Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

TS dust collection

Posts

TS dust collection

#1

TS dust collection

eliot feldman

I have a real nice 5 HP Powermatic TS. But , you know, for years now I've never gotten a moments satisfaction from the point of view of dust collection. And all the dust seems to settle in the bin with very little going to the DC. I use a fairly big 2 HP dust collector for it. I even installed one of those plastic box-like covers that close in the motor to ( supposedly) improve the dust collection. But the simple fact is that there is only the slightest suction that I can feel at the saw blade. I looked at a Sawstop TS the other day in a local woodworking store and noticed that there is a more elaborate set up under the saw for dust collection. That one has a short run of hose -- inside the saw-- going from the port up towards the blade. I suppose I could fix up something like that for my saw, but shouldn't a 2 HP dust collector do better with what I have now?

Re: TS dust collection

#2

Re: TS dust collection

Larry in NW Ohio

Elliot I would read up on DC at Bill Penz web site, he1s the granddaddy of DC. I`d like to give you his web site but it`s still in my last computer drive and I can`t get at it without a new or use power unit. Maybe someone will chime in with it. If I find it before they do I`ll give it to you. But one thing I will tell you, that one 2HP DC can be a great dust pickup machine and another 2HP machine just like it from another company wouldn`t beat out a house sweeper. Good luck. Larry

Re: TS dust collection

#3

not something I fret over

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The larger particles from the saw blade are slung toward the bottom of the saw with large momentum. I takes a hurricane to reverse their direction of travel. The fine dust is sucked away by my Oneida collection system and the larger particles pack into the bottom of my Delta cabinet saw, where they don't bother me at all. Eventually they reach equilibrium. Occasionally I stir them up and into the dust collection pipe.

Re: TS dust collection

#4

Re: TS dust collection

Rick in Colgate, Wi

I also use a 2hp dust collector on my Craftsman professional table saw and it really does a poor job of collecting saw dust. I'm thinking with the use of zero clearance inserts just not enough air is being pulled thru the saw for the dust collector to work efficiently, maybe I'll try leaving the clean-out door open a bit to see if that helps.

Re: TS dust collection

#5

Re: TS dust collection

Jerry Roberts

I had or have the same problem with my Unisaw. What I did is stop up all the openings around the saw with plastic bags. The dust area inside the saw is not by any means airtight so for the most part the only suction now is where the exaust hose is but is not 100%

Re: TS dust collection

#6

Re: TS dust collection *LINK*

mdclor

Eliot, I have a PM 66 with a 3 HP motor and use a 2 HP cyclone. A huge amount of the DC capabilities are dependent on your tubing getting from the saw to the DC. This is where Bill Pentz may be of some use to you, but his site is information overload.

I always have a significant amount of dust in the bottom of the saw, but that doesn't concern me because I am not inhaling that dust and that is the goal. As was mentioned, the lighter particles are collected. FWIW


Bill Pentz

Re: TS dust collection

#7

Re: TS dust collection

Barry Irby

Eliot, a few years ago I did a LOT of work setting up the DC in my shop and started with my TS. Its a Delta contractors saw so it has almost no cabinet or enclosure. I put a box sort of the shape of a cereal box up around the blade and brought the hose out the front so that the blst gate is right at the front near the switch for the saw. The blast gate has a micro switch that turns the DC on.

All that aside, some of what I learned is that a lot depends on air flow. Huge airflow in volume and not so much pressure. I suspect that your set up lacks air flow, if the cabinet is carefully sealed. OTOH, I agree with Bill. The stuff left inside the cabinet doesn't really matter. Its too big and heavy for you to inhale. The important stuff to collect is the tiny particles that stay suspended in the

air and thus could enter your lungs. Think of the particles coming off a saw blade. You could calculate the velocity of the tips of the blade and figure The mass and energy of the large particles and then try to figure out how much air and how fast it would have to be moving to capture it. Very difficult to do.

My enclosure works very well because the blade basically flings the particles directly into the box. There is a distinct difference in the amount of debris coming off the top of the blade with the suction on and off.

The other thing to consider is that the fine particles are the dangerous ones and you should install an air cleaner. They are a little controversial in that the air motion necessary to carry the particles to the filter may keep them flying longer, giving you more opportunity to inhale them. Without the air movement the dust might settle out faster. Once it sticks to whatever surface, its unsightly but not dangerous. The very best protection is your personal protective gear. We should all be wearing masks or some sort of filters.

