Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

One of those counter top finish questions

Posts

One of those counter top finish questions

#1

One of those counter top finish questions

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Yes, another one of those "What's the best finish for a wood counter top" questions...

My wife wants me to start another project (I haven't even completed my little half round table yet). She wants a new counter top on the bathroom vanity my dad and I built about 12 years ago. My daughter is getting married this summer and there is a long list of "little things" to do before hand. Like landscaping the dogs mud hole we call the backyard. (FYI - multiple dogs and green grass can not coexist. I've tried everything over the years - going artificial.)

She went to the big box store and priced out granite and other man made material. $1000. What? I don't think so. I think the current Formica top is just fine. But I was over ruled.

I made the mistake of suggesting a wood top. Dumb. I know. But I thought it would be quick, simple, and cheap(er). My dad did this with Maple years ago and it is still holding up surprisingly well. I'm sure he just used whatever poly the hardware sold him.

So I started to search the archives here for this question. I've read numerous threads about using Waterlox. I understand it is tung oil and phenolic resin based and is good for this type of application.

I've used Waterlox in the past and remember liking it. But I also kinda remember reading here a thread by Ellis (could be wrong about that) that the formulation has changed on Waterlox and maybe it's not as good as it used to be? Again, I could be remembering that all wrong. But, wasn't there something about it?

So, in its current form, anything wrong with using Waterlox in this application? Is there another tung oil & phenolic based varnish to recommend?

The top will likely be ordinary maple. I still have to read up a little on making a wood counter top, like how to make it look about 1-1/2" thick and rout a profile on it. Oh, and what to put under it kind of things...

Thanks!

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#2

Love Waterlox

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

But, it is a softer finish film, even when using the hi-gloss version that has more varnish resin. I would not use it in a high-wear area like a kitchen counter (DAMHIKT), but a bath vanity should be fine. Start with an application of Original Sealer, then build with the Gloss, and finally rub out to the sheen you want.

Unless you work with a piece of slab, you're probably looking at an edge-banding situation to get the thickness you wish.

The cut-out for your sink(s) is done with a template and router using either a guided bit or a bushing. You can make the template out of 1/4" ply, and if doing new fixtures they should come with a spec sheet and pattern. Since the cut-out doesn't have to be pretty, you can also just use a jigsaw.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#3

Clint Searl

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

Clint Searl

Short of an epoxy, a waterborne poly floor finish will be as durable as anything else.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#4

Hard wax oil as alternative?

dIZd

I researched this several months ago when I was asked about a kitchen island top. You can do a search for hard wax oil and see a range of products available. I had decided on Osmo Top Oil if I was going to try it. This product (apparently) leaves the wood with a bare wood look. Product description says it has no solvents. I posted a question here about this product at the time but got no response. Don't know it that means no one here has tried it or no one interested in responding. If you try it, let us know how it works for you.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#5

Maybe it's just me....

Dick Coers

but my bathroom vanity top is no place for wood. Shaving cream, tooth paste, wife's hair product, occasional hair spray, wet hands shutting off the tap, etc.... Just too much water for me to be comfortable with wood being used there. Same thing goes for those glass bowl sinks sitting on top of the countertop. How do you get the intersection of the glass and top clean? Our hard water sure doesn't help either! Corian or resin top with undercount sinks only for me thank-you very much.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#6

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

John in NM

My wife's vanity has an oak top finished with some kind of poly, I forget what exactly. Works fine, though care should be taken to seal the wood where the cut outs are made, and to caulk around the sink with a high quality caulking.

I use Waterlox sealer/finish a lot, but I would find it a bit thin for this kind of application. I did once use their marine finish, it was a much thicker product and might work well on a vanity top. For the use though, I found poly to be the best bet.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#7

not just you......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For my life style wood is an utterly impractical surface for kitchen or bath.

$1000 for a vanity top? One can get rock (little of it is granite) for as little as $30/ sqft. 5 x 3 vanity would be $450. Install yourself, easy on a vanity and it could be cheaper.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#8

I agree with Dick& Bill

Mike Potts

Wood on a bath counter top is just going to be continual maintenance down the road. I re-did two full & one half bath in the last couple of years and went with the molded resin. It has a marble look and comes in a lot of different shades. I believe in K.I.S.S. there's no cutting holes or caulking. you can install it in less than a hour. One tip on the plumbing, use all new from the shut off value up, I've learned over the years when you try to go cheap and use the old lines and fittings you've just got a leak waiting to happen. Good Luck on the project.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#9

Ah Hum ... Gents

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If SWMBO wants a wood top on the vanity,

SHE . . GETS . . A . . WOOD . . TOP. [end of report] :D

SHE can change it out later, but without the "I told you so" look from Joe, things will be better for him.

