Re: Take The Other Fork
Barry Irby
Tom, we are talking about two or maybe three different things here. A drill rotates the bit, a hammer drill rotates the bit and also hammers it in a linear motion into the material, and an impact driver rotates the bit and provides impact in a rotary fashion. The hammer drill excels at drilling into masonry because the rotary motion helps clean the debris out of the hole and the impact tends to crush the stones and concrete in front of the bit. An impact driver is similar to Mark's example of pushing the nail with the hammer or hitting it. You can try really hard to push a nail without much success, but drive it quite easily by hitting it with the same hammer. The impact driver does not hammer the screw the way a hammer hits a nail, it rotates it with impact or a striking force or circular motion. As a result, an impact driver does not wallow out the hole as you are visualizing.
Impact drivers are quite remarkable in that a fairly small one will drive deck screws easily. I have a little Bosch 12 volt one and it will drive two to three inch screws into pine like butter. And, unlike a drill it does not seem to apply the "equal and opposite force" to your arm and shoulder. By the end of the day driving screws with a drill will tax your arm and rotator cuff, but not nearly some much with and impact driver.
OTOH, and impact driver is so quick and powerful that it is not the tool of choice for drywall screws. I do it, but you really have to pay attention. It will shoot one all the way through the drywall in a flash. Really need the screw gun for that. Screw gun is set up to allow you to press the drywall into place with the snout making the depression for the mud, drive the screw and then stop it automatically at the surface.
As far as Engineered fasteners go, there has been a lot of engineering apply to both nails and screws. When I was in college at Va. Tech there was a Wood Technology lab with a guy there with a doctorate who spent all day every day testing every kind of fastener you might apply to wood. I'm sure the Forest Products Laboratory has similar programs, so there are people that know what there is to know about nails and screws. What I recall is that screws are much better in "withdrawal" and nails a screws are fairly similar in sheer, depending on the shank diameter. What you are discussing with the Mike Holmes thing is that the building code is "prescriptive". There is a chart in the code that describes how many nails of what size and type you will use to make each connection. The chart does not describe screws. The same connections could be made with screws, but when the code was written screws were not commonly used. When air driven fasteners came along we had the same problem in that they were not mentioned in the code. Eventually, the manufacturers got them added. Holmes' problem was that prescriptive thing. If you want to do something not prescribed in the code, you have to provide the Engineering Data to prove it is equal or better. So you just get beaten down to the lowest common denominator.




