Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

OT: Roofing Advice

Posts

OT: Roofing Advice

#1

Bart Goldberg

OT: Roofing Advice

Bart Goldberg

Im getting quotes to replace my 20 year old roof, and several of the roofers are suggesting Tamko Heritage (not the Premium) shingles. Anyone have experience with this brand?

Thanks

Bart

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#2

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

Barry Irby

I have used the Tamko Heritage shingles several times on various houses. These are thirty year shingles and most probably you will get the full thirty years out of them. If you are in a very severe climate, you may not. (desert sun, arctic cold)

Some of the companies are selling their "30" year shingles as Lifetime shingles. I wonder whose lifetime?

Also, ask if you get an actual written warranty. You won't get it unless your roofer is factory trained and certified by the manufacturer.

OTOH, Maybe you should check with your wife and see if she still has the warranty papers on you?

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#3

Roofing Warranty

Dave Bair

Most are next to worthless since they only cover the cost of materials, the smallest cost of a roof job.

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#4

Bart Goldberg

Re: Roofing Warranty

Bart Goldberg

Actually, the TAMKO warranty is quite good - It covers all Materials and Labor, non-prorated for the first 15 years.

Bart

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#5

Bart Goldberg

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

Bart Goldberg

Thanks for the info -and yes SWMBO still has the warranty for me :)

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#6

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

Larry in NW Ohio

If a person is reroofing I would highly suggest to get an estimate on steel shingles. I had ours done about 3 years ago and people are still asking us if they are steel. You can not tell, even up close, if they are steel or asphalt or whatever. They are more expensive, but they are warrented for LIFE, and if you sell the hose the buyer gets a 50 year warrenty, in writing. I even see the standing seam steel roofing being put on more and more. If a young person would put on a steel roof right off when they build a house would put it on, they would be farther ahead. I`m more than happy with them, of course it hasn`t been very long. I would at least get an estimate. Larry

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#7

Re: Roofing Warranty

Bill Howatt

From what I've heard is the shingle company will blame inadequate ventilation and anything else they can think of as to the cause of the premature failure. Good chance they are right.

Bill

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#8

Re: Roofing Warranty

TomD

That's right. If you look at the bag it will give the specifications of what has to be done to earn the warranty. Never seen a roof done that way, and I have seen a lot of roofs. Of course that could be the advantage of a factory certified, upsell, on a roofing job if they actually did the job properly. But then 30-years to life is a long time for anyone to stay in that business.

I haven't been all that satisfied with the asphalt on my roof. My experience is that it always fails somewhere, pretty fast. But lucky to say that it also seems fairly good on other parts of the roof, even when they get very old. My most recent experience was putting on a new roof on the rear of my shop. I used some architectural shingles that seem quite sturdy, and look really well. They are a newish product in that they now sell these at minimal additional cost, and with the same coverage, while getting more of the beef in the exposure. Time will tell.

I would certainly welcome an opportunity to try something better, like steel. Asphalt is not ideal for my situation, but for now the upgrade products all require pro install - they probably get more recent graduates from the crowbar or something. I'm sure I couldn't handle it...

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#9

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

mdclor

+1 to steel roofing. Check with your insurance company; they might give you a discount on your homeowners premium.

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#10

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

Bill Howatt

A possible problem with steel roofing, if you are in a snow area, is the orientation of your roof relative to entrances and doors. Neighbor installed steel which was expensive but looks very nice. He finds it a PITA when the snow lets go and lands in a heap on his driveway and porch. Of course, the snow sliding off is an advantage if you worry about snow loading.

Bill

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#11

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

Joe Mohnike

You might want to check with your homeowners insurance carrier. Some (most) companies will require the roof be replaced in 20-25 years, regardless of the warranty.

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

#12

Re: OT: Roofing Advice

Larry in NW Ohio

In reply to Bill`s question about snow sliding off. With shingles that LOOK like real shingles, with the gravel and all, I don`t think it would slide any more that asphalt ones, and the smooth ones, I think they have things to put on the roof to stop it. Larry