MM

[striking a blow for marital harmony] ;)

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#10

Re: Ah Hum ... Gents

Barry Irby

I agree. Which part of she is in charge did any of you forget? Make her whatever she wants and then remake it later when she wants something else.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#11

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

don stephan

You might consider a test panel with a Cleveland product, Pratt & Lambert 38 alkyd varnish.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#12

You're ignoring the project delay time

Dick Coers

when the finish on the wood top fails. It may take months/years to get a replacement for that trashed wood that will hold up to all the water, soap, and gunk.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#14

A very good point...

John in NM

I've been very slow to learn to avoid the "I told you so look" :D

On the other hand I have a terrible memory for conversation, and usually forget everything but the gist in mere minutes. I credit that for my lasting as long as I have! :D

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#15

Re: Where can you buy it?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

It looks like Sears Hardware stores carry it around here as well as various hardware stores. I may check it out. Their web site indicates it's only in 1 gallon cans though.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#16

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for the replies.

Some suggested molded resin tops or similar. The problem with that is this vanity is something my dad and I made a long time ago. It's over 7' long, and a regular store bought top won't work. It also has a cut-out at one end where the toilet is. It's shaped kinda like a flag pole.

Thanks.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#17

Something Not Mantioned

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Joe,

We're all getting older and time changes us all. So too, it will effect your counter in some ways. Maple will darken a bit by itself, but oil finishes, especially those based on linseed or soy oils (most all poly and varnishes) will yellow as time goes by. Waterlox less so, but some notwithstanding. We may not notice this on darker/stained woods, but on light stuff like maple it will be very noticeable. The combination of a light wood and an oil finish will be pronounced before long.

If the "Decorator" has light/blond wood in mind and wants it to stay that way for as long as possible, you should be looking at the higher-end waterborne finishes such as General Hi-Per Poly or Enduro or Target Coatings products, as they stay water-white over time.

PS: If you go with a waterborne, you should first seal the wood with a light application of super light solvent finish like ML Campbell Lacquer or freshly mixed Ultra Pale shellac.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#18

Ellis Walentine

What I'd do

Ellis Walentine

If it must be wood, you need something harder than Waterlox. I put oil-based polyurethane on my new maple kitchen countertops almost two years ago and it is holding up perfectly. I wouldn't recommend anything that can be dissolved in nail polish remover.

With poly, the finish will dull as it wears, so you want to keep an eye on it and probably recoat every two or three years.

My 2¢

Ellis

PS Waterlox has changed their recipe a couple times over the years to comply with shifting VOC requirements. The new version apparently works about as well and offers similar protection to the previous version, but it handles differently and has different drying time. Neither is a serious problem. It is still too soft a finish for work surfaces and counter tops in my opinion.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#19

Re: Epoxy is good,

TomD

Get a variety that is UV resistant, most of the big makers have some. You have to coat all surfaces, tope bottoms, sides, etc... You can finish the thing with some varnish, or 2 pack varnish. With epoxy, you can make the sink out of wood also...

Or Behlen's Rock Hard Tabletop Varnish has a good reputation.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#20

Kneale Brownson

Pouring Plastics

Kneale Brownson

I built a small corner vanity in a tiny bathroom maybe 40 years ago. After staining the wood and setting in the sink basin, I used a crafts product called pouring plastic that was marketed as suitable for wet locations. It darkened the white caulk I used to seal the sink, but otherwise has remained sealed and shines up when cleaned well.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#21

Re: Pouring Plastics

Yonak

Kneale, I've never heard of pouring plastic. It sounds very interesting. Is it designed as a finish ? How well does it level, in your opinion ? I wonder how it sands and if it takes wax and buffing well.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#23

Re: Pouring Plastics

Yonak

Oh, right. I wasn't making the connection.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#24

Waterlox soft?

Alex Y

I'm surprised to see that comment a couple of times in this thread. Anyone else here old enough to remember when what is now branded as "Waterlox Gloss" was branded as "Waterlox Gym Floor Finish"? I always assumed (no scientific testing here) from the name that it was very hard and tough. In my own limited use, it has seemed only slightly less hard than shellac, and of course MUCH tougher.

Re: One of those counter top finish questions

#25

Then & Now

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

McCloskey (now Valspar) used to make a product with tung oil called Gym Seal. Used a lot of it on floors because it wouldn't chip or flake off, even though it would "dent" when stuff was dragged across it. You could "renew" the finish with a light scuff with No.1 wool and just apply another coat. Great stuff; died the "VOC Death" along with so many other products.

Waterlox has had to change their formulations over the years, but is still a softer film than most any poly will give, but it doesn't have the film toughness it once had. Any finish chemists lurking to give us a quasi-tech explanation of why?