Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

advice on buying a drill

Posts

Re: advice on buying a drill

#26

Re: Take The Other Fork

Barry Irby

Tom, we are talking about two or maybe three different things here. A drill rotates the bit, a hammer drill rotates the bit and also hammers it in a linear motion into the material, and an impact driver rotates the bit and provides impact in a rotary fashion. The hammer drill excels at drilling into masonry because the rotary motion helps clean the debris out of the hole and the impact tends to crush the stones and concrete in front of the bit. An impact driver is similar to Mark's example of pushing the nail with the hammer or hitting it. You can try really hard to push a nail without much success, but drive it quite easily by hitting it with the same hammer. The impact driver does not hammer the screw the way a hammer hits a nail, it rotates it with impact or a striking force or circular motion. As a result, an impact driver does not wallow out the hole as you are visualizing.

Impact drivers are quite remarkable in that a fairly small one will drive deck screws easily. I have a little Bosch 12 volt one and it will drive two to three inch screws into pine like butter. And, unlike a drill it does not seem to apply the "equal and opposite force" to your arm and shoulder. By the end of the day driving screws with a drill will tax your arm and rotator cuff, but not nearly some much with and impact driver.

OTOH, and impact driver is so quick and powerful that it is not the tool of choice for drywall screws. I do it, but you really have to pay attention. It will shoot one all the way through the drywall in a flash. Really need the screw gun for that. Screw gun is set up to allow you to press the drywall into place with the snout making the depression for the mud, drive the screw and then stop it automatically at the surface.

As far as Engineered fasteners go, there has been a lot of engineering apply to both nails and screws. When I was in college at Va. Tech there was a Wood Technology lab with a guy there with a doctorate who spent all day every day testing every kind of fastener you might apply to wood. I'm sure the Forest Products Laboratory has similar programs, so there are people that know what there is to know about nails and screws. What I recall is that screws are much better in "withdrawal" and nails a screws are fairly similar in sheer, depending on the shank diameter. What you are discussing with the Mike Holmes thing is that the building code is "prescriptive". There is a chart in the code that describes how many nails of what size and type you will use to make each connection. The chart does not describe screws. The same connections could be made with screws, but when the code was written screws were not commonly used. When air driven fasteners came along we had the same problem in that they were not mentioned in the code. Eventually, the manufacturers got them added. Holmes' problem was that prescriptive thing. If you want to do something not prescribed in the code, you have to provide the Engineering Data to prove it is equal or better. So you just get beaten down to the lowest common denominator.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#27

Impact drivers and drywall...

John in NM

Good synopsis Barry.

My impact is my favorite drywall driver. Bit doesn't cam out as bad as with a regular driver, and the lower speeds are capable of very nice control of depth, each impact winding the screw in a hair more. Probably not fast enough for a pro, but then I'm too slow and tidy to be a pro at anything :D

I had very much a love/hate relationship with cordless tools until impact drivers came along. Now I would never be without one, love the thing. Drives 3 and 4 inch screws into construction lumber with no pilot hole and doesn't break the screw. Amazing tool.

I'm always a little puzzled by the cordless hammer drills, but then I've never tried one. They really don't seem up to the task compared to those old Milwalkees (not the beer :D ) or an SDS hammer. Its gotta be a sales gimmick to get people to buy the slightly more expensive set at Home Depot, knowing full well that most will never use the hammer feature.....

Kind of like 4 wheel drive come to think of it :D

Re: advice on buying a drill

#28

Re: advice on buying a drill *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

John.

I am gonna stray a little bit from the others.You didn't say what type of work you would be doing mainly. I have been using a Craftsman Nextec 12 volt set in a professional shop environment for about 2 years now. The set,which included a 3/8" drill and a 1/4" hex/impact driver was around $100.The 12 volt batteries last along time,the drill and impact are compact and light. We do have 18v in Makita,Dewalt and Ridgid at our facility and use them on bigger work,drilling with holesaws,drilling thick steel,etc. but my 12 v C'mans are on my bench and do 98% of my daily tasks. Sears (and Menard's under the Masterforce name) sell the kits ,extra batteries are around $24,less when on sale. That alone makes it easy to own a couple spare batteries for 1/2 the price of 1 larger battery.

If having a Makita or Milwaukee or Bosch appeal to you they make very good 12 volt lithium tools as well.

Any of the major brands are great and the lithium batteries are light years ahead of the older NiCad cordless tools.

I did upgrade the chuck on the 3/8" drill( it was a weak point,came loose alot) to a clearanced at Lowe's for $4 ,1/2" Jacobs keyless chuck. No slippage now but it did make the tool heavier.


http://www.menards.com/main/p-2257940-c-9066.htm

Re: advice on buying a drill

#29

Re: Impact drivers and drywall...

