I have an 80gal, 6hp, up right air compressor that I rigged up a drain line from the center to the outside edge w/ a ball valve for easy draining. I'd read were you need to drain the tank to keep it from rusting out. Makes sense! Not getting to use as I had hoped I hadn't drained it for sometime. Being the faithful steward of my tools that I am I drained the tank yesterday. OMGosh the rusty gunk that came out!
Now what do I do?
I'm thinking I could dismantle the whole thing, put 10gal of silica sand in the tank, chuck it in a lathe, & spin it till it cleans up the rust inside. Then drain & clean out the sand, pour in a gallon er so of rustproofing paint, chuck it back in the lathe, then drain out the paint & let 'er dry.
Your idea would certainly help protect the inside of your tank from further rusting, but I've never heard of anyone going to these lengths, not that they haven't or that they wouldn't be worthwhile. All things being relative, do you think that without rustproofing your tank will rust through in your lifetime? Maybe there are other issues, like rust in your air output, but that's what filters are for.
It just sounds like too much work for not enough payoff.
You've got the right start. Now add an air-activated condensate drain and your tank will stay nice and dry and (assuming its a quality unit) will live to be used by your grandchildren.. Put it on after your ball valve.
Wilkerson auto condensate drain Part No. 4919K13 Price $85.00
I have had one installed on my big I-R main compressor for 10+ years. Once a year I close the ball valve and remove the unit, take it apart, clean and lube (with synthetic white grease), and re-install. Works beautifully. Controlling the amount of moisture (there will always be some) in the receiver tank will also help keep your air lines dry.
Keep in mind as well that manufactures know that the tanks collect water as water vapor condenses out of the compressed air. Because the tanks continually expand and contract, there's no way to coat the tank to make it rust-proof, but even if there were, you still have to keep the tank drained to keep your air supply dry so it doesn't pay to try.
There is part of me that agrees with Mark. The Automatic valve would be a good idea, except that I know myself well enough to know that I would not give t the maintenance he gives his.
I have a 6 Gal compressor I bought from Sears (Emerson) over 40 years ago. It recently rusted out. I Abused it badly. Only drained it every few years whether it needed it or not. Sometimes it got daily hard use and sometimes it sat for years without use. Sometimes I drained more than a gallon of rusty oily goop out of it, sometimes very little. I may have the tank welded and put it back into use.
I wonder if draining the tank actually extends the life of the tank. Using the tank constantly wets the inside and provides with with oxygen. Pretty much perfect conditions for rust, with or without water in the bottom.
As I was thinking about this, I thought about the fact that water heater tanks are glass lined to extend their working life. Wonder if that would help Compressor tanks? OTOH, An old Dog plumber that used to work for me thought the glass lining was worthless or even worse than not lining them. His premise was that there was always a flaw in the lining and that all of the corrosion was concentrated onto those spots.
Another thought, one of the things that protects water heater tanks is the anode rod. Wonder if an anode would extend the life of a compressor tank.
I also agree with Ellis. You are proposing a lot of work and expense for probably little and certainly an unknown payoff.
No way I'd have it welded and use it again. It is a pressure vessel and it needs proper welding. Also, if it is rusted in one spot the rest is probably in bad shape anyway, ie, nothing real strong to weld the patch to. Lots of stored energy even in a 6 gal tank at 120PSI.
1. This discussion reminded me that my valve was due for a cleaning so I took a stop-watch out to the garage and hit the button. It took my exactly 11 minutes and 27 seconds to unship the valve, take it apart, clean the piston, cylinder walls, and O-rings, grease it up, reassemble and reinstall it.
2. Along the way I opened the ball valve to see what would drain; clear water with a hint of an oil sheen. Doesn't look like I have much rust in my tank at all, even after 10 years. At this rate I'll have to revise my estimate for life expectancy of this tank to include my great-grandchildren.
Once a compressor tank starts to pin-hole it's time for a new tank; it will continue with more pin-holes as you play "dutch-boy". You can buy a new tank to fit your compressor pump, but you'll need the brand and model to ensure you get a proper fit for the mountings and connections.
So if I do no maintenance (the plan so far), for 25 years, and nothing goes wrong, what will go wrong is a pin hole will develop? There are tanks out there holding thousands of pounds of pressure per square inch. There are propane tanks with low pressure, but high badness factor. If I can forget to open the valve more than once every few years, and all that happens is a leak at some point. Sounds good.
When I moved into current shop about 20 years ago, the one thing that went wrong in the move was that the pressure return tube bard was broken off the pressure switch. Unrepairable, as it is made of waxy plastic, but I glued it back on with epoxy anyway. Still working fine. But if I should happen to get a pin hole in the tank and have to replace the machine, not too many tears will be shed. So if enormous shop exploding explosions are rare, what's the downside?
I should say that I am normally a maintenance kind of guy. When I bought the unit, I had a day job, and right away the valve snapped off the tank. Up here, no parts retail until quite a while later at which point I bought about 3 replacement valves. But by then the pattern of care was well established...
Not worth the bother really, even uncoated tanks last for years. Frequent draining will help a lot, so do that instead and don't worry about some rust. Rusted tanks usually go with a pin hole or two, and as there is no phase change to the compressed gas, they don't explode like propane tanks.
