Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

Posts

Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#1

Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

David Hay Denver

I've been looking at dust collectors recently and wanted to get the thoughts of the folks here. I'd love to get a cyclone system like the ClearVue or Oneida systems, but that just seems really out of reach, cost-wise at the moment. So I've been looking at more "standard" dust collectors, with the idea of putting in a Thien baffle in, at some point. I have a 20x24 shop with the standard assortment of power tools (table saw, band saw, jointer, planer, etc.)

Right now, my current favorites are:

Delta 50-761

Grizzly G0562ZP

SHOP FOX W1687j + upgraded filters from Wynn

The Delta has a smaller motor and impeller combination, but I can mount the motor upside down and have the intake pipe come straight down from the ceiling, which seems to count for something.

The Grizzly seems like a pretty decent machine, though it has an aluminum impeller, which may or may not be an issue. It's also the least expensive of the three.

The Shop Fox appears to be the same as the Grizzly, except that it has a steel impeller but would need upgraded filters/bags (only comes with 30 micron bags). By the time I get the upgraded filters, it's getting close the price of the Delta.

So, any thoughts on these machines? Others I should consider for my size shop? Other ideas?

Thanks!

David

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#2

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delt

Robby Wright - San Marcos, CA

Take a look at the Penn State cyclones and dust collectors. They seem to rate pretty high in the tests and I have had good luck with their products.

http://www.pennstateind.com/store/dust-collection.html

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#3

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delt

William Duffield

Have you looked at the JDS Dust Force? I've been very happy with mine.

Why spend all the time and effort building a Thein Baffle, when you can retrofit the equivalent of a JET Vortex to any of the dust collectors we've been discussing for less than $6? The one I built with minimal effort from a $5 IKEA wok and some hardware I had laying around the shop works well.

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#4

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delt

mdclor

David, it is all about moving air. Using a bigger impeller and motor is one way to do that. Other options are to minimize the length of the tubing, using the appropriate sized tubing, minimizing the bends, sealing the joints, having at least a straight 5' run into the impeller, etc. You might be best served by paying Oneida to design a system for you. Then you can discuss various trade offs to get maximal benefits at the lowest cost. You don't have to buy any hardware from them.

I have no connection with Oneida other than that of a satisfied customer.

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#5

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delt

David Hay Denver

William,

I think I have a general idea of what you've done to retrofit your dust collector, but could you provide more specifics or even a picture? Am I thinking, correctly, that the wok goes convex side down and there's a hole drilled in it somewhere to let the air through to the top filter?

Thanks!

David

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#6

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delt

Larry Rupprecht

David,

I sent you an email about a possibility. Let me know if you did or did not get that.

Larry

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#7

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delt

terry quiram

No recommendations but I will say I have had very unfavorable experience with Grizzly concerning a large power tool.

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#8

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delt

William Duffield

No air hole needed, and the wok goes convex side up. If you google images of "JET Vortex" you will see how simple it is. The wok that IKEA sells is the same shape and diameter, for all practical purposes. All you have to do is remove the wok's handles, find a light weight steel or aluminum bar, drill a hole in the middle, drill a hole in the middle of the bottom of the wok, bolt them together, adjust the shape of the bar slightly to give you a couple inch gap between the funnel and the wok, and attach the assembly to the funnel in the middle of the dust collector with some sheet metal screws, with the wok hanging upside down below the funnel, and Bob's you uncle.

I didn't take any pictures of mine, because I didn't think anyone would need them once they'd seen JET's implementation. Maybe that was a bad assumption, since I had assembled many dust collectors, including a couple of the Vortex models and I already had an IKEA wok.

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#9

Me too

Dick Coers

I won't talk much about it because I was recently banned from another site for talking negatively about Grizzly all the time!

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#10

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delt

David Hay Denver

Thanks for the description. Between that and a Google image search, I think I have a pretty good idea of what you're describing. Definitely something good to keep in mind!

David

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#11

Re: Opposite experience!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I had a Grizzly 6" planer, used it for several years without any issues at all. It remained square and true until the day I sold it to a friend when I replaced it with an 8" Griz with carbide inserted spiral head about 6 years ago, Zero problems with 8" joiner to date, been a great machine that provides as far as I can tell the same excellent surface to problem boards as the Byrd head in my 20" Planer.

I have had a Grizzly 3 HP Cyclone dust collector for about 7 years, I did have a capacitor blow a few months after installation. Called Grizzly, they were very helpful, sent a new cap within 3 days, replaced it Zero problems since.

In fact when examining the Grizzly equipment I have (and the ones I have seen at woodworking shows) the fit and finish far exceeds the Delta and other equipment now made in Asia. In my opinion the quality control of Grizzly (and the part availability) is much better than the quality of the "USA brands" now made in foreign lands.

I would say the older USA made products by Powermatic, Delta and the ilk were better products as well as the Italian and European products of today (alibit at a higher price point), I have a PM-90 Powermatic lathe, a Delta Unisaw (made in Tenn), and a Minmax MM16 all great quality. But I purchased a Powermatic woodworkers drill press at over $1K. It is very noisy, have had problems with the chuck and fit and finish is not up to Griz standards I have seen.

