Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Lathe problem

Posts

Lathe problem

#1

A.J. Hamler

Lathe problem

A.J. Hamler

Got a question on lathes -- not turning, but the lathe itself, which is why I've posted this here instead of in the turning section. I've been turning for decades, literally since high school, but I'll be the first to admit I know absolutely nothing about mechanics or machinery. I know how it all works, but when it comes to a machine's innards I'm completely helpless. I'm having an issue with my nearly new Jet 1221VS lathe. The description of the issue is as follows:

1) For some reason, a couple months ago out of the blue I started getting out-of-round turnings. Not with green bowls or something like that which will often start deforming as you turn them, but with well-seasoned wood. Happens with all kinds of turning -- spindle, faceplate and chuck turning, not just one type -- so I think I can rule out a bad chuck or faceplate but I really have no idea.

2) At about the same time, I started getting a ton of vibration. Not surprising once things get out-of-round I suppose, but the vibration is relentless. I fear the lathe is going to walk off. Even when the out-of-round issue hasn't gotten too bad, I'm also getting a lot of chatter.

3) And finally (and this may be the big clue), about the time this all started happening, the lathe started making a whining noise from the headstock. Can't pinpoint it exactly, but it seems to be higher in the headstock rather than down by the motor but I really can't be sure. The pitch of the whine changes as the speed changes.

Other stuff -- I've looked all over the inside of the headstock with a flashlight and I and can find absolutely nothing rubbing against a wheel or belt that might make that noise; it's clean as can be in there. I keep my chisels very sharp so we can rule that out. The lathe itself is very steady on the Jet steel legset (although it is, of necessity, on a mobile base); however, it's been on that mobile base since day one and I didn't have this issue then. While not causing the issue I suppose the mobile base could be amplifying the problem, though.

If I had to make a mechanical guess (a dangerous thing for a mechanical dunce like myself), I'd guess it was an issue with bearings. But as to how or why the issue suddenly appeared in a new lathe, or how to fix it or, heck, even where the darned bearings are is a mystery to me.

Any advice? Thanks in advance!

Re: Lathe problem

#2

Re: Lathe problem

John McGaw

Any number of things come to mind. First would be the main bearings being worn out. Second would be a bent shaft. Third would be the drive system -- especially if you have a lathe with a Reeves-type drive (these have always been a horror story for me). These would certainly be capable of giving you out-of-round turnings. A simple measurement of runout and a firm shake should tell you about the bearing(s).

Re: Lathe problem

#3

Re: Lathe problem

Roy

Try running it without anything on the spindle. Do you still have the noise and vibration? Check the spindle nose to see if something is keeping your chuck or faceplate from seating on the face of the shoulder behind the threads. Check to see if there is something on you faceplate or chuck.

Roy

Re: Lathe problem

#4

JL

Re: Lathe problem

JL

Is your lathe still under warranty?

If you had a larger lathe (such as my 1642 EVS) - I would suggest you check to see if your headstock and tailstock were aligned. Which is something you might check anyway.

Put the tailstock quill at full extension and see if the points on your drive spur and live center match up when the tailstock locked down.

With the larger lathes, if the lathe is correctly leveled - the points can sometimes not match as the bed is somewhat torqued.

Obviously this usually isn't a case for smaller lathes such as yours.

My first thought is the spindle bearing. It may be bad.

My next thought (which is easy to correct) is that the surface on which your lathe is resting may not be completely level anymore.

I presume you have checked your belts and your motor mounts - but if they are worn they can also cause this problem.

Re: Lathe problem

#5

Re: Lathe problem

don stephan

Expanding on this, bring the tailstock up to the spur drive, then rotate the spindle by hand to see if you can notice the spur drive center is staying lined up with the point of the tailstock.

Re: Lathe problem

#6

Re: Lathe problem

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

One or both of your main bearings have failed. To prove this to yourself, mount something to the headstock, e.g., a scroll chuck, face plate, spur center, Jacob's chuck, anything you can get a grip on. Put your left hand on top of the headstock and grip the "something" with your right hand. Try to move it forward and back and up and down. If your bearings are sound, the spindle and whatever you have attached to it should not perceptibly move, except they should rotate, of course. You can do the same test with the hand wheel, which is closer to the other main bearing. Another test of failed bearings is that the headstock will get hot to the touch due to friction in the bearings when you are turning stock on the lathe (when you are getting the whining noise), and it will be hotter where the bearings are pressed into the headstock casting.

A minor issue with your description that made finding a parts list and diagram a bit of a puzzle is that your lathe is a JWL-1220VS, not 1221.

If you want to know where the bearings are, there is a parts diagram here: http://www.ereplacementparts.com/jet-jwl1220vs-708376vs-variable-speed-mini-lathe-parts-c-32652_32854_154998.html

The bearings are part #s 6 and 7. If they are both bad, replacing them will cost you about $60. Getting them out is not easy. You will probably need a wheel puller. Putting them back in should be done with an arbor press. Note that the cast iron headstock casting is kind of brittle, so you don't want to be bashing it to move the bearings. And, of course, there are several other parts that will need to be removed first--everything in the parts diagram on the dotted line that runs through the bearings--and reassembled after you've replaced the bearings.

