Sharpen planer blades
Doug Ridley
Anybody tried to sharpen the Delta 12&1/2" lunchbox planer blades? If so how? How did you do it? Maybe some kind of a jig? I thought maybe they could be sharpened one time as the dang things cost $30.00 a pair.
Doug
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Sharpen planer blades
Doug Ridley
Anybody tried to sharpen the Delta 12&1/2" lunchbox planer blades? If so how? How did you do it? Maybe some kind of a jig? I thought maybe they could be sharpened one time as the dang things cost $30.00 a pair.
Doug
Re: Sharpen planer blades
Barry Irby
If you are talking about the ones that are about half inch wide and double edged, I don't think you can sharpen them. The depth of cut is indexed of the width of the blade, so if you grind any away your planer will cut less or not at all. You might be able to touch them up with a diamond hone if you only take off a few thousandths.
Fine Wood Working just had a blurb saying they were suing carbide blades and liked them. They were lasting much longer. I don't have any experience with them and I don't know if they make them for your planer, but it might be something to check into. Cost more up front, but get more life out of them.
I have the version of the Dewalt planer that the knives can be sharpened. I have tow sets and I mix and match the knives to offset the nicks so I don't have to grind away so much steel. You might try that on yours. (I sharpen both sets at the same time to keep them dynamically balanced.) That would not be an issue on yours because your don't sharpen them.
I do occasionally.
Keith Newton
When I can't get my hands on them as quickly as I need them.
Are use my little table saw the grinding wheel on it. The jig, is just a piece of plastic laminate with a straight fence bonded to the back edge, which runs side to side across the table. It needs a gap for the wheel to come up through, with a little clearance around the wheel.
The sharpness angle, is set by raising or lowering the blade. And you set the fence back for blade width.
I use a 1/4" to 1/2" white alundum wheels, with a Koolmist spray head set about 1" away from the contact point, which allows faster grinding speed, without hurting the temper.
Keep your fence low, out of the way of your hands, because it takes both hands to keep even pressure, while the pinky does the feeding both ways as you slide it back and forth.
I have a little gram scale that I use to balance them on, and I usually home them on one of those giant Japanese water-stones after grinding.
Due to setup and cleanup time, I usually wait until I have about 4 sets to do, then I don't have to think about changing blades as they start to dull.
The are much easier to maintain if you change them earlier than later.
Life is too short to waste it using a dull blade.
no need to worry about overheating
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If these blades are typical they are ground from M2 steel which was tempered at about 900 F.
Well, you may be right, but are you sure grinding
Keith Newton
Won't get the edge higher than that?
One of my favorite uses for my old blades, is to cut them in half, dull both edges, then grind the ends like a chisel razor sharp. Then I roll the edge over forming a still razor edge, to use for my final finish on turnings on the lathe.
If I don't get the edge red, I can't roll the bur, due to it fracturing. Surely this means it has been annealed, no?
Re: Well, you may be right, but are you sure grind
r payne
No. Just getting it to glowing doesn't equal to the piece being annealed. Depending on the lighting conditions, glowing red indicates a temp of 700 to 1000 F. For annealing, the steel needs to get hot enough for the crystalline structure to change (for simple steel that is around 1500 F). Some alloys are tempered around 1000 F. I'm guessing you are tempering the used blades.
ron
Data
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
It is common for industrial planers to have on-board knife grinding capability as part of the machine. That is to say the knives are ground in place using a grinding wheel without the aid of coolant. My experience doing this operation suggests that typical grinding will not affect the hardness of M2 steel.
Turners routinely grind their M2 and similar metal lathe tools freehand on 3600 rpm wheels.
It may well be that a poorly cutting abrasive (dull or too hard a bond) aggressively applied to a planer blade edge could affect the hardness of the fine edge.
Re: Data *LINK*
Keith Newton
Yes, my Old Crescent 24" planer has the grinding attachment, and I have used I don't know how many times since I bought it around 1972. And yes, it is used without coolant, but according to the way I was taught, the cup wheel just barely touches the knife enough to see sparks. This requires a full day to grind the 8' of knives in the 4 knife head.
I find it quicker and easier to climb up onto it with a 2x4" diamond hone which I've bonded onto a handle, and hone away the shine about 4 times between grinding. Then I take them out to sharpen on the TS. The same is true with the four knife 12" jointer.
Due to the ease of knife changing on the little planer, if whatever I'm working on will fit through it, I will use it even though it is slower than being able to hog off 1/8" or more with 15hp driving the other.
