I've been asked to build a trestle dining table for a couple. The husband works at the same company as I do, and the wife works out at the same gym. So, I says to myself, how hard can this be? I envisioned just sending off a bunch of designs to them, have them pick one and build it. Well, of course, things don't work that way. Sarah wants me to just design one and they'll take it, which, for me, is a nightmare of the first magnitude. So I Googled trestle table images and sent her the Googled search page. The ones she likes are all rustic.
HOW DO YOU BUILD RUSTIC? Seriously. I have no idea how to do rustic. Any hints?
Study the pictures of the tables she likes up close and at a distance and figure out what characteristics gives them a rustic appearance and appeal, then play with those characteristics in your head, refining as you go, until you have your plan. If your plan turns out to be very close to one of the pictures, well then the other designer had good taste.
I don't build stuff that I would not like owning myself. I have no interest in learning skills and techniques that I will not use for stuff I like in the future. If someone wanted me to build a rustic table I would steer them to someone that liked building rustic furniture and knew how to do it for I would have no interest learning.
Actually, I'm with Bill on this, in that it's something I don't really relish learning. I'm mostly doing it as a favor to them (they're very decent people), and there's no one else I know who does furniture at all in this community (small town MN). The table isn't hard at all, but it's the surface and finish that concern me.
It seems to me one of the characteristics of rustic furniture is no visible finish. This is in conflict with the functional need for a finish so the table doesn't look bad quickly. So, as you think about the finish, think flat. From what I understand, there are water-based finishes that come out matte.
I notice Hutchinson's library system doesn't use "rustic" as an identifier in the catalog, preferring "country furniture" instead (this is one of the grand things about the Interweb - I can look at your library's catalog). Clearly, the librarians involved aren't woodworkers, or they'd understand the difference. But some of the seven titles from that search term include "rustic" in the subtitle, so you've got some starting point there. MNLink, which ties all of Minnesota's libraries in, lists either 447 or 43 titles (can't quite tell) on the search term, "rustic furniture," but I don't know how fast those interlibrary loans happen.
A lot of the rustic stuff that winds up in books seems to have been built by city folk trying to imagine what it would be like building furniture while living out in the far edges of nowhere, using limited tools and materials, and an attitude of just getting it done because the fields need planted. So wood is selected for bark edges or wane, insect holes, splits, etc., and things are not necessarily symmetrical.
But all this is done with a design in mind, so it's artful rather than awkward. The couple - particularly, I bet, the wife - would probably not appreciate your completing the design with a huge oil stain in the middle, as if a transmission had been rebuilt on the table.
I'll stop now, because I'm way over my head here, not having built anything I'd be willing to call furniture that would qualify as rustic. The woodshed built from shipping pallets, now, that qualifies; but that's some years in the past.
Ok, so it looks like knotty wood with a medium color finish will fit the bill? While knotty alder is an ever popular choice, I don't much like it myself, finding it too soft, weak, and unstable for furniture of any quality. Better off with #2 pine for that - it's usually cheaper.
Is there a local yard around where you could find some #2 common oak? Does oak grow up there (I'm woefully ignorant )?
I would try to find some oak with knots and add as little rustification as possible. Oak also takes a stain better than alder or pine. If rustification is desired, you can attack it with a powered wire brush with quite good effect. Though labor intensive - not the wire brushing, the sanding that follows must all be done by hand - it is the closest I've gotten to actually liking a rustic finish.
Some caramel color stain and a flat finish and you're done.
Another thought - don't send her pictures. Do you have some nice pieces of furniture around the house that are of the kind you like to build? Often seeing a well made and well finished piece in person will sway a person towards that style and execution. When confronted with pictures on the net they opt for the currently popular stuff they see everywhere - it's safe.
I forgot to mention: this is going to be made of cherry. They have a stack of locally harvested cherry in their barn, much of which was milled at 1" or 7/8", not the 1-1/8" that I normally get. Since that stack was cut with a Wood Mizer, it has the bandsaw marks on it and will need to be planed down. So, then will I need to distress that surface after it gets planed?
That's probably a good idea, Bill, send them packing to the library and tell them to pick from a short list of books. Pick one, bring me the picture, and I'll make it. Plus a matching bench. All with a matte finish suitable for generations of kids and abuse.
I do recall one trestle table I saw at a Crate and Barrel that had an applied live edge. They did a nice job, but it seemed a bit contrived to me.
Bruce, you don't have to cave and totally surrender your fine woodworking dignity. I, myself, would draw the line at purposefully distressing the surface. I feel that's a cheap trick by some quick-profiteers to make it look like the cheap, defective wood they used was for design reasons. You'll notice that almost none of Stuart's rustic examples were "distressed". In fact, some look quite well polished.
I believe I would skip-plane the cherry and if you come to a point where the saw marks are interesting yet not looking too raw, you may decide to stop there. If not, the rustic is in the design of the table not the roughed up appearance of the surface.
Your friend told you to choose your own design. I believe they'll be happy with whatever you come up with.
Root River Hardwoods with stores in Preston and Albert Lea list "rustic" grades of several species, including red oak and alder. They have quite a selection and the pricing is not outrageous. Customer service is excellent from Andy Bahl, partner and manager at Preston.
Maybe their snapshots of "rustic" will give you more ideas for the species.
Disclaimer....I am only a customer, not connected in any way.
Most of what I see fitting that description, are just so clunky, although it doesn't have to be that way.
Have you talked budget with them yet? Even if they provide the lumber, especially since it is not milled to a suitable dimension, you need to make sure they know that you can't compete with the junktique market, nor with the import market prices.
If I were you, I would surely talk them out of the benches. Those are so uncomfortable, that a steak dinner would be reduced down to the enjoyment level of hot dogs, or not much better than sitting around a fire on a rock. It is ok now and then, but not every day.
I looked through the images in that trestle table link and spotted this one. It seems there are degrees of refinement in various perceptions of "rustic." For example, a lot of the trestle tables on that rustic furniture link were more like "funky." Thick, clunky-looking, crude, primitive might be better adjectives. Like something Davy Crockett might have cobbled together for his one-room cabin, armed only with a hatchet. At the other end would be the Nakashima-inspired tables that have actual or simulated wane edges and simple, refined architectural underpinnings. The only good way to know what to recommend to a client is to go to their house and check out the rest of the furnishings. What level of refinement, what colors, proprtions, textures, details, etc. would mesh with (not necessarily match) their interior? As the designer, you can figure this stuff out and make an informed recommendation. Without knowing, you have to rely on input from the customer, who probably can't sketch what they want and doesn't have the design lexicon they need to communicate all the design aspects needed to arrive at a good solution. I suggest you pay them a visit and take your sketch pad and maybe some wood species samples +/- finish samples.
That was very succinct. I would just add, that after you find what they expect the finished product to feel like, if you have an inspiration, you should gently pull them your way. Then feed them a dialog that they can share with their friends. That is to say, that perception is more important than you might think.