Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Sanding pine boards

Posts

Sanding pine boards

#1

Sanding pine boards

Adam

I've been trying to sand 1x8's and 1x4 clear pine boards to stain for trim in my son's house. No matter what I do, I end up getting the corkscrew looking swirls throughout the wood. It doesn't seem to make any difference which sander I use. Started using a Dewalt orbital and then went and purchased a Festool 125 with the same results. It's worth mentioning, that approx. 7 years ago I did trim work for 2 bedrooms upstairs and one bath with no problems with markings on the wood. I guess what I'm trying to say is that it's not my first rodeo with sanding and staining. I should also note that last night I tried using a Makita square sander and still had marks in it also (not as bad). You get to a point to where you just want to toss in the towel, that's why I'm here this morning hoping that someone can tell me that I'm not crazy and give me a few suggestions as to what to try next.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#2

More info needed

John Veerkamp

What's your sanding protocol? How coarse do you start and how high do you progress? What kind of paper are you usinf? Many cheaper sandpapers have irregular grits- 120 may actually have some 100 grit in it. Are you thoroughly cleaning before moving to the next finer grit?

Re: Sanding pine boards

#3

two important factors

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Quality of machine and quality of the paper

I use an air driven 12000 rpm air driven sander and either Klingspor or 3M paper and I don't have the problem. I do have the problem with cheap 100 grit paper, maybe because of poor grading of the abrasive.

For your task I would think that 120 grit would be a good starting place.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#4

Re: Sanding pine boards

Barry Irby

Sanding in a linear motion approximately parallel to the grain is the best Idea. A drum sander like a Perfomax will do that. Of course you can hand sand. (Yeah sure)

Are you using quality sand paper? Occasionally there is a stray grit of larger size on the sheet and this can create the swirls. You can minimize this by "breaking" or scraping the face of the sand paper over a really sharp corner on a piece of metal.

Are you using fresh sharp sandpaper? Unfortunately you should use sandpaper like it was free. (Or you stole It, or your disreputable BIL bought it) This is especially true on pine. the difference in hardness between the types of exposed wood is huge and often there are large area of the softer wood exposed. The softer wood tend to sand away much faster, leaving a wavy surface. Really sharp sandpaper and a firm backer behind it tends to help.

I would suggest minimal power sanding with a ROS and then finishing up by hand with the grain.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#5

Re: More info needed

Adam

I'll have to look over lunch hour to see what paper I'm using. As for the grit, I start with 120, 150, 180, and then 220. My sander is hooked to a vac. with very low suction, therefore I didn't clean between grit change. Last night, I tried just starting out with 220 and ended up with the same results. A lot of head scratching going on and laying in bed trying to figure things out.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#6

Re: Sanding pine boards

Keith Newton

Start with the finest paper you can get the job done with, then use light pressure. RO sanders don't need downward pressure to cut fast, especially on soft wood. Then use slow movement around the board. This will keep the threads finer, whereas fast travel produces coarse threads to the screw pattern.

If you are using a Bosch, the orbit is larger with the leaver forward, and smaller with it pointed aft.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#7

Re: Sanding pine boards

Michael Wilkins

Barry mentioned using a drum sander to get parallel scratch patterns on the pine. I would not recommend that approach. When I got my drum sander, I decided to give it a test drive, using a piece of pine lying close by. Big mistake. The pitch from the pine loaded up the paper to the point of having to replace it. Leason learned.

Start with a 120 grit paper and use good quality like 3M or Klingspoor.

Good luck and watch those fingers.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#8

Re: Sanding pine boards

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi Adam,

I use a lot of pine, & don't have the problems you are describing. Assuming the surface is fairly smooth to start with, my routine is:

ROS with 150 grit (use 120 grit if surface rough)

Vacuum surface

Square 1/4 sheet sander with 220 grit

Vacuum surface

Light Hand sanding with the grain with 220 grit

Vacuum & apply finish.

I use quality paper, and don't apply pressure to the sanders. Let them do the work. I vacuum between sandings to insure that all loose grains from the previous grit are removed

Good Luck

Ron

Re: Sanding pine boards

#9

Re: Sanding pine boards

Yonak

I'm wondering if pitch is the problem. I notice that debris stuck on the sandpaper can cause circular marks. Immediately after cleaning the sandpaper do you notice the swirls ?

Re: Sanding pine boards

#10

Re: Sanding pine boards

mdclor

You might be seeing what Teri Masaschi calls pigtail squiggles which she describes as long "coiled spring" marks. According to her they are created when the sander is loaded with grit and dragged around the surface. See her book Foolproof Wood Finishing, page 39.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#11

Re: Sanding pine boards

del schisler

i didn't read any other post's yet, what kind of sandpaper ? box store stuff, may not be very good , if that is what you are using the little pieces come's off on cheep paper causing those swirl marks, post a picture of close up ? and what grit are you using , if this is boards from box store they should be smooth enough ?

Re: Sanding pine boards

#12

Re: Sanding pine boards

Adam

That is the perfect explanation to what is appearing in the wood. In one of the other responses, it was talking about pitch on the sandpaper. There hasn't been a single spot on any of the paper when I was done sanding.