The little unit I'm linking to can turn any grinder into a cooler /faster unit no matter what type of wheel you choose to use. You know the industry doesn't slowly grind any of these blades dry, whether they heat treat them before or after.
Bill, I suspect you are retired, and work for your own pleasure, so the time you spend sharpening probably doesn't matter in the least to you. But I'll bet you a six-pack of your favorite beverage, that you don't have a blade in your shop that you lean into with no concern about turning the steel blue.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/KOOL-MIST-PORTAMIST-SPRAY-MACHINE-SYSTEM-60M12-INCLUDES-CONCENTRATED-COOLANT-/261455854321?_trksid=p2054897.l5661
Re: Well, you may be right, but are you sure grind
Keith Newton
I'm afraid I don't have a means to measure the heat at the cutting edge while I'm grinding, so I like to be cautious not to change the properties. One thing is for certain, is that the hottest location in a grind, will be right at the edge, because the heat further down in the bevel, will be quickly absorbed into the mass. The part doing the work of staying sharp, is that most vulnerable to over heating.
I picked this from a machining forum. "M2 in the ASM heat treaters guide. 1250º hardness drops to low 50s rc after it cools."
Since the edge of my little scraper chips out when I grind keeping it cool, but will roll a nice hook when I get it red, is indication enough for me that I have softened it. I call that annealing, but you think that is tempering?
Re: Sharpen planer blades
Lars Parrington
i sharpen mine with a diamond stone. I use a 3x8" 600 grit eze-lap stone. A finer stone would make the process take too long, but a coarser stone would probably work great.
I use a homemade jig to hold the knives, which is just a piece of wood, about 1.5" x 1.5" x 12", with 2 slots cut down the length of it at a 45 degree angle. I cut the slots on the tablesaw, using a blade of about the same width as the planer knife thickness. Do an image search for "planer knife jig" and you'll see lots of similar jigs.
About 5 minutes of honing gets the blades back to a fresh edge. Then I take the knives out of the jig and rub their backs on the stone a bit to take off the burr.
I've had good results using this technique on both a 12" delta lunchbox planer, and also a 13" dewalt dw735. The knives are not supposed to be resharpenable on the latter, but it works fine.
A Day to sharpen!
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I am retired now but ran a hardwood lumber business for 25+ years and shoved a few feet of lumber through a machine with segmented knives. I think it has 9 rows of 3 knives per row . It takes me 15 minutes at most to regrind these knives and another 15 minutes to clean up and readjust pressure bar and rollers. The grinder does not use a cupped wheel. It is a regular circular pink wheel with a fairly soft bond. I crank it across the knives as fast as I can and one pass does the sharpening of the secondary bevel. Because more metal is removed from the primary bevel it may take more than one pass. The motor stalls with too heavy a cut when doing the hollow ground primary bevel.
I helped teach a lathe class with Bonnie Kline. We had 12 students with 4 tools each. Between sessions, about an hour, she reground these 48 M-2 tools on a 3600 rpm grinder. The wheel was likely 60 or 80 grit, white.
M2 tool steel and those similar do not need to be treated delicately.
Annealing is fundamentally different from tempering, but that is another topic. In your case you are lessening the hardness of the steel by tempering through heating at something above 1000 F which makes it tougher (M2 is not tough at high hardness). It is not normal to affect hardness with typical grinding. A thousand turners will confirm this fact.
Re: Well, you may be right, but are you sure grind
r payne
From the metallurgy I've read to support my blacksmithing habit, annealing has a very specific definition. Tempering, in most books has a different definition. (Tempering has an older definition that is looser.)
For M2, in order to anneal by spec, you need to heat it to 1600 F or hotter and cool slowly (less than 40 degrees F per hour) to below 900 F. Since M2 will air harden, if you heat the edge above austenizing temperatures, you will be quenching it unless you cool it slowly.
If the edge is softer after your grinding, you've tempered the edge.
Thanks r payne, and Bill for the explanation.
Keith Newton
I thought tempering was a fast cooling which raised the hardness, and annealing was a slower cooling which softened but toughened by taking away the brittleness.
Im sure I got that from my dad, who was the son of a blacksmith, back when I was making my first carving tools by grinding old files into what I wanted on his grinder. There was nothing but a gray wheel, and a cup of water which I dipped into often. These were crude tools, but I still love to use them whenever I need them.
