Re: Well, a lot different
"
"In the mean time medicine was put on a scientific basis and we now have experts (AKA physicians) schooled in this science available to advise people what works, for what, based on scientific studies."
I basically agree with that, so long as we are not suggesting that Doctors have significant expertise in cures. They do not. The do continuing education to keep updated on the latest greatest, but have at best a general understanding of what the science you describe is. So your outcome will depend on whether that science is good. Amateurs can figure a lot of that out for themselves as well or better than a doctor. For instance, as I recall the story, when the heart association decided to recommend cholesterol drug therapy there was a long standing study (one of only a few) on heart disease in Framingham Penn, that did not support that finding, and many members of the board resigned over that recommendation. You don't have to be a genius to have concerns over that kind of event, or to trace possible connection on the voting when non-profits are pulling in hundreds of billions from big pharma. Science is many things, but it can't succeed in the absence of integrity. There a scientific basis to that fact.
"Some will persist in not believing in this science, supporting their beliefs by anecdotal evidence and hope, and they will fall prey to the advertising Barry describes and keep these markets thriving."
Hold on there, one of the categories referred to was big Pharma ads, the very science we should be able to rely on.
PBS Newshour interviewed reporters from the Economist who have written a book about the 4th way, which is what to do to change our system now that the West appears to be falling behind, and in the face of other "successful" models like China ( unproven contention). I don't think the models of democracy, science, and rule of law have failed, unless it turns out to be impossible to get people to actually support them by doing what is right every now an again. And that may be impossible.