Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

advice on buying a drill

Posts

advice on buying a drill

#1

advice on buying a drill

John Lucas

I need a new battery powered drill. The two I was using have finally reached the age of being useless. I need one of the newer ones in about the $100 to $150 price range. Probably 18V. Is lithium the way to go on these. I haven't looked at rechargeable drills for years. I went to Lowes today to glance but didn't have time to do anything other than price shop. Which ones are you all happy with.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#2

Re: advice on buying a drill

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I have had three battery drills over the years, but the batteries went sour and would not recharge.

I read about the Rockwell 3rill drill, bought it for $136 a couple years ago and am fully satisfied with it. It came with two lithium batteries and recharge in 30 minutes. The company sent me a replacement free of charge when the drill got stuck in the #2 position and would not work anymore as intended. A lot of tools came with the new one.

I highly recommend the Rockwell 3rill.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#3

Re: advice on buying a drill

BrianMonumentCO

Even though this may not be a stategy that you may not want to employ, most battery powered devices are ultimately disposable. That means that after a period of time the batteries will flag and the mess needs to be replaced. Ultimately you must replace a system as the batteries die out.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#4

No question about lithium: yes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A lithium-ion battery will sit on the shelf for months and be ready to go, fully charged, when you need it. Unless you use your drills daily and enough to cycle through a Ni-cad (can you still buy those new?) or NiMH battery at least every second day, go with Li-Ion.

That said, I wish someone built a lithium-ion cordless drill at an affordable price with a pistol grip (at the back of the body) rather than center grip (partway along the body). I really prefer pistol grip for drilling, because I can get my hand behind the chuck.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: No question about lithium: yes

Jesper, Denmark

I concur about the Lithium.

I have three drills and one impact wrench - all Makita, so they share batteries - 14.4 and 18 volt and the batteries work on all of them.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#6

Re: advice on buying a drill

Keith Newton

I have a Rigid, and Makita drill driver set. The Makita gets used probably 20 times more often than the other.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#7

Re: advice on buying a drill

John McGaw

I bought one of the DeWalt 18V lithium sets when they went on sale at Amazon six months ago. Set had the drill, impact driver, two of the light duty batteries and a charger in a case. I'm very happy with the set. During my bathroom project I finally gave in and bought one of their compatible circular saws and one of the heavy duty batteries. The stuff I got was the old-style XRP equipment, not their newer 20V slide-on style but that doesn't bother me as it was cheaper and seems to work just as well.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#8

Re: advice on buying a drill

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Li Ion is the preferred battery chemistry for this application. Eventually the battery will wear out. Hence, it makes sense to get a guaranteed for life battery by buying Rigid from Home Depot. If you do any screw installation buy the combination pack they sell, drill and impact driver.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#9

Break the Battery Cycle

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've had a number, going back to the 6v screwdriver. Thing was, when the batteries reached the end of their useful life it cost nearly as much as a new drill to replace them. Tried the rebuild deal but between cost and freight, there wasn't much difference.

Enter Ridgid Tools (Emerson Electric) with lifetime battery replacement - FREE.

I have 12v and 18v Li drills and impact drivers and, absent them being run over by the truck, will not be buying another battery-run drill just to get new batteries. ;)

Re: advice on buying a drill

#10

Re: No question about lithium: yes

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Have a look at the Rockwell 3rill...it does have the pistol grip....and free battery replacement

Re: advice on buying a drill

#11

Re: The road less travelled

TomD

Not being a pro, I just buy the 36 buck ones that come on sale at various places. The feature set is better than my original Makita 9.6, and while they don't make that nice squeaky noise the newer quality ones make, they have solf start, 2 batteries, and a charger. And come with a complete set of bits.

As a supplements, I own a corded driver for drywall. Yeah, cords, wouldn't be without mine. It drives screws hard all day long when I am doing a really big job. Normally on big jobs the screws are relatively close together which reduces the disadvantage to hauling a cord. And I use a brace with the LV adapter that takes bits. Another tool that works better than the stupid expensive drill drivers for certain uses.

My dad needed a new drill driver, so I bought him a very compact and light Milwaukee, that does not have a jacobs chuck. It bayonet mounts the bits. It is a lot faster, only about1/2" in diameter, for tight work, doesn't unscrew itself in tight work. It uses standard bits and holders, and I bought a set of basic twist drills to use with it from LV. All around superior to a drill with a quick change jacobs chuck.