At any rate, I suppose I will continue sharpening with the Kool-mist, because I can grind faster without burning my fingers, and not using it when I want to be able to roll a burr.
Re: Sharpen planer blades
Bill Leffingtwell
Lars jig and process for planer blades is almost word for word the same as mine.I bought a DW735 a couple of years ago and was shocked at the cost of throw away blades.I had always sharpened my own blades before.I asked about this here (WC) and several woodworkers who were familiar with the 735.Most said NO NO cant be done except for one who said what have got to lose,try it. So I did and the blades work as well as new after 3 sharpenings It is pretty obvious that the decision to say the blades were Throw Aways came from the Marketing Folks.I am happy with planer (a couple things could be better) but it is the best small planer I have ever used.
Re: Sharpen planer blades
Lars Parrington
Thanks for backing me up Bill. I agree the dw735 is a great tool. You can tell someone put a lot of thought into the design.
One thing about it is that it has 3 blades instead of only 2, which makes sharpening a little tricky. I'm still using a jig made for my old planer, so it only holds two blades at a time. I swap out blades while sharpening so that each blade gets approximately equal wear. That method seems to works well enough, but all the swapping draws out the process a bit. How do you do it? Do you have a jig with 3 slots?
Re: Sharpen planer blades
Bill Leffingtwell
Three slots does create a problem(maybe more mental than actual) using a 2 1/2"oak board I cut one slot in the middle and 2 outboard slots, then install the blades and then wedge them tightly. Then set them on the table saw bed and look for tiny gaps, and tap the board lightly to make sure they are pretty much even.I think if you do the same blades each time thet should remain matched. This sounds complicated but isn't. Anyhow this works fine in the planer. Now when I nick a blade?? I'll deal with that when it happens.
Expectations.......
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If these knives are M2 tool steel or something similar, and you run them to as dull as would be typical for planer blades it will be impractical to sharpen them by hand. I tried it on 8" jointer knives worn till the edge was rounded and nicked and after an hour I concluded that the small price Misenheimer charged to sharpen was money well spent. Removing on the order of 0.01" of abrasion resistant tool steel by hand is an arduous task.
Is there a reason these knives can not be sharpened by a saw shop that does this kind of work?
Re: Data
John Lucas
Bill you can't overheat a HSS blade with a grinder enough to do any damage. That being said I use a wet wheel grinder to sharpen my planer blades. Well actually the last time I simply made a wooden jig and sharpened them on sandpaper attached to my table saw. They were simply dull and not chipped so it didn't take much doing.
Re: Expectations.......
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Very true Bill, Although I have the tools to sharpen planer blades (up to 12" easily) as I have a 6 X 12 Boyer Schultz surface grinder, I don't have the need any longer. Prior to retiring I purchased a 8" Griz joiner with segmented carbide head, and my son purchased a stationary 20" planer for me with a Byrd head as a retirement gift. I still have an old Delta bench-top planer (DW 733) and have some M2 stock to make blades if I decide to use it (haven't used it in a few years), but would have to send it out to have heat treated. Takes some time to remove HSS steel, even with a surface grinder. As far as removing the temper from HSS when grinding, our tool room ALWAYS wet ground all the items - we used a great deal of HS steel in our mold and punch press department, and Yes you can damage /overheat / warp HSS steel when grinding, especially on small cross-sections while taking heavy grinds. One of the reasons for wet grinding is to prevent warping the tool due to temperature variations in the part. The other issue is that although you can reach about 1000 deg. f without damage (dull red), you can easily reach bright red on sharp edges, exceeding the working temperature & softening the tool edge. Grinding HSS requires a fairly heavy pressure and special wheel when hand grinding, and one definite no-no is dipping in water to cool between grinds as that can cause micro-cracks due to thermal shock. I always liked the old green wheels for HSS, think the industry has replaced them with either metal wheels with bonded material or diamond wheels.
Re: Expectations.......
Doug Ridley
Lotsa good info! Thanks. I'm gonna give it a try. Nothing to lose.
Re: Expectations.......
Lars Parrington
Bill, I know you've planed bazillions of board feet, so your experience here far exceeds mine. But, I assume you're accustomed to using a big powerful stationary planer, not a small lunchbox type. I suspect the lunchbox type is much less tolerant of dull blades, and so the blades we are sharpening are not in as poor conditon as you describe. Also the blades are not very thick (~1/16"), so sharpen faster.