Barry Irby

I can't think of a good way to describe "rotary" impact. I think that's the part most people don't "get".

I was thinking about drywall and the impact driver. The part I like about a screw gun is that you can firmly press the drywall into position with the snout on the gun and drive the screw. It occurs to me I have a little driver attachment for my drill that does the same thing. I am going to have to try it with the impact driver. This could be good.

The impact driver is a game changer of a tool. And you are right, it will drive deck screws all the way through deck boards almost effortlessly, not that you would want to.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#30

Re: The road less travelled

r payne

I'm a bit confused. When you talk of hammering in and impact drivers. Impact drivers work different than hammer drills and screws aren't "hammered in" with an impact driver. The impact of an impact driver is a rotational force while the impact of a hammer drill is straight in.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#31

Re: Impact Drivers VS Hammer Drill

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Tom, from your post it seems you have used a "hammer" drill rather than an Impact driver! I agree the Hammer drill does not have any use in driving screws, as the "hammer" motion is only "in and out", but the "impact driver" works like an air impact wrench. This means you are "impacting" in a rotary motion. These DO drive /remove screws in material that you cannot drive / remove the same screw using torque only. My son has a storage shed based on a retired Semi Trailer. We installed vinyl siding on the trailer using self drilling metal screws. He first tried using a conventional Porter Cable drill. The result was stripped heads, broken screws etc. We tried my impact driver and installed all the siding without any issue. I have found many times in my life that an Impact wrench would remove bolts that would break using torque only. I find the same is true with the impact driver. When driving long screws in Oak or similar material the impact driver will do it without stripping the head out. In my opinion the hammer drill is useful only for drilling in masonry, rock or similar material.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#32

Ellis Walentine

Battery rebuild follow-up and pricing *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

I checked with our local battery specialty store about rebuilding power packs and he was kind enough to send a thoughtful response and a current price list for rebuilding various voltages and amp-hour ratings of batteries. Here is some of what he had to say:

Rebuilding is typically worth it for the better (commercial type) drills (DeWalt, Milwaukee, Ryobi, Skill, Porter Cable, etc.). It is typically not worth it for the lesser quality, homeowner type drills (Black and Decker, Craftsman etc.). We are usually $15-$20.00 less than normally-priced drill packs at Home Depot or Lowe's, unless they have a sale going on, such as what DeWalt does with their two-pack specials that they run.

We usually rebuild the standard batteries with an 1800 mAh (1.8 Ah) cell. For the higher capacity packs (DeWalt XR+ etc.), we use a 2200 mAh (2.2 Ah) cell.

Shipping will add about $5-$8.00 per pack depending on the shipping zone, so this may create a cost issue. Our lead time is usually about 7-10 days for turnaround.

From the standpoint of rebuilds, in general, it is certainly better to have them rebuilt than to just trash them. When the cells come back to us the old cells are properly recycled at an EPA-approved smelter and therefore do not enter the waste stream, so it is a good thing to do.

We do not rebuild Lithium Ion (Li-Ion) packs at this point. It is not something that we do not have the ability to do, as we tab up Li-Ion cells all the time; it is more of a factor of liability. Li-Ion cells are very volatile and need to be charge controlled. If we were to rebuild a Li-Ion pack, we'd need to use the exact cell that the manufacturer (DeWalt, Milwaukee etc.) used when they originally built the packs, otherwise it creates the possibility of having the wrong charge control parameters, which can create a risk of thermal runaway on the cells, resulting in explosion of the cell. It is just next to impossible for us to determine which cells each Manufacturer is using and then have them on hand for timely rebuilds. So, at this point, we do only Ni-Cd (Nickel Cadmium) and Ni-MH (Nickel Metal Hydride) cells.

As for aftermarket rebuilds, we have used some from time to time for people who need another pack and do not have an old housing or situations like that. These aftermarkets are all made in China and we have seen some issues with the quality of the aftermarket packs on the market. Everything we do here is done in house by our own assemblers.

DRILL PACK REBUILD PRICING

6.0 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 5 @ 2.99 EA = 14.95 + 5.00 LABOR = $21.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 5 @ 3.99 EA = 19.95 + 5.00 LABOR = $24.95

7.2 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 6 @ 2.99 EA = 17.94 + 6.01 LABOR = $23.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 6 @ 3.99 EA = 23.94 + 6.01 LABOR = $29.95

9.6 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 8 @ 2.99 EA = 23.92 + 6.03 LABOR = $29.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 8 @ 3.99 EA = 31.92 + 6.03 LABOR = $37.95

10.8 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 9 @ 2.99 EA = 26.91 + 8.04 LABOR = $34.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 9 @ 3.99 EA = 35.91 + 8.04 LABOR = $43.95