Note that there is also a bearing in your live center (parts 52, 53 and 54), which is held in the tail stock. There is a chance that it is bad, but based on the location of the whine, I suspect this is not the case.

Re: Lathe problem

#7

Re: Lathe problem *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

If you can find the actual bearing specs you might be able to order from the Big Bearing Company at a considerable savings. I've used them a couple time with good results.


Big Bearing Store

Re: Lathe problem

#8

Re: Lathe problem

Dick Coers

I'm skeptical that worn bearings are going to give you out of round turnings. Seems like the rollers or balls would have to be almost falling out for that to happen. I'd suspect you have something loose in the headstock. Maybe something that is allowing play that is parallel to the bed. But even then, out or round turnings seems unlikely. Loosen the belts and see if you can find some looseness somewhere.

Re: Lathe problem

#9

Re: Lathe problem

William Duffield

I have a local bearing company that I use. Of course it's more expensive than an internet based company, but less than Jet official parts, and there's no shipping and no sales tax. (It's in Delaware.) I can walk in with the bad bearing and they will find me one to replace it. They will know whether I need a sealed or a shielded bearing, and whether it needs to take thrust forces.

Re: Lathe problem

#10

Re: Lathe problem

William Duffield

If the bearings don't have the kind of play you describe, they can't cause the problem. I've been inside the heads of JET mini-lathes more than once. The only other thing that can come loose is the set screws that hold the stepped pulleys in place (one on the spindle; one on the motor shaft). But he said he checked that.

I have one more thought. A.J. didn't say whether he was using a face plate or scroll chuck which are threaded to the end of the spindle, or a spur center or Jacob's chuck which are attached with the #2 Morse taper. If the latter, the taper could be loose and have gotten junk in it. That's easy to fix with a Morse taper cleaner (or compressed air and a clean rag), unless the female taper has been galled, in which case he will need to replace the spindle and the spur center.

Re: Lathe problem

#11

A.J. Hamler

Re: Lathe problem - update

A.J. Hamler

Based on suggestions here, I've looked at it some more. I tried William's bearing test and it proved negative -- I used both a faceplate and a Morse taper chuck, and it feels as solid as the day is long. Spins freely, but no movement in any other direction.

I also checked several other things suggested here like alignment of the spur center with the tailstock & etc. All seemed well and good.

Now, as an example of how mechanically clueless I am, one thing I didn't do before my original post was to remove the belt and try running the darned thing. That thought came to me as I was fussing with it this morning, and lo and behold, the whining isn't coming from the headstock at all, but the motor itself. The sound appears to me emanating from the back of the motor, not the end with the stepped pulley. Something on that end is whining. It's a metallic whine; doesn't sound at all like wood chips rubbing, but what do I know.

I'm beginning to think I have two issues here that are probably not related, (but again, what do I know) and my out-of-round/vibration issue may not be related to the whine. I think my next step to check the out-of-round issue is to get the lathe off that mobile base and solidly on the floor, and then turn something to see if the vibration and such is still there. Does that sound like a logical next step for that issue?

As to the whining that I now know is definitely in the back end of the motor, any suggestions? My limited mechanical wisdom, which is scanty indeed, says it might be something as simple as replacing the brushes.

Re: Lathe problem

#12

A.J. Hamler

Re: Lathe problem

A.J. Hamler

Mine is indeed the 1221VS, not the 1220VS.

Re: Lathe problem

#13

Re: Lathe problem - update

Bill Howatt

There are some suggestions for vibration in the troubleshooting section of the manual.

The motor being a DC motor does have brushes so you should check them.

Bill

Re: Lathe problem

#14

Re: Lathe problem

William Duffield

Oops! ereplacementparts.com let me down! They evidently don't have a diagram and parts list for your new JET 12" mini-lathe. I'm very sorry to have misled you.

I found the JWL1221VS's manual on JET's website, at http://content.jettools.com/assets/manuals/719200_man_EN.pdf

Finding it was not straightforward, since they list their machines by product number. The product number is 719200. Write it down, in case you need to order parts.

It has a 110 V DC motor, with brushes. Therefore, worn brushes could be the reason for the whine. On page 20 of your manual you will find the procedure for inspecting the brushes, and also a procedure for removing the spindle from the headstock (if you need to replace a worn belt or if you ever needed to replace the bearings). The manual also gives you a list of reasons for excessive vibration, and what to try to correct each problem. It starts on page 23. Some of these, we didn't mention.

The quality of the parts diagrams in the official digital manual is vastly superior to the copies that ereplacementparts provides.

The manual also states that your lathe has a five year warranty.

