to spot variations after getting the ends and that first side straight.
Now, there may be some small steps along the edges of each pass that aren't perfect, but not enough to lead to problems on the other face as it is fed through the planer. Then, if there is enough thickness you can always flip it, then run that side up through the planer last.
One last thing. When face gluing wide boards to make thicker lumber, keep in mind that both don't have to be perfectly flat. both could be bowed, then glued with the bows opposing each other to end up with a straight beam. This is not a strong force to overcome, and virtually nothing compared to the strength of a good glue line. That would also leave more thickness to flatten after the glue-up.
And if you had the stamina, you could do it with a #7 or #8 . I have the planes but not the stamina, but I don't have a hand held power planer, so I try to make do with my 8" jointer. I explain to people that this technique allows you to run a shop with a jointer that is approximately half the width of your planer: 6" and 12"; 8" and 16"; 12" and 24". Of course if you use my technique, ~ half your boards that come with a twist will need to be relegated to rails, stiles, drawer runners, and if the twist is bad enough, cock bead.
If the piece of lumber in question needs much flatening another piece of lumber should be selected. 4/4 lumber will be about 1" after drying so at most there is only 3/16" available for flatening and smoothing BOTH sides. So as a practical matter we are talking about clipping off at most 1/8" from diagonal corners if the lumber is twisted or 1/16"form the ends and opposite middle if the lumber is bowed.
The jointer is a good place to start and whatever else needs to be done can be done in minutes with a hand plane. As a practical matter the task simply does not require more extraordinary measures. Nor is it essential to have a mirror flat surface to proceed to surface planing or even gluing a panel.
No, I don't have a power plane. I have a couple of hand planes, but as William points out, that takes a lot of stamina. I have used them on occasion to remove enough material from short lengths of stock to stop them rocking.
And, to Bill -- I agree that mirror flat isn't necessary (we aren't building a hubble space telescope).