Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

Posts

PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#1

PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

paul grover

Has any one replaced the 3 belt and pully on a unisaw with the groved pullys like on a Powermatic?

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#2

Why would this "upgrade" be needed?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have never known anyone to complain about belt slippage on a Unisaw. Unsure what you mean about "grooved pully". My Unisaw runs with three vee belts that fit in the sheave (sheave is a grooved pulley).

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#3

Re: Why would this "upgrade" be needed?

paul grover

I thought there would be less vibration. When I changed my belts, I made the mistake of not buying a matched set. Thanks Paul.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#4

Matched sets are no longer an issue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a friend who rebuilds woodworking machines and sell them. He told me that belts are now made with sufficient tolerance that one just buys three belts from the same manufacturing lot and they will be "matched".

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#5

Re: Matched sets are no longer an issue

paul grover

Thanks, I will replace with new belts. Thanks Bill

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#6

Re: Matched sets are no longer an issue

Brian in SLO

If vibration is your issue why not try 3 sets of link belts.

I put those into my Unisaw with good results and no slippage.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#7

Re: Matched sets are no longer an issue

Tom

Link belts are good.

what happens if you go for one belt? A lot of the time they are too powerful anyway.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#8

Too powerful for what?

John in NM

I don't get this at all. If the saw is too powerful, sell it and get a smaller one.... usually it goes the other way though, since you will find when ripping 8/4 rock maple that a cabinet saw is not too powerful, if anything it is just right or underpowered.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#9

Delta recommendation

Howard Acheson

I seem to recall that Delta strongly recommended against link belts on the Unisaw. Their uneven stretch caused some sort of problem, I think.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#10

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

Ken M.

I wouldn't waste my time with link belts. 3 belts from the same manufacture (bought at the same time) is all that should be required. Any bearing or industrial supply house should have quality belts.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#11

Re: Delta recommendation

Bill Howatt

While I don't know the specifics of the Delta recommendation, it makes good sense to me. I just can't see link-belts meeting any sort of "matched" requirement that you would want on a 3-belt pulley given all the moveable parts.

Bill

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#12

Rick L

Three belt myth

Rick L

One belt is all you need on a unisaw. I've seen and used many Euro slider panel saws with 9 hp motors and up to 18" blades and never at a loss of power or belt slipping.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#13

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

BrianMonumentCO

Unless the manufacturer recommends it, I am inclined to run a stationary power tool as sold with respect to belts motors etc. Delta sold the UNISAW with 3 belts that is how the designers determined it should be run.

That is how I run mine.

No point in changing it if I can get the replacement parts.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#14

Rick L

Over engineered

Rick L

The pulley system was over engineered and over built for it's time. I used to do repair and warranty work on Delta Machinery as a technician for a dealer. The regional sales rep used to tell me you only need one belt and the present-day engineers knew that but couldn't change it because of marketing. People would flip out and think they were cheapening the saw instead of bringing it to a practical level. Powermatic eventually went from three belts to two belts on the PM 66. I'm not saying to change the pulleys. Just that you could get away with one belt and be perfectly fine. Cogged belts would be a better choice than standard V-belt or Linkbelt on a Unisaw. Linkbelt was popular for a contractor saws which has a gravity weighted motor and the Linkbelt didn't suffer from memory issues. On a unisaw the motor has a fixed tension memory issue is not a problem. The belt memory issue on a Contractors Saw causes the motor to bounce up-and-down and on the up bounce it tends to slip and lose power.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#15

Re: Too powerful for what?

TomD

I don't normally rip thick stock on a table saw. I've been down that road where I ripped a piece of dead straight stock and it divided into 2 pieces that were as crooked as a two strung bows. Fun times. No question that table saws are designed to rip the heavy stuff, but realistically they had different people in mind for that job. I just feel silly making guitars and taking any unnecessary risks with the fingers that might play them. Actually, you can hurt a lot more than fingers.

Also, when making really great stuff, it is rare that I want to make the cuts parallel to the sides anyway. I normally want to rip with the grain, and that is another reason to use a bandsaw.

I use table saws for a lot of things, but for the most part they are not jobs that require 3 belts and 3 hp. Saw power is one thing that makes table saws dangerous. There isn't any reason to have a lot more power than I can use. Maybe Saw stop will add a feature to their fence that stops the blade if the piece starts back at more than a certain MPH.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#16

Re: Over engineered, I agree with Rick L

Keith Newton

I picked up a really old Delta saw once which had a 1hp motor, then came up with a new 3 hp. I had a single pulley on hand , so tried it. I never had a problem with it, and in fact it may have been a little quieter

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#17

That is silly

John in NM

For two reasons that I can come up with right off:

1. You've modified your work habits to avoid the accident you fear and attribute to too much power. You are using a 3 hp saw as if it were a 3/4 hp saw - the power you are not using is no danger to you and thus the saw is not too powerful. It may be inefficient for how you choose to use it, but if that bothers you just sell the saw and buy a smaller one.