So far I am not loving the impact drills everyone has moved up to. I also speculatively wonder if the hole they make isn't oversized for the screw.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#12

Re: advice on buying a drill

Barry Irby

I have a bunch of Makita 12 volt NiCad drills and an impact driver. Struggled with the batteries. Bought a second set just to get new batteries. Had batteries rebuilt. That worked fine, but the years go by and they are shot. Family gave me a Bosch set with the drill and Impact driver with the little 12 volt LIon batteries. Really like them. they got stolen so I bought a new set. The thieves failed to take all the batteries, so I have lots. I really like the small size. Makes the old Makita set feel like monsters. The weird thing about the Bosch set is the chuck on the drill loosens itself every time after about three holes. I complained to Bosch and they sent me a new one (drill), its just as bad as the one I sent back. You would think Bosch could make a better chuck.

With all the trouble I have had with batteries, I would seriously look at the Rigid ones.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#13

Re: advice on buying a drill

clay foster

I like the onehanded chuck on my Bosch. Our little Makita had a two handed chuck, and my old hands just don't grip like they used to. The chuck on the Makita will go down to zero, so when I'm using very small bits, I use the Makita. There's more things to consider than just batteries.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#14

Re:One handed chuck

TomD

Yeah, one handed, I guess that is what the chuck I was referring to is. Same deal for my dad, he can still play the piano at 89, but he does find his hands weakened. And it has other advantages.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#15

Thanks guys some good things to consider


Re: advice on buying a drill

#16

Re: The road less travelled

Keith Newton

Tom, where the impact driver really shines, is for driving the screw. I like to compare it to driving a nail with a hammer. You can't use it to PUSH a nail deep into the wood. Well, I suppose you could, but it would take a lot more energy.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#17

Tails and all... was: road less travelled

Bruce McCrory

I still have my tailed B&D from .... umm, probably 30 years ago.

This last winter, a new DeWalt drill started the holes, and an impact drove the screws into DF framing. Nails simply shattered or bent at half-inch penetration. The pro-drywaller liked his Lithium Ryoba impact drill, but he was using mine by the end of the day.

I tried a couple juicers (9.6, 12?) a few ago, and now use the metal boxes they came in for storing odds and ends.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#18

Ellis Walentine

I get my batteries rebuilt

Ellis Walentine

Costs about $40 for a 12v pack.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#19

Re: I get my batteries rebuilt

John Veerkamp

$34 at Batteries Plus

Re: advice on buying a drill

#20

Take The Other Fork

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Impacters are not drills (although can be used for small holes in masonry); they're made to drive screws not make holes. If you want a precise hole, use a straight drill.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#21

Shipping avoided

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The main problem with a rebuild is the shipping cost. But just about everywhere has a Batteries Plus store , or something similar. Without shipping a rebuild is cost effective

Re: advice on buying a drill

#22

Re: Take The Other Fork

TomD

Don't they drill holes in Masonry?

Re: advice on buying a drill

#23

Re: The road less travelled

TomD

Keith, I can't fight the consensus, and the consensus is they are great for driving screws. What bugs me is why. If you imagine a screw half way in, what is the impact doing, it is presumably enlarging the spiral cavity the screw is sitting in, while the screw is being twisted in. That makes me wonder how we know that enlargement is precisely the size it needs to be to provide greatest screw performance, which is presumably the point. Of course the same question can be asked about a screw that is simply twisted in. Has anyone seen tests that compare fastener performance when hammered in vs when twisted in. It would be easy to get some base numbers from a torque wrench or something. And then there is the question of what the hammering is doing to the screw integrity. Basically screws need to be brittle to survive the treatment they get from the process, but that isn't what they need after they are set.

Up here we have this guy mike Holmes. Don't know if you get him down there. He is always using his hammer drill to frame stuff. Drives me crazy. Then one day he ends up in LA doing some build and they shut him down for using screws, since they aren't engineered fasteners. But hammer drills have created a sort of cancer of guys who don't get nails and how to use the geometry they supply and are screwing everything because it is "better". Which is doubtless true for something like call backs for squeaks.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#24

Yeahbut

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You'll find that the regular impact driver units are not build to take the abuse like a real hammer-drill, let alone an SDS rotary hammer.

I would have no problem using one on a soft brick or "lite block" wall for a hole up to say 5/16" but not beyond that.

Re: advice on buying a drill

#25

So so results with MTO

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I did the rebuild thing two years ago. Dewalt 12V rebuild by MTO battery rebuilders. Cost $42.53 with shipping. Battery performs pretty much ok but doesn't seem to hold a charge very long. I use it as a second drill. Since then, I'v gone the Rigid 18V route and am quite happy.