Consider some questions (long)
Grant in Iowa
Dave,
What machine in your shop will run more than all others? Your dust collector.
What machine will run more than many others combined? Your dust collector.
What machine, unlike any other, has the job of keeping you alive longer? Your dust collector.
What machine has a motor that runs at or near capacity almost the entire time it is on? Your dust collector. Do you REALLY want anything less than a good motor on this machine? What will you be able to do if the dust collector is off line? How long can you wait for a replacement?
Does it make sense to skimp on the one machine that helps protect your lungs and helps prevent a fire? Your answers are your own, but they lead you in the right direction.
about 7 years ago, I decided on an early Grizzly cyclone and ordered one. I was excited to receive the white and green monster. Three weeks later, having heard nothing, I called them and inquired when it would ship. They said they couldn't tell me, but would determine when a container with one in it was due in, and then they'd call me and inform me it would be shipping. No problem they said, my credit card wouldn't be billed until it shipped. I began wondering how long it would take to get replacement parts. Then I talked to an electric motor specialist who told me to get a quality motor like Baldor for any machine that would run hard several hours at a time. I called Griz back and canceled my order.
For me, considering those items, and talking it over with my wife (she was sold on the health issue alone), prompted me to buy an Oneida Dust Gorilla (early model). Baldor motor, steel impeller balanced so well it spins for a minute or more after it is shut down (gates closed). Great build quality, great customer service. No wonder they do so well in reviews. The machine arrived in under a week being shipped from Oneida to Iowa. Opening the boxes further reinforced that the decision I made was a good one. It has run without issue ever since.
Since I broke the bank, I waited three or so years to install permanent piping, getting by with a long flex hose. During this time I "let the tools decide where they wanted to be". That was also a good move, because I have not needed to modify the piping at all since. I also ordered my DC piping from Oneida. I saved money on blast gate adapters and welded up my own from their straight pipe. This savings alone made up the cost difference of both of Oneida's competitors at the time.
Great system, very little fine dust left around in the shop these days, which means there is very little in my lungs as well. I do intend to upgrade the filter soon, as the available technology at the time was not as good as today's offerings.
Another aspect is that the larger machines make less noise, and what they do make tends to be of a lower pitch. My cyclone alone can easily be talked over, it is only when we add a planer or other spinning cutter to the airflow that it gets objectionable. Indeed, my 15" planer sounds rather air-raid sirenish when coupled to the ample air flow of the cyclone.
Cry once when you buy it. Spend the $ now and thank me in the future. Can't afford it? wait until you can.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa