Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

One of those counter top finish questions

Posts

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#26

Hardness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You don't need a lab or a PhD in paintology to come to your own conclusions about hardness. How easily it dents is the metric. Pencils of various hardness are used to determine hardness, but a thumbnail does fine in a pinch. The best(hardest) floor finish will be impossible to dent with the finger nail. Hard to dent is a good one.

Varnish is made from resin and oil. The oil provides the curing and other properties, like flexibility. The resin is typically hard and maybe brittle and lacks flexibility. In the simplest sense the oil to resin ratio is varied to tailor a finish to an application, more or less hard and more or less flexible.

If there was perceived demand hard varnish could be made.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#27

So

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It depends upon the type and amount of resin used? Or

Does the resin used need a particular solvent (or percentage thereof) to make the product useable? If not, then why should that be impacted by the changing VOC regs?

Granted, exterior finishes are generally softer to allow for seasonal wood movement, but when it comes to interior floors I don't necessarily agree with the "harder is better" concept. I helped refinish a number of hardwood floors back in the 60's and 70's using "soft" gym seal, and they looked good after decades of traffic and furniture moving.

BTW, I've heard of the "pencil test" but it had nothing to do with floor finishes :D :D

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#28

Re: So

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It depends upon the type and amount of resin used? Or

Does the resin used need a particular solvent (or percentage thereof) to make the product useable? ..........I don't know, but I'll bet it is one of several factors including cost of components and consumer demand and consumer ability to successfully apply it, as well as perceived toxicity of the cross linker that

but when it comes to interior floors I don't necessarily agree with the "harder is better" concept. I helped refinish a number of hardwood floors back in the 60's and 70's using "soft" gym seal, and they looked good after decades of traffic and furniture moving..........The gym finish common in the 60's and early 70's was an isocyanate crosslinked varnish. I used it on hardwood floors, well, most did. Dog toe nails would not dent it. It lasted 20 years on our floors. It was the gold standard of durable and hard. But EPA banned the isocyanate used as the hardener.

BTW, I've heard of the "pencil test" but it had nothing to do with floor finishes....lost me on this one

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#29

Kneale Brownson

That's similar.....

Kneale Brownson

to what I used. I looked at that vanity this morning and find it still shiny and smooth after all these years of abuse from toothbrushes, soap, water, scrubbing, etc.