Re: Lathe problem

#15

Re: Lathe problem - update

John McGaw

Indeed. The DC motors used in ever lathe I've seen has been of the 'brush' type including my own. The big Leeson motor on my lathe has always made a subtle 'whine' from new but it has never affected its operation at all.

Re: Lathe problem

#16

Re: Lathe problem - update

Dick Coers

I can't imagine vibration is causing out of round turning. How much is it out of round? What are you turning, and how are you holding it? Is it dry wood? What size and what tool are you using? I would not go to the effort to take it off the stand. Vibration will cause a rough turning, but not an out of round. Considering the rpm of the wood, vibration would have a real rough time of being in the exact same place on the turning (making it out of round). I've read quite a few people use a chuck that is not bottomed out on the shoulder of the shaft. The threads bottom out in the chuck, and results in a mess when turning. You need to contact clean steel to steel, at the shoulder. I think we will need pictures and very specific information if we can help any more.

Re: Lathe problem

#17

Re: Lathe problem - update

Bill Howatt

Yes, more detailed info is needed.

I have turned what I considered dry wood and found that the end product was not perfectly round. Possible causes, IMO, the wood wasn't as dry as I thought, the turning modified some forces in the wood and sanding makes bowls oval because of the toughness of side vs end grains.

Bill

Re: Lathe problem

#18

Re: Lathe problem

del schisler

i don't quite follow, how can a chunk of wood be out of round when turned on the lathe? isn't it round ? what i would do is to see if the spendle is off center of the bed ? take and measure from the spendle to the bed with someting accurate and see when you hand turn spindle , and see what you get? what i don't get is when you turn a block of wood down to round how can it be out of round , are you Measuring it ? i guess most other post's have ask lot's more i don't see how vibration's can cause out of round wood ? i may be dense but ??

Re: Lathe problem

#19

A.J. Hamler

Re: Lathe problem - another update

A.J. Hamler

Thanks again everyone.

I've gone through all your suggestions, and have repeated the vibration troubleshooting in the manual (yes, I checked the manual before my first post). I've also done all the alignment checks between head/tail stock and it's fine. Haven't yet tried it out by doing a test turning, as I've been concentrating on that whining sound which is clearly a separate issue.

I've checked one of the brushes and it seems fine -- the lathe isn't that old and the brush appears to have tons of lifespan left -- and put it back in. Whine still there. Can't check the other brush as it's inaccessible due to the way the motor's mounted. The brush cover cap is up inside the bedways and there's just no way to get to it without removing the motor first. Grrrr. Disassembling machinery is terrifying to this non-mechanic, although a man's gotta do what a man's gotta do so I'll suck it up, cross my fingers and jump in.

Due to a bunch of stuff I need to get done, though, I think I'm going to have to put off disassembling the motor from its mount for a bit till I wrap up other work tasks. That way I can take my time without worrying about work stuff. In the meantime, I think I'll try a quick test turning and see if all the things we've come up with to reduce the vibration have helped that issue.

A.J.

Re: Lathe problem

#20

you tube video?

Chuck in Mtl.

Would it be possible to put up a you tube video that will illustrate the noise that you hear?

Re: Lathe problem

#21

Re: Pretty easily...

TomD

Depends what out of round means, we don't have an example do we? I read pretty much the whole thread.

So what happens in one case is you go too fast across the piece, and what you cut is a spiral, this is sorta how threads are cut freehand. Then you recut that rubbing the bevel, now you are riding an out of round surface, while possibly cutting another shape beneath it. You can get terrible vibration. The solution can be twofold, one is to roll off your bevel just enough that you are scraping a little, in the extreme you can whip out a scraper and have at it. Since by definition a scraping cut is one in which the bevel doesn't rub, you cut through the odd shape you have created into round material underneath.

Another easy way to get rid of the spiralling, and interrupted cutting is if the piece involves, or can involve, an entry as when cutting into a bowl one is hollowing, that kind of cut starts out as a plunge, or a scrape, and the bevel is established on fresh material. As a result, so long as one cuts properly, there is no risk of picking up a spiral and running over it.

Re: Lathe problem

#22

Re: Tailstock Alignment.

TomD

Tailstock misalignment will induce a longitudinal taper, of course you may never notice it if you are using feel or calipers to size the part, but you will in fact be cutting a taper to come out with a cylinder.

Re: Lathe problem

#23

A.J. Hamler

Re: you tube video?

A.J. Hamler

never did a youtube video in my life, but all my cameras have a video function, so I'll give it a try.

Re: Lathe problem

#24

Take Pictures

Stuart Johnson

Take a lot of pictures as you are dismantling to help put it back together.

Re: Lathe problem

#25

craigd

Re: you tube video?

craigd

>>never did a youtube video in my life, but all my cameras have a video function, so I'll give it a try.

It is pretty easy, especially if you have a gmail account - my android phone even uploads videos to my youtube account at the touch of an icon, it automatically used my gmail account info. I took a block of wood, put a slot in it and voila, instant phone/video cam tripod mount.