Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

Posts

Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#1

Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"If most of your woodworking experience consists of reading there are several traps waiting for you. The first is believing that reading about woodworking is the same as woodworking. "

Seen in this blog entry.

This describes me well. I spend way too much time reading FWW, PWW, LostArtPress blogs, other blogs, watching videos, books and such, I don'thave time for actual ww'ing. I read alot about it. Think about doing it a lot. But never seem to do it much.

I spend way too much time on my iPad reading. I hate my iPad too by the way...

Anybody want to trade an LN Panel saw for a nice little iPad. I read on a blog the LN saws are pretty nice.

I'm guilty. I admit it. Anybody else?

P.S.

I like reading R. Lang. Plus, as I recall, he is from the town next door to my family in Granville...

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#2

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

Bob Lang

Thanks for the kind words, Joe. I'm actually from Kent, moved to the Columbus area in the early 80s when northern Ohio almost shut down. Spent most of that time in the Newark/Heath/Granville area before moving to Cincinnati 10 years ago.

I think it's interesting how we've gone from little available information 35 years ago to the overload we have today. Too many people with too little experience waste too much ink and pixels on things that don't matter much if your goal is to build something nice. My theory is that you can judge the importance of any given topic by how much is written about it; it's an inverse relationship. We've grown in the quantity of woodworking knowledge, but not the quality. But it is an easy way to kill some time reading or establish your 15 minutes of fame writing.

Hardly anything in woodworking is as black and white as people try to make it and the best way to find out what really works for you is to get out to the shop and try it.

Bob Lang

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#3

poor trade

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Anybody want to trade an LN Panel saw for a nice little iPad"

You will just be trading reading for hand sawing and neither is particularly productive at getting stuff built.

I find clubs similar. Most members come to be entertained by woodworking. A few come to learn the trade. I'm fine with that.

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#4

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

Tony - Memphis

So, does that put you, as a writer, in a tough spot? I would imagine it would be a tough thing to balance magazine content. Hard to provide topics that appeal to the general audience.

Another perspective is I wonder how many new woodworkers we have because of the increased information available? And, how many viewers/readers are content with just that - being a spectator?

I have been at it a while and don't find much in the WW mags that interests me anymore. Now and then I see an interesting technique I'd like to try or a particular design I like, but overall.... I only subscribe to one magazine and have been considering dropping it. I just recently trashed most of the magazine collection I had in the attic.

And, to be fair, I started as a spectator just out of college when I had no cash or space to work. There wasn't much digital content then, so I poured over the magazines and watched Norm and The Woodright's Shop.

Anyway, it would be interesting to know the breakdown of it all. One last thought is that it is amazing how much BAD information is out there. I agree that there are at least a dozen ways to do anything and hand cut dovetails are not required, but I see lots of safety issues and very one sided presentation out there. I'm afraid too many newbies are discouraged because they are lead to believe they need a PM2000 to make anything decent.

Tony

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#5

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

Dave huber

I agree there is no substitute for actually making sawdust.

Hobbies, however, have many more uses than production of actual, finished product.

I have had and have several hobbies that occupy my time and mental energy.

Woodworking, like most of the hobbies that I am interested in, requires a focus on process and theory. These lend themselves to study and research.

That's part of the fun. Debate - even internal debate - over the esoteric is what makes for passionate hobbyists. It is also what sells books and magazines.

Take a look at a book, website or magazine devoted to any other hobby, whether it is photography, rose gardening, rock hunting, butterfly collecting, sewing, backpacking or sailing, and you will find that they have their own "pins first or tails first" debates. They have them over and over. Just like we woodworkers do.

The mental process of mulling over what to do, when to do it and how to do it is useful even if it does not produce sawdust.

I can't make sawdust whie waiting in an airport lounge for my delayed flight. However, I CAN figure out how I will manage to make a particular joint or cut. This mental woodworking is useful and part of the fun, in my experience.

Now, with that, I'm going to go downstairs and finally make the chisel handles I've been thinking about with my new lathe. I've got some design ideas I want to try out in real life.

Have fun.

Dave

BTW, I'm a pins first guy.

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#6

Debate and magazines...and an idea for the editors

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You stated. "Debate - even internal debate - over the esoteric is what makes for passionate hobbyists. It is also what sells books and magazines." I agree with the first part but the second doesn't occur in magazines. It is in the Forums where the flaws of "pins first" are revealed, and thankfully, some Forums allow it more than others (if you know what I mean :) .

