Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Posts

Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#1

Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Blondterror

I run a small one man woodworking business (Tables, Stools, and Bowls) in my basement shop.

I am expanding my basement shop and installing a larger dust collection system with drop down connections for my table saw, bandsaw, planer, jointer, router table, and 2 lathes. I was thinking that my Drill press could go w/o a connection but am not sure on this... I expect to use grounded PVC pipe with Y joints and gate valves for each machine. I am relocated my dust collector to an outside shed to get the noise outside and make emptying the collection barrel easier and get the fine dust outside. I need to buy a new cyclone/dust collector to mount in this outside shed ... I do not want the unit to be too tall (6-7' at most) to keep my wife happy because the shed will be outside of our dining room bay window.

Any recommendations on a good unit that meets these constraints?

Chris

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#2

Oneida

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They will design and provide parts and it will work.

A lathe is nearly impossible to collect chips from. They are big and have a lot of momentum that must be turned around to the inlet target. My solution is to have a floor extension that I sweep the big chips into when they get ankle deep (or before :) )

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#3

Small Reply

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Can't help you on cyclone brands but I will note that "grounding" your PVC lines is a) a waste of time, and b) may induce clogs. PVC is an insulating material. While it will build a static charge, unless the unit is running almost continuously, that charge will not become strong enough to do anything to the dust stream. If, OTOH you plan on running the DC continuously for 6-8 hours a day, you'd be wiser to use metal ductwork and is grounded.

BTW, as you haven't mentioned it, your main duct should be run if 6" or larger pipe with your drop using 4" piping.

Good luck. Sounds like you're having fun.

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#4

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Blondterror

Thanks for the feedback... I will work with Randy @ Oneida to design a system around one of their 5 HP cyclones using their designed 6" metal pipe and 4" drops.

I have been happy with my Super Dust deputy and bet their custom system design will be even better... esp with the vac unit located outside in a shed attached the the outside wall of the shop.

Chris

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#5

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Hank Knight

I think all the name brand cyclones are good. I've had a ClearVue system in my basement shop for about 5 years and I've been very happy with it. I used 6" S&D PVC overhead lines (not grounded) and built my own blast gates with low-voltage magnetic switches that control the cyclone operation from each machine station. Works like a charm and less expensive than a commercial operating system.

Hank

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#6

Money

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"can't buy you love" but it'll get you a fair amount of satisfaction.

If you've got the scratch to spend on a full Oneida System, go for it.

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#7

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Jesse Cloud

I have an Oneida 2 HP and I'm happy. Unless you plan really long runs or don't want to open and shut blast gates, 2 HP may be enough for a one man shop. I have mine connected to a Unisaw, DJ20 jointer, 18 inch bandsaw, lunchbox planer, and router table. The gate to the jointer stays open, and I generally only have one other tool running at the same time.

About the drill press: your cyclone isn't going to do much for it. Ditto your miter saw. I have those two hooked up to shop-vacs with an auto switch that turns the vac on/off as the tool is turned on/off. They don't make a lot of fine dust anyhow.

Another thing to think about before your design is modifying your tools to have bigger dust ports, even if it means cutting a bigger hole in some sheet metal. I have done that with a couple of tools and it makes a huge difference.

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#8

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Blondterror

I will most likely go with one of their 3HP V-System 3000 units which should be plenty of suction for my medium sized shop. I do not think I need the 5 HP for the demands I will put on the system. Plus it saves a big chunk of change.

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#9

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Cameron Hood

Just a reminder--if your dust collector is outside, you are going to be sucking all the heat (if you live in a cold climate) or air conditioned (if you live in hot) air outside and since they do move a LOT of air, the cost of producing hot or cold air will definitely be a lot higher. Some people find a way to recycle the air exhaust from their DC.

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#10

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Larry in NW Ohio

A little bit different way to do the blast gates. I have an Oneida DC for over 10years and it does a great job. About the dust gates, I also built mine and I think they do better than boughten ones and much cheaper. I use air cylinders to open and close the gates and works very well. Have you read anything at Bill Pentz site on dust collection, he has the best write up on that subject than any one has.Larry

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#11

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Hank Knight

Hi, Larry,

Yes, I've read the Bill Pentz info. He's the reason I chose a ClearVue cyclone. The ClearVue design follows Pentz's design and does, indeed, capture a large percentage of the fine dust. I can't compare it to an Oneida, or any of the others, because I've never used any of them. But I'm very happy with my CleatVue. Before I installed it, I was having lots of sinus trouble from the fine dust, and my lungs were probably suffering as well. All that's in the past since I installed my DC system.

I used a blast gate design Jameel Abraham was nice enough to share with me. The blast gates are mounted overhead, out of the way, and operate with pull cords. I added magnetic butterfly switches that trigger the relay that turns the cyclone on and off. Here's a photo of the assembly:

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Clear%20Vue%20Cyclone%20Installation/DSC_0004Medium-1.jpg.html][/URL]

Here's a shot of the overhead blast gate:

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Clear%20Vue%20Cyclone%20Installation/DSC_0001Medium-1.jpg.html][/URL]

There's an LED photo sensor on my dust bin that shuts the cyclone off when the bin gets full:

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Clear%20Vue%20Cyclone%20Installation/DSC_0008Medium.jpg.html][/URL]

It's a very functional set-up.

Hank

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#12

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Blondterror

very nice... what was the source for those blast gates? Did you fab them yourself?

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#13

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Hank Knight

Yes, I made them myself from a pattern given to me by a friend:

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Clear%20Vue%20Cyclone%20Installation/DSC_0004Medium.jpg.html][/URL]

I added the electronics (magnetic switches) to the design:

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Clear%20Vue%20Cyclone%20Installation/DSC_0007Medium-1.jpg.html][/URL]

A close friend built the switching circuit for me. It includes the bin-sensor shutoff. I have the schematic diagram for the circuit I'd be glad to send you if you're interested.

Hank

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#14

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Larry in NW Ohio

Hank I`d be interested in the design of your system, the gates and sensor wiring lay out if it wouldn`t be to much trouble. Your gates are a good design, now if you could put an air cylinder on them, they would open and close automaticly. For me I would need them to open when I turn the machine on because the rope could be right in my face and I would still forget to open it. I also looked at clear vue, but Bill was in the very early stages of design when I ordered my Oneida. Nice design. Larry

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#15

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I personally have a Grizzly 3HP cyclone with a cartridge filter. I have been quite happy with it in my hobby shop. At the time I purchased mine I really wanted an Oneida, but at that time (8 or so years ago) the cost was prohibitive for me. I piped my system with 2 main 6" feed lines (split off the 8" inlet) and dropped to 4" flex at my machines as almost all my machines are on mobile bases. Only issue I have is that the 55 gal drum fill up quite fast when I am doing a lot of planing on my 20" planer. I can fill it in just a few hours. I mention that as the height of a system normally is greatly dependent on the size of the collector "barrel", My system is probably over 7' tall with the 55 gal drum!

Re: Dust Collection Unit recommendations

#16

Larry, check your email.