Our big compressor at work has a coated tank of some sort - never gets any rust and it's 20 years old or so. Inside of the tank is probably painted, though I think a 2-part curing product would work better. I bet Mark's IR is coated inside too.
Don't explode (unless, of course, some idiot tries to put 600 psi into a tank rated for 150), they fail by leaking; most often rusting through at the welded seams. Oogie Boogie internet stories are BS.
Fuel tanks do explode, but if a pin-hole is caused by rust, it's rust from the outside, not condensation of water inside.
I started out getting some rusty water when I'd manually open the drain every week or two so I doubt there's any kind of magic coating. But I got tried of constantly trying to remember to do the drain and did the research that led me to the Wilkerson drain. It's the only one that I've found that doesn't need some kind of relay to actuate it and, while the price has gone up in 10 years, it's still the cheapest solution I've found (kid next door wanted $5 a month to come over and do it )
My point was that with little maintenance I got 43 years out of a tank. It was a cheap set up I bought to allow me to spray some beams because I was tired of stain running down my arm and into my shorts.
I suspect the water condenses out of the compressed air onto the walls of the tank. I am not a chemist or expert on corrosion, but I am betting the freshly condensed water is rich in oxygen and about as corrosive as water gets, short of having acid or some other chemical in it. I doubt it corrodes much faster in the puddle of water than in the open air part of the tank.
I wish I had the $85 for the auto drain valve, but I don't think I paid much more than $250 for the whole set up. So adding a third to the cost to get more years does not make much sense.
I wish I were better about periodic maintenance like draining the tank or refurbishing the valve, but a man has got to know his limitations.
I also think the chances that a tank will rust out in a fashion that will result in an explosive decompression complete with shrapnel is vanishingly small. A larger danger is that a pinhole will develop and the unit will run itself to death, if you are not home to hear it and it might over heat and start a fire. My compressor is outside my shop in a closet. What are the chances It will explode when I happen to be standing there?
I have a friend who has tanks older than mine and some of them are welded. I will have to ask him about the Duct boy concept, But I am not aware of him re-welding any of them.
As an Aside, I bought on of the little (five gallon?) compressors for my portable unit to run nail guns. I was factory reconditioned. I used it a few minutes to be sure it worked and put it away with the drain open. (For once I was a good boy.) Several months later I got it out to use it to use it and something in the little Yoke on it had plugged itself up. The part was about 60 bucks but in the nick of time I discovered it was still under warranty. The Porter Cable service center (somewhat reluctantly) repaired it.
There might just be a magic coating in my tank. About a year and a half after I got the beast, the pump started going bad (got really noisy). I-R sent a tech out. He ordered new parts and offered to change out the pressure-trol so the compressor would run to a higher pressure, but still stay within the receiver's (tank's) rating. When he came back with the parts, he essentially stripped the tank, so I opened the drain and sprayed the inside of the tank with a pump sprayer and phosphoric acid which would convert iron oxide to iron phosphate crystals that tend to halt further rusting. That, along with the drain, may, indeed, be what's working to keep my big tank for rusting, although I rather doubt the phosphate is still there after 10 years. But . . . . clear water is, well, clear.
When I looked into this years ago, all that I found was that to have a catastrophic tank failure if an air receiver you needed at least one of two things: a) over-pressurization beyond the tank's structural capacity (its max-pressure rating) or b) an outside impact that compromised the tank's structure at a very fast rate such as would result from a penetrating bullet strike or a large impact like getting hit by a vehicle. A pin-holed tank will simply leak air pressure where the rust has eaten through the steel. Biggest danger with a corroded tank is that the leaks will cause the compressor to run continuously exceeding either the motor's duty cycle or the electrical circuit's capacity thus posing a serious fire risk when one or both overheat.
Now that you mention that Minnesota incident, I have a vague memory that the conclusion was refuted at some point, but can't remember where or when.
Rust is continually degrading the “tank's structural capacity” at some point it will fail, regardless of the tanks label.
Maybe 99.9999% from a pin holes and vent safely but denying the possibility of failure is there is a foolish risk no one should take.
Every tank should have a safety plug that will blow out before the tank fails in the event that the pressure controls should fail to turn off the motor.
I believe most compressor are equipped with a safety pressure relief valve. I know my I-G has one that is "supposed" to blow out above a given pressure; so does my portable 2hp Thomas oil-free. Can't tell you for sure their spec, but I'll bet they're somewhere less than my tanks' max pressure ratings of 175 PSI and 150 PSI respectively.
Ellis: Don't think I'm really that ambitious. That was more/less a failed attempt at humor.
I'd like to think there is some form of preventative maintenance to keep the tank in good shape regardless of how long I live. Maybe someday your grandchild will pick it up cheap at my estate sale because yours rusted out. LOL!
Phosphoric acid isn't something I would of thought of. Just how did you spray it in there, Mark?
When the tech stripped off the compressor pump, he also removed the pressure-trol and fittings. I had a qt. of the stuff so put it in a garden sprayer with a long wand that would fit thru the tank's intake hole, pumped it up and worked the wand around inside to coat all the walls. Before he put the thing back together, I opened the bottom drain to let the excess out. As mentioned, I have no idea how long the iron phosphate has lasted, but keeping the tank drained with the auto-valve has made a provable difference. If you have water in your tank, it will mess up your air tools and play havoc if, like me, you do spray finishing. I also run my air through coalescing filters that also get drained (manually) in a regular basis.