A while back I made a return trip through Fine Woodworking Volume 1 to 123. I thought I saw more points of view passionately presented and critiqued in the early issues and then it got bland. Personally, I would find it easier to resubscribe if more points of view were passionately presented and critiqued in the magazines. But then I might be the only person that would read an article about someone building a Federal card table in their garage on a discarded kitchen table for a bench and their modest tools stored on a shelf.........

Which resulted in an idea to challenge the editorial staff of magazines to consider. How about an article on a shop (the presumption being a shop that is making stuff)? A few times a year there would be an article on some shop telling about what they make, how they make it and what tools are used. I'll even suggest the first two shops- Robert Millard and the Mack Headley and Sons shop in Winchester.

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#7

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

roger lance

Dave.....As today is my 67th birthday (how did that happen??!!), I want to agree with you about the mental challenges of woodworking which is one of the main reasons I became involved......I realized that woodworking would help keep my mind active.....it offers good mental exercise.....there are numerous problems to be solved in any build.

I also recognize that not everyone is the same in this activity. There is a continuum of makers and talkers......commenters and doers.....experienced and inexperienced.....and it takes awhile to learn who is who.....what is what. Woodworking is a big tent and there is room for all types.....after all, this is about getting enjoyment.....fulfillment....into our lives.

But, have you ever noticed how the really accomplished only show up to display their latest work and then disappear until after they've made something else ?? As for myself, I fall somewhere in the middle of the continuum.....which is not a bad place to be.

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#8

Re: Debate and magazines...and an idea for the edi

Bob Lang

Hi Bill,

We (Popular Woodworking Magazine) have a semi-regular feature called "Great Workshops". We covered Rob's old workshop (one car garage) in November 2007. We've talked about going back to his new shop now that he's moved to the basement. Link below is to back issue blurb, and there is a link there to Rob's website.

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/articleindex/great-woodshops-great-work-from-a-small-shop

The Headley shop sounds like a great idea, I've enjoyed your descriptions of your visits there over the years. Want to write it for us?

We need to be reminded from time to time on what guys like you like and don't like, feel free to get in touch or comment in this thread.

Bob Lang

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#9

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

Bob Lang

One of the biggest challenges is deciding where to aim. There is a broad spectrum of people with woodworking as an avocation. One one end are guys with a surplus of money and time who are checking woodworking out (perhaps only for a year or two in between golf and scuba diving). At the other end are guys who need to be making something, and they'll find a way to fill that need regardless of their resources or circumstances. In between are all sorts of sub groups, skill levels and stuff they get from the craft that goes beyond (or never gets to) making stuff.

As with any business, the temptation is to take the easy way out and pluck the low hanging fruit. It isn't that hard to set up an online presence or get published. That's short-sighted because the audience wanders off when they reach a point where they are more knowledgeable than the authors or online gurus.

Bob Lang

(wearing my personal, guy who has hung out on Wood Central for a long time hat, not my company hat)

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#10

Ellis Walentine

The editor's challenge

Ellis Walentine

About 20 years ago, American Woodworker magazine conducted a gigantic survey of Woodworking in America. We came away with a very detailed picture of who considers themself a woodworker, their shops, the kinds of projects they like to make, and where they buy their tools and equipment -- among a zillion other mundane facts and conclusions. It was a gold mine for editors and advertisers.

Editorially, the survey told us which topics needed to be aired and at what frequency, what styles of furniture and skill-building topics the most people favored, and what would keep or attract the most subscribers. The trouble, though, was that, as Bob says, there are so many varied interests that it's hard to come up with stuff that will interest or suit everyone. This begets the editorial quandary of where to concentrate effort, given that you don't have the time or pages or budget to be everything to everybody.

All of this gives rise to the individual "personalities" of magazines, and the personalities that write for and edit them. Each represents a decision about where and how to target the available resources, whom to hire and what kind of editorial to produce. We summed it up in one terse question: Who's the reader?

Ellis

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#11

The trouble is . . .

Bob Lang

that survey led publishers to believe that content could be reduced to a formula, and it's better to trust the formula. Most mags today are following a model based on that 20-year old information and doing what everyone else is doing. I see the same thing online, people aren't really sharing first-hand knowledge, they're just putting out the same kind of thing they saw someone else do. It isn't at all creative, and every time something gets repeated it gets watered down.

I would hope that the current abundance of information, and ease of dispensing it would develop an audience that would demand and support something better.

Bob Lang

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#12

not here

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is no lacking a challenge to "convention wisdom" on this Forum! In fact, over the years several conventional wisdoms have been dispelled here. Perhaps the most significant was the data provided by Steve Elliot that buried the notion that high performance steels could not be sharpened to the same degree as traditional steel(although this nonsense continues to be stated in other venues).

