Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Sharpen planer blades

Posts

Re: Sharpen planer blades

#26

Re: Question on surface finish

Barry Irby

Bill, its been a long time since I had much experience with big machines and I have a Dewalt now that has the knives that are designed to be sharpened. I sharpen them myself. All that aside, I think a factor in the quality of the surface the machines generate is the number of cuts per inch. Each cut is a scallop or scooped out trough. I have seen commercially planed lumber that has the ridges left by the planing at least an eighth of an inch apart. The head on my planer turns at ten thousand rpm's if I remember correctly and the feed rate is relatively slow so I am guessing there are more than a hundred cuts per inch. This effectively eliminates the scallop effect. The newer machines have three knives and two feed rates, but I am betting that even at the faster rate it has more cuts per inch that a big old York or whatever. Some of the lunch box units now come with spiral heads. Have not seen one but I would like to. Might be interesting to find out the statistics on both types of machines.

Re: Sharpen planer blades

#27

Cuts per inch

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This isn't the only metric. The size of the cutter head enters the picture. Many (maybe most or all) large machines have a variable feed rate. I can make scallops at the highest feed rate. And I can not make them at a lower rate.

There are lots of variables that affect finish. Rather than believe that large machines can not be run under conditions that produce a smooth surface it may be that the real situation is that the small machines can't be run at conditions that are highly productive at the expense of a poorer finish. There are double head machines that produce 13/16" lumber in one pass at high feed rates. Indeed, under these conditions the finish may be compromised, but the cost of planing is almost nothing. But that does not mean a well tuned ancient 12 or 13" Delta can't produce an acceptable surface. I have never heard an owner of one complain about surface quality.

Re: Sharpen planer blades

#28

Re: Question on surface finish

Lars Parrington

I've probably given the wrong impression, since I mostly don't care about the surface finish that comes out of my planer. The important thing to me is that there is as little tear-out as possible. However, since you asked about surface finish, I'll try to quantify it for you:

The knives in my planer have seen maybe 50 bdft since the last sharpening. Across the width of the knives, there are currently areas that are sharper than others, so there are different surface finishes which show up as streaks down the length of a board.

In the best streaks, the wood has the same shine as a freshly hand-planed surface and is nearly as smooth. If you look very close, you can just make out the scallops which are spaced ~1/32" apart.

In the worst areas, the finish is duller, as though it were sanded at 120 grit, and there are some ridges from nicks in the knives. I measured the worst ridge I could find and at it was approx .001" tall (measured using a dial test indicator graduated in ten-thousandths).

I'd guess I could get away with a starting grit of 180 on this surface, maybe even 220, using a ROS. I don't really know though, because that's not how I work. My finishing prep is usually a #7 plane, followed by #4, followed by dull 220 grit ROS.

For reference, this was a dewalt DW735 planer, set to its fastest feed rate, and set to take off 1/32" of material. Lumber was black cherry ~10" wide.

Re: Sharpen planer blades

#29

Re: Cuts per inch

TomD

Probably true about the respective limits. The small machines are not even trying for high productivity so they better deliver a clean surface. Whereas when a big machine fails to give clean results it is pretty much a design decision. Why bother if the piece is going through a belt sander anyway. There isn't any reason why it couldn't give clean results.

A machine that planes 13/16" in a double pass is to wood, what the Hummer is to gas. I could see it making a gerbil happy. Seems like a horizontal resaw might be a better first step. Of course you can always burn fine cabinetwood for heat, which is great from a Green perspective, because it's carbon neutral.

Re: Sharpen planer blades

#30

Re: My experience on surface finish

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

My previous planer was a 12" DeWalt DW733, My current planer is a stationary 20" 5hp (can't remember the name, sure it is a Gee Tee as almost all new ones are - bought from Wilke tool about 8 years ago) with a Byrd head (segmented carbide inserts in a spiral).

I kept sharp blades on my DW733 - issues I had were snipe on almost every board, variations in thickness across the boards, often as great as .010 ~ .015 (this with the head locked). Tear out when grain reversed or not fed "with the grain", even when I sprayed the board prior to planing, and fairly slow operation, especially when a large amount of material needed removal. Surface finish was pretty good BUT not quite as good as my stationary fed at low travel speed.

My stationary planer will remove 3/16" on a 12" oak board if I desire - probably more, just usually don't want to remove that much from one side - I alternate sides each pass.

I have Zero tear out and never have to wet a board surface, I actually fed a fully assembled paneled door assembly (someone had miss-assembled, duh.) and it leveled the surface without any tear out of any kind, I often feed the unit without even looking at grain orientation! I have ZERO snipe even on 12' long boards. My surface finish off the planer is better than I previously obtained from the Benchtop. I can either scrape (never need to plane) or make one pass with my 4" orbital / 120 Grit and no marks remain.

I have so little variation across wide boards (< .002) that I no longer even think about it. The planer is so repeatable I can set the crank wheel in the same spot and I get .750 thick +/- .002 every time.

My son did purchase the planer with the Byrd head but it was delayed in shipment so Wilke sent the unit with the standard blade head and we changed it a month or so later to the Byrd. I didn't run enough material through the standard head to determine its capabilities but as I remember it was near the same quality as the benchtop, the Byrd made a world of difference.