sanding pine and sand paper
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
First a disclaimer, I have zero experience with electric random orbital sanders. However, in the past I sanded enough that I invested in an industrial quality air driven ARO brand ROS and the 18 cfm at 90 psi compressor to feed it air. I still have and use it but I don't buy paper for it as often. My sander does not have vacuum. The exhaust port for the air blows most of the dust off while sanding......outside only!.
I don't work much pine. It is too soft and I don't like dealing with the resin. I use poplar for house trim.
Stain grade pine will be one of the "soft" pines. It may be eastern white pine or a western soft pine. In the green state any of the pines are laden with pitch. For furniture work this pitch must be "set" which is done at high temperature in a kiln. Setting is just the volitilization of the more volatile resin components rendering what is left less sticky and less subject to bleed. It is not a stretch to imagine that the lumber that shows up at Home Depot may have been dried more, or less, hot with the pitch more, or less, set.
Get the lumber hot and the remaining resin will become sticky. Anyone sawing pine already knows this fact from noting build up on the saw teeth. Care must be taken when using belt or drum sanders to not clog the grits with resin and dust. I clogged an 80 grit drum belt in minutes sanding white pine.
In the case of my ROS sanding paper the finer grades typically come with a coating to repel sticky stuff, be it finish or resin. This paper is commonly called "stearated paper" because in the past the coating was a metal salt of stearic acid. I don't know if this material is still used or something else. In any case this paper is typically white. If this paper costs more, it is certainly not significantly more and I think no more for what I buy.
As a test I took a piece of planed KD eastern white pine and sanded it with 180 grit Klingspor stearated paper with my ARO brand ROS. This grit removed planer marks quickly and left a finish ready for stain, one step.