Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

Posts

OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#1

OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

Barry Irby

They advertise all kinds of drugs on TV. Some of the ads give hypochondriacs Terrible diseases and they have to ask their doctor for the cure. Others offer to sell you stuff like vitamins, testosterone, nitric oxide, Estrogen boosters, and what not.

Then there ads for laser hair removal, The NoNo thing, and other such things.

Most of this stuff strikes me as dangerous at best. I can't imagine using these things for any length of time and not suffering side effects. Of course, there are lawyers advertising to help you sue for that.

Is there any place to get facts? (Yes, I would like to be younger, taller AND better looking, but not if I am going to grow a third arm.)

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#2

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

Basil

Tell me about that drug that grows a third arm. I'm always in need of another hand.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#3

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

TomD

beauty products are generally widely reviewed, after hearing so much about nono I looked it up, people are not generally happy with it, and claim it leaves brittle sharp remnants.

Generally stuff like vitamins can't be advertised as effective, or they would be drugs, so normally the doses and products are not effective by design. Though in many cases the products are highly effective if used in theraputic quantities. That can be an iffy experiment since there is little money in popularising an un-patentable like Vitamin C. I have used a number of vitamins that were life changing, and have been of repeat benefit for different problems.

Drugs have been heavily regulated, a regulatory regime that like many others seems to be at least partially broken in several ways. The main architecture is still there, but there have been some tragic options put on the market in recent years. Doctors are highly skilled but experts in diagnosis, not cures. When they tell you what is wrong, they are certainly worth listening to. When they tell you what to do about it, they are often wrong. I am not in the habit of disregarding their advice, but over time much of it has been contradicted by new theories.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

Jack Guzman from Maine

In answer to your question,there are many places to get facts. but one of them is never TV. It is a medium for entertainment,driven and financed by advertising.Nowhere in the equation is fact. In order to sell products businesses go to great lengths in bending the truth. One of the biggest businesses in the US is the pharmaceutical industry and their concern is to sell drugs. They just say what they can to get people to buy. Much room for misleading information there. ---Jack

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#5

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

Larry in NW Ohio

Barry If you see something that you might like, you can go to Bed,Bath and Beyond, they have a lot of the things that are the "As seen on TV" products." You could at least see the product and handle it, and give it the once over. Good Luck Larry

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#6

Time Was . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

people went to their doctor with a list of symptoms. Now they walk in with a list of medications.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#7

Re: Time Was . .

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

My wife is an RN in a major clinic. She will attest to what Mark said. They come in and want a medication they saw advertized.

I sold a piece of furniture to a guy who is a researcher here at the UI. They research things like drug ads. He told me that the ads cost a fortune to make and run. But the return on investment is enormous.

Rule of thumb, if you have a medical problem, go to your doctor and let the doctor prescribe what is best. People hear the side affects cited at the end of commercials but don't take them seriously. They should. That's why following your doctor's advice is clearly a better way to go.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#8

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

John Luke

Getting medical advice from a TV ad is like getting financial advice from a Nigerian Prince email.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#10

Historically......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....people relied on their Dr. for such advice. It still seems like a good idea.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#11

Depends on what you mean by history

Dick Coers

Further back, a guy with a Conestoga wagon and a team of mules, drove around selling elixirs. Lots of alcohol, or cocaine, or other such remedies. Then electricity came in and you could buy all sorts of devices to calm the nerves. Maybe not much different than today for some of these things.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#12

Well, a lot different

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the mean time medicine was put on a scientific basis and we now have experts (AKA physicians) schooled in this science available to advise people what works, for what, based on scientific studies.

Some will persist in not believing in this science, supporting their beliefs by anecdotal evidence and hope, and they will fall prey to the advertising Barry describes and keep these markets thriving. For these people there are also devices and additives that will boost your gas mileage 30%, reduce you home heating another 30%, purify your water of harmful stuff, effortlessly reduce your body weight, etc. It all makes it so easy to provide an answer to a student in the sciences who asks, "why do we need to learn this stuff"?