2. Too powerful for your mode of work is not the same as too powerful for mine. Not everyone works as you do, not everyone builds what you build. Blanket statements like "too powerful anyway" tell me that you have not considered that the OP may require that power just as you do not.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Consider...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...that many modern vehicles run a single serpentine belt to spin the alternator, A/C compressor, water pump, air pump and power steering pump, which can all easily total over 10 HP. Granted, it's a grooved belt, but many of those accessories don't get a 180º wrap like the motor and arbor pulleys on a table saw. No surprise to me that a single belt will work on a 3HP table saw.

Jason

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#19

I wonder...

John in NM

If it has to do with modern rubber vs. WWII vintage rubber. I bet it wasn't over engineered by the standards of the day, it just seems that way now.

If you and Rick both say you can get away with a single belt and no slippage, I'm certainly willing to believe it. Too bad you didn't tell me two years ago when I bought new belts to go with a new motor! :D

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#20

Don't extrapolate to other machines

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My 20" Delta band saw has a three groove sheave(to name these things correctly). I was told that it would do fine with just one belt. Well it doesn't. The single belt screams for a couple of seconds before the massive wheels come up to speed. When it fails it will be replaced by 3 belts. Buying 3 belts to begin with would have saved the cost of the 4th belt that will eventually have to be bought.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#21

Hey John, I'm pretty sure I  read Ricks assertion

Keith Newton

Assertion more than once, but I don't recall if I commented before.

Don't worry, just be happy.

What I have wondered though, is why the thinner grooved belts like all newer autos hasn't made it to the TS. It sure seems like any belt memory vibrations would be improved.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#22

More than just power...

Tony - Memphis

I upgraded from a contractor's saw to a PM2000 for way more than power. Actually, power was not really a big factor. Although, there were a couple of times when a board pinched the blade and stopped it. That startled me and when one gets startled, they do things they don't think about - like react. Generally, the more powerful saws are also heavier and more stable. I feel more comfortable given the stability. When using the saw, there is still only an inch or so of blade above the table and everything else is more stable (much better splitter too), so I think more power is good!

I've read that increased power is safer. I'd have to think about that one for a while, but in some cases, I could see it.

And lastly, in the words of the great Tim the Tool Man Taylor - "The answer is MORE POWER."

Tony

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#23

Yeah, just being ironic really

John in NM

I probably would have installed three belts regardless :D

The drive pulley is especially small for obvious reasons. Could be that is part of the motivation for multiple belts - small pulley is less surface area for the belt to grip. For the extra $30 or so, I think I'd probably choose overkill vs. underkill.

A wide flat belt like a car's serpentine seems better to me too, especially with a small pulley. I suspect that manufacturers just take an "aint broke, don't fix it" mentality.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#24

Rick L

25 hp bandmill 1 belt

Rick L

I can show you a 25 hp bandmill with a single b width belt rather wil cut through antique 12" oak beams all day and has for over 13 years. Your argument has no legs to stand on.

Re: PULLY AND BELT UP GRADE

#25

Re: 25 hp bandmill 1 belt

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

As an retired Engineer that designed and installed many drive systems in my day - When the number (and type) of belts needed is determined there are a lot has a lot more factors than Horse Power that has to be considered. Feet per minute (RPM and Diameter of the pulley(s)) Static load to be brought up to speed. Diameter of the pulleys. Tension methods used to keep belt tight. Everyone seems to be stuck on horsepower. With the right "gearing" you can move a Locomotive with a clock motor - might take a week or two to see the movement, but it will do it! There are a LOT better drive belts today than was present 50 years ago, and certainly the Delta saw drive could be changed to a single belt drive with some design changes. However the current 3 belt drive works - and works well. As an Engineer, I probably would not waste time on re-design of the saw, the current drive system is "cheap" to produce and has a century or so of proven durability in service. I am certain when the design was made it was tested using steel blades (carbide was not commonly used then due to cost) and testing was done with a dull blade cutting some very hard wood at the maximum thickness the saw would cut. Most of us will never do this - but the ability to force the saw through was important to commercial users - downtime to change / sharpen the blades is expensive. Remember the Unisaw was designed for and purchased by lumber yards and commercial users when it came out - it was way to expensive for the common hobbyist woodworker.