I'm resawing 5/4" cherry. The lumber is kiln dried and from a reliable supplier. As I'm resawing an 8" wide board it cups on both sides of the kerf. At the end the board pops apart. I'm using a straight resaw fence and a 1/2" 3 TPI hook blade.
Examining the boards after the cut, the outsides are convex and the insides concave. The concavity is around 3/16". I'm trying to get around 1/2" thick boards when complete.
I think it's the stock I'm using. Very flat sawn. Would I do better with rift? Any other workarounds?
Les, It sounds like your KD lumber may have picked up a little moisture on the outside. You might try putting it in a warm dry space for a while to reduce the moisture on the outside.
You don't indicate how much lumber you are needing to saw, and your profile is empty of any information like location, but if it is only a few boards, and your are located where it is starting to warm up, you might just leave them in a car left out in the Sun for a few hours. As for the board which is already ripped, I would put it back together the way it was, with a spring clamp holding the halves tightly together. This can be your control sample. I would check it about every hour, to see when they straighten out.
If you are somewhere like here, where we are expecting two more days of rain, you can build a tent with a tarp, and space heater to dry a whole stack. Look in the articles section, for one I authored in Feb for finish drying and de-bugging.
If you are just dealing with one or two board, you might be able to heat the convex sides up with a heat gun, or even hair blow dryer.
In desperation to recover a needed piece of resawed rare lumber I did the following and it worked.
The problem is that the interior of the board in under tension. This tension is pulling at the interior. Put a damp rag on the concave side(inside) and iron it with flat iron set on Hot and steam if you have it. The steam will plasticize the cellulose-lignin structure and allow it to relax. If it chooses to flatten, clamp it flat and allow to dry.
If the cupping is essentially instantaneous it is a result of stress relaxing from cutting through a stressed board. Shrinkage/expansion do to moisture regain or loss takes at least hours if not days.
If he flattens the concave side with moisture, then planes his saw marks away, what do you expect will happen? My expectation is that the cup will be right back in there.
As for the time to dry, will be relative to the amount and depth of higher MC on the faces of the board before it was cut, then temperature and dryness of the hot air.
A few years ago, I took a pair of finished table leaves to deliver to a client who wasn't home. I left a note, then went to eat, and back home for the evening. I didn't think to bring the leaves in, and found them in the car cooking in the middle of the afternoon. When I brought them in and unwrapped them, I was just sick, because they had been all the way through the finishing process.
After mulling over the situation, it dawned on me to reverse the sides which were out, toward the inside, then put them back into the hot car. It took less than an hour to return to flat. I can't say that this will happen always.
But it sounds to me like his lumber was dryer in the middle than the outsides, which is the opposite of your first statement about de-stressing. If it hasn't picked up more moisture after leaving the kiln, then they over did it with the steam at the end.
As lumber dries it can develop a moisture gradient across the thickness. A gradient can happen while air or kiln drying, but it is more likely in kiln drying where the rates can be higher.
Let us begin with the lumber dry on the outside but wetter in the middle because of this moisture gradient. At this point the outside dimension of the lumber has become fixed. (Once dry the wood becomes rigid. Wood requires moisture to be able to move.) As the middle continues to dry it tries to shrink, but it can't because the dry outside of the lumber is set in size. The shrinking of the inside builds tension in the inside of the board as the shrinking inside pulls against the fixed outside dimension.
In oak this tension can become so great that the interior fractures along the rays, resulting in what we call honeycomb. Fracturing is rare in other species so the tension remains hidden until the lumber is cut in a way that allows this tension to be relieved. When resawing the lumber will immediately cup. When ripping the kerf may pinch together.
It is common to have this tension in lumber at the end of a kiln drying cycle. Large kilns will have the means of injecting steam into the kiln at the end of drying. This steam plasticizes the wood allowing the outside to relax(change size) to relieve the internal stress, resulting in stress-free lumber.
However, if your lumber took hours or days to cup then it could be a moisture regain or loss problem.
Someone questioned that what I said worked could work. When I made this piece I only had access to a small amount of old growth Honduras mahogany. I had to resaw a piece of 8/4 for the top(note book match). Now mahogany is the least likely lumber there is to have drying tension, but this piece did and it sprung after resawing. I had to rescue this lumber for the top by any means. I steamed the interior for many minutes to get it hot and steamy. The goal was to get at least half the thickness plasticized and hence relaxed. I don't recall how long I dried it clamped flat, probably several days.
Unknown at the time, mahogany bleeds some red stuff when it is steamed. Wife's steam iron became coated with the red stuff. The ultimate success of this cupboard somewhat compensated for the flat iron damage.
Did the board relax to flat during steaming and you clamped it to hold it in that condition, or did you just clamp it flat?..........some of each.
No guarantees it will ever work again as I practiced it. But it is guaranteed that if you can get the piece steamy hot it will plasticize and if clamped flat it will stay that way. The tension is on the inside so that is the place to focus stress relaxation. It's a lot or effort but in my case any effort was worth it.
Someone that fixes antiques said he has straightened warped panels by blowing steam on the concave side, then clamping flat to dry. He though that hot and damp were essential.
As Bill said, there was a moisture gradient in your board when you resawed it. The outside fibers were at a higher MC than the inside of the board. This is common when dried lumber has been stored in a humid environment after drying. It happens with all cuts -- flatsawn, rift and quartered -- and they all behave as you described when resawn.