The most credible challenges to popular notions is to be found in professional shops making a living practicing efficient, reliable ways of doing things, even with hand tools.......which is the inspiration for sending Ellis to Maui or some place of greater hardship to report on these efficient and reliable ways of doing stuff.

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#13

Re: not here - you are right there - not here

TomD

"Perhaps the most significant was the data provided by Steve Elliot that buried the notion that high performance steels could not be sharpened to the same degree as traditional steel(although this nonsense continues to be stated in other venues)"

This presupposes we know what high performance is, and why it is considered necessary (errors on tool handling for instance). Or is it just a short form for a steel designed for some other purpose other than woodworking. Hitachi actually has steels designed for hand tools, but wait a second, aren't those the steels these die block steels are debunking.

Hitachi for instance has group revenues of 9.6 trillion yen, and the craftsmen they supply still go through an apprenticeship program. And the people they make stuff for are scarfing down US noble logs by the boatload, not the other way around. But hey what do those guys know.

And then there is the whole, are the people doing the test competent and objective thing.

I do agrees some unsharpenable steels are sharpenable. TR12 router is a good example of that. Very popular model that many Ks of US folks bought. Unbox that baby and the carbide 2 flute bit was razor sharp, back in the 80s. According to US magazine the carbides are too big to sharpen razor sharp. Wow Hitachi must have some magic steel. Quick, lets have a US magazine write an article about how those superstitious tool users across the pacific think they have magic steel. And of course HSS Japanese hand tools have been for sale in the US since at least the 70s. you know, ads in magazines. So if you say Woodcentral solved that problem, I have to say that sounds like someone was born on 3rd base thinking they hit a triple. If one is ignorant enough, every day is full of wonderful discoveries.

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#14

Re: Guilty

TomD

Really, if you spend any time here at all posting, there is probably something else you could better do. Not because there is anything wrong with this place, it is great, but I forget who said it, someone like Hemmingway, to the effect that if you write for free you are an idiot.

One thing I do is overcompensate for poverty mentality. Being in Canada, we are exposed to all the stuff in the US, but we can't easily or cheaply get at it. And then there are things none of us could get, like decent saws, planes, chisels in a western format, in the 80s. When that stuff comes up, I find myself buying things I don't need because I think it will be my only chance. What really happens is over the following years it gets even more abundant.

This applies to knowledge, so the ability to actually communicate (and in this case no borders exist) with people with greater knowledge than one has is intoxicating. And another thing is the idea that being knowledgeable is good. If you can feed the thread, you are a winner. But the latter is a generation gap thing. We value the knowledge because knowledge is scarce in our (now 54) experience. And you get the good jobs because you have knowledge. The reality is that in a knowledge economy knowledge is a cheap commodity. So back in the 80s individuals mostly couldn't afford a real time stock quote feed. Now everyone can get that for cheap, and for most of us realtime-enough is free. It is still worth billions to get the info a few milli seconds faster than the market, but other than that, the info is valueless. The kids coming up don't know a world were knowledge is hard to come by, so they won't care about people who have it, or think it is great that you know something. Soon enough, everyone knows. So in a sense, the online contribution thing is not only worthless, but foolish.

I often wonder if people like Ellis are laughing at us because we all flock here to provide free content. Badger Pond aside... I don't think Ellis is because it costs a lot to provide a place like this, so in a sense content providers are paid. But the whole thing is a bit like a Walmart: Some people were born into a world with Walmarts; Other just escaped from behind the Iron Curtain, and are seeing a department store for the first time; and others still are driving the tour bus that is taking the tourists from the Iron Curtain around.

Re: Robert Lang described me in a blog entry

#15

Re: The trouble is . . .

Tony-Memphis

Tough gig! I guess on the other other hand, I enjoy reading about styles and techniques that aren't my cup of tea. I'm not a fan of Craftsman style, but I still enjoy reading about and I almost always learn a new trick. I also pick up basic approaches, etc. to woodworking in general. But, I find myself spending about 15 minutes going through a new issue of XXX magazine and its hard to justify the price or the paper. I've been at this since about 1996 and I have read enough that I know what to do. That doesn't make me any good at it - I just know what to do (usually three different ways to approach it). I still have a lot to learn and I hope to continue to learn and get better until they plant me as fertilizer for a tree for someone else to build something with! And, of course, I learn more doing than reading. I get and have gotten lots of direction from the various media and I appreciate that, but I still learn the most doing. And last, but not least, there is the entertainment aspect. Sometimes, I enjoy reading (or just looking at pictures and captions) when I just want to relax. Anyway, it would be interesting to repeat Ellis's survey and see where we stand these days.

Tony (spent all weekend yardworking, but wanted to be in the shop - hoping for rain!)