Seems you or someone you know has had problems with Grizzly, this is certainly not my experience ~ nor that of several other people I know! Sorry for your problems, but I can assure you that is not the norm.

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#12

Re: My whole shop was Grizzly

C. John Hebert

Nothing but good words and experiences about Grizzly tools. Had a problem with my oscillating sander, and had the new part withing 3 day's...can't speak highly enough about them

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#13

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delt

Paul Blackwell

When I downsized my shop, I sold my Jet twin canister 3hp. dust collector and replaced it with a Grizzly G0703P 1 1/2 hp. cyclone dust collector. I've been using it for over two years, and am very satisfied with it. At the same time, I bought a Grizzly 6 inch jointer with spiral head and carbide inserts. This provides the smoothest cut I've ever seen a jointer produce. Only minimal sanding required. My experience with Grizzly has only been positive with both equipment and customer service.

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#14

Consider some questions (long)

Grant in Iowa

Dave,

What machine in your shop will run more than all others? Your dust collector.

What machine will run more than many others combined? Your dust collector.

What machine, unlike any other, has the job of keeping you alive longer? Your dust collector.

What machine has a motor that runs at or near capacity almost the entire time it is on? Your dust collector. Do you REALLY want anything less than a good motor on this machine? What will you be able to do if the dust collector is off line? How long can you wait for a replacement?

Does it make sense to skimp on the one machine that helps protect your lungs and helps prevent a fire? Your answers are your own, but they lead you in the right direction.

about 7 years ago, I decided on an early Grizzly cyclone and ordered one. I was excited to receive the white and green monster. Three weeks later, having heard nothing, I called them and inquired when it would ship. They said they couldn't tell me, but would determine when a container with one in it was due in, and then they'd call me and inform me it would be shipping. No problem they said, my credit card wouldn't be billed until it shipped. I began wondering how long it would take to get replacement parts. Then I talked to an electric motor specialist who told me to get a quality motor like Baldor for any machine that would run hard several hours at a time. I called Griz back and canceled my order.

For me, considering those items, and talking it over with my wife (she was sold on the health issue alone), prompted me to buy an Oneida Dust Gorilla (early model). Baldor motor, steel impeller balanced so well it spins for a minute or more after it is shut down (gates closed). Great build quality, great customer service. No wonder they do so well in reviews. The machine arrived in under a week being shipped from Oneida to Iowa. Opening the boxes further reinforced that the decision I made was a good one. It has run without issue ever since.

Since I broke the bank, I waited three or so years to install permanent piping, getting by with a long flex hose. During this time I "let the tools decide where they wanted to be". That was also a good move, because I have not needed to modify the piping at all since. I also ordered my DC piping from Oneida. I saved money on blast gate adapters and welded up my own from their straight pipe. This savings alone made up the cost difference of both of Oneida's competitors at the time.

Great system, very little fine dust left around in the shop these days, which means there is very little in my lungs as well. I do intend to upgrade the filter soon, as the available technology at the time was not as good as today's offerings.

Another aspect is that the larger machines make less noise, and what they do make tends to be of a lower pitch. My cyclone alone can easily be talked over, it is only when we add a planer or other spinning cutter to the airflow that it gets objectionable. Indeed, my 15" planer sounds rather air-raid sirenish when coupled to the ample air flow of the cyclone.

Cry once when you buy it. Spend the $ now and thank me in the future. Can't afford it? wait until you can.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#15

Re: Consider some questions (long)

Larry in NW Ohio

Grant Very good read. I basicly did the same thing when I bought my DC. The only one made in the USA at the time, and even now that I know of, is the Oneida. Also at the time it had an American made motor, guess what a Baldor. It`s been something over 15 years and not even a hic-up. I wouldn`t even think of getting anything else. Larry

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#16

Re: Baldor

Lars Parrington

I have 2 baldor grinders, and they're both awesome.

But, my cheap and presumably chinese-made Jet brand dust collector is also great. I too can have a conversation with it running, and it takes quite a while to spin down after I shut it off. It's a 1.5hp single stage dust collector I picked up used for something like $300. It came with the 2-micron "dust-dog" filter. I retrofitted a Thien to it at one point when I was doing a lot of drum sanding.

Whatever system you ultimately choose, I'd strongly recommend using filters instead of dust bags. The filters have drastically more effective area than a bag, and so will allow you to acheive much higher CFM rates, everything else being equal.

Re: Dust Collectors: Grizzly vs. Shop Fox vs. Delta

#17

Re: Dust collector remote control *LINK*

Lars Parrington

While we're on the subject of dust collectors...

I've been pretty happy with this remote control I got for $10 off amazon (see link below). I think it's actually intended for outdoor xmas lights, but works fine with my 1.5hp single-phase dust collector.

Seems like a much better deal than the $80 dust collector specific remotes I've seen elsewhere.


http://www.amazon.com/dp/B001Q9EFUK/ref=pe_385040_30332190_pe_175190_21431760_M3T1_ST1_dp_1