Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

cupping while resawing

Posts

Re: cupping while resawing

#26

Re: More info

Sgian Dubh

"Here is a link to an article on timber drying faults by Richard Jones."

Thanks for the name check Bob. That wee graphic was put together after some intensive and wide ranging research for a manuscript on timber technology (still seeking a publisher) and consultation with a few experts in the field, including peer reviewing on the section on drying wood from a highly respected US based timber technologist. Slainte.

Re: cupping while resawing

#27

question and comment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In your description you speak of drying defects happening at moisture contents well about the typically quoted fiber saturation value of about 30%. You can not get drying stress until the wood shrinks. It is my understanding that the wood does not begin shrinking until it is about 30% MC.

In a rapid drying situation the average MC could be 45% and the surface well below 30% and shrinking. Is this the situation you are describing?

And, it should be noted that only a tiny mill could afford to stack lumber on end to prevent staining. More typically the lumber is simply dipped in fungicide in this country. I know of one mill not set up for dipping and they immediately put maple on "shipping stickers", 1/4" sticks, that keep the layers separated during transit to a kiln where the lumber will be put on larger sticks and likely dipped.

Re: cupping while resawing

#28

Re: question and comment

Sgian Dubh

"In a rapid drying situation the average MC could be 45% and the surface well below 30% and shrinking. Is this the situation you are describing?"

Yes.

"it should be noted that only a tiny mill could afford to stack lumber on end to prevent staining."

The photograph I showed of end piled sycamore Acer pseudoplatanus came from a large kiln drying operation in Scotland. "Large" may be a deceptively small drying operation compared to those run in North America where the scale of a typically "large" business is so much greater. Slainte.

Re: cupping while resawing

#29

Re: SUCCESS! ??? Have you planed it down yet?

Keith Newton

You might still be in for a surprise if not.

You didn't bother trying just dry heat on the other side, I don't suppose?

I don't recall if you ever mentioned what the final use for this wood would be.

Re: cupping while resawing

#30

Re: SUCCESS! ??? Have you planed it down yet?

les winter

No I have not planed it down yet. The final use was to be sides for a saw till.

I did not try dry heat.

Re: cupping while resawing

#31

Re: SUCCESS! ??? Have you planed it down yet?

les winter

It's planed and pretty much holding flat.

Re: cupping while resawing

#32

I have

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you go back to my post of an example, that top was most certainly planed after steam flattening. If the wood gets hot and wet enough to plasticize it the drying stress will be relaxed. The board will no more spring back to its cupped position than a steam bent chair leg will spring back. The only question is whether in a home situation enough steam and heat can be applied to get to the plasticized state. It will take a while, apparently about 10 min in this case. I think I steam treated the 3/4" material for more like 20 min.

Re: cupping while resawing

#33

Trying Heat

les winter

Just for completeness, I took my last cupped piece outside and laid it concave face down on the damp lawn in strong sunlight.

An hour later, the cup side became slightly convex and the previously convex side became slightly cupped, as expected. Out of the sun, in my shop, the board returned to the original cupped condition over a 1/2 hour period.

My board is not suffering from a moisture differential.