The dw735 blades are indeed M2 steel. I sharpen them once I see/hear the planer starting to struggle and notice the surface quality deteriorating.
Typically these small planers barely have enough power to begin with, have marginal power feeds, and are really loud. When the blades start to dull, the volume goes up a lot, and I have to help the powerfeed out by pushing or pulling the board as it goes through (the dw735 is much better than my old planer in this respect, but still has difficulty sometimes).
I also have come to expect and count upon a very high quality surface finish straight out of the planer. As such, I notice when the quality starts to degrade. I've heard lunchbox planers typically produce a better surface finish than larger machines. With sharp blades I expect no tearout even when the grain direction is backwards (although i do still sometimes get a small piece torn out right where the grain reverses).
I'd estimate I go roughly 100 bdft between sharpenings, and thats mostly maple, cherry, and walnut that was previously skip planed by someone else. Note that I'd count a 8' long 1x6 as 4 bdft here, even though I'd generally end up planing at least 3 passes on each side of such a board.
OMG!...
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
....to borrow a phrase from the youth crowd. I had no idea. I expect to plane many hundreds of bdft between sharpening. Indeed, I would likely not be able to tell that your blades were dull.
Which leads to the question....why are people buying these machines? Used Delta, Powermatic and Parks 12 and 13" light industrial planers are available for a few hundred dollars. For a few years we ran the business planing on one of these machines(it was slow doing 500 bdft).
Re: OMG!...
Lars Parrington
Well, obviously a lunchbox planer is a compromise. They're cheap and they don't take up much room, and you can carry them around when you need to. They also seem to produce a better surface finish than the big machines. The tradeoff is that they're slow, and loud, and not very wide, and less tolerant of dull blades. Also, I'm sure some get much more mileage out their blades than me, but I'd guess they're using softer woods or sacrificing surface quality.
In my case, I really don't have the option of using a larger machine. I am constrained by the size of my workshop. It's the basement of the house I'm renting. While it's a reasonable amount of square footage, there are lots of obstructions (boiler, chimney, stairwell, columns, walls) that make it difficult to locate machines in such a way that they have a decent amount of infeed and outfeed length.
I bought my first lunchbox planer back when I knew almost nothing about woodworking. It was used and rusty and ~$20, how could I go wrong? I used to carry it out of my basement shop and set it up on the driveway when I wanted to use it.
Later I had a friend who would sell me a 20" grizzly planer for a good price. But I couldn't figure out any place in my shop where it could live, even if I were to put it on a mobile base.
I bought my current planer shortly thereafter. It lives on a stand that straddles the boiler. That is the only place in my shop that it could go where I could feed an 8' board through it (and in practice I can squeeze ~9'6" through it).
So, obviously my set up is not ideal, but it's actually pretty decent. The planer works well. It gives me great results. If I spend 1/2 hour refreshing the blades before every other project, so what?
Someday when I get a bigger shop, I'll get a big planer. But I doubt it will entirely replace my little planer. I expect I'll still use the little one for the final pass on anything narrow enough to fit though it.
Question on surface finish
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Having no experience with your machine, I am wondering what about it would provide a better surface than any other planer. In my experience finish depends on adjustment, stability/rigid of planer parts and sharpness of knives. If anything I would expect a large machine to be more stable and hold the lumber more stable.
Small planer owners seem to fuss about snipe. There isn't any on a well adjusted heavy machine. I was in a shop recently that had a 24" Powermatic with a Byrd head. The finish off that machine was nearly as good as a hand plane. I was astonished.
To get calibrated, can you be more quantitative about the finish you can expect? I begin with 120 grit on the results of our planer(or a swipe with the hand plane), or nothing if I am painting the result.
Agreed 12 or 13" Delta, Parks or Powermatic is not portable. Moving one downstairs would be a daunting task and dust collection is marginal. While trying to move our former 13" Powermatic it tipped over and broke wife's leg. I always set a planer up so it would throw shavings out doors to be cleaned up with broom and snow shovel.
Re: Question on surface finish
TomD
The small planes can do a better finish, it is probably the chip breaker. Also, they can't be pushed as hard which when the larger machines are pushed, they might not work as nicely. The obvious advantage to the large machines is the capacity and depth of cut. Cut quality wise, there are innovations in head construction that may allow the big machines to cut very well also, but those heads sometimes cost a few small planers for what the head costs.
Another advantage to the small planers is they often will go down to 1/8, which the thinnest the big machines will handle is 1/4". This can be a big advantage in certain crafts.