Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

Posts

Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#1

Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

roger lance

This is one of those small rant/personal opinion threads that you may be able to top with a similar tool experience of your own. But IMHO, there is a tool in my shop that is a necessity yet it never fails to challenge, fight, frustrate, and try me each and every time it's used. It does its job.....it picks up the mess....cleans the saw dust and shavings.....restores order. But it can't roll over its own power cord.....the fittings will not turn to relieve a fouled hose.....the fittings fall off.....the bucket body seems to catch on anything handy when you do get the thing to roll.....etc....etc. I give you my nominee for a needed tool that needs, IMHO, some small improvements.....please.....


Now, this is a burr under my saddle.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#2

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

Frank /Fenton Mo.

Electric cords on anything get caught on everything.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#3

I agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

this indeed is the tool that least performs its intended task and does it in the most annoying way. You didn't even get to the too frequent filter cleaning out part. I installed "central vacuum" to be mostly rid of the damn thing.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#4

Another case of the bottom line...

John in NM

Those ~$100 shop vac's do their job just well enough and no better. At work we have a $500 Dayton that shares none of those faults you list.

I never get around to spending the $$$ on one for my shop though, seems like that extra $400 is always more useful in other areas.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#5

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

Barry Irby

The rule of Extension Cords: (on a construction site) If you have a hundred feet of cord, its a foot too short, if you have 200 feet of cord, its two feet too short, If you have 300 feet of cord, never mind, you will never get it untangled.

I had a Sears shop vac for thirty years. The howling banshee of death. I agree with everything you said. I now have a Rigid one. I agree with everything you said. It has lots of storage parts on it. Just roll it around and it will tear off a door facing, stumble over its cord and everything falls off it. They seriously need a better filter/easier to clean.

I would like to borrow or use one of the high end ones to see for myself that it is truly better. It would have to be amazing to get me to spend $500 or 600, but I would like to be amazed.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#6

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

William Duffield

I have a Rigid with the same set of neuroses. At least it's quieter than the previous shop-vac, but still not quiet enough. I also have a Festool CT26. It's a lot quieter, doesn't trip over its cord, does an excellent job of holding and managing tools, but I don't use it a lot for general clean-up because the bags are way too expensive, even though they don't spill any dust at all when you are replacing them, so I keep the otherwise bootable shop-vac around. Another annoyance with the Rigid is the control unit for automatically turning the vac on and off when you turn the tool on and off. The unit (which you have to purchase separately) is way back on the wall, so you have to go all the way back there every time you change tools. And for sure you will find the shop vac blocking your path to the outlet, and standing on both cords. The control is built into the Festool vacs, so you plug the tool into the vac and switch the vac to "auto". (Fein vacs do this, too.) A further advantage of the Festool is that you can just velcro the tool power cord to the vac hose and leave it there. When you need to swap tools, the power cord and the vac tube both disconnect at the tool. No more running around the shop juggling cords.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#7

duel personas?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Vacuum attachments at 30 paces?

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#8

Re: duel personas?

roger lance

Does its job.....but PITA doing it.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#9

Shop Vac Workaround

Paul Leuba

One approach to mitigating the flaws in a shop vacuum is to use the tool just for its vacuum and not as a dirt/debris repository. Add a dust deputy type cyclone collector to the end of the 2 1/2" hose of the vacuum and then use a 20' or so length of smaller diameter hose attached to the cyclone collector to do clean up without moving the vacuum or the dust deputy. A high performance filter in the vacuum will prevent the recycling of small dust particles into the shop air and the filter will stay usable for an amazingly long time because the overwhelming percentage of the dirt/debris will be deposited in the cyclone canister.