12.0 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 10 @ 2.99 EA = 29.90 + 10.05 LABOR = $39.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 10 @ 3.99 EA = 39.90 + 10.05 LABOR = $49.95

13.2 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 11 @ 2.99 EA = 32.89 + 12.06 LABOR = $44.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 11 @ 3.99 EA = 43.89 + 12.06 LABOR = $55.95

14.4 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 12 @ 2.99 EA = 35.88 + 12.07 LABOR = $47.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 12 @ 3.99 EA = 47.88 + 12.07 LABOR = $59.95

16.8 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 14 @ 2.99 EA = 41.86 + 13.09 LABOR = $54.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 14 @ 3.99 EA = 55.86 + 13.09 LABOR = $68.95

18.0 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 15 @ 2.99 EA = 44.85 + 15.10 LABOR = $59.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 15 @ 3.99 EA = 59.85 + 10.10 LABOR = $69.95

18.0 VOLT 3000 MAH NIMH

3000 mAh 22-0803 X 15 @ 4.99 EA = 74.85 + 15.10 LABOR = $89.95

19.2 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 x 16 @ 2.99 EA = 47.84 + 22.11 LABOR = $69.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 16 @ 3.99 EA = 63.84 + 16.11 LABOR = $79.95

24.0 VOLT

1800 mAh 11-0902 x 20 @ 2.99 EA = $59.80 + $30.15 LABOR = $89.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 x 20 @ 3.99 EA = $79.80 + $30.15 LABOR = $109.95

36.0 VOLT HILTI PACK

1800 mAh 11-0902 X 30 @ 2.99 EA = 89.70 + 40.25 LABOR = $129.95

2200 mAh 11-0906 X 30 @ 3.99 EA = 119.70 + 40.25 LABOR = $159.95




Warehouse Battery Outlet

Re: advice on buying a drill

#33

Re: Battery rebuild follow-up and pricing

Howard Norman

Thank you Ellis, that is the best writeup that I have seen on battery rebuilding.

Howard

Re: advice on buying a drill

#34

Re: Take The Other Fork

TomD

Barry,

thanks for taking the time. Having used the impact drivers I still hadn't got the point that it is a rotational impact. Thanks for all the info.

In the Holmes case it was more than just that they hadn't caught up with screws, it was that they did not allow them because they failed. It was quite a while back, though I think I have a DVD of that episode (like west coast style), but my recollection is that they had a problem with the screws. Of course the problem might have been that "all" nails are OK. California being Sinker heaven, it is hard to think of other nails that would perform less well, so they are probably pretty safe, since nails are low tech, and "all the same". Screws not at all. There are a slew of different types, so maybe part of their beef was just getting comfortable with the types. Might also be different today, as probably 10 years has gone by and the selection of screw type just keeps getting larger. Some of the boxes are explicitly marked "construction" and cost a fortune as it happens... For that mater, I drove a box of strongtie screws today, restructuring a set of completely rotted out steps. So I guess that stuff is approved for something.

You are right about shear. What Holmes didn't seem to get was that the structural apps are engineered so the fasteners load primarily in shear.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#35

Re: Take The Other Fork

Barry Irby

Fasteners in wood is a much bigger topic than it looks like. Take for example the problem with "nail Pops", that used to be common in drywall. They were using the old blue nails that has smooth shanks. They would back out, creating a "pop" in the finish. Had to do with the wood expanding and contracting repeatedly over the seasons and sort of squirting the nail back out. The roofers solved the problem by using nails long enough to drive all the way through the sheeting. It was found that if the tip of the nail were not in the wood, they did not have nearly the tendency to back out. Drywallers tried using longer nails. Made it worse by giving the wood a longer "stroke". The answer was shorter nails with ring shanks, and eventually screws.

I had not thought about nails being a "lowest common denominator" fastener, but I guess you are right. If everything is engineered around a small crummy nail, the only way to go is up. As for air driven nails, they don't permit the clipped head nails with the heads off to one side (to allow for easy collating) anymore, especially in hurricane country.

They tried using wide crown staples on roof shingles. Not enough resistance to blow off. Had to develop guns that would shoot regular roofing nails without punching them through the shingles.

Next time you screw down a deck or something similar that uses hundreds of nails, try an impact driver. You will be impressed. And, I am not a big guy, so I like the little 12 volt ones.

Another tool I have that I like in the right application is a Spinright, a strip fed screw gun that will drive 2" screws. Not an impactor, but it really is neat for screwing down plywood or decking. And they make it with an extension so you can stand up and screw down the floor. (My son learned that if you REALLY LEAN ON IT you can drive a screw into the deck with it running in reverse. Talk about a wallowed out hole.)