Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

The chat with Peter Korn

Posts

The chat with Peter Korn

#1

The chat with Peter Korn

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

RE: Korn chat linked to below

Let me say from the start that I would not be at home in that school.

The topic was design. Peter offered a design philosophy for the school, “We encourage each student to find his or her own voice in design. Anything from Shaker-inspired to art furniture is fair game. We don't teach period reproductions, though.”

I was reminded of another quote, I think out of the staff at College of Redwoods. In reference to studio furniture, which he/she called “narrative furniture”, “Narrative furniture is more focused on expressing the personality of the maker”, [than a place to put your socks].

If the student of this school is doing woodworking for the purpose of converting their “voice” into a piece of “furniture” , or “more focused on expressing the personality of the maker” the result can often be an unattractive(to many) and impractical place to store their socks. Most often I label these results “art projects”, not furniture. (I mean art project as descriptive not a pejorative label.)

I have always considered “reproduction” (more or less) woodworkers to be lesser mortals because they could not or would not create their own designs. I have changed my mind on this topic. Many of the best woodworkers I know are building to have a place to put their socks. They are choosing designs that have stood the test of time to be more or less reproduced, assured of a practical and attractive place to put their socks. The reproduction can be chosen to stretch the makers skills- good, better , best if you know Sack. Having a sock drawer talk in their voice is farthest from their mind.

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#2

Adam of Oakland

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

Adam of Oakland

bill, i don't see the link, would love to read this!!! sorry, i'm a WC tyro so not sure where it might be located.

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#3

directions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Go down the message posting list to a recent post by Ellis on Philly. Note that the title of the post contains the word "link", which means that somewhere in the post there will be a link to something. Indeed if you open the posting way at the bottom in blue(I think it is blue) is a link to the "Chat" with Peter.

There is a boggling amount of stuff here at Woodcentral. If you poke around somewhere there may be a list of links to all the recorded chats. Note that at the top of the page that opens in Messages that there is a chat link for Michael Dresdner, finishing expert.

"Chats" are something our leader arranges where some notable person engages in an "on-line" conversation with WoodCentral participants.

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#4

Alan Young

Here's the Chat Link  *LINK*


Peter Korn Chat

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#5

Re: Here's the Chat Link

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

You can also go HERE to see other chat transcripts from the past.

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#6

Ellis Walentine

Speaking of guest chats... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

... and traditional woodworking, when I ran into Mario Rodriguez the other day, he agreed to join me some evening for a special guest chat. As you may know, Mario is a woodworking author, a real traditional furniture maker, and a partner in the Philadelphia Furniture Workshop. I haven't lined up a date yet, but it'll happen.

Ellis


Philadelphia Furniture Workshop

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#7

Ellis Walentine

As someone once said...

Ellis Walentine

... it takes all kinds to fill the freeways. Peter's school caters to the kind that values self expression. With any luck, the results are attractive and functional. There's plenty to be said for reproduction furniture, and, by and large, its adherents are probably the most skilled woodworkers around, judging by the instructors I know (or know of) -- Edwards, Headley, Breed, Lowe, Latta, Underhill, Bender, etc. -- but, functionality aside, the aesthetic doesn't necessarily agree with everyone. The originators of 18th and 19th century furniture styles were innovators themselves at one time, building their signature styles on the foundation of classical proportions. Modern studio furniture is sometimes overly conceptual and silly, but if it is designed to function -- as a dresser, as a table, as a chair -- there are certain parameters that must be met for the piece to succeed. Aesthetics are in the eye of the beholder, and traditionalists and reproductionists are beholden to an aesthetic that has weathered the ravages of time. But not everyone was brought up with those familiarities and preferences, and a lot of modern-day craftsmen are inclined artistically and seek to develop personal styles or genre-specific styles to appeal to a target market or demographic. How well they succeed can usually be gauged by their reputation and the prices they are able to charge for their work. My hunch is that they all build functional sock drawers when that's what the customer or market wants.

Diff'rent strokes.

Ellis

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#8

Clint Searl

Very well put, Ellis


Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#9

Differn't Strokes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Each of us here have devoted some kind of time to developing a skill-set we refer to as "woodworking." Whether by machine, hand, or some percentage of both, we carry on the basic lessons, millennia old, of using a material that is available to most all of us to make something. That "something" may be useful, it may be purely decorative, but it is the "making" that is important. Judge yourself by what you make and you risk your soul. If you believe in Creation, you have to acknowledge that everyone makes mistakes. Looked at Ostriches, Aardvarks, or a Platypus lately?

We woodworkers can operate on two levels. One being craft, in how well we master and apply techniques and technologies (rudimentary to complex), the other being vision, in how clear an idea we have of the object that we work to produce. Whether that vision is of something made 100, or 2,000 years ago, or first conceived last night over dinner, makes little difference. Whether we spend 20 years, 20 hours, or 20 minutes making the object is also of little significance beyond the evaluation that the item could have been done better if more (or less) time was invested in the making.

If we choose to denigrate one person's efforts based upon our own preferences, we diminish what we, ourselves do. My father was very dedicated to the phrase that "You point a finger at someone, you point at least three at yourself."

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#10

The value of a critic

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Are you denying the value of a knowledgeable critic? I have acquired a friend who is formally trained at a leading art school. She pursued a career in art and design. (she designs gorgeous Arts and Crafts accessories, some of wood) She allows me to bounce furniture ideas off her. I see something I like that I would like to reproduce, more or less, and ask her opinion. For no better reason than I have access to lots of pictures of student work these ideas are often created by students at wood working schools.

It is typical that she finds them over done with creativity. Stripping away some of this creativity and occasionally adding back a detail or two improves the piece in her mind and mine. These exercises have taught me several things.

1. I sometimes know a good design when I see it but I can't originally produce a successful design. I suspect this situation is not rare. I don't believe a few weeks of training will turn a pig's ear designer into a silk purse designer and if this is a fact it is well to accept the situation.

2. The typical woodworking school student of 1 or 2 years has not received sufficient training and experience to have become a good designer.

3. A talented design critic can be helpful. Even experienced writers know the usefulness of a good editor. There may be an analogy in woodworking.

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#11

Re: The value of a critic

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"I don't believe a few weeks of training will turn a pig's ear designer into a silk purse designer and if this is a fact it is well to accept the situation."

Argue for your limitations, Bill, and they will be yours to keep.

All too often students do well on some test and think they know it all. Actually, all they know was on the test.

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#12

Clint Searl

I don't need no stinkin' critic

Clint Searl

A critic is just someone exercising his/her collection of biases, a task that I can perform better about my own stuff.

Re: The chat with Peter Korn

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: I don't need no stinkin' critic

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

You know what they say--if you're the smartest person in the room, find a different room. Otherwise you'll never learn anything.

If your woodworking goal is reproduction furniture, great! But I would think you'd want to keep seeking out the best in the genre to improve your own reproductions, starting with the large concepts, and working your way down to the smallest detail.

On the flip side, maybe you're exploding with creativity, and not many can help you with the creative side, but there could be someone out there who can point you to better execution. I have a very good friend who pursued an art degree, and he went to some top schools for it, at great cost, only to find that an ideology was being pushed much more than any help in how to execute the ideas he had.

I don't have much room in my life for something that is purely form with no function, but I won't begrudge someone that pursuit, and if I see such an item elsewhere, I might appreciate it if it trips my fancy. However, that piece would probably not excite me if it had a poor finish on it and the joinery were sloppy. We all know that writers of all kinds go through many drafts of each work they produce, why wouldn't a woodworker?

Jason