I've used this arrangement for a few years and find that I empty the cyclone about 10 - 12 times for each time I empty the vacuum. The longer hose eliminates the need to tow the vacuum throughout the shop where it will tip over its own cord and otherwise get in the way.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#10

Alternative

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I use a 20' 4" flex hose, with adapter for 2-1/2" hose and fittings, on my DC to clean saw dust in the shop. The shop vac is therefore a stationary tool which I only use hooked to the sander via a 1-1/2" hose and fitted with a HEPA filter. the small amount of debris that I don't wish to run into the DC gets swept up the old fashioned way. The only time the shop vac comes out of its niche is when there's water to be picked up.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#11

Ya but

Bruce Mack

I have a big Ridgid vac mostly stationary with a Dust Right strapped to it. Because I use it on the lunchbox planer and contractor table saw as well as to pick up shavings and small off-cuts from the front side of my bench I have a 20 foot length of 2 1/2" diameter hose attached to a flexible but heavy wire coil extension from the Dust Right. I need the length to get it from the back 40 to the bench but it's as heavy and unwieldy as an anaconda.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#12

Another Alternative

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

These make great dust collectors. The one trouble is that they tend to empty the dust on the kitchen floor, which can lead to duels of a different kind.


img

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#13

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

My Fein turbo II rolls without tipping when you pull it by the hose. It is also quiet enough to talk next to it in a normal voice and be heard.

Lee

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#14

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

Jesse Cloud

The other nuisance about the Crapsman vac and its cousins is the static electricity. I feel betrayed when a tool I paid good money for gives me a jolt. Also, they seem to be pretty useless for the small stuff. Run it in bright light sometime and see how much dust is in the exhaust. It sucks up stuff off the floor and spreads it through the air so you can breathe the air into your lungs - and that's progress??

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#15

Adam of Oakland

Re: Shop Vac Workaround

Adam of Oakland

this seems like a good logical next step for me and my craptastic crapsman. I wonder: what is your system for stowing the 20' of extra hose?

great thread, guuys :-)

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#16

Re: Shop Vac Workaround

Bruce Mack

It detaches easily, and I replace it with the original 7 foot length. The 20 foot segment stays coiled on the floor, leading to near mishaps. I should do better.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#17

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

TomD

I like the small RSP i have. It shares some of the faults you mention. The top heavyness is key to wet use, at least at the price, which was around 45 bucks. Equip it with a hose from a real vac, and a goretex filter, it is dead quiet and does great work.

I bought a rigid in the larger hose. We use it for wet clean-up in the basement, but the accessories really are crap.

Then I have a dust collector with the 4" hose. The rigid is the one I would part with.

When I used to make boats with vac bagging, we would run a cheap as dirt, banshee loud, shopvac for 6-12 hours at a go, over and over. It never failed us or broke down. We would set it up to run when the left the shop.

The solution for the smaller ones is probably a good old non-wet vac, they run quiet, have real brushes and hoses, and people are tossing them to buy the Dyson nonsense, which is high concept design (good), but cheap execution on the fundamentals like the brushes.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#18

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

Mine eats pencils.

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#19

Re: Shop Vac Workaround

Paul Leuba

I store the 20' x 1 1/2" hose coiled on a garden hose hook on the wall of the shop.

Paul in Hunt Valley MD

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#20

I call mine Sparky

Tom Dunlap

For a long time I'd get sparked from static electricity. Like the cat, I'd jump and flinch.

During a convoluted conversation with my brother the topic came up. He does computer repair so discharges his spare electrons often and sometimes where's a leash. He suggested grounding the case somehow.

My solution was to take some screw a piece of chain about 10" long to the base of the unit...short enough not to get under the wheels. After that, no more sparkies!

Tom

Re: Nominee of tool with duel personas.....

#21

Re: Shop Vac Workaround

William Duffield

If the shop vac was a middle line backer, you've now added a nose tackle to the team. :D That's more stuff to take up valuable floor space and to have to push or pull out of your way.

Oneida makes an attachment specific to the Festool dust collectors, the Ultimate Dust Deputy II. It locks to the top of the CT so it doesn't take up any floor space, and drastically reduces the Festool bag usage. However, Oneida's products and service are not nearly as high quality as Festool's (read the reviews). If you are doing lead based paint abatement or asbestos abatement, the Oneida bag doesn't meet the containment requirements of the standards. Unlike the Festool bags, when you empty the full Oneida bag, or even the Fein vac, any other shop vac, or your dust collection system bag, you get a face full of the stuff you have collected in the bag. Wear at least an N95 dust mask when emptying your dust control systems.