Re: TS dust collection

#8

Re: TS dust collection

William Duffield

I have an Industrial SawStop. It's dust collection was nothing to write home about. When they came out with the Professional model SawStop, I upgraded the dust collection on my saw to what is considered the best system in the marketplace. I also hook the new improved blade guard up to a 135 CFM Festool CT26 with hepafilter. That catches almost all the fine dust that comes off the top of the blade, but the saw cabinet still fills up with dust, and I have to periodically clean it out with a shopvac. (The Festool bags are too expensive to use for coarse dust that my dust collector doesn't catch.) Also, I often use just the riving knife instead of the full blade guard, and therefore still get lots of fine dust in my face. My dust collector is built by JDS, and unlike a lot of other systems, it doesn't grossly exaggerate its capacity. I'm still not completely happy with the amount of dust the SawStop leaves in the bottom of the cabinet, but I suppose I don't need to clean it out as often as I would with another brand of cabinet saw.

Re: TS dust collection

#9

Re: TS dust collection

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Dust collection on a tablesaw is all about air flow!

First, for air to flow out of the cabinet into the DC hose/duct fast enough so the dust can't settle on the cabinet floor, the same amount of air (CFM) must be allowed to enter that is trying to be removed. For that to happen the total area of all openings and gaps must equal or exceed the cross-sectional area of the cabinet dust port so sufficient make-up air can enter, and also so static pressure resistance is low. Otherwise you are throttling the air flow.

The space around the blade insert, any insert, is not nearly enough to allow much if any air into the cabinet! In fact, most of the time the blade gap and any holes drilled in the insert will be totally useless- they will be blocked by the board when you feed it into the blade!!!

Dust can also be trapped in the gullets of the blade and then thrown off in all directions in the plane of the blade, including directly at the operator. Depending on the pulley sizes and motor RPM, the dust can be hurled off a 10" blade, at over 120 mph (for a Unisaw)- that is 10,560 fpm!!! and much greater than typical DC velocities which often average 4000 fpm. To stop the dust and capture it above the table you need an over-blade shroud. But not just any shroud. The shroud must conform to the stock, reduce the kinetic energy of the fast moving dust, and contain it until it slows and the DC air flow can collect it. But here is the problem- a hard, close-fitting shroud like SS, shark guard, etc. etc. can severely limit take-up air! They also leave a large gap when cross-cutting thick boards like a 4 X 4. One partial solution is to use a bristle skirt. The bristles conform to irregular shapes, kill the kinetic energy of the dust, and do a decent job containing it, yet will allow make-up air to enter. You will see them on CNC routers, etc. The big disadvantage of all over-blade dust shrouds is that they can get in the way and cannot be used during a number of sawing operations- tenoning, making box joints, etc., etc.


Re: TS dust collection

#10

JL

Re: TS dust collection

JL

A weird solution - try waxing the inside of your dust bin in your table saw.

Get a reasonable quality auto wax with a good hard finish. I was somewhat skeptical at this solution at first - until I tried it.

This isn't a solution that works by itself - but it does help.

Re: TS dust collection

#11

Re: Question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Elliot, is the saw generating dust in the shop or are you just concerned that the dust is accumulating in the bottom of the saw? I have a Delta Unisaw with a 5 HP Grizzly Cyclone, mine does collect dust in the bottom but as Bill said, that really doesn't concern me in the least. I have no issues as I never really see dust in the air when I am sawing, actually very little dust accumulates on the wood being sawed or on the table, so to me it is a non-issue. I don't change blades very often, but when I do I usually turn on the dust collector and "stir up" the dust until it enters the collector tube, then I shut it off. (Mostly I do this as it is a lot easier to retrieve the spindle nut when I drop it ~ happens too often).

Re: TS dust collection

#12

Re: TS dust collection

eliot feldman

All these answers are great, but WOW(!) yours seems one of the most inventive ( except , maybe, about auto- waxing the interior). Thanks for this response. did you make or buy the bristle shroud?

Re: TS dust collection

#13

Depends on what is most critical

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A production ripping operation would benefit from a top mounted bristly dust picker-upper. But for most of what I use a table saw for this arrangement would obscure seeing where the blade was going to cut and otherwise get in the way. Imagine ripping or cross cutting the cock beading strips with this arrangement in place. Impossible.

I don't find some dust crumbs on the saw table an annoyance worth trying to fix.