I usually find the MC gradient, if any, in my lumber by comparing moisture meter readings at different depths in the board, though sometimes the differences in the readings aren't really telltale. Then, I need to actually resaw a test piece to see what's going to happen. You can chop a short piece off the end of your test board and turn it on end and resaw it to see quickly if the board has this tension built up in it. If so, I prefer to dry the board in my shop rafters or attic (or other warm place) for a couple days to bring the MC of the outside fibers down to equilibrium with the drier inside fibers, thus relaxing the tension.
If you've already sawn the wood and now have two cupped bookmatched pieces, you can reverse the cupping by either steaming the inside fibers or drying the outside ones. The boards will flatten, the only difference being that if you dry the outside, you'll be bringing the MC of the outside fibers back down to something like the MC of the inside fibers, and conversely, if you add moisture to the inside wood, the net MC will be higher.
Anyhow, that's been my understanding and experience.
My theory is residual stress from drying. The board cupped instantly and popped at the end of the cut, the classic sign that the interior of the board was under tension from drying stress..
What exactly is "drying stress" and does it matter how the moisture gradient in the board has come about, whether through a kiln-drying process or by being subjected to a different environment? The effect on resawing is the same. I'm curious as to qualitative differences.
I used Bill's method: wet towel, iron set at max, lots of steam, 10 minutes of ironing, clamp to a flat surface. Let sit in the clamps for 14 hours. The board is now flat. I put it back in the clamps and will leave it for another 24 hours.
A few details:
The dimensions are 5/8" x 8" x 30". The board was cupped across it's width and bowed along its length. Flat sawn cherry. Kiln dried. I used a really thin towel to get the iron close to the surface.
I also applied a couple of passes w/o the towel for good luck.
Before I tried steaming, I soaked the concave side of one cupped board and let it sit. No change.
I clamped one board and let it sit. No change. So I've concluded that for this board the steaming worked.
what Bill is describing is case hardening, (not the same as case hardening in metal). This happens when the outer surface dries too quickly in initial drying. The moisture still inside stresses the walls of the cells. Eventually that moisture finds its way out, but the internal structure of the wood doesn't like being squeezed and when you cut into it, it springs back. If you resaw a piece and it cups immediately, or if rip cut closes during the cut, you have case-hardened wood. A piece of case hardened wood can have an even moisture content, and be at equilibrium moisture content with its environment. It's screwed up no matter how wet or dry it is, and you can't do anything about it until you cut into it and relieve the stress.
Ellis is describing wood with differing moisture content on the inside and outside of a board. This is also likely to move when you cut into it, but not as dramatically and this condition isn't permanent. This is why people advise leaving wood to sit for a while when you move it from one environment to the other; it takes time for moisture to get to the middle of a board through openings in the cellular structure or vice versa.
If you want to measure moisture content, a slice off the end won't tell you what is going on in the middle of the board. Most of the moisture migration goes through the end grain and as an individual board adjusts there can be considerable variation from the middle to the ends.
I generally don't go back to suppliers who deliver case hardened lumber. I've seen bad things happen during rip cuts due to that condition and fixing it usually leaves parts too small.
I've always had trouble fully comprehending the lingo associated with case hardening, drying stresses, moisture gradients and springback. From your explanation, I think we can assume that the stresses that occur when the initial drying is too quick are in the nature of compressing the moister (more moist?) fibers in the center of the board. If so, why doesn't the board cup outward instead of inward when resawn?
Also, what does it mean when a board spreads apart (instead of the kerf closing) when you rip it? Is there a reverse stress gradient going on there?
I know this topic is mystifying to a lot of people, so I welcome digging deeper into it. Thanks for holding forth.
Well, that will come tomorrow. This AM friend and I cut a 110' tall multi-stemed(4) 30" hickory and we have been working on limbing, piling brush, bucking, and loading all day and managed to get only about 1/3 of it on two large trailers. And it was not for lack of saws that we made so little progress, having on hand a small , medium and large Stihl professional saws. It was just one huge tree. Anyway I'm too pooped to write.
1. Go back and read my explanation.
2. The interior of the wood is under tension once dry. What is confusing is that initially during drying this interior is under compression. but once the outside of the board becomes dry and fixed in a larger volume that it would if dried slower the interior shrinks and now is in tension.
3. I regard "case hardening" as an extreme case of drying stress. But I suppose one could call any tension in the interior case hardening.
We sold lumber for years and storage was in outside shed. Checking by the most reliable method (oven drying, moisture meters are notoriously inaccurate at low moisture content)stored lumber got up to 10% in damp winter conditions and a low of 7% when it came out of the kiln. It would be unusual for shop conditions to cause lumber to get below 7%. Hence, the overall range for lumber being bought and worked is around 3%. This piddly moisture range is not enough to induce much stress during an acclimation in the shop.
However, restricting drying or regain to one surface will cause a reversible cupping that I don't define as drying stress. I call this phenomena differential expansion or contraction due to moisture regain or loss. No stress is involved.
Our cabinet shop customers typically took delivery and began working the lumber within hours, if not right away.
Air dried lumber is another situation, where any range is possible.
I think we can assume that the stresses that occur when the initial drying is too quick are in the nature of compressing the moister (more moist?) fibers in the center of the board.........Part way through drying this is the case, not at the end of drying. If so, why doesn't the board cup outward instead of inward when resawn?......because when fully dry the interior is under tension.
Also, what does it mean when a board spreads apart (instead of the kerf closing) when you rip it?....... This phenomena is more likely a result of stress induced by some growth condition of the tree. I have seen logs bust half way down the length when the saw starts in the end. Once can only imagine the stress that remains when this lumber reaches the shop.