Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

Posts

Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

#1

Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

Ronster

These 2 walnut logs I just got have a minimum heartwood dia. of 12". Not huge. Going to the sawyer early next week. If quartersawing is an option, should I ask for it? Greater stability, right? But perhaps not better looking as in the case of white oak? Also, would you slightly oversize the normal cutting thickness even if this will end up as 3/4" stock? [I know how to sticker and store, and I have inside space for drying.]

continued thanks for everyone's thoughts!

ron

Re: Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

#2

Re: Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

John McGaw

Quartersawing wood will generally yield something which is more orderly and boring unless the wood has medullary rays which show up as the sought-after flake figure in oak. That said, I once saw a large standing cabinet which had quatersawn walnut in the door panels and it was quite pretty, the vertical stripey figure accentuating the height of the cabinet nicely. I don't know if the QS in that piece was full-thickness or veneer but it set of the rest of the walnut. Personally, if I had logs to be sawn, I'd go for plainsawn since that is more useful in most furniture.

Re: Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

#3

Not with a 12 inch "log"

Dick Coers

Percent of sapwood to heartwood is going to be your biggest issue with that size. Rift sawn will yield the same look in walnut, with more yield. In your case, just have them plain sawn.

Re: Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

#4

Re: Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

roger lance

Things you might do to decide:....1) go to a wood store and look at quarter sawn walnut.....2) ask the sawyer for his opinion.....3) plain saw the log and get boards that are flat sawn, rift sawn, and quarter sawn just by the nature of that procedure (which is what I'd do FWIW).

Re: Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

#5

No, log is too small, and plain looks better in Wa

Keith Newton

Walnut is stable enough to not worry about the rest .

Re: Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

#6

Re: Is quartersawing walnut a good idea?

TomD

I wouldn't quater saw it, if you flat saw it you will get some "quarter sawn wood" on either side of the pith, and depending on the cuts, you will get it reasonably so outboard the pith. My preferred cuts with a chainsaw mill are to start right through the pith, since the heavy kerf wastes the most waste wood that way, but obviously your saw will be different..

What you really need to think about is the dimensions of what kind of wood you really need to get to do whatever you are doing. 12" is a little small to get too deeply into this. But for instance, assume you wanted the wood either side of the pith for frames, it could be radial in that application, and you would need what thickness pre-drying to get the finished thickness you would need for that application? What about the flat sawn wood, what is is for, and what does it need to be dimensioned at? It is hard to get specific because often when you do, the project is no longer there when the wood is dried. In that instance, and owning a band saw, I try to leave pieces as thick as possible until I resaw them, then I further reduce them when I have them dry.

Another reason to do this is let's say you need a variety of wood when you have it all dried, but you didn't perfectly yield every thickness in the correct amount. Thick wood is often more relatively expensive, a lot more, than thin wood. So if you had to go source some light wood for say panels, you might do better both in exoticness and cost, at the wood store. The least sawing yields more expensive thick wood from your home sources. I find thick wood generally dries really well also. By thick, I mean 2 inches plus or minus.