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#13

Re: Depends on what you mean by history

Dave Bair

What's really troubling is that there are a group of quacks who have revived the electricity/magnetism/elixir/folk-medicine myths. They pander to those folks who don't trust medical science, drug companies, or the FDA. They detect a grand conspiracy between the three to create diseases, like cancer, so that they can sell more drugs, get grants or further their government careers. They rely on antidotal evidence (unpasteurized full-fat milk cured my son's autism) or get their medical advise from expatriot Russian "doctors" who have no medical licenses "because the medical establishment wants to keep them quiet".

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#14

Mistrust can be earned

Dick Coers

Mistrust of modern medicine may be earned. I visited multiple doctors and was finally put on antidepressants, by a traditional family doctor, as the cure for my fatigue. I finally found a young doctor that was also a cancer survivor. She started specializing in integrative care, preventing illness instead of treating it. With some simple testing, she brought me back to a pretty good state with diet modification (gluten free) and a natural desiccated porcine thyroid medicine. If I waited for traditional medicine to heal me, probably would have been dead. Not exactly opposite of traditional medicine, but traditional treatment did nothing for my condition.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#15

the medical/pharma complex

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

I distrust most doctors and most drugs not because they cannot work but because they represent only one approach - the one that makes money for drug companies.

Ask your doctor how many medical school hours were dedicated to nutrition and the concept of wellness by giving the body the tools to heal itself through natural nutritious foods versus drug education. Guess why drug companies write many of the texts used in medical school.

Genuine healthy wellness and drugs have very little to do with each other. The drug industry profits from our chronic sickness brought on primarily from poor eating habits.

"Let food be your medicine and medicine be your food" - Hippocrates

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#16

Antidotal evidence?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Did you mean "anecdotal evidence?"

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#18

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

Chuck Kettler

If you work for the pharmaceutical industry for any length of time the behaviors of senior management will give you an idea as to why you see such drivel on TV. The needs of the patient are foremost in the minds of the clinicians and discovery scientists. The almighty dollar is the focus for management and that is why you see the erectile dysfunction drugs costing >$25/tablet for those without insurance. The priorities of health care are following the rest of society in search of profit with the secondary concern medical outcomes.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#19

Re: Antidotal evidence?

Dave Bair

A spelling error; "anecdotal" was intended.

Re: OT TV Ads for drugs questions?

#20

Re: Well, a lot different

"

"In the mean time medicine was put on a scientific basis and we now have experts (AKA physicians) schooled in this science available to advise people what works, for what, based on scientific studies."

I basically agree with that, so long as we are not suggesting that Doctors have significant expertise in cures. They do not. The do continuing education to keep updated on the latest greatest, but have at best a general understanding of what the science you describe is. So your outcome will depend on whether that science is good. Amateurs can figure a lot of that out for themselves as well or better than a doctor. For instance, as I recall the story, when the heart association decided to recommend cholesterol drug therapy there was a long standing study (one of only a few) on heart disease in Framingham Penn, that did not support that finding, and many members of the board resigned over that recommendation. You don't have to be a genius to have concerns over that kind of event, or to trace possible connection on the voting when non-profits are pulling in hundreds of billions from big pharma. Science is many things, but it can't succeed in the absence of integrity. There a scientific basis to that fact.

"Some will persist in not believing in this science, supporting their beliefs by anecdotal evidence and hope, and they will fall prey to the advertising Barry describes and keep these markets thriving."

Hold on there, one of the categories referred to was big Pharma ads, the very science we should be able to rely on.

PBS Newshour interviewed reporters from the Economist who have written a book about the 4th way, which is what to do to change our system now that the West appears to be falling behind, and in the face of other "successful" models like China ( unproven contention). I don't think the models of democracy, science, and rule of law have failed, unless it turns out to be impossible to get people to actually support them by doing what is right every now an again. And that may be impossible.