Unfortunately had to work through my lunch, so was unable to go home to see what the manufacturer was on the paper. It is paper that I purchased from Wood Craft when the Festool sander was bought. The paper that I used with the Dewalt sander went to my daughters house last weekend, and it was doing the same thing.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#13

Re: Sanding pine boards

William Duffield

Is your Festool ROS a RO-125 or an ETS-125? If it is an ETS, is it a 3mm orbit or a 5 mm orbit? If it's an RO, are you running it in orbital mode or in aggressive mode?

I would think Woodcraft would have sold you Festool paper to go with the Festool sander, especially since the hole pattern is quite different on the Festool sanders than on other 5" ROSs. If you are trying to use 5-hole or 8-hole paper with the Festool sander, it won't effectively clear either the sanding dust or the grit that comes off the paper. If you are using Festool paper, what kind of paper is it? Festool makes several different kinds of paper, for different applications. For raw wood, Rubin is the preferred paper. Granat will also work well, but it is significantly more expensive than Rubin. If you are using Festool paper, how much suction is your vac applying? Festool sanders are designed to use very low suction. If you have it too high, the vac sucks the sander down onto the wood, causing more swirls, and overworking and overheating the paper. The sander should float over the surface, and you should not need to apply more than the lightest downward or sideways pressure.Did you break in the Festool sander? I've been told they work much better after having been run a couple of hours.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#14

Re: Sanding pine boards

John Pappas

Agree with Keith on the use of a light touch

Re: Sanding pine boards

#15

It's not the paper...

John in NM

Within reason, any decent paper will give you decent results.

It's the pressure. When pressing too hard on a random orbital sander or tipping it to use just the rim, you loose the random part of the sanding action. Sanding too narrow a board will do it too, you need most of the pad in contact with wood for most RO sanders.

The effect is much worse on soft woods like pine. Some pine is softer than others too.

I've seen it on walnut, mesquite, cherry, etc though, so it happens in hardwood too. Keep the sander flat on the board (and covering 3/4 of the pad at least) and let the sander do the work, as another poster suggested. Start fine with pine, 120 or 150 should do it. With hardwoods, start with 80.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#16

Re: Sanding pine boards

Keith Newton

Adam, did you use a wash-coat before you tried the stain? This may help make the problem more forgiving.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#17

Too many grits

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is standard to skip every other grit size. If you start at 120 the next step is 180. There is no reason to go beyond 180 in you application.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#19

Yep, that too...

John in NM

As you said before, light touch, and a wash coat (light sealer is how I take that) should take care of it.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#20

problems at 220?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't think it is possible to get visible swirly scratches from 220 grit scratches. I'm thinking pitch balls are accumulating under the paper. These indeed will exert extra pressure and make marks.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#21

Dale Lenz

Festool 125

Dale Lenz

Have that sander and 2nd line from bottom model of Festool sander for the past 3-4 years or so. Lately, I've notice the "corkscrew swirls" on cherry lumber...why, IDK? I solved the problem by turning the sander speed down to about half or so. I believe I have the vacuum set on high, no sure with out checking. Anyway, by slowing the sander speed down, solved the problem. I might try running the sander faster and turn the vacuum down ????

Re: Sanding pine boards

#22

Re: Sanding pine boards

Adam

To answer a lot of questions, the paper that I'm using is called Rhynogrip. The two gentlemen at Woodcraft said that they like it just as much as the paper that Festool sells and one guy said that he likes it even better. The hole pattern in the paper matches the sanding pad on the sander, so there is not a mismatch. After reading all the posts, I was thinking that maybe having the vac. hooked up to the sander was the cause of the problem ( to much pressure, heat, etc). Just got done doing about a 4ft spot on a 1x8 without the vac even hooked up. Didn't have as many of the pigtail looking things in the stain, but still had a lot of sanding marks using only 220 grit.

I then thought that maybe I should turn the speed down on the sander and proceeded to do another 4ft section. The results were just as bad as they were in the beginning of these endeavor, if not worse. To answer another question, I was just letting the sander float with just guidance from my hand. I'm beginning to think that painted trim isn't going to be too bad after all.

Another question was about a wash coat. I'm assuming you are talking about the pre-stain because it is pine. I am using that also.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#23

makes no sense

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

With air driven sanders the faster they go the better the finish. Like I said mine turns 12000 rpm. I think the "corkscrews are balls of junk under the paper. They might be a result of resin from the pine balling up dust and grits and then rolling around between the paper and the board. Heat from this sander, which could be rpm related, may be causing the resin to bloom to the surface while sanding.

Its pine, sands easy. 120 followed by 180 is enough. Hand sand it.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#24

Re: Sanding pine boards

don stephan

Does it make a difference if the sander is picked up while still running, then turned off; or allowed to stop while still in contact with the wood? Seems like I've read both recommendations in the past.

Re: Sanding pine boards

#25

Re: I Suppose I'm Being Cynical,

William Duffield

…but all too often, the retailer likes the product best that has the highest margin. :D

I have no experience with RhinoGrip paper. I am totally satisfied with the performance of the Festool papers. I couldn't find any pictures of RhinoGrip papers with the proprietary Festool hole pattern. Does your paper have the center hole? It is essential to the performance of the Festool random orbital sanders. Does your vac have a variable speed control? All the Festool vacs, and also the Fein vacs, do. This is also essential to the performance of the Festool vacs. Other sanders, whose suction cannot be reduced, may pull the sander right down onto the wood, which has the same effect as